4 ms·
> As a young girl, Alice (not her real name) logged on to the popular live video chat website, Omegle, and was randomly paired with a paedophile, who coerced he
by echelon 3y ago
> As a young girl, Alice (not her real name) logged on to the popular live video chat website, Omegle, and was randomly paired with a paedophile, who coerced her into becoming a digital sex slave. Nearly 10 years later the young American is suing Omegle in a landmark case that could pave the way for a wave of lawsuits against other social platforms.
This is fucked. We shouldn't have to put safety padding on everything as a stand-in for something parents are supposed to do, ie. being responsible for their brood.
Should we put inflatable balloons around people because cars and high velocity objects exist that we can collide with?
Should we ban kitchen knives because they're sharp?
Asphyxiation is the leading method of teen suicide. Should we stop selling plastic, rope, and anything that fits around a neck and/or head?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wolverine876 3y agoWe do implement many things that protect people, sometimes children in particular. They aren't perfect, but they can prevent a lot of damage. The question, as usual, isn't all or nothing. It's what can we do that will meet all the criteria as best possible: not infringe on freedoms, reduce harm, be affordable, etc.
- bogota 3y ago100% agree i think the bigger issue is at least in the US and many other countries we have lost all faith that the people making those choices will do so in a responsible or ethical manner. Essentially we lost faith in the system and I don’t think it will ever come back. So where do we go from here?
- wolverine876 3y ago> Essentially we lost faith in the system and I don’t think it will ever come back. So where do we go from here? A bit extreme? It will come back if you choose it, if you do it. The despair, as I posted, is trendy but it's absurd - the most ridiculous, counterproductive philosophical trend I can imagine. Stop philosophizing and just start doing!
- bogota 3y agoI don’t think im being extreme. That is the way I see it. That is the way the various media outlets portray it. And that is the rhetoric that has taken over politics. What should I do? I have no one I want to vote for and honestly I don’t care enough to do it myself. At this point it’s just figuring out how you can profit off this and get your own piece of land to check out on. I don’t find this to be depressing it’s just what I see as facts.
- wolverine876 3y ago> I don’t find this to be depressing We'd have to redefine depressing to exclude that post. Look at all the ways it advocates quitting; it's impressive in a way. > That is the way the various media outlets portray it. And that is the rhetoric that has taken over politics. Do you think that makes it true? That seems to support my claim that it's trendy, and people repeating these things because others say it are by definition following a trend. I've seen many trends come and go, but this one - despair as a trend - is the dumbest. Also, who is going to get anything done? We aren't children; our parents won't fix things if we don't do it. We'd better get to work, like prior generations who sacrificed and built so much. What will you tell your grandkids - 'well, I just quit; it was the fashionable thing to do.' Have you considered this trend is encouraged by people who don't want you getting in their way? You are handing all your power to them.
- afavour 3y ago> Should we put inflatable balloons around people because cars and high velocity objects exist that we can collide with? You’re talking in hyperbole but… yeah, we do a ton of work to make roads safer than they might otherwise be. What purpose do you think pedestrian crossings serve?
- lazide 3y agoTo make the bodies easier to collect? (/s kinda)
- CrimsonChapulin 3y agoIn the US, they serve to shift blame from distracted drivers for running someone over sadly (crappy j-walking laws) in addition to the normal use.
- JSavageOne 3y agoIt's horrible that this happened and obviously I'm glad the pedophile is in jail, but how exactly was she "coerced"? And how is any of this Omegle's fault?
- johntiger1 3y agoYeah it's unfortunate, but I don't think Omegle is exactly at fault here. Perhaps we should consider the abuser to be the one at fault?
- shadowgovt 3y agoWe can and do, and on the other side of a legal process, it may be found that Omegle is not at all liable for the actions of its users. ... and if the owner of Omegle doesn't want to take the years it'd take (and tens of thousands in legal fees) to find out whether or not they're liable for a silly project they put together for fun, I can't fault 'em.
- willsmith72 3y ago> how exactly was she "coerced"? Yeah no this is a terrible take. She was coerced by being an 11 year old talking to a grown adult. How do you think she was coerced?
- thaumasiotes 3y agoUsually being coerced would involve some amount of coercion.
- JSavageOne 3y agoWell that's the question I'm asking, and you didn't answer the question > coerce - persuade (an unwilling person) to do something by using force or threats. What was the threat? Why did she oblige? Why didn't she just block him?
- Crespyl 3y ago
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYep. If the pedo found her at a walmart, would she sue walmart too? Weird people, pedos, criminals are everywhere.... parents somehow teach about "stranger-danger" offline but not online, and then blame platforms their kids use, even though they are too young to use them in the first place.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jhallenworld 3y ago>If the pedo found her at a walmart, would she sue walmart too? Well, yes! A different example: with few exceptions (gun manufacturers), when people die everybody even remotely involved gets sued. Examples: Station Nightclub fire, Surfside condominium collapse.. In the case of a pedo at Walmart I could imagine: "Didn't the staff notice the guy dragging the girl out of the store? Why didn't they get involved?" Walmart has much more money than the pedo.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Didn't the staff notice If you want a proper Walmart analogy then you should stick the child in a remote part of a vast parking lot, so that there's no reason to expect the staff to notice. And at that point the case seems too weak to try.
- nrb 3y agoA more accurate analogy would be if they ushered the child into a backroom where a stranger was seated across from them with a glass divider between them and then they left the room. This is the whole point of Omeagle, to facilitate these interactions. Would it unsettle anyone if Walmart were doing that, and would they be legally responsible for whatever happens in there?
- Dylan16807 3y agoThat still involves humans actually seeing the people being paired up. It's not more accurate. And if Walmart had a thousand anonymous meeting rooms it wouldn't be Walmart anymore, so the analogy falls apart at that point.
- Izkata 3y ago> Should we ban kitchen knives because they're sharp? How about spoons? https://nypost.com/2019/05/16/police-station-mocked-for-photo-of-knife-haul-that-includes-a-spoon/ https://nypost.com/2019/05/16/police-station-mocked-for-phot...
- jodrellblank 3y ago> "Should we ban kitchen knives because they're sharp?" We do in the UK: https://www.gov.uk/buying-carrying-knives https://www.gov.uk/buying-carrying-knives "It’s illegal to: use any knife or weapon in a threatening way, carry most knives or any weapons in public without a ‘good reason’, sell most knives or any weapons to anyone under the age of 18." - And yes that includes kitchen knives because there's a callout - "In Scotland, you’re allowed to sell 16 and 17 year olds cutlery and kitchen knives." > "Asphyxiation is the leading method of teen suicide. Should we stop selling plastic, rope, and anything that fits around a neck and/or head?" We regulate them or have standards around them[3]: "The Toy Safety Directive, BS EN 71-1, raises attention to plastic bags and plastic sheets. It specifies bags larger than 380mm opening circumference and having a drawstring closure must be made of a material which is permeable to air. Except where application requires airtight sealing, all bags are to be perforated with holes of 4mm diameter minimum, spaced on 30mm grid. Bags for child appealing products and toys must have a minimum of four holes; other bags to have a minimum of two holes". Your stance "we shouldn't have to do things about dangers" is silly, we do a lot of things to reduce risks in a lot of areas. Learning from other people's tragedies and trying to safeguard others from having to go through them is one of the long-running threads of civilised society. Should we restrict electric wiring options in houses because electrocution and fires are a thing? Yes. Should we restrict food production options because salmonella is a thing? Yes. Should we have building codes because shoddy buildings fall down and kill people? Yes. Should we have laws about lead and carcinogens and things in products? Yes. Should cars have to meet crash test safety conditions? Yes. etc. etc. > "Should we put inflatable balloons around people because cars and high velocity objects exist that we can collide with?" We do; drivers are surrounded by inflatable airbags. [rant] Look at the social messaging around bike helmets. You never see people telling runners to wear a helmet in case they suddenly come upon a head injury. But take say YouTuber Tom Stanton who makes unusual engineering projects, including a flywheel bike[1] which he rode at walking pace down an empty country lane, and in his next bike video, a homemade supercapacitor bike[2] he's wearing a a helmet because of all the flack he got in the comments on the earlier one. The point is not whether helmets prevent against brain damage in certain situations, the point is what situations are casual everyday recreational cyclists getting into where they risk brain damage? And the answer is cars. And the social messaging for helmet wearing is to shift blame from car drivers hitting cyclists to cyclists "not taking safety precautions". [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gahKxbwUcYw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gahKxbwUcYw [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_f8Q2_Q_J0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_f8Q2_Q_J0 [3] https://qualityinspired.co.uk/2020/03/suffocation-warning-recommendations/ https://qualityinspired.co.uk/2020/03/suffocation-warning-re...