3 ms·
As context, from the link: >> "In response to a request for documents pertaining to the decision-making behind the proposed CSAM regulation, the European Commi
by ethbr1 3y ago
As context, from the link:
>> "In response to a request for documents pertaining to the decision-making behind the proposed CSAM regulation, the European Commission failed to disclose a list of companies who were consulted about the technical feasibility of detecting CSAM without undermining encryption."
>> "... a list of experts who helped the Commission draft the text related to potential solutions to detect child sexual abuse material in end-to-end encrypted communications."
This doesn't sound like a list of those who supported it. Only who were consulted.
Maybe some more consideration before we start burning witches?
- isodev 3y ago>> Such a requirement is fundamentally incompatible with end-to-end encrypted messaging because platforms that offer such service cannot access communications content. The challenge is that based on the advice of experts, the commission made recommendations which violate or are in conflict with end-to-end encryption. The public deserves to know the lineage of such decision-making and (rightfully) stimulate or recommend improvements to the process.
- ethbr1 3y ago> The challenge is that based on the advice of experts, the commission made recommendations which violate or are in conflict with end-to-end encryption. "Based" is doing a lot of service there. Maybe they were fully in support. Maybe they told the EU it was a terrible, stupid idea and were ignored. At the end of the day, the EU body made the proposed regulation, and I'd like to know individuals' involvements before assuming their opinion. F.ex. I would assume that Alex Stamos didn't tell them it was a brilliant idea
- isodev 3y agoExperts are entitled to their opinions, I wouldn't judge anyone on the list for their stance. Seeing the list as a whole, however, makes me wonder if the commission or lawmakers in general have access to adequate technical expertise and representation from the industry.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoIn theory you are right, but why would the EC consult with Canadian, British and Australian government people? And what do you think they said? "No, you will ruin E2E"?
- namdnay 3y ago> but why would the EC consult with Canadian, British and Australian government people? to know how they're planning on managing the same issues? i'm not a fan of CSAM either but it makes sense to talk to your neighbours to know how they're handling things?