3 ms·
I think what will happen is what happened to hardware. You used to come across people who could do things like solder components to a board and hook up various
by lordnacho 3y ago
I think what will happen is what happened to hardware. You used to come across people who could do things like solder components to a board and hook up various ICs as well. Heck, I did this at uni.
Now that layer of craftsmen is gone. You are either an uber-expert in how computer hardware works, or you just buy the hardware and treat it like a kind of magic.
Traditionally to become an expert you went through an intermediate stage, showed your interest, and got trained. Your hobby could turn into a profession, since the step up was gentle and interested people were needed to do some of the supporting work.
Nowadays if you're going to work in a chip fab, it's not because you were a soldering iron kid. You go through a quite long academic process that doesn't really recruit from the ranks of the hobbyists, though of course you'd expect there to be some natural interest. But the jump isn't gentle, you end up learning some pretty advanced things that make soldering seem like the stone age.
Software has this layer of craftsmen still, though it is rapidly dying, and not just from LLMs. There's a enormous number of people who can more or less hook up a website and make it work, without knowing everything about how exactly it does that. There's also plenty of excel people and python scripting people who use code in their day-to-day, but can't tell you advanced concepts. There's a lot of modern services that make this sort of thing easier (wordpress etc), and this level of skill is very learnable by people in the developing world. It's not like you can't become a real expert in those parts of the world, but economically it makes sense that there are a lot of intermediately skilled there.
What will happen with GPT and the like is the experts will not need as much help from the juniors. If you're a software architect in charge of a whole system, you won't just sketch out the skeleton of the system and then farm out the little tasks to junior coders. Maybe there are pieces that you'd farm out, but you will definitely save on the number of juniors because an LLM will give you what you need.
The result being that we'll get fewer people trained to the highest levels, but those who are will be much more productive. So those guys will indeed be entering the quantum age, but it strands a lot of people.
- cousin_it 3y agoYes, the same thing happened before. There was a generation that tinkered with cars, there was a generation that tinkered with radios. There was a generation that tinkered with computer hardware. And then there was a generation that tinkered with software, and now it's going away. The real question for me is whether AI will put humans out of most intellectual work, not just programming. Then, even if AI is shared equitably and satisfies our every need, most of us become some kind of sponges that don't need to think for a living. Or human intelligence will remain but only as a peacock's tail, like physical strength is now. Maybe a true "friendly AI" would recognize the human need to be needed, for human capabilities to stay relevant, and choose to put limits on itself and other AIs for that reason.
- lordnacho 3y agoMaybe there will be an intellectual version of sports? Regulated to only allow actual humans, done for much the same reason as physical sports? I guess that sort of thing already exists (eg Chess).
- cousin_it 3y agoThe arts might be the "peacock's tail of the mind". Many gatekeepers in the art world now are putting up roadblocks against AI art, and from that perspective they're right to do so.
- throwaway4aday 3y agoThe ideal outcome is that we automate all of it and then just do the things that we find fun. For those who really want to continue to be at the bleeding edge there will be the option of enhancement/merging/uploading/whatever winds up working in the end but I think that existence will be very different from our current human experience much like if you could uplift a chimp or a dog to the level of a human.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]