6 ms·
Just because you're paranoid, doesn't mean AI's not after you
- FFP999 3y ago> horses "didn't complain" when cars were invented It's not that often a member of the executive class forgets themselves and says the quiet part this loudly: to them, we are livestock.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- n4r9 3y agoDoes seem to be happening more often, recently. E.g. "We need to remind people that they work for the employer, not the other way around" (Tim Gurner) and "People who worked remotely during the pandemic didn’t work as hard – regardless of what th ey told you.” (Stephen Schwarzman)
- FFP999 3y agoSure would be a shame if everyone at Gurner Group decided not to show up for work on the same day. Maybe then Tim Gurner would realize who actually keeps the wheels turning. But more likely it would be a classic "no...it's the children who are wrong" moment.
- Voultapher 3y agoYou know .... livestock might also be complaining right this moment and we don't categorize it as complaint and or worth listening to.
- FFP999 3y agoIf you've ever heard a pig scream you know they're complaining. Doesn't leave much room for doubt.
- Xcelerate 3y agoI don't understand why people always assume upside and downside risk are symmetrical on the big issues. Consider the set of potential outcomes on a few political hot-buttons: Global warming (incorrect): We wasted some fraction of human time and resources implementing carbon capture that wasn't necessary. Minor economic hit compared to the counterfactual situation where global warming was never considered. Global warming (correct): We prevented the collapse of the planet's climate and the ensuing death of most living creatures. AI will take our jobs (incorrect): We wasted time unnecessarily preparing for a paradigm shift in employment that never happened. Universal basic income was implemented which led to a small positive/negative change in worldwide economic productivity. AI will take our jobs (correct): UBI was never implemented. A feedback loop emerged where almost all wealth siphoned quickly to a few individuals. The reward mechanism that incentivized the general population to work broke, and hasty attempts by the government to implement a "fair" system of resource distribution among the now "economically worthless" population failed and led to mass supply chain failure, worldwide mental instability, and societal collapse. Even if you consider the probability of the latter scenarios to be something like 1%, I would argue they are still worth wasting human time and resources on.
- pdonis 3y ago> Global warming (incorrect): We wasted some fraction of human time and resources implementing carbon capture that wasn't necessary. Minor economic hit No, it's not at all a "minor economic" hit with the measures that are being proposed. It is a huge reduction in standard of living for everybody in first world countries, and forcing those who currently don't enjoy a first world standard of living to stay in poverty. Of course, you could avoid this by building nuclear power plants instead of the draconian carbon reduction/elimination measures that are being proposed. Then we could have the best of both worlds. But no climate change alarmists are proposing that. Why not? > Global warming (correct): We prevented the collapse of the planet's climate and the ensuing death of most living creatures. No actual scientific predictions make this claim. It is hype and FUD. > AI will take our jobs (incorrect): We wasted time unnecessarily preparing for a paradigm shift in employment that never happened. Universal basic income was implemented which led to a small positive/negative change in worldwide economic productivity. If you think UBI will just be a "small" change, I have some oceanfront property in Tibet I'd like to sell you. > AI will take our jobs (correct): UBI was never implemented. A feedback loop emerged where almost all wealth siphoned quickly to a few individuals. The reward mechanism that incentivized the general population to work broke, and hasty attempts by the government to implement a "fair" system of resource distribution among the now "economically worthless" population failed and led to mass supply chain failure, worldwide mental instability, and societal collapse. The consequences you describe here are actually consequences of UBI, not "AI". The potential negative consequences of "AI" are negative consequences of particular humans using AI as a tool to prey on everyone else--just as such humans have always used whatever tools they can to prey on everyone else. The solution to the problem is not to ban the tool (even if that were possible--you can't ban knowledge). It's to stop letting a few humans prey on everyone else. And the best way to do that is to decentralize power and stop thinking that governments can solve problems. Governments are actually an even better tool than "AI" for some humans to use to prey on everyone else.
- FuckButtons 3y ago“And anyway most people like to be employed” is exactly the kind of room temperature iq take I would expect from someone who is equating ai putting people out of work with the rise of the equine glue industry without seeming to have any appreciation for the horrific reality they are alluding to. It’s amazing to me that people who are supposed to have foresight to navigate their companies have so little imagination.
- s3p 3y agoAs a point of housekeeping, the title here was a little confusing to read. A lot of negatives. Reading the article seems to give a completely different story as a telco exec likens the horse-to-car transition as similar to what we're experiencing now with AI/ Not sure how the title fits in to that.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago"Just because you're paranoid, doesn't mean they're not out to get you" is a standard saying (with "they" left undefined, and fitting in nicely with the way paranoids often talk). The headline is riffing on that saying.
- fendy3002 3y agoI consider AI as still at the early stage, if we're talking about chees AI that began it's popularity in 80s and the surge of LLM at 2018. Yet just after several years since chatGPT, I see that there's many drawings of AI-generated that's good. The growth of AI is astonishing fast and in 5 years it'll be completely different beast than today. I think people underestimate the capability of AI. It's effect may be equal with or more than industrial revolution. Mass surveillance, deep fakes, text to voices, ocr, autonomous driving, will be conducted at a scale that never be seen until now. This may be the first time where a small set of party can hold physical (like in military) powers over millions of people, after nukes.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoI was expecting more from an article with this title. Seems a bit shallow.
- coding123 3y agoThe horses didn't complain but I bet their population dropped
- wishfish 3y agoI don't know if this is correct, but recently read it was a decline of 2 million+ horses in 1900 to about 238,000 in the UK.
- avgcorrection 3y agoThat’s what the article says. Via ChatGPT or something.
- damnesian 3y ago>how did horses feel when cars were invented? They didn't complain or go on strike' Guaranteed though, more of them were eaten or sent to the glue factory.
- beardyw 3y agoHorses didn't complain because they were dead.
- elzbardico 3y agoIf the promises behind the current hype on AI are correct, this means the end of the middle classes, the end of any chance of social mobility. So, it is going to accelerate things that were already in motion, but by a massive factor. And it is pretty ironic that a lot of the capital that went into this was the result of massive monetary expansion that led initially to massive asset inflation and later to garden variety inflation. The thing with inflation is that is never distributively neutral, it is always a wealth transfer engine. Richer people in a inflationary expansion are able to capture a lot of the early money, and so the capital holding class are able to do things like dabbling first on self-driving cars, and now on massive LL Models. So, basically, we are transfering income and wealth from the poor to enable the rich to get rid of their need of buying labor from the poor. How this doesn't end in a dystopian dictatorship beyond any of the worst nightmares of people like Orwell, or else in a Frank Hebert's "Butlerian Jihad" is something that I am at a loss of imagination to see.
- photochemsyn 3y agoA better analogy IMO is the transition from subsistence to industrial agriculture. Once upon a time, at least half the U.S. population worked in agricultural fields - then, to condense a lot of history, tractors and seed implanters and combine harvesters were invented, and now something like 2% of the U.S. population is directly involved in growing food (although certain vegetable and fruit crops are much more labor-intensive). I've never heard anybody bemoaning this development - agricultural field jobs are back-breaking and dull - but it did create a situation of greater societal dependence on a much smaller number of farmers. Ensuring that everyone gets enough food then becomes something of a socioeconomic problem rather than a technical problem. Now, if LLM-related technology starts making major inroads into the well-paid upper-tier employment sector, this could get a bit more interesting. My favorite suggestion is to use LLMs to replace shareholder-appointed corporate board members - and hey, why not the shareholders themselves? LLMs might be much better at generating capital from investments, and as they're not wasting the money on giant yachts and private islands, they might be much more efficient at plowing capital gains back into research and development and so improving manufacturing. This sort of highlights the fact that a society in which all the wealth is in the hands of a few aristocrats is a society doomed to eventual extinction, particularly in an era of rapid technological innovation.
- avgcorrection 3y agoAI is not after anyone. It’s still those same executives that compare people with domesticated animals (or whatever).
- jongjong 3y agoI often feel like some people around me have been programmed by the AI as they're constantly regurgitating some trendy mainstream narratives word-for-word. I increasingly feel like an 'Outlier' from the series Westworld. I think it's probably because we're constantly bombarded with mainstream narratives and people in our peer group are shown the same news articles and content at the same time. People who actually believe the articles/mainstream narratives tend to come across (to the rest of us) as though they've been programmed because they're all saying and thinking about the same thing at the same time in perfect unison. There's something eery about that.
- screye 3y agoAI and capitalism are an incredibly dangerous combination. Associating your human worth with your economic productivity and then limiting exponential economic productivity to a few already powerful people is a nightmare. Economies of scale can be rephrased as winner take all. Never thought I'd say this, but I am glad post modernism exists. A philosophical movement that rejects grounded representations of art or philosophy is somehow the perfect bulwark against AI.
- valine 3y agoWhy would it be limited to a few people? If the impacts are as far reaching as people expect an open source AGI will be inevitable. Useful algorithms are very hard to keep secret. I imagine a future with few jobs, where everyone is largely self sufficient. Would that really be so bad?
- TerrifiedMouse 3y agoDoesn't matter if AGI is open source. The main problem is the devaluing of human labor which a lot of people today trade for vital goods and services. People who own nothing that can produce continuous value will not have anything to trade with in the long term and will effectively be excluded from the economy.
- valine 3y agoYou're describing a post scarcity world. The whole point of an economy is to manage scarcity, talking about economic value post AGI is nonsensical. The responsibility to produce and distribute goods post AGI will fall to the government. Your doomsday scenario only exists in a world where the government purposefully chooses to deprive its citizens. People who don't want to depend on the government could always spin up their own AGI and become self sufficient. Some solar panels, a few robots and some farmable land are probably all you need when it comes down to it.
- TerrifiedMouse 3y ago
- coffeesque 3y agoI find the following useful for my own sanity, some might say it's a little overkill, but whatever ig news.ycombinator.com##td.title:nth-of-type(3):has-text("AI")
- happytiger 3y agoI swear to goodness I keep seeing the same headline on the same site with a different technology every few years.