24 ms·
Google argues iMessage should be regulated by the EU's Digital Markets Act
- repelsteeltje 3y agoSigh. It was to be expected that regulation intended to shield users from big tech harm is twisted to instead have one giant attack another.
- nulld3v 3y agoIt's working just as intended. If one big company points out that another big company is breaking the law and is willing to fight to prove it, I'm all for it.
- superduty 3y agoBreaking the law?
- nikanj 3y ago”They’re not allowing our spam on your phones!” I get so much SMS and email spam. I get so little iMessage spam. If getting green texts from Android users is the price I have to pay, so be it.
- chmod775 3y agoSMS spam in Europe? Living in Germany I haven't gotten a single unsolicited SMS in my life - and some of my phone numbers are public on the internet.
- dontlaugh 3y agoHappens to me sometimes in the UK
- pohuing 3y agoI'm a mother for weirdly may children who have new phone numbers, considering I'm a single male at 25yo. That's the primary spam in Germany for me. But Google filters those messages perfectly
- quitit 3y agoThe odd thing about all of this - why do they think Apple will make the messages from other platforms blue? Of course they won't, because there won't be feature parity. The point of SMSes remaining green even though that they are largely without cost is because it signals to the user that iMessage's/Facetime's features aren't available. Google who argued that apple's designs aren't worthy of protection are now arguing that the colour of a freaking text bubble has great importance. Which one is it?
- bilbo0s 3y agois twisted to instead have one giant attack another ..for the purposes of invading user privacy no less. Can't have iMessage out there free from Google Ads can we? And we certainly wouldn't want all those iMessage users to not have the pleasure of having their data sold to info brokers? That's a human right isn't it? /s These tech firms are just wayy too powerful. It's like if you take one down, the others say, "Awesome!!!", and they start selling the data that we've now legally obliged the first tech firm to give them access to.
- room500 3y agoI don't understand how opening iMessage would sell existing iMessage data to anyone? Today, if an iPhone user sends a message to an Android user, that message is sent via SMS. If Google wanted, it could already scrape the message. What would change if the protocol was open and the message was sent to the Android device using iMessage? There is no expectation for Apple to give Google read/write access to the iMessage database (not that it exists, but still). What is the downside of users being able to interoperate and use the protocol?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sigmar 3y agoIf Apple stopped using their iMessage-noninteroperability to dissuade consumers (via network effects, degraded quality of images, etc) from trying other mobile OS platforms , wouldn't that also help any third party that wanted to challenge Apple and Google's dominance?
- ericmay 3y agoProbably not. It’s better to think of this as Google trying to go after Apple to the sole benefit of Google than it is to think of this as “if Google wins this it will create lots of third party challengers”. Network effects also aren’t really all that bad. Would you want 15 apps that you have to rotate through to communicate to different people with, all with different features and capabilities? Probably not. You’d build some protocol on top to make that easier. But then someone says hey you need to open up your protocol and support my protocol and on and on we go. The crux of this story and most similar stories is that Apple went and made the best product and it’s so good that others can’t compete with it. If the opposite were true we’d just have people battling it out like we used to with video game consoles. Instead we have gigantic multi-hundred billion $ companies attacking Apple’s products and services with big government tools.
- xigoi 3y agoI'd rather have 15 different open protocols that someone could create an universal app for than 7 different proprietary protocols that each require you to have a specific app.
- repelsteeltje 3y agoThat's off course the point Mike Masnick (of TechDirt fame) has been making: https://knightcolumbia.org/content/protocols-not-platforms-a-technological-approach-to-free-speech https://knightcolumbia.org/content/protocols-not-platforms-a...
- ericmay 3y agoI think what you and others are confused by is that you will be required to have many specific apps regardless of whether the protocols are “open” as you do now because the companies building the apps will always build proprietary features to get you to use their specific app, otherwise we would just coalesce around one messaging app and most will lose a lot of the money they are currently making. There is nothing stopping anyone from using open protocols or different messaging apps today. What’s so frustrating about Google’s attempt to leverage lobbyists to handicap Apple is that customers did coalesce around an app: iMessage, and all of this talk about “open protocols” is just marketing. The protocols you want to use are already here and already open!
- quitit 3y agoThe EU have a proven history of not being very good at foreseeing obvious, unintended consequences, they also have no history of addressing those short-comings after they arise which is a weakness common to legislative bodies (large, slow, and change requires significant effort to generate support.) So it strikes me as a bit insane that they want to make a lot of very large changes simultaneously. Of the new proposed changes, I can see so few actually rendering any net benefit to the consumer and EU businesses. There is so much wishful thinking going on here. Do EU lawmakers believe that these changes will let EU tech businesses shoehorn themselves into these large, difficult to compete against platforms? It is not clear that it'll just be a land rush lead by large american tech companies. Then for any EU companies that do find a niche, they will simply be bought out - just like how the EU's AI darlings were. It's like they have been baited into this maliciously: why wouldn't the EU introduce changes in a controlled roll out, where they can manage unintended consequences and limit the political fallout for problems that arise. Doing all of this at once is insanely risk-filled, and I feel this will put the journey to consumer protections on the back foot. A politician is not going to have the appetite to delve into this if it turns into toxic soup, meanwhile other countries progress will stall as they gesture warningly at the EU's mistakes.
- timmg 3y agoI find it interesting how these big (near?) monopolies are fighting each other through the anti-trust system. Even as it seems the anti-trust system isn't working well on its own. I really don't know what the answer to all these related questions are (App stores and App store fees and payment systems). But it does seem to me that most of these biggest companies should be tamped down in some way. Not sure I know what the exact right answer is, though.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoAdversarial Interoperability, such as here, seems like the right move to me. AT&T was doing the same shit: you have to use only manufacturer provided equipment, you have to communicate like we want you to. The online world has yet to have a Carterphone moment, where users are freed from the mothership's shackles.
- nywles 3y agoHow about mandating that a business should be able to offer personal customer care to everyone using their products? These companies can only grow this profitable because they don't have to support their users.
- kwanbix 3y agoI really don't get what is it that people like so much about iMessage that they use it instead of WhatsApp or even Telegram or Signal. I really don't get it. Can anyone explain what is it that is so good that you end up using a solution that 40% in the USA and 60% in the rest of the world cannot use?
- nerdjon 3y agoIn the US we used text messages for years so just sticking with that makes sense. I guess most of us just never really saw a reason to move to anything else. Why would I when I have been communicating with everyone through my phone number for 15ish years? I have honestly been curious why the rest of the world doesn't do this? Was SMS not used as much?
- mattmanser 3y agoYou were actually late to text messages, not early. The US still had huge pager numbers when consumers in the EU was all in on text messages. For example this article discusses low SMS usage in the US from 2000: https://www.nytimes.com/2000/12/07/technology/us-is-lagging-behind-europe-in-short-messaging-services.html https://www.nytimes.com/2000/12/07/technology/us-is-lagging-... Just like you were late to dropping cheques vs chip and pin, the US has been a laggard in consumer adoption of some technologies. Might be something to do with the relative power of your state governments vs federal meaning your infrastructure is sometimes less co-ordinated, as a guess.
- nerdjon 3y agoI can't read the article but going on what you said... that's interesting. Then I really don't understand why did the EU just not stick with SMS (and iMessage). Like what was the value of going with a new app. I was just using this same number with SMS on dumb phones... why would I switch?
- marcod 3y agoSMS were expensive in Europe.
- kklimonda 3y agoSo this is not about forcing Apple to make clients for competing platforms, but to allow businesses to send spam to more users? Well, thanks Google.
- foota 3y agoI don't think this is an accurate take. The DMA is about businesses and their relationships with consumers, so any regulation has to be targeted to that. The argument is that Apple not allowing businesses to use a protocol on par with iMessage is the issue here.
- funnybeam 3y ago“ businesses and their relationships with consumers” Sounds like spam to me
- kevingadd 3y agoYou realize there are actual legitimate uses of SMS and people choose to use it, right?
- frizlab 3y agoThere are few, and it open the door to spam, yes. I’d rather than not even have the possibility.
- smoldesu 3y agoAny sufficiently advanced networked computer will have the potential for spam or malicious users. iMessage already sees this without being an open protocol; it's deeply-integrated nature makes it a prime vector for malware and 0-click spyware. Adversaries like NSO Group actively exploit this. The goal isn't a more locked-down phone, it's transparent communications infrastructure that inherently resists attackers. Anything else is an imperfect solution that relies on trust more than mechanical security. If Apple wants to lead the way on that, they should do the world a favor and propose their own open SMS encryption standard. As it stands, their 'ours is better but we wont show you' approach is about as obvious as security theater gets.
- nerdjon 3y agoI do have some slightly concerns about iMessage being opened up and no longer linked to Apple products for a spam standpoint. But I get plenty of SMS spam so I guess it's really not much of a difference. However kinda related I am curious about RCS. I tried looking this up but I can't find much concrete information on it. Is it actually universally E2E or only some? I find some reddit posts implying it's some. Do all RCS messages go through Google's servers? Or some other central servers that are not the involved carriers.
- kelnos 3y ago> Is it actually universally E2E or only some? I find some reddit posts implying it's some. The E2EE on RCS is an extension to the protocol developed by Google. I don't know who has implemented it other than Google. So if a user is on a carrier that does their own RCS impl (many carriers piggyback off of Google's so they don't have to deal with it), they may not have E2EE. > Do all RCS messages go through Google's servers? If your carrier isn't using Google's implementation, and you're messaging someone on a carrier also not using Google's implementation, then it won't go through Google's servers. Otherwise, it will. In theory, this won't matter, assuming the E2EE is implemented correctly and securely. I don't know if an audit has been done, though. There's also the case where one person is on a carrier using Google's impl, and the other is on a carrier that is not, and that carrier has not implemented E2EE. Then the message will go through Google's servers, and Google will be able to read it. This is how I understand it, anyway; I don't intimately know the details of the protocol, so this might not be 100% correct.
- nerdjon 3y agoInteresting, assuming this is all correct (I tried to look around and the information on this seems to be purposefully vague from a marketing standpoint for RCS.). I am perfectly fine with Apple not rushing to implement RCS. It may be a business decision for their part but any chance that the messages information will go through Google's servers is a full no go for me and is not a valid alternative in my opinion. Even if it is encrypted (which seems to not be guaranteed anyways), it still gives Google data I don't care for them to have.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LispSporks22 3y agoWhy doesn't Google have a go at building something better than iMessage rather than beg for regulations? Also, wrt to RCS its very much carrier oriented, and I personally would not want to have anything to do with them – next thing you know they'll have pay-for tiers or goddamn advertising in my messages.
- broken_clock 3y agoWhy didn't other oil companies have a go at building something better than Standard Oil?
- nickpp 3y agoActually they did. Standard Oil was already on the way out at the time of its anti-trust action and subsequent breakup. It's well documented.
- deadmutex 3y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Allo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Allo
- CLIML 3y ago[dead]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38189869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38189869
- daft_pink 3y agoIt’s really unfair that Google, which has constantly killed good messaging apps for terrible ones would get to force Apple to give them access to successful one. If google had just kept the chat service everyone already used in Gmail called hangouts instead of making constantly crappier versions and forcing us to use them, they probably wouldn’t have this problem. Now no one wants to use their messenger that they strong armed the carriers into letting them implement, so now they get to force it on Apple users. Dear Google, if we wanted your crappy messaging service we would have bought an android phone. Thanks, the users.