18 ms·
Tesla Cybertruck Owners Will Face Absurd Resell Penalties
- jdsully 3y agoFord made me sign a contract similar to this when I bought a Bronco sport. I was annoyed the dealer sprung it on me at the very end when I was getting the keys, but didn’t plan to resell in the first year anyways.
- fabiensanglard 3y agoIs that even legal, to ask you to sign that after you paid for it? Or was it before?
- dangus 3y agoYou can be asked all kinds of things. It's a little trick law enforcement tends to use: ask for things that the person being asked doesn't have any obligation to do.
- colejohnson66 3y agoAs long as no consideration has exchanged hands or signatures signed, then yes. Contracts can be modified up to the second they are signed as long as both parties agree to it. Obviously, no one could negotiating away contract like this, but you always have the option to walk away.
- jdsully 3y agoDuring the closing in the finance office.
- h2odragon 3y agoJust admit they can be remote controlled and call them home when the "owners" displease you. That might be a little rank even for Musk. Make it part of the EULA. "By opening the door you agree to ..." Add an NDA clause. If these are "bulletproof"; could someone be kidnapped by their car? I was gonna make a crack about keeping a window breaker handy in case the door locks got overridden but even that might not work.
- neuromanser 3y agoJust keep a brick in the glove compartment.
- m463 3y agoDon't you mean a giant ball bearing? :)
- jstarfish 3y ago> call them home when the "owners" displease you You're not being inventive enough. Drivers are not liable when autopilot fails. Neither is Tesla. If it gets into an "accident" involving a body of water, electromechanical locks and bulletproof glass will seal your fate...and nobody will be held accountable. The New Model Y[andere]: You'll love it, or else.
- pxmpxm 3y ago>>If these are "bulletproof"; pressed sheet of 304 stainless :: "bulletproof" polyurethane over more plastic :: "vegan leather"
- Detrytus 3y ago> The electric truck weighs 7,000 pounds according to Musk, making it about as heavy as a Ford F-150, but can accelerate from 0-60 in under 3 seconds. Finally, the most missed feature in a pick-up truck is here! > The futuristic-looking truck has a bulletproof, stainless steel body and is “waterproof enough” to cross rivers like a boat, among a long list of claims that only seem beneficial during an apocalypse. This, however might actually be useful, given the current geopolitical climate...
- hedora 3y agoI was going to chime in to make fun of the paltry towing capacity I assumed it had, but it's rated to 14,000 lbs. That is significantly higher than the F-150 electric's 7700-10,000 lbs.
- grepfru_it 3y agoThat 14k towing capacity can probably only be sustained for like 28 minutes. Edit: expect a ~73mile range at 14k. For comparison an f250 towing 15k lbs gets about 9mpg. With a 55 gallon tank, the f250 is still a better option for practical reasons. Let’s revisit this 5 years after the cyber truck release
- m463 3y agoMaybe pull-through superchargers will become a thing. There will have to be something for the semi too. I guess another question would be - how often do pickups get used for towing, and how far do they normally go? I've heard that only rarely do people use the bed of their pickup, let alone tow.
- grepfru_it 3y agoYes but commercial pickup trucks far outnumber residential-rarely-ever-tow pickups. The people who need 11k towing capacity are likely towing for commercial reasons. Or they are Uber rich and have a yacht they need to pull. Rarely very rarely do you see someone driving an eg F250 because they like the dualie setup in the rear. Source: I live in texas
- gamblor956 3y agoAs previously discussed in other HN threads from last week, these penalties are DOA. Some of them, such as the liquidated "damages" clause which is clearly just a penalties clause, are straight up illegal. Courts will punish parties attempting to enforce a penalties clause, usually by requiring them to pay the opposing parties' legal fees.
- Arrath 3y agoI would love to see a detailed legal breakdown and examination of how many of the clauses in this contract are complete, utter, unenforceable horseshit.
- signatoremo 3y agoThere are many precedence, Porsche being one. I’m sure their lawyers aren’t naive. We want to ensure that cars are available to reach true enthusiasts, to be driven and enjoyed for years to come. For this reason, those allocated a 911 S/T in the US will be required to adhere to an agreed minimum retention period, set at one year https://www.drive.com.au/news/porsche-stops-supercar-scalpers/ https://www.drive.com.au/news/porsche-stops-supercar-scalper...
- buffington 3y ago> their lawyers aren’t naive. Lawyers, being very much not naive, knowingly write contracts that are unenforceable in court. They're ok with that because they know the majority of those who sign the contract assume it's legally enforceable and never challenge it.
- signatoremo 3y agoNo, they write it because they are confident they will prevail in court. They wouldn’t leave it to chance. That’d be naive. Why do you think nobody has successfully challenged Ferrari and Porsche? Scalping is very lucrative after all
- gamblor956 3y ago
- sonicanatidae 3y agoTalk about a big ole bag of, "yeah, you can keep this horse shit".
- pfannkuchen 3y agoThis is pretty obviously intended to prevent essentially scalpers from selling the early units for massive profit. Not sure why people are mad about this? South Africa man bad?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- carstenhag 3y agoBecause after paying in full for it, it's your decision what to do with it. Compress it into a steel cube, sell it, drive it.
- jterrys 3y agoRight. Have you considered perhaps that there's entire industries out there plagued by organizations that use automated tools to muscle out consumers from access of general goods with with no intent of using those products themselves and only act as an artificial intermediary to resale said goods and inflate the price for their own benefit? This plagues concert tickets, shoes, clothing, computer parts, sometimes evening necessary goods like cleaning wipes and toilet paper. Are those people just good hard working honest capitalists that create a market opportunity and deserve to use their products as they damn well please too?
- ryaneager 3y agoYeah, that’s a problem the FTC should solve and not the companies selling goods. An individual should not be restricted on reselling their own goods.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoOkay but the FTC isn’t solving it so you expect a company who thinks this is a problem to do nothing? Anyway how would the FTC solve it? Instead of having a contractual agreement between individual parties, you would prefer the government to ban something? This would for sure end up restricting free exchange more than one-off agreements like this.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38237287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38237287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38236701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38236701
- haliskerbas 3y agoAnd when the pieces don’t fit together, no one faces a penalty. https://insideevs.com/news/694929/tesla-cybertruck-matte-black-impressions/ https://insideevs.com/news/694929/tesla-cybertruck-matte-bla...
- bandyaboot 3y ago> I do think it’s pretty cool that the all-terrain tire option is a custom Goodyear with notches in the sidewall to accommodate the plastic aero covers The second mortgage that you’ll need to take out when it comes time to replace them will be notably less cool.
- dangus 3y ago"Absurd" is quite an editorialized part of this headline. Maybe Gizmodo should report on the facts and let us decide if we think it's "absurd?" I personally think it's reasonable enough. For one, buyers signed on the dotted line. It's a luxury product that nobody needs. They don't have to buy one For two, nobody likes scalpers. I don't think any court would award the damages that Tesla would be seeking here but they're well within their rights to try and enforce their contract, and they're well within their rights to ban customers (Ferrari is also known to do this to owners who "tarnish their brand")
- camdenlock 3y ago> Maybe Gizmodo should report on the facts and let us decide if we think it's "absurd?" This never has been (and probably never will be) Gizmodo’s M.O. ;)
- dangus 3y agoI know, I know, pretty unrealistic wishful thinking.