6 ms·
Globalisation is a far, far bigger deal than you think
- chiefalchemist 3y ago> But the flip side of this story is one of risk. Each of these companies represents an important micro pinch point in the global economy. If we are now living through a new Cold War, and if that Cold War begins to affect global trade (this might already be happening) then He missed an even more important point. That is, globalization's foundation is ultra-inexpensive shipping of raw goods, parts, and then finished product. Long to short, globalization is dependent on the status quo fuel. That is oil. Lots of cheap oil. So the risk isn't simply from the bottlenecks and lack of economic diversity. It that globalization perpetuates a status quo that favors climate change.
- ben_w 3y agoIf the promises of small modular nuclear reactors comes to pass[0], we can have hydrocarbon-free shipping without much difficulty. Even without that, there are solutions. [0] I'm not holding my breath but I'll be happy if it does work out. IMO the biggest problem isn't even making them work, it's making them safe against deliberate tampering by highly motivated people with a lot of time on their hands.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago> without much difficulty This may be a underestimate of what would actually be involved with this change.
- chrischattin 3y agoThe technology is there from what I understand. The difficulty will be on the regulatory/bureaucratic side.
- bilsbie 3y agoWhy can’t cargo ships tow a multi acre barge covered in solar.
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoNot a chance. Shipping is taking a global mix of low cost workers and then as cheaply as possible getting goods from A to B. The margins are razor thin, generally negative with boom years in between. A 400m containership is operated with a crew of 16 + whatever maintenance technicians are on board. How du you feel about leaving a single low paid person in charge of the reactor on a 6 hours on and 6 hours off schedule? The long distance shipping industry is looking at methanol, ammonia and hydrogen to decarbonize.
- ben_w 3y ago> How du you feel about leaving a single low paid person in charge of the reactor on a 6 hours on and 6 hours off schedule? The way small modular reactors are advertised, that's not the risk I'm worried about. Instead, I'd ask: what can Hamas/North Korea/literal pirates do if they boarded the vessel half way between ports, and are actively trying to cause problems.
- rsynnott 3y agoAssume you’re talking about use in shipping? _All_ shipping is only about 10% of transport emissions.
- jszymborski 3y agoGP wasn't talking about emissions, they were talking about the price of oil. Also, 10% of emissions from one single source is a lot! (Some might say a boatload)
- FpUser 3y agoYou have to consider percentage of emission vs percentage of the goods moved. I believe shipping is way more favorable in the regard vs it being replace by local shipping by millions of trucks.
- bombcar 3y agoThose millions of trucks still roll, bringing goods to and from the ports.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoYes, GP here. I'm also talking about the fact that the very foundation of the globalization economy is based on fossil fuels. That belief (?) is going to influence decisions literally from the bottom up. As long as that foundation is printing money - and it is - it's going to influence all that sits on too of it.
- ihaveajob 3y agoThe cost of shipping overseas at scale (thanks to containerization, automated ports and gigantic ships) is lower than doing so locally with less efficient means (i.e. your chicken farmer's diesel van). Given that, even if the price of oil goes up, the math doesn't change because costs rise uniformly.
- weberer 3y agoI don't get it. Instead of a truck driving 100 miles from the factory to the store, you now have ships driving thousands of miles halfway across the world to a port, where a truck then picks up the product and drives 100 miles to the store.
- bberenberg 3y agoYes but you’re ignoring how much each carries. If you look at amount carried per amount of fuel consumed per journey, container ships are much more efficient than trucks regardless that one journey is 100 miles and the other is 3000.
- pier25 3y agoBut you still need to carry the contents in a truck from and to the port.
- weberer 3y agoNo, my point is that the trucks are still there. The ships are just adding an extra step that wasn't there before.
- bberenberg 3y agoAh gotcha I misunderstood. Are you then suggesting that everything everyone needs to consume and dependent supply chains be provided within close proximity of every individual consumer then?
- somenameforme 3y ago
- DiscourseFan 3y agoWell ok sure, but how do we manage specialized inputs for the production of the global economies goods and services in an efficient manner without gloabalization? Everyone growing up thinks they are going to be a "doctor" or a "lawyer" or a programmer or a professor or whatever, some very large sector of labor that requires very little specialized inputs: but in fact, the vast majority of people become involved in labor that intersects with the global economy in ways they only understand in a small way. That is the nature of our modern economy, why capitalism is so robust is precisely because it has somehow managed to efficiently distribute labor such that all these various processes whose complexity is dizzying in nature are able to work like grand clockwork. If an alternative form of economic planning does not come about, since Global Capitalism introduces so many externalities it will destroy itself relatively quickly. Such self-destruction seems inevitable at this point, but we are not given real alternatives: Communism is a spectre, it haunts discourse since it exists as the only alternative posited that seeks to increase productivity and global wealth. Others are simply regressive, right-wing policies that emphasize a return to communal life (whose advocates forget, or perhaps are simply unfamiliar with, the extraordinary poverty of traditional rural communities). And yet not once has communism been shown to out-compete capitalism in terms of wealth generation and the destruction of poverty. Capitalism has been adapted so severely to social concerns that it is difficult to tell (especially in China, which still calls itself communist) where the social policies end and the wealth generation begins. Though it is not and cannot be the end of history. But then how could our future be anything but at the same time both fantastically wealthy and horrifically dystopic? Out of that extreme chaos, what could come but more chaos, more terror, more luxury and more suffering. Magnitudes of pleasure and displeasure vacillation, desire inversion, operational schizophrenia, than we could even comprehend today. The alternative is already a lack of an alternative.
- ochoseis 3y agoShipping is cheap these days because volume is up, and because losses due to theft (thanks to containerization) and piracy (thanks to Team America World Police) are down.
- bumby 3y agoI wonder how much this changes as American priorities change. It seems as the population ages and entitlement spending as a proportion of GDP grows, there’s less tolerance for expensive world policing.
- pier25 3y agoThis was my first thought too. The reliance on shipping and the resulting emissions. It wouldn't surprise me if the huge cargo ships produced more emissions than cars globally.
- rsynnott 3y agoI mean, this is something you can trivially look up. Shipping, total, is about 10% of transport emissions, cars and vans are 50%, road freight is 25%. (Shipping, there, does include some stuff other than cargo, but it’s mostly cargo).
- pier25 3y agoYes I was on my phone before but here's some more data. https://ourworldindata.org/ghg-emissions-by-sector https://ourworldindata.org/ghg-emissions-by-sector Shpping is 1.7% of global emissions. Much less than I had expected from reading the OP article.
- dzink 3y agoThat makes energy innovation the most critical of our lifetime. Without the small manufacturers doing niche products worldwide everyone becomes much poorer on goods and services they need. That hits poorer countries the worst and triggers more war as people find fewer means of getting out of poverty (Putin was able to motivate Russians from far regions that thought washing machines were worth plundering and sending back.) Globalisation keeps the world at peace - as long as world leaders see the scales of the choice between maintaining trade and starting a war tilted toward trade, the world is a better place. Fossil fuels for transport and coal burning in China likely contributes the most massive amounts to global pollution. Thus innovation in nuclear would be massive, and improvements in battery storage would increase the utility of seasonal renewables as well as electric transport. Humans are benevolent when they are fed, warm, and secure. The most important effective innovation keeps humans from getting on each other’s throats.
- bcrosby95 3y ago> Globalisation keeps the world at peace - as long as world leaders see the scales of the choice between maintaining trade and starting a war tilted toward trade, the world is a better place. Kinda. It also means certain in-countries can do whatever they want to certain out-countries.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThe collapse of this network is a very real scenario for the collapse of civilization. When the power plant can't get a spare part, because the shipping truck can't get gas, because the pump in the gas station doesn't have electricity. - and on and on. The entire infrastructure of the world is intertwined. During the last two years I was on projects where one single part could no longer be sourced, and it held up millions of dollars of other inputs. It doesn't take everything collapsing, it only takes just enough.
- HPsquared 3y agoCOVID at least made people think about these things, but we have a long way to go.
- bumby 3y agoThe book “lights out” gives an eye-opening look at this in terms of the electrical grid. Apparently, there are many transformers that can only be manufactured by a couple overseas manufacturers, sometimes with 18+ month lead times. And some of the infrastructure needed to deliver these parts (e.g., railways) don’t even exist anymore.
- RandomLensman 3y agoThe ability to improvise or produce locally (and in limited quantities) is not as poor as often made out (in particular because you throw away the rule book). Doesn't mean some specific things would not be difficult to get. Also, even in wars with heavy and broad destruction there wasn't a collapse of civilization.
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoThe global trade market is much older & stable then we think. Already in the 1600’s the Dutch figured out it was more efficient to import grains from Eastern Europe. And focus on agriculture fitting to the land. Napoleon, Hitler, Stalin came along. And some bad years during the war. But essentially the Dutch haven’t produced one of their main staple foods for the last 400 years.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoMaking grains is a basically three steps. Making carbon fiber weave is three hundred steps. We are in a complexity crisis and almost no one sees it. There isn’t a human on earth that could single handedly remake a factory that produces high quality carbon prepreg sheets. We made world massively complex, but humans are absolutely no smarter than 10,000 years ago. This is extra bad for our below average types. The kid working at Jiffy Lube flurry years ago could be competent at that, he had to know three oil filter styles, and four oils. Now, his generational equivalent has to know so much more and do it while globally connected to an attention-addiction.
- klabb3 3y agoCan’t China start a new Cold War pretty easily? Any other country China sanctions, even the US, would be crippled. China would suffer retaliatory sanctions too of course, but it seems like they’d be able to weather such a storm much easier than anyone else. Or is this too simplified?
- throwuwu 3y agoChina is not independent for the inputs both material and capital to those industrial processes. They also are not able to consume all they produce so a vast majority of their outputs would dry up if they were to start a trade war.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoChina kind of needs that trade surplus of ~$1T, more than all the other countries need that equal but opposite trade deficit.
- Cacti 3y agoCCP member nervous they will get dragged out into the street by angry, unemployed, unmarried 20-30 year old men
- speed_spread 3y agoCCP will start a war just to give those guys something to do. It's all explained in Dead Kennedy's excellent "Kinky Sex Makes the World Go Round"
- goalieca 3y ago> Or is this too simplified? China’s economy is not too strong in fact and they have few allies with strong economies or militaries.
- OJFord 3y agoI think this paragraph from the OP addresses that pretty well: > One obvious takeaway from the paper: whoa, America is far more reliant on China than it thought. But actually this underplays the complexity. Think back to our Brandauer electrode. The chances are that it was made of metals which were originally refined in China (I’m guessing here, but given China is the world’s biggest metal refiner this is not implausible). Those metals were then shipped to the UK where they were turned into the micron-accurate electrodes I saw being turned out of the machines in Birmingham. Then they were shipped back to another factory, probably in China, where they were put inside a rear view mirror. Now I'm not saying China's not capable of manufacturing that electrode, probably of the 45% not made by Brandauer some or all are from China anyway, but the point is it shows the kind of disruption it would cause to any country. Some like China less than others like the UK, sure, but still disruption. Globalisation isn't quite 'we all get everything from China now'.
- Tiereven 3y agoThis is why I want to see micro-fabrication become ubiquitous. I believe a massive economic revolution that vastly improves our world is possible. I think this is a world where smaller manufacturers can compete with giant foundries, but it depends on 1) automation of small-scale raw-resource production (mining, plant materials, or even better yet, recycling for raw resources.) 2) a massive investment in micro-fabricator processes (not just 3-d printing, but modular and high-quality output of formed metals, textiles and even electronics that doesn't require hours of mucking with calibration.) 3) Replacing business-to-business-only networks with a blurred business-to-business-or-consumer one, where locally produced materials can be just-in-time committed, produced and shipped to either customers, small, in-situ manufacturers or repairmen, or even another manufacturer for advanced finishing of intermediate goods.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoThe process of mining, to ore, to refining to sponge to billet or extrusion is not something you are going to do in your garage. If we JUST look at aluminum… it’s mined in places like Australia, Chinese companies then ship it to Iceland for refining on tankers because of cheap electricity, then back across the world to china where it made into powder/sponge at basically one Chinese city, where then it may be turned into billet, shipped across ocean again to USA maybe through Panama to the east coast where a company gets it in, then CNC machines it into some low tier product that is destined for a landfill but markets it as a made in USA widget. Between the fact that this metal was handled and shipped across the world two or three times… the regulation and necessarily environmentally dirty processes are just not happening in the USA. We have regulated ourselves into the most unearned environmentally “conscious” position. The fact that we have people controlling narrative about climate change and they aren’t pushing to deregulate in order to move production away from China is all anyone with experience in manufacturing needs to know on this “debate”. You let me know when “Greta” Co is pushing to make the world less reliant on China in order to not just mask the environmental costs of production.
- ricardobeat 3y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/1027795/europe-primary-aluminum-production-by-country/#:~:text=In%202021%2C%20Russia%20was%20the,3.9%20million%20metric%20tons%20produced https://www.statista.com/statistics/1027795/europe-primary-a....
- alberth 3y agoWork From Home (WFH) One thing WFH advocates fail to recognize is that, if companies embrace it - now they have the ability to replace super high paying US based WFH employees with low cost WFH (anywhere in the world employee). WFM advocates don’t realize that they are effectively advocating for offshoring their own job.
- pylua 3y agoThere has to be labor protections for us employees and us companies or companies that do business here must adhere to it. After all, I cannot just get a visa to go live in India, even though I might be able to have more material wealth there just based on the power of the dollar. The U.S. citizen is at an inherit disadvantage due to other countries not being as friendly with the visa. US government should also be careful about increasing the wealth of countries not in the us sphere of influence.
- lagniappe 3y agoWouldn't that be WFH?
- dvngnt_ 3y agooff shoring isn't new but it also isn't easy to do well depending on the position
- sillysaurusx 3y agoHear, hear. You know where I’d like to offshore my job? Literally anywhere other than Missouri, where I live. WFH means I can participate in companies that do important work without having to move my family away from their family. If that means I get replaced by a talented hacker from India someday, the tradeoff is still far north of worth it.
- alberth 3y agoAnd someone living in Columbia or Peru, which is approx same timezone as Missouri, who make literally 1/10th the wage of someone in Missouri … now has the ability to get your job. Be careful for what you wish for, is all I’m saying. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_countries_by_monthly_average_wage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_countries_b...