8 ms·
I've never understood why restaurants themselves don't charge for prime-time reservations. If scalpers can do it, the restaurant can too. Because let's be hone
by crazygringo 3y ago
I've never understood why restaurants themselves don't charge for prime-time reservations. If scalpers can do it, the restaurant can too.
Because let's be honest -- dining at certain highly exclusive restaurants on a Friday night is just as much of an event as going to the theater. These aren't neighborhood restaurants with average food that are meant for locals that we're talking about here. These are fancy. If you want to eat at 7 pm on Friday, why shouldn't it be more expensive than Tuesday at 5 pm?
And if restaurant owners don't want to take advantage, they can always offset it by lowering the food and drink prices slightly the whole week long. (Not that they're obligated to -- making a profit is already hard enough as is.)
- richiebful1 3y agoI've been to a restaurant that already does this: pay $X a head, with that dollar amount applied to your bill. I want to say one of the big restaurant POS providers (maybe Toast) provided the infrastructure behind it.
- jahnu 3y agoI read POS as something angry before I read Point Of Sale!
- hooverd 3y agoIf you've worked food service or retail those are interchangeable.
- barbazoo 3y ago> with that dollar amount applied to your bill that's smart, that way you get tricked into including yet another line item in your tip
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThey mean the deposit to reserve goes toward purchasing whatever you buy to eat.
- bombcar 3y agoMany bars and such already basically do this - they call it "happy hour" and it's often a whole afternoon until the rush.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah, I often like eating earlier and in some places, happy hour can be a really good deal. Just ate at my standard pre-theater place a couple nights ago that has $1 oysters--which I love but hate spending $3 each on.
- brewdad 3y ago$3 is cheap. I just paid $3.75 each in Seattle and that was a discount compared to what some of the nicer/more touristy places in town wanted.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah. I'm sort of amazed this place still has them at that price. Surely it's a loss leader to get people in at Happy Hour. (This is Massachusetts.) Works for me though. While I otherwise like the place well enough I'd probably be going somewhere else absent the happy hour oysters.
- heisenbit 3y agoIn my city in Germany they are now doing exactly that - no show must pay. While there is no flood of bots we have trade fairs and too many people hosting a group guests started reserving seats in Chinese, Italian, Steak etc. restaurants to later offer their guest a last minute choice.
- barbazoo 3y ago> no show must pay Out of curiosity, how does that work? When making a reservation do you have to provide your credit card? I highly doubt that given that it's Germany :) Seriously though, how do they make people pay?
- ducklingquack 3y agoExactly that: “Please provide your card to complete the booking”. I was so pissed about it I signed up for Revolut (for their single-use cards). Funnily enough, restaurants that force you to do this are neither the best nor especially highly rated.
- lxgr 3y agoHow would a single-use card help? In my experience, restaurants taking deposits will actually charge the deposit to the card at the time you are making the reservation and credit it towards the final check amount if you do show up.
- brewdad 3y agoI’ve seen it both ways. For larger parties most places near me charge upfront. For couples or parties up to 4 the charge hits 48 hours before your reservation or whatever the cutoff happens to be. In one case, I did have to get the bill adjusted because the restaurant forgot the credit our deposit. I think it was an honest mistake since we’ve never had a problem there in half a dozen other visits and it’s only for parties over 8 that they charge the deposit. Seeing as the whole place only seats about 40, they don’t get many large parties.
- bradleyjg 3y agoMany people get mad if these things are made too explicit.
- akoboldfrying 3y agoYou hit the nail on the head.
- justinlkarr 3y agoI think this is actually common now. I'm often asked to make a deposit on a reservation when using Resy. I'm not aware that there is variable or dynamic pricing component to it, however. That's a great idea and something I bet they are considering. In practice, dynamic pricing it is not a panacea. You still need to beat the arbitrage market. Charge too much: customers don't reserve. Charge too little: brokers snap it up.
- eternauta3k 3y agoAuction them off :)
- 1_1xdev1 3y agoOn Resy, at least, there is not dynamic pricing (though, in theory, restaurants can apply different deposit/cancel fees to different "reservation types", or different days. But nothing dynamic based on demand or anything)
- justinlkarr 3y agoThis is interesting. Are there restaurants doing this kind of variable pricing? I bet there are some eager GMs thinking about it.
- nurple 3y agoMost restaurants will have a cheaper menu for lunch than for dinner. Nice places will usually have different menus, but many just serve the same for simplicity and cost.
- bmmayer1 3y agoI can speak to this! I was "canceled" in 2014...before it was cool...for doing exactly this[0] A couple reasons restaurants don't do this: 1) Loss of quality control over customer experience. For example they provide a $100 dinner, but the client expects a $200 dinner. That creates bad experience 2) Desire to maintain accessibility on price point (same reasons artists don't charge more for tickets) and perceived inequities of charging extra for reservations 3) Rewarding loyal customers who value the food / brand / hospitality rather than the highest bidder which tends to bring in out-of-towners, Amex centurion card holders, wannabe influencers -- people that don't help create loyalty There are many other reasons I'm sure as well. Most chefs/GMs/owners I talked to at the time emphasized that they sincerely are not in this for the money, and yes, they like to make a living, but being able to build a community of food lovers who are passionate about their brand is what they really care about. I ended up pivoting to try to build a shift management app soon thereafter...didn't work out but a good entrepreneurship lesson! [0]https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/03/everyone-seems-mad-at-reservation-hop-founder-admits-he-was-taken-aback-by-the-criticism/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/03/everyone-seems-mad-at-rese...
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThese reasons seem to only apply if the surcharge applied to every reservation? Could only charging for peak times cause these downsides?
- sumtechguy 3y agoThere is another way. It involves no money and nothing for the restaurant to do. First come first serve. Basically you want in. Show up and stand in line.
- touisteur 3y agoMany places in Paris do that now with virtual waiting line (show up, get a number and an ETA, get bipped when it's about to be your turn...). Nice when in a walkable nice neighborhood.
- paxys 3y agoPlenty of high end restaurants in the city do this. The problem is that it usually makes things worse. If I want to book a dinner, and the restaurant has something like a $200 non-refundable deposit, I'm going to think long and hard before committing because my plans can always change. A bot on the other hand wouldn't hesitate because they can turn around and sell the reservation to anyone they want. The deposit is simply a cost of doing business for them.
- koolba 3y ago> A bot on the other hand wouldn't hesitate because they can turn around and sell the reservation to anyone they want. The deposit is simply a cost of doing business for them. If the spot itself is actually worth $200 then the restaurant was forgoing that per seat and suddenly made $5000+ per day. No restaurant is going to pass up $1.8M of “free” revenue. Either the seats are worth the price or they’re not.
- paxys 3y agoIt isn't free revenue. The deposit is applied to the final bill.
- koolba 3y agoIt’s free revenue if it’s not transferable.
- paxys 3y agoIf you mean restaurants need to start checking everyone's ID at the door to ensure the names on the reservations match then no, no one wants that.
- jrockway 3y agoI'm fine with that. They should do it for concerts, too. A little bit of inconvenience is often better than paying market price; you can easily fill every restaurant in the city every night with people that make more money than me.
- spyder 3y agoOne of the reason is mentioned in the article: "When guests drop $100 or more just to walk in the door, “people have [the] wrong expectation when they come” he says because those expectations might be unreasonably high."
- sva_ 3y ago> I've never understood why restaurants themselves don't charge for prime-time reservations. If scalpers can do it, the restaurant can too. Some do charge something like $50 for the reservation. And if you can't come because there is a major blizzard in the city, tough luck ...
- wenc 3y agoI think Tock tried to do dynamic pricing for tables. (Tock was founded by Nick Kokonas a former Chicago mercantile exchange trader and co owner of Chicago-based Alinea). Alinea also has other ways to prevent no shows like selling tickets etc. Tablz from Toronto does dynamic pricing.
- websap 3y agoWell artists do charge differently for different areas of the venue. One could argue that prime time dinner is equivalent to watching Louis CK from the first few rows.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI thought "Lunch Menu" and "Dinner Menu" were a way to reasonably implement precisely that. On the other hand if it gets more granular... there may be no winning. Budget-conscious will feel they're being priced-out, and the fancy-rich will not go to a restaurant that nickle-and-dimes / seems desperate for every last cent.
- mmanfrin 3y agoI literally built this for OpenTable.
- 1_1xdev1 3y agoResy's original business model, too (though they worked with the restaurants directly)
- steveBK123 3y agoI’ve thought the same in NY for a while. Any reasonably popular spot is now gates by an obnoxious reservation system like resy. I have to check every Tuesday at midnight for the 5 minutes that the next weeks tables open up before they are booked. Then I have to put down a credit card. Next I get bombarded with push notifications and texts with increasing urgency leading up to dinner that I must show up on time or forfeit money. When I show up on time they don’t seat me but suggest I go wait at bar and buy drinks. Finally they seat me and remind me I only have the table 90 minutes. You know what, just charge me for seats. Let’s just go completely nakedly economic because you’re already 90% there with extra steps in the way. It is called the hospitality industry but you’d never know it given what the dining experience has turned into.
- el_nahual 3y ago> Finally they seat me and remind me I only have the table 90 minutes. As someone that lives in Mexico City where dinners (and lunches!) easily last 3, 4 or even 5 hours this sounds horrifically demeaning.
- steveBK123 3y agoI've been to places that are clearly managing their service to hit that 90 minute mark too. Over the top pestering to get your orders in the second your but hits the seat.. coming back to upsell you more drinks at the 20/40min mark, and then completely disappearing from about the 55min mark onwards so you can't put in a dessert order.
- whelp_24 3y agoI mean if it's really just that in demand, isn't this just waiting in line?
- timbo1642 3y ago[flagged]
- rootsudo 3y agoMany places do have a booking fee and then grant it as immediate credit. $20 booking fee, $20 in credit for drinks and whatnot. It isn’t a new idea. Free outside hours, booking fee with credit during prime time.
- kenhwang 3y agoMy friends actually had a startup that did exactly this and had pretty great initial success. Restaurants could pick how much they charged for reservations, whether that cost could be applied to a portion of the bill, or whether it was a straight up auction for spots. They thought there would be pushback from customers, but the customer feedback was excellent. The friction mostly came from the restaurants. They either had antiquated reservation systems (many on pen and paper) and didn't like the idea of letting software control their table planning (since free reservations could be cancelled on the spot on the whim by the serving staff but cancelling a paid slot really irked everyone). Or poor accounting practices that made it really hard for them to accept that a customer already prepaid $500 for a meal in another system that'll all be bundled in a big check later. Or that they couldn't be sketchy about customer tips if it's being tracked. It was also difficult to scale the business quickly because every restaurant had to be trained and onboarded individually, and every restaurant had an unicorn of an operation that the software had to be able to handle.
- philwelch 3y agoAren’t these the same restaurants where you can get a table by tipping the maitre d? Or did that stop being a thing in the last ten years?
- wodenokoto 3y agoHigh end restaurants in Denmark (like Noma) will charge you the full course at reservation time. No backsies
- whelp_24 3y agoDoes this really sound like an ethical practice to you? This doesn't benefit customers at all. Especially if it is already expensive, why make it more expensive?
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoWeirdly enough restaurants don't want reservations. They want long lines. That way they create a situation where you SEE how popular a place is. A line is much easier to see than a date dropdown that is booked out for 2 months. It's also easier to keep the restaurant full. A full reservation where not everybody shows up might cause empty tables. A long line fixes that.