4 ms·
> This is important, because whoever (or whatever) comes after us might still have a shot at colonizing Mars … What is this fixation people have on colonising
by rsynnott 3y ago
> This is important, because whoever (or whatever) comes after us might still have a shot at colonizing Mars
… What is this fixation people have on colonising Mars? Like, why is _that_ the reason that civilisation reemerging would be important?
- anjel 3y agoVapid atmosphere and high levels of Radiation...sounds charming. I hope they like living underground as trogs.
- nuccy 3y agoMars might be just a first (easiest) step for becoming multi-planetary/spacefaring civilization. By itself it is not that special or important but if you have a colony on another planet you focus more on space technology and other options that it brings.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoBecause then we can stop caring and go on as before! :) No, honestly I don't know either. I don't know what it even changes without mentioning Mars at all, and that's what all the "the Earth has been always gone through that" or worse advocates do not get? Besides it comparatively not being true at least at that timescale or with that population.. it all does not matter: It has never been about Earth in general or what may survive or reemerge at some point, it has always been about us (and our children)?!
- sillysaurusx 3y agoWhat do I get out of it? Happiness, of course. If my life was all about me and ny children, then it’d truly be meaningless. Say we ran with your perspective. Mars doesn’t matter. Ok, that means it’s guaranteed that you, your children, and the descendants of everyone you know will die as our sun heats up. This is not so far away, as the video illustrates. So then, what do you get out of this? A few dopamine hits and some nice chemical reactions before the eternal void? What’s all of our work even amount to? We have the privilege of being the only life form ever to use technology. Technology! We can do things. Most life can’t do a damn thing. They live, briefly, and then die, gruesomely. And till the asteroid hit, that might have been the story of our planet until the sun gobbled it up. (Though imagining dinosaur astronauts is fun too.) Would you say that asteroid is all about you and your children? It’s what even made it possible for you to be here, along with the unbroken string of cells from billions of years ago till the present day. Me and my children? We’re nothing, in that perspective. We are here thanks to everyone that came before. And we owe it to those who come after to let them live an even better life. So unless you want the descendants of everyone you know to die horribly one day, colonizing space is our only way out. But that’s just what I get out of it. After all, my own chemical reactions are unlikely to change a thing, over a single millisecond of that video. There’s nothing wrong with focusing on yourself and enjoying the ride. But personally, I end up a lot happier trying to make life be about more than little ol’ me. (My daughter says "gaaaa!" as I write this, which is either a salute of agreement or a firm rebuttal. Time will tell.)
- throwbadubadu 3y agoMars or even stellar exploration will matter, or would, if we make it there... didn't question that. And it is not just about me and my nonexistant children ;) But tbh, if something after us emerges again in some millions of years is similarly important to me as if any other alien life exists.. and no it won't help me any bit over the sadness of massive unnecessary suffering we will cause to ourselves and all the living beings around us in the near future. I am not a sad / depressive person, but no, a future alien population (no matter if earth or somewhere else born) will not help the current perspective at all, or make me happier? > We have the privilege of being the only life form ever to use technology. I doubt that is and will be true. I don't get your following derivations, I think you understood me wrong.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoWhat would make you happier? I ask in earnest, since finding meaning is a lifelong pursuit. Being able to thumb our nose at the universe by colonizing Mars before the sun wipes out the solar system appeals to my rebel tendencies, since the sun is the ultimate authority, after all. May as well give it a good run for our money. There’s also a chance that being on Mars is exactly the right spot to be in when our sun starts to expand. I guess I like the idea that even if we humans don’t get there, something that descends from us might. Actually, I like the idea that something a few steps up the evolutionary tree (like an alligator) will spring to life and discover the merits of language, if some cataclysm wipes us out. Or maybe reptiles in space is just my thing. The early Apollo missions were a missed opportunity to make a lizard astronaut a reality. If there’s some other way to escape the existential dread of none of what we do mattering whatsoever, please share. It’s at least nice to imagine that one of our cells will make it from earth to mars.
- seadan83 3y agoRemember, the very best conditions of Mars will always be far worst than the worst conditions ever present on Earth. Mars is _incredibly_ inhospitable; even a nuclear wasteland Earth is easier to live on than Mars. Second, a permanent Mars colony will always be dependent on the Earth for regular resupply. If Earth were to become toast, so would the colonies on Mars. This person gets into it in more detail: https://www.quora.com/How-would-we-be-able-to-live-on-Mars?no_redirect=1 https://www.quora.com/How-would-we-be-able-to-live-on-Mars?n... Further, stating that the most salient problem for us to solve now with technology is a problem that will occur 5 billion years from now - strikes me as hubris. That _we_ must be the ones to save the Earth, as if we will have failed unless _we_ are the super heroes that save humanity for all of time. Meanwhile, the Earth is a giant garden. Given our focuses, I don't think future generations will think of us as heroes. I don't think future generations will think of us too kindly at all.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- api 3y agoIt’s a next step toward life expanding beyond Earth and into the universe, and not just human life because we carry a ton of passengers along with us. It ultimately comes down to whether you think that is good. BTW I too am skeptical about Mars but for wholly different reasons. The Moon makes far more sense for a first step for numerous reasons, and beyond that I think settling space itself would be better than settling down in another gravity well. Become truly and permanently spacefaring. None of this helps climate change though. I consider them unrelated issues.
- jwells89 3y agoThe thing about Mars specifically (compared to the Moon) is that it represents a much larger commitment. Long term human presence on Mars isn’t something that’s as whim-friendly as the Moon is: you either plan for being there long term (including some level of self-sufficiency) or you don’t go. At the same time, it’s a goal that is probably within closer grasp than building freely-moving, permanently spaceborne crafts that are large and advanced enough for continuous, long-term human inhabitation. With that in mind, many view human settlement of Mars as something as an insurance policy against decades-long periods of stagnancy like we saw from the late 70s up through the 2010s. It’ll apply strong pressure on the parties involved to continue to improve the technologies involved in getting out there and back and living there in ways that a human presence on the Moon won’t (you can’t get away with a lightly modernized rehash of the Apollo missions; that’s not good enough).
- johnny22 3y agoi don't care about colonizing mars beyond it being the closest planet to do so. The earth isn't going to be habitable sometime in the next billion years as the sun gets hotter and then turns into a red giant. We (or life's other descendents) have to go somewhere. (the earth itself might also become less habitable all by itself over time, but i don't know enough about that)
- cratermoon 3y agoLongtermism is a cancer.
- api 3y agoI agree. The main problem is that it’s impossible to reliably project out even decades let alone centuries or millennia. So longtermism gives you this blank slate to tell any “just so story” you want. Speculating is fine but you can’t use pure speculation to justify things in the real world. That’s the problem. Truth is that we have no idea about anything much past our own slice of time. In 2000 years we may be extinct, reverted to hunter gatherers, settled across the solar system like in The Expanse, or extinct or kept in zoos by superintelligent posthuman AIs that have expanded out into the cosmos. Or none of the above. Who knows.
- jacquesm 3y agoWe're already outside of the envelope that I envisioned as a kid for the era we are living in and the departure gets more extreme with every year that passes. But we seem to have been unable to outrun wars, greed and outright evil. Those you can definitely count on for the longer term unless we start to actively work against them.
- api 3y agoI don’t think we will be rid of those things until we start understanding how incentives work. Game theory should be taught in high school.
- hef19898 3y agoMaybe we should stop believeing humans could be modeled at all. We are not computers running some software...
- jacquesm 3y agoI think a big part of the problem is that we keep on creating structures where malicious individuals have a disproportionally high chance to end up with their grubby little tentacles on the levers of power. You'd think WWII would teach us that lesson forever but for some strange reason we are immune to absorbing this and we have made that same mistake at least another few 100 times since then. And one of these days one of those idiots is going to kill us all. And for some reason it is always men.
- xeromal 3y ago> We choose to go to the (X) in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard