7 ms·
US Air Force's new B-21 Raider "flying wing" bomber takes first flight
- anovikov 3y agoA rare example of a revolutionary new aircraft being developed without crazy delays or cost overruns. How long is it going to take to the IOC? By about 2030?
- throw1234651234 3y agoThat's the thing, I am pretty sure sure it's entirely evolutionary, without knowing anything about the project. B-2 with better stealth, engines, software, and hopefully lower maintenance costs. Still more than any other country accomplished, but this is built on a solid foundation, without much departure. If anything, it's a mature, modernized B-2.
- anovikov 3y agoThat would be too good to be true. It's in fact a smaller airframe with less range. Medium strategic bomber, not a proper one. Will still be good to go because new tankers will provide it with enough range and are available in large numbers.
- euroderf 3y ago> new tankers will provide it with enough range and are available in large numbers. Plenty of tankers ? That's unheard of. Like plenty of strategic airlift.
- throw1234651234 3y agoI think that was a calculated move based on what you described and the fact that the US has based these in allied countries during operations, so the full "strategic" range isn't really needed.
- ianburrell 3y agoThat is exactly what is needed. The B-2 is too big, too expensive, and too few. The B-21, two thirds the size, is much more useful for modern warfare. The US is planning on buying 100 of them instead of the 21 B-2, and replace the B-2s, B-1s, and maybe the B-52s. The B-21 has the same range as B-2, it is the B-2 that is shorter range than B-52. Smaller bomber is much more flexible. Most missions don't require B-2 or B-52 size when carrying a few cruise missiles or guided bombs. If do need more, than can send two of them and those are available.
- hondo77 3y ago> The US is planning on buying 100 of them instead of the 21 B-2... The Air Force wanted to buy over 100 B-2 but Congress said "no". We'll see what happens this round.
- credit_guy 3y agoNope. Smaller airframe yes, but a design that benefited from decades of advances in both algorithms and computing power. It most likely has a much better lift-to-drag ratio than B2, and more efficient engines too. It will at least match B2's range. Though the Raider’s true range remains classified, estimates place it at approximately 6,000 miles of range without refuelling, highlighting the platform’s extraordinary global potential. [1] https://www.airforce-technology.com/comment/b-21-raider-usaf-northrop-grumman/?cf-view https://www.airforce-technology.com/comment/b-21-raider-usaf...
- mrDmrTmrJ 3y agoIt's completely evolutionary! To add context here. The B-21 is an manned version of a drone called a RQ-180, which is an extremely stealthy flying wing. Coupled to existing engines (widely believed to be F-35 engines possibly with an increased bypass ratio). The B-2 had this huge problem where the original design (called "Senior Ice") was a stealthy high altitude bomber - like the B-21. But, at the last moment, the B-2 was completely redesigned to have low altitude flying capabilities - greatly increasing the cost of development and timeline. With the B-21, Northrop reverted to the original (Senior Ice) design. Building on top of all the technologies proved out by the RQ-180. And with a development team at the Strategic Capabilities Office organized to prevent anyone from adding or changing requirements. Evolutionary design + proven subsystems + focused and stable requirements. Likely the best managed DoD acquisition program in the last one to two decades.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chasd00 3y ago> the B-21 is an manned version of a drone called a RQ-180, that's interesting, i wonder if that's where the unmanned mode of the B-21 comes from. Being able to fly unmanned would be useful in very high risk scenarios.
- thunderbird120 3y ago>the B-21 is an manned version of a drone called a RQ-180 No it's not. The RQ-180 as a HALE drone with no weapons. The B-21 is a dedicated bomber. Despite both being flying wings with roughly the same basic shape the airframe requirements are completely different.
- belter 3y agoSpot the differences... "Comparing Stealth Bombers" - https://www.airandspaceforces.com/app/uploads/2019/12/Comparing-stealth-bombers-1.pdf https://www.airandspaceforces.com/app/uploads/2019/12/Compar...
- morkalork 3y ago2 less corners and half the payload?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI think the intention here is for the B-21 to utilize swarms of "loyal wingmen" drones.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoNo, those programs are unrelated to the B-21, and the B-21's design phase precedes the existence of the loyal wingman concept. It also doesn't fit the mission profile of the B-21, as it's job is strategic bombing using stealth, which is done solo not in formations. It'll no doubt have networking capabilities with ISR drones to set up kill chains but on mission it will be completely silent in terms of EM emissions. The B-21 itself is also optionally manned.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agohttps://www.flightglobal.com/military-uavs/us-air-force-commits-to-fielding-loyal-wingman-uavs/146802.article https://www.flightglobal.com/military-uavs/us-air-force-comm... > The loyal wingman concept will also be extended to the top-secret Northrop Grumman B-21 Raider stealth bomber. > “The B-21 is a very expensive aircraft. It has a certain payload and range. We would like to amplify that capability. It has the ability to penetrate, which is valuable,” says Kendall. “What we want is something that can go operate with it. I wouldn’t say ‘accompany it’ necessarily. The tactics are very much to be determined.”
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoOutstanding work! Congrats to the team!
- yread 3y agoIt's annoying that they don't compare the costs: B-2 has a unit cost of 2.13B$ (1997 $) = 4.08B$ B-21 has a unit cost of 0.55B$ (2010 $) = 0.78B$ Looks nice right? But projected unit costs for B-2 in 1997 were also 0.74B$ (1997 $) so who knows how it ends up
- miketery 3y agoMuch of the cost in per unit is due to initial capex (e.g. R&D and tooling). I would hope they're reusing many of the things from the first version. This would make the new version much cheaper per unit. But agreed that cost is likely to balloon, both government and defense contractors are incentivized for it to balloon (it's a lucrative jobs program for many across many states).
- coredog64 3y agoThe rule of thumb from my senior aircraft design course was that 90% of the cost is designed in before you bend the first piece of sheet metal. Commercial programs have their own guidelines about how many planes you have to make to break even, and even there where they aren’t radically pushing the envelope it’s on the order of hundreds.
- Racing0461 3y agoIsn't cost misleading? the "cost per plane" is usually the input (total money dedicated by congress including 50 year maintainence window) divided by the output (number of planes). so it looks unusally expensive (f35 prOGrAm coSTs 1.5 TRilLiON DollARS) but the actual materials of the plane is a minute fraction of that nummber which is what people think of when they hear cost.
- slt2021 3y agobasically military budget will always eat 1/4 to 1/3 of the US budget no matter the output, so if it produces few dozen F35 then yes - it will look like costs per unit are outrageous. a lot of military spending is fixed costs that pentagon is unable to dial down, has to spend due to contracts and maintenance, and basically jobs + pork barrel program. so they just play "hollywood accounting" tricks by allocating their spend from line item A to line item B, depending on what voters will bear. one decade it will be Afghanistan war, another decade it will be airforce development, this upcoming decade it will be Navy spending on new boats etc.
- blinding-streak 3y agohttps://archive.ph/9TQU8 https://archive.ph/9TQU8
- jillesvangurp 3y agoAt this point in history, what's the point of having a super expensive bomber plane with an actual human pilot vs. having a much cheaper, autonomous, hyper-sonic, and disposable delivery vehicle in the form of a rocket? Flying from A to B with cm. precision is pretty much a solved problem. Doesn't require a human flying a thing. Why would you fly such a thing in any situation where you might have to risk losing the plane + pilot?
- slt2021 3y agohaving a pilot makes it somewhat protected against electronic warfare you dont want russia/iran to just steal your latest tech bomber, do you? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93U.S._RQ-170_incid... also rockets will never replace planes, these totally different platforms with different purposes
- snakeyjake 3y agoPrecision is solved, but many of the solutions can be jammed. What can't be jammed (easily) is laser guidance. The B-21 can fly over a target and a crewmember can point a laser at a target and the bomb will ride the beam down. Remote laser guidance is difficult due to latency. The B-21 was designed to operate both manned and unmanned.
- doctorhandshake 3y agoIs it possible to provide laser guidance from satellite?
- snakeyjake 3y agoIt may be possible from low earth orbit but time overhead is, at maximum, 20 minutes. Add in obstructions like terrain and non-ideal look angles and you may be only able to paint a target for several minutes if at all. This would require extraordinary precision and coordination to achieve. I am comfortable saying that it is realistically impossible from higher orbits.
- 3y ago
- sva_ 3y agoThese B2 Bombers are impressive when they fly over. When we were kids, my brothers and me would always excitedly shout and point at them when we saw them passing by in rural northern Germany. I saw a lot of them back then, probably on mission. I didn't really grasp at that time what seeing them meant.