5 ms·
US healthcare illustrated: The impossibility of getting a bill for five stitches
- 29athrowaway 3y agoA nonprofit where the CEO makes millions of dollars in bonuses.
- rqtwteye 3y agoThere are a lot of nonprofit executives in the Washington DC area. Once you see their houses and cars you realize that "nonprofit" often only means that the profit doesn't go to shareholders but to leadership of the nonprofit. they are still greedy bastards.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoAnd much of it is tax free.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI don’t understand how hospitals and insurance are constantly getting away with this nonsense. Even if people are against socialized medicine and free markets, they should at least make sure that there actually is real market where all participants have the necessary information. And hospitals should be forced to follow rules like sending itemized and accurate bills on time. When I worked in the office I often overheard people being on the phone daily for hours to deal with hospital or insurance. They can basically ignore callers without any repercussions. I don’t understand how this abuse can be accepted.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoBecause Congress won’t fix it.
- knightofmars 3y agoAnd lobbying makes sure they won't.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoDon’t blame lobbying, blame a lack of decent humans in a position of power. How much lack of function do you need to take orders from a lobbyist as a representative? Are we electing people? Or puppets? Mostly rhetorical.
- willcipriano 3y ago"don't blame them, they were tempted with bribes!" is to use the younger generations terms, cope. It wasn't that these were upstanding people lead down the wrong path, they were corrupt from the start.
- nickjj 3y agoWhat's really nonsense is that prices for known covered procedures through insurance aren't available until you've already enrolled into that insurance. For example, insurance companies will never tell you the "allowed coverage" of anything until you've already enrolled into their insurance in which case you're locked in for 1 year due to open enrollment. Imagine if you go to the dentist and your insurance says it will cover 100% of preventative care such as a cleaning. There's always a * there which states they will only cover 100% up to their defined "allowed" or "covered" amount which is a value they get to define in secret. It means if your cleaning costs $150 they might decide to only cover 100% up to $110 because they determined they won't pay more than that and there's no way to find this number out until you've already enrolled and either had the procedure done or have your medical provider submit a claim as a price check but at that point it doesn't matter because you've lost the ability to pick providers by price. The numbers change every year and every provider has different numbers.
- danaris 3y ago...But it's even more complicated than that, because for many providers that submit directly to insurance (this obviously doesn't apply to those you pay out of pocket and then submit to insurance yourself), they will completely either accept the "allowed amount" from the insurance if it's lower than what they would normally charge, or possibly partially accept it, dropping their fee from what it would normally be, but not as far as the allowed amount, leaving you still paying some amount more than the copay. Single-payer healthcare cannot come soon enough.
- danaris 3y agoIt is impossible to even have anything resembling a "free market" for healthcare. Free markets in that sense require that what's being bought be a commodity: it can't be something that's life or death, the buyer has to be able to shop around, has to have perfect information, and has to have ample differentiated options within easy reach. None of those are likely with (especially non-elective) healthcare. Healthcare must be treated as a human right, not a profit center.
- rqtwteye 3y agoI am not even talking about "free markets" but just a functioning market where all participants have the necessary information and have to follow certain rules. It seems hospitals and insurances can get away with murder unless you can afford to pay for a lawyer full time.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI'll be macabre because it is what happens when you mix markets and human morbidity and mortality. What is the market value of your parent's life? Your children? Your spouse? Care to put an exact dollar amount beyond which you would not pay for care for them?
- jmclnx 3y ago>The key point made there was that it wasn’t even health insurance companies that were the issue, which is what many people assume. Rather it’s the hospitals. It takes one to now one. Health Insurance tells the hospital what they will pay for servicing their "client". Plus the Insurance Company will tell their Client "we will not pay for your life saving treatment" if they determine it is too expensive. I will not speak to the rates they charge for malpractice insurance. There is a reason health care is too expensive. Plus I am sure the bonus an Insurance Company CEO gets dwarfs the total of all bonuses people in the non-profit hospital gets.
- psychlops 3y agoHe got healthcare, the health insurance caused the problem. His own insurance company was complicit in the scam by paying $4500 of the bill thereby inflating prices for everyone.
- karakot 3y agoit's not scam, they're inflating their profits (and prices for everyone else). Look up 80-20 insurance rule.
- oatmeal1 3y agoFraud perpetrated against the little guy isn't of concern to the government.
- giantg2 3y agoYou'd be surprised what your Attorney General's office will do for the little guy when a company is breaking the law.
- oatmeal1 3y agoThey won't make sure it doesn't happen again to someone else.
- giantg2 3y agoOk... I mean there's already a law saying they have to provide that itemized bill. Laws don't prevent future occurrences of anything, so more laws won't stop all future occurences. So why do you propose? Sounds to me like enforcing the current law is a pretty good start. Consistent enforcement could prevent many future occurrences.
- aaomidi 3y agoYou’re right I would be surprised.
- 3y ago
- giantg2 3y agoYou don't go to Goodbill for this kind of thing. You file a complaint with your Attorney General, your insurance, and the BBB. Goodbill might work for legitimate bills, but this hospital sounds like it is acting fraudulently. How the insurance approved paying $6500 for 5 stitches is interesting since they usually fight paying bills and set caps on what a procedure can be reimbursed for. This makes me question if there isn't more to this.
- ghastmaster 3y agoI had a surgery that I had years to prepare. I did much research into costs. There are surgery centers that have transparent pricing all over the US. Surgery center of Oklahoma is one. I used them as baseline to consider local costs. I was uninsured and asked the local hospitals and surgeon what the prices were going to be. I did qualify for assistance. I paid my surgeon pronto($2,600) and had to wait for the hospital to approve my assistance application. The anesthesiologist(which I hadn't anticipated, thought that was going to be in the hospital bill) told me to pay $35 dollars to keep my $1,800 bill from going to collections. Once I showed them the approval from the hospital, they would accept that and reduce it to $180. After calling the hospital constantly to get the bill reduced, 6 months later they told me they were waiting to see if I qualified for Medicaid, which I was no where near qualifying for and never requested. I just had their standard financial assistance reduction from about $18,000 to $6,000. In the mean time, my anesthesia bill made it to collections for the full amount. Because. I tried initially to get all my ducks in a row. I tried to pay everyone. Ultimately, I only paid the surgeon the full amount. The medical groups will write off the difference between what they billed and what they sold my debt for. This will reduce their "revenue". I won't ever pay them. Bye bye credit. Cash is King. Edit: I knew going in what the prices were and two of the three parties fumbled the process of payment. Those two didn't get paid because I was frustrated.
- rjtavares 3y agoThe idea that either hospitals or insurance companies are single handedly to blame for the mess that is the US healthcare market is naïve. You can't have a normal billing process when the buyer can't decide what they want. The problem is: a person can't decide the best treatment for their disease. The extreme case: a person that goes through a surgery cannot decide what care they need or want (they are under anesthesia when that decision needs to be made). So, someone else needs to manage the cost, not the end customer. Who? Insurance passes the cost to the customer, and companies buying health insurance can't really decide on the care needed by their employees. That leaves the government to be an effective regulator of cost. The US decided they don't want that. Fix that before anything else.
- BadCookie 3y agoMaybe what you are saying is true in emergency medicine, but it’s very easy to rack up thousands per year in non-emergency medical care. If someone’s doctor orders, say, an echocardiogram or an MRI done, typically that patient is going to wait several weeks before getting the imaging done. But how easy is it to price compare for that sort of thing? Not easy at all. Most patients will go to whichever hospital their doctor sent them to, and the doctor has no idea which hospital offers the best deal (partly because the price depends on someone’s insurance plan)!
- rjtavares 3y agoYou will go to whichever hospital your doctor sent you in any case... The idea that price shopping in important is healthcare is completely unproven worldwide, as far as I know.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[Dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38255496 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38255496
- underseacables 3y agoRelated, If you file a prescription on insurance you're not then allowed to pay a lower price using cash. CVS told me the price of a prescription on insurance was high. I said, what if I pay cash, they said, no, once you file it on insurance we can't sell it to you for less than that. Like WTF?!
- cachencarry 3y agoI've never seen a pharmacy that works like that, they most likely just told you that because they didn't want to do the extra work rebilling. Or it's a CVS only thing, which would be pretty messed up considering they run their own insurance company and pbm.
- willcipriano 3y agoIt's legit and common. > Much publicity has surrounded the use of gag clauses in contracts between insurance companies or their pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) and pharmacies. These clauses prohibit pharmacists from voluntarily informing patients that their prescription medication may cost less if paid for directly by them instead of through their insurance. > How often an insurance copayment exceeds the cash price for a prescription is not definitively known; however, Van Nuys and colleagues reported that such overpayments affected 2.2 million (23%) of 9.5 million prescription insurance claims from a single large insurer. Additionally, in a 2016 survey involving over 600 pharmacies, approximately 39% of respondents stated that a gag clause prevented them from informing patients about other payment options between 10 and 50 times in the last month. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6293384/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6293384/ Antitrust action when?
- cachencarry 3y agoOh, I agree all of that is real and common What I meant is I've never seen a pharmacy that will refuse to bill to cash when directly asked.
- cyanydeez 3y agothere's a company called Emergency Physician professional association. they appear to be fishing for additional management fees over and above the hospital bill. I contacted the hospital and confirmed they're a contractor but couldn't provide anything else. when contacted for itemized billing, the first time, they just lost the bill. the second time they offered a discount when asked for the name of the doctor who they managed, they could not provide. it's clearly some kind of hospital kickback scame.