10 ms·
Universal UI search is great, and at this point it should be present in all but the simplest applications. I first saw it introduced in Google Docs, and it's pr
by crazygringo 3y ago
Universal UI search is great, and at this point it should be present in all but the simplest applications. I first saw it introduced in Google Docs, and it's precisely for things you suspect exist, but it's not even remotely clear which menu, submenu, or dialog it's in. (Apple OS Settings is another great example of it.)
E.g., you want to apply a hanging indent in Docs? Just type "hanging" into the menu search, and it shows "Indentation options". It's smart enough to know that hanging indentation is an option within the dialog that shows up there. And the menu search seems to have a large range of synonyms, so typing "picture" brings up lots of "insert image" choices.
But it bothers me that even in Docs, almost nobody knows about menu search because it's hidden under the "Help" menu, rather than being a nice prominent rounded search box in the upper-right corner like you'd expect.
Menus are great for discoverability (so do not get rid of them), but frequently you know what an application can or cannot do (e.g. you assume a word processor can do hanging indents or watermarks), but you don't know where exactly it lurks in the menus or which tab of the settings dialog, and don't want to waste two minutes hunting for it.
It's time for a universal search box to exist in every major desktop application. Apple and Microsoft really need to take the lead here to provide standard API's and UX components for this, and it saddens me that they haven't, and continue to show no signs of interest.
- psd1 3y agoMy first exposure to command search was in VSCode, so there's that
- jonhohle 3y agomacOS has had the ability to search menus for what seems like a decade. It should be a feature of the toolkit, not something apps need to implement themselves. This doesn’t extend to other UI elements (like System Prefs/Settings), but I agree that it should (and again, should be a toolkit feature).
- crazygringo 3y ago> macOS has had the ability to search menus for what seems like a decade. Wow, TIL. Talk about a hidden feature. So it turns out it's under the "Help" menu, and it just says "Search". I had always assumed that this searched help topics, not menus. But it's also pretty miminal, seemingly without support for synonyms or features inside of dialog boxes -- e.g. if you type "pref" it won't find "Settings". It also doesn't have a keyboard shortcut to trigger it (like Docs). So I think there's still a long way to go to make it a central UX feature.
- cdcarter 3y agoCmd-Shift-/ triggers the macOS help search in any normal app. Easy as pie.
- DonHopkins 3y agoBut not as easy, efficient, or self revealing as pie menus! ;) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37907449 >The whole point of pie menus is to be "self revealing", supporting discoverability and browsing and prompting and gently training users to quickly use the gestures without looking, through rehearsal. They solve the problem of gestures being invisible and impossible to discover and learn. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pie_menu >>Pie menus are a self-revealing gestural interface: they display multiple options to a user and direct them to select one. >>Users operate the menu by observing the labels or icons present as options, moving the pointer in the desired direction, then clicking to make a selection. This action is called a "mark ahead" ("mouse ahead" in the case of a mouse, "wave ahead" in the case of a dataglove). >>Repetition of actions and memorization of the interface further simplify the user experience. Pie menus take advantage of the body's ability to remember muscle motion and direction, even when the mind has forgotten the corresponding symbolic labels.[1] >However Apple has never adopted pie menus, Steve Jobs thought they sucked, and Donald Norman has never been a big fan, and he totally missed the point when I tried to explain it to him at Ted Selker's NPUC workshop. >I had the honor of meeting Steve Jobs at EduCom on October 25 1988, when he released the NeXT machine. Sun had lent me a workstation to demonstrate NeWS software in their booth, right across from the NeXT booth, and Ben Shneideman brought him over for a demo of the stuff we'd developed at HCIL. >So I gave Jobs a whirlwind tour of pie menus, the NeWS window system, UniPress Emacs and HyperTIES for about half an hour. Jobs was jumping up and down, pointing at the screen, and yelling "That sucks! That sucks! Wow, that's neat! That sucks!" >When I explained to him how flexible NeWS was, he replied "I don't need flexibility -- I got my window system right the first time!" But I gave him a NeRD button, anyway (which I'd made for NeWS window system NeRDs, but he liked because it had a lowercase "e" like NeXT). [...] The GIMP developers are even more stubborn and insular-minded than Steve Jobs, but with absolutely none of the design skills, visionary creativity, empathy for users, or obsession with usability.
- maven29 3y agoUbuntu Unity DE used to offer this for all GTK apps through the HUD. You could hit alt and type to get to the menu item you need. Gnome turned out to be a poorly thought-out opinionated mess, learning all the wrong lessons from Apple's work.
- heavyset_go 3y agoIn Plasma Desktop, you can do the same thing by hitting CTRL+ALT+I, or by setting up your own shortcut to trigger the Command Bar feature.
- stuaxo 3y agoSomeone added this to Gtk 2 and 3 apps, but the mechanism if used isn't there in Gtk 4.
- benhurmarcel 3y ago> But it bothers me that even in Docs, almost nobody knows about menu search because it's hidden under the "Help" menu, rather than being a nice prominent rounded search box in the upper-right corner like you'd expect. They changed it recently. Now it’s a nice prominent rounded search box in the upper-left corner.
- crazygringo 3y agoThanks -- I've never seen it, so I got curious. Just tried zooming way out in my browser, and it shows up once my browser zoom is down to 75%. It does appear, but only when there's already space for every other toolbar button already -- so only on larger screens, not 13" laptops. But it does turn into a magnifying-glass icon even on smaller screens. I just never thought to click it -- I would have guessed it would bring up a zoom menu or something. (The ever-present confusion around when magnifying glasses mean search, find, or zoom...) It's progress!
- heavyset_go 3y agoOn Linux, Plasma users can do this in KDE apps by hitting CTRL+ALT+I to launch the Command Bar. Menus in Qt and GTK apps can be exported over D-Bus, allowing for desktop environments, or 3rd party HUDs, to implement menu search bars, as well.