7 ms·
RIP Google Groups Dejanews.com Archive?
- fifticon 3y agoand google continues their efforts to convince me to never rely on one of their products :-/
- rjgonza 3y agoHow come, is dejanews.com being gone due to some failure of/at Google groups?
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoGoogle owned dejanews.com
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoIn the last year or so they sold Domains from underneath without warning. They also apparently changed the settings on two older Gmail accounts to make them inaccessible. I kept those accounts around because they had a maiden name and other services tied to them, I know for a fact at least one of them has an alternative contact email. There's no information on recovery and no way to contact anybody. Maybe it's just timing, but, it feels like in the last year or so, things have especially been going downhill with them and there have been more Google related fires to fight. As a result, I've moved my team off Workspaces and I'm winding down that Google org. And no, Google, I'm not signing up for YouTube Premium. I previously thought things were decoupled decently from Google and enough fallbacks were in place, but now I see the company as a clear risk and am doing everything I can to avoid it.
- yetanotherloss 3y agoOut of curiosity what are you moving to? Ended up moving to gsuite because it was relatively stable some years ago until the domains thing but hasn't boiled over into a problem I needed to deal with imminently.
- jsnell 3y agoWere you actually affected by this somehow? Because, you know, this page had been nothing but a redirect to Google Groups for 22 years. That seems plenty of time for people to update their bookmarks. If you weren't affected, this doesn't really sound like an argument made in good faith.
- ketchupdog 3y agoFortunately, the person you were responding to wasn't making a bad faith argument, or even arguing at all, but was rather expressing a common opinion based on anticipating entirely predictable behavior.
- jsnell 3y agoWhy would that be any better? You still seem to be saying that comment had nothing to do with the submission, and is something commonly on HN. In fact so often that one can easily predict that it'll be spammed to any post about Google. Something predictable and boring is not the good kind of HN comment. It's an even worse comment when nothing was killed in this instance as far as I can tell. The headline is just a total fabrication. Nothing had been hosted on that URL for 22 years except a 302 redirect. The archive is just as functional (or non-functional) as it had been for the last two decades. But maybe I'm wrong about that. Maybe something did use to work for the OP and was broken recently.
- squarefoot 3y agoRegarding Usenet, I was convinced to never trust Google anymore the day they removed the discussion search filter from the search engine, which happened roughly 10 years ago. Before that date one could search for people discussing products or services, while after that day one would be inundated by a pile of pages selling those products or services. They first removed the filter from the main page, but kept it reachable through the search URL, then completely removed the functionality, although people were already complaining. It wouldn't cost them a dime to keep it; that was a deliberate move to direct users searches from community forums to commercial pages. https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-filters-gone-17993.html https://www.seroundtable.com/google-search-filters-gone-1799...
- thevagrant 3y agoIs there any alternative archive?
- bobsmooth 3y agoI can't imagine being a historian in 100 trying to piece together history from a largely forgotten internet. Whole forums that shaped me as a person have been lost to time. Archive.org helps, and there are individuals with site rips on aging hard drives, but I'd bet more information has been lost in the past 10 years than all of human history has created before it.
- mcherm 3y agoEvery single conversation before 1859 between any 2 individuals who were not literate has been lost. While I decry the unnecessary loss of this record (which Google maliciously chose not to offer to archivists, knowing full well that archivists would choose to preserve them if given the opportunity), we are actually living in the BEST recorded era of history, because only now have certain kinds of preservation become possible.
- tekchip 3y agoCould you expand some more on this? Short of active curation of small segments of online, deemed important, snapshots kept alive by constant maintenance (I wonder what the internet archives drive failure rates look like), there isn't a digital medium readily available (to the masses) yet that can survive 100+ years while also storing a meaningful amount of information. There are research efforts like Microsofts crystal thing. But so far no real winners.
- Kye 3y agoNot the person you replied to, but: Documents rarely survive just by being physically durable. They survive first by people making an effort to preserve them. Deja News might be the most complete archive, but it's not the only effort to preserve Usenet. For example: https://archive.org/details/archiveteam-googlegroups https://archive.org/details/archiveteam-googlegroups It's a roundabout way to do it, but probably includes enough context on what's missing for a historian to dig into other archives to find it. History is like RAID: given enough parity information, you can reconstruct much of what's missing. That's how we know so many lost texts exist, and occasionally find them: stuff we do have references them and sometimes offers clues on where to find it. Digital information in particular benefits from getting smaller relative to available storage size. Running a Usenet server used to be a huge financial burden. Now I could hold most of it on a keychain. This makes replicating it across the planet to resist the chaos of human nature easier. It might die in one place, but it's also somewhere else. It would take a world-ending event to wipe out anything you might find in /r/DataHoarder.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oofoe 3y agoWas there not a huge archeological effort by people all over the place to resurrect old backups and older servers so that the news archive could be complete? Lovingly retrieved, curated and donated because DejaNews was going to be "forever". I realize that breathless reviews of "Small Wonder" and 40 line Boba Fett .sigs may not be the wisdom of the ages, but it's still an important part of the history of the Internet.
- dn3500 3y agoYes, the UTZOO Wiseman Usenet Archive. It was on IA for a while but has been forced underground for legal reasons. You can still find copies pretty easily. https://archive.org/details/utzoo-wiseman-usenet-archive https://archive.org/details/utzoo-wiseman-usenet-archive
- rwmj 3y agoIs there a Torrent of that somewhere so we can keep it alive?
- logifail 3y agoThere's a .torrent file listed under https://archive.org/download/utzoo-wiseman-usenet-archive/ https://archive.org/download/utzoo-wiseman-usenet-archive/ but I've not [yet] looked at it...
- IAmNotACellist 3y agoUnfortunately that only contains the index ('listing.txt') and not the content
- golem14 3y ago""" In 2020 after sustained legal demands requesting a set of messages within the Usenet Archive be redacted, and to avoid further costs and accusations of manipulation should those demands be met, the archive has been removed from this URL and is not currently accessible to the public. Included in this item is a file listing and the md5 sums of the removed files, for the use of others in verifying they have original materials. """
- altdataseller 3y agoI remember the good ole days when I discovered I could actually talk with like minded fans about anime in alt.fan.dragonball (AFD). monkeigh, tazer, Naa, MiraiMatt, JimboChiu, MattBlue. I still remember all their screen names
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoWhat I miss from those early days is the complete lack of profiles. People really were just screen names, there were no user profiles. Often one didn’t learn more about one’s fellows unless one arranged to meet up in real life (which was a thing back then). When people could not insist on a particular demographic identity or political wing, no one was looking for personal validation and discussion remained limited to the subject of the fora. Consequently, ideological battle was limited, and while flame wars were common, they usually involved nerd minutiae instead of society-wide polemics. Compare this to later social media, where it has been taken to extremes: I’ve seen Mastodon users whose profiles are a long list of their gender identity, sexual preference, furriness, autism or mental afflictions (officially diagnosed or self-diagnosed), favored political party, and COVID masking status, and in discussion of any topic we are supposed to consider all this.
- aaomidi 3y ago> When people could not insist on a particular demographic identity or political wing I’m not sure if your memory is playing tricks on you or what, but politics has basically always been a part of these forums once the internet shed its “nerd” status. Heck, extremist politics found a safe place for itself in many of internets early forums.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoThe politics I remember from the early internet was idealism about alternative approaches, like libertarianism or communism of whatever stripe. Such internet-nerd politics were usually divorced from what was actually going on in mainstream politics, and therefore there wasn’t the exhausting, unescapable partisan squabble as found on social media today.
- m0d0nne11 3y agoUSENET did, obviously, have a lot of garbage but it was manageable, contained boggling amounts of valuable info and nobody (yet) "owned" it. Now, with The Great Enshittification of the Internet nearly complete, USENET's loss is just that much more painful because it could have been prevented.
- LightBug1 3y agoThe End of History? ...
- raxi 3y agoIt is down for many years already and no one spotted.
- jl6 3y agoDid something get announced? The search interface at groups.google.com still seems to work. (Well, it works as well as its modern incarnation ever did. It’s been some time since there was a way to cleanly browse a newsgroup using Google Groups).
- layer8 3y agoI’m a bit confused. According to the Wayback Machine, dejanews.com already redirected to groups.google.com for many years, similar to how www.dejanews.com still does. So they just dropped the redirect from the plain domain without “www.”?
- grepfru_it 3y agoThe domain apex has always been a problem for hosting companies. Since the apex domain is usually overloaded (TXT SPF MX records etc) it’s very easy for the A record to be modified or lost unintentionally. It’s almost a breath of fresh air to see such an old solved problem (you do run a cmdb right?) appear again even if temporarily
- jvolkman 3y agoSeems like the content is still there? Here's me getting smacked down as a kid for asking for warez: https://groups.google.com/g/alt.games.doom/c/RrzQBjHIa6k/m/QBn-fDzymIsJ https://groups.google.com/g/alt.games.doom/c/RrzQBjHIa6k/m/Q...
- godber 3y agoHaha, thanks for sharing!
- sandyarmstrong 3y agoYou are a brave soul. I can't bring myself to share my pathetic early teenage exploits on Usenet. Hexen was awesome though. :-)
- coremoff 3y agoFWIW I think nightdive studios are planning on remaking that next (following their System Shock 1 remake)
- kstrauser 3y agoYou should have replied that their sig was unnecessarily huge and was clogging the servers more than you did. Most of what I know about online knife-fight arguing came from Usenet.
- jbverschoor 3y agoWell, it’s a great source to train your LLM. It makes a lot of sense to hide it from competitors
- gjvc 3y agowe need usenet back
- WillAdams 3y agoYeah, the closest thing to it is Reddit, and that's nowhere near egalitarian enough.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoUsenet was all about longform text. People posting to it were seated comfortably at a chair and typing on a keyboard. Reddit is today mainly browsed by people on their phones, a medium that discourages longform text no matter how much people claim to be just as proficient on a touchscreen keyboard as a real one. Moreover, Reddit’s redesign discourages substantial discussion, and even if one chooses to use old.reddit.com, you still suffer from the overall culture of the site being set by the new interface.
- crtasm 3y agoNothing to stop a subreddit running a bot to enforce minimum post length and detect obvious attempts at padding to bypass it, I guess? The effects of the UI are still a problem though as you say. I view reddit less as a site, more a collection of lots of subs that vary a lot in how they feel.
- ok123456 3y agoHow about forum software that enforces that top-level comments must be at least 500 characters, and replies need to be at least 140 characters? Also, enforce a max thread depth of 7. Anything past that is usually bickering.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoMods on any decently popular subreddits will tell you that they feel limited in what rules they can enforce. Reddit users get used to the sitewide culture, so if they come onto a subreddit and run up against strange rules, they hassle the mods. I’ve seen whole mobs, drawing in even the sub’s regulars, harangue mods as “gatekeepers”, with few or none standing up for the traditional rules. Also, I’m not sure if it was true or a conspiracy theory, but I recall once hearing that mods of the most popular subs cannot institute any rules that would reduce “engagement” (and thereby profit), as Reddit would then replace them.
- alberth 3y agoIt’s been this way for 20+ years. > Google Groups became operational in February 2001, following Google's acquisition of Deja's Usenet archive. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups
- dragontamer 3y ago> The requested URL / was not found on this server. That’s all we know. This is the part people are talking about. This all could just be a weekend glitch that's fixed on Monday or Tuesday this week. I wouldn't leap to the conclusion of this title without an announcement from Google.
- reidrac 3y agoOnly mildly related but I'm using Eternal September to follow a handful of newsgroups and the spam I see in those come from Gmail accounts via Google Groups. I wonder of it would be better if Google was out of Usenet completely instead of not completely caring.
- shever73 3y agoI use Eternal September too. I wish that there was another archive of Usenet. Google’s “stewardship” of it has been predictably disastrous.
- StableAlkyne 3y agoMy conspiracy theory is that they bought it to kill Usenet. Search is their business, and users going to Usenet (which you can't exactly search without an archive) instead of a forum on the web hurts business. So they bought DejaNews and slapped a deliberately bad UI onto it. And as every ISP dropped Usenet, people were told "Go to Google Groups to keep talking." And because the UX was outright worse than the newsreaders they had been using (no killfiles, no moderation for spam, etc), people left for forums.
- Projectiboga 3y agoThe ISPs all dropped USENET when NY AG Coumo strong armed several ISPs to drop Usenet Binaries for the made up reason of Child Porn. The tell was he wanted them to drop all binaries not just the 'adult' ones. He was running for Governor, which is why I felt it was a publicity stunt and a favor to big media, who didn't want to litigate about Usenet due to the complexity and the existing case law.
- StableAlkyne 3y agoThe worst part about the whole thing is they could have just dropped the binary groups and kept the text groups. By dropping all of Usenet, they killed most of the discussion and effectively handed it to the binaries users. In doing so, they created an environment where most people using Usenet were doing it to pirate stuff, and those users had already moved to private providers who could afford the bandwidth. Nowadays all you get when you search for Usenet providers are folks dedicated to binaries. Piracy won and smothered out discussion in the process. Even the Usenet sub on Reddit is just discussions that toe the line on Reddit's piracy rules. The only text-only provider I'm still aware of is Eternal-September. I've heard of SDF offering newsgroups as well but I haven't looked into it.
- willtemperley 3y agoMarl the Marginal User strikes again. https://nothinghuman.substack.com/p/the-tyranny-of-the-marginal-user https://nothinghuman.substack.com/p/the-tyranny-of-the-margi...
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoGonna have to call foul on everyone not including an ObHack in this thread.
- spandextwins 3y ago[dead]
- brudgers 3y agoCultural vandalism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups#Google_Groups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups#Google_Groups
- WalterBright 3y agoNNTP still survives. The D language forums are based on NNTP. It's nice to have forums that are text only (no emojis), no signatures, no ads, no fat borders, etc. I also wrote an archiver for it that creates static web pages out of the threads.
- layer8 3y agoHow does text-only imply no emojis?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 3y agoThey don't get recognized and replaced with a cartoon image.
- yason 3y agoUnicode has code points for emojis. You can just use those and they will show up as images, given proper encoding such as utf-8.
- wolverine876 3y agoAlso nice for lightning responsiveness and threaded conversations. It's as if News has everything I want in a forum and nothing else.
- zeruch 3y agoI still recall trying to recruit one of the dejanews SREs to come work at my then employer (VA Linux) to now avail. A couple of months later he was a Googler.
- gandalfian 3y agoThe terrible irony is now nobody reads Usenet because of the spam. But people continue to endlessly automatically spam because Usenet is picked up by web indexers like Google who read the spam links. So Google dejanews has killed the very thing it valued. The machines have taken over and pushed out the humans.
- thom 3y agoThis gave me a sudden panic, but no - it's all still there in Google Groups, enough teenage angst and purple prose to roll my eyes back in my head with such force that I temporarily tumbled back in time. I don't know if Usenet or IRC were really significant, compared to the social media of today. Certainly there were more nooks and crannies in which to hide, more corners you could call your own. But that's also what growing up feels like. That park bench where maybe you had your first kiss and it was once the entire universe, that's really just a place for people to sit, it means nothing. That small place you loved can't exist anymore because you're bigger, you see a broader horizon, you admit others. You can never fit yourself back down into that little, sheltered place, and you blame the places you inhabit now for being too open and noisy. Growing up is being messy, incoherent, disappointed. There's no medium that can take you back to the clarity of youth.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]