3 ms·
That's not actually how the industry works in the general case. Health "insurance" companies no longer provide much insurance. Instead they mainly just create p
by nradov 3y ago
That's not actually how the industry works in the general case. Health "insurance" companies no longer provide much insurance. Instead they mainly just create provider networks and administer claims on behalf of self-insured group buyers (mainly employers and unions). The remaining fully insured market is relatively small.
Health insurers have low profit margins. You can read their audited financial statements for the publicly traded ones. Some are even non-profit. The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) set a minimum 85% medical loss ratio. The insurers have to cover their operating costs and profit margins out of the remaining 15%. Even if we were to replace commercial insurers with some sort of "Medicare for all" system that would have only a marginal impact on costs to patients and availability of care.
The real drivers here are the big employers. They are the ones ultimately paying most of the bills, and they insist that insurers ration care to control costs.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) set a minimum 85% medical loss ratio. The insurers have to cover their operating costs and profit margins out of the remaining 15%. That's also a perverse incentive though. With capped "profit" windows, how is a company to make more money? Well if healthcare costs increase, then premiums need to. 15% of 1.3X is bigger than 15% of X, after all. And healthcare providers are unlikely to object to higher prices. And what if your insurer gets involved in vertical integration - perhaps Kaiser style, perhaps less formal? Now you get to reduce the actual cost to you (the insurer) by removing the middleman, and you get increased profit by keeping the price the same. It might show up on a different ledger on your books, but nonetheless...
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> And what if your insurer gets involved in vertical integration - perhaps Kaiser style, perhaps less formal? Now you get to reduce the actual cost to you (the insurer) by removing the middleman, and you get increased profit by keeping the price the same. It might show up on a different ledger on your books, but nonetheless... Regulators are not this dumb or corrupt. This is not a big money making business, as evidenced by Buffett/Bezos/Dimon’s foray failing: https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2021-01-04/buffett-bezos-dimon-healthcare https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2021-01-04/buffett-be...
- peteradio 3y agoUNH stock has doubled since 2020. Someones making big money.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoBecause the risk of removing ACA legislation is gone. It’s a company with very reliable revenue that will keep up with inflation with relatively low liability.
- cycomanic 3y agoAnd despite that Unitedhealthcare has grown from ~$70 billion revenue in 2007 to $320 billion in 2022 and is making a $20 billion in profit (which I'd argue is a pretty healthy profit). So I guess the health insurers are just working around the system.
- nradov 3y agoYou're mixing up UnitedHealthcare with it's parent publicly traded company UnitedHealth Group. They sell other services and technology products unrelated to medical insurance, and those contribute a lot of the net profit. Medical insurance is a high volume, low profit margin business. https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/0000731766/000073176623000008/unh-20221231.htm#i6b660947fab7488cb4d33baca2cb3a37_88 https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/0000731766/0... It is reasonable to criticize insurer profits but overall those are only a small part of much larger systemic problems in the US healthcare system. Even if profit margins were somehow cut to zero that would have only a marginal impact.
- maxerickson 3y agoThe real drivers here are the big employers. They are the ones ultimately paying most of the bills, and they insist that insurers ration care to control costs. Are US costs reasonably described as well controlled?
- nradov 3y agoCertainly not. But without that pressure from large group buyers, costs would be even more out of control.