6 ms·
Here is the interesting thing - India never had the concept of static IPs for residential home Internet. You have to pay a premium to get one, request for one w
by Brajeshwar 3y ago
Here is the interesting thing - India never had the concept of static IPs for residential home Internet. You have to pay a premium to get one, request for one with reasoning and has to be "for commercial."
So, all of our neighbors shares IPs or are within a range. It is fun knowing what all of my neighbors and the a few blocks away are all downloading.
- shmde 3y agoI got scared looking at all the pornography and movies that I never downloaded popping up thinking someone hacked into my network.
- rinze 3y agoThis made me remember one anecdote written in one of the books about how Amazon became what it is today (it could be "The everything store", but I'm not sure.) If my memory serves me well, the book mentions that, for a while, Amazon had "the most read books in your zip code", until someone realized some corporations were so large a zip code was basically just them. So that became "the most read books at Intel's research department", and the entire thing was scrapped.
- cameronh90 3y agoIn the UK, it’s not uncommon for a large building to have its own postcode. It’s quite useful because in most densely populated areas, you can use the postcode alone to navigate to within a hundred metres of your destination.
- fbn79 3y agoSame for Italy
- vasdae 3y agoI don't know of any country in the world, developed or not, that has static IPs for residental home users. It's a waste of IP addresses.
- Etheryte 3y agoIt used to be common in Estonia, these days I think it's slightly less so, but the price is in the ballpark of five bucks a month to have a static one. It has many good uses and is definitely not a waste if you need it.
- vasdae 3y agoIt's a waste for the ISP when 99.9999% of users do not need a static IP address. When users turn off their routers they can reassign the addresses to other users. Not to mention the privacy issues of always using the same address.
- grotorea 3y agoI think that's too much 9s if you consider everyone who would run a home minecraft server or some other small scale personal server if having a static publicly addressable IP was easy and simple.
- HenryBemis 3y ago> and is definitely not a waste if you need it. Well then 99.9999% of the people don't really need it. But if one decides to run their own mail server at home (to save those 5-10-20 per month for their mailbox) it's worth the trade-off. > Not to mention the privacy issues of always using the same address. For me that's the thing. Privacy AND Security. Especially when you got something 'listening'/waiting.
- account42 3y ago> When users turn off their routers Which 99.999% of users don't do, ever.
- hnlmorg 3y agoI wouldn’t be at all surprised if it was an even smaller number of people than that.
- underseacables 3y agoMy outside IP address in Missouri hasn't changed in at least five years. No matter how many times I try to get it to release and renew, I always get the same address. So I'd say that's pretty static...
- batch12 3y agoSo if you have the same large ISP as me, you can change your IP by changing the MAC of your router and rebooting your modem.
- anonymousnotme 3y agoI don't have to reboot my router or modem. I just have an a script that changes the MAC and releases and renews or rather gets an IP address via DHCP. My ISP is slow at handing out an IP address out as it takes several minutes, but it is automated. When the same operation is done for an IP on the LAN, it is a second or or two to get a new IP address. I figure the main reason to get a new IP address is so that web sites can't track one by IP. If carrier grade NAT is used, then is there a point in changing one's IP? If one does not use any peer to peer, then it seems that carrier grade NAT should lower the cost of one's internet service and that should be preferred. If one needs anonymity for bittorrent or other peer to peer, then shouldn't a VPN or i2p be used? I got the impression that i2p might be slow.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoI noticed that I kept getting the same IP address after reboots and even extended (tens of minutes) of the router being switched off. A couple of years later my house was raided by the police. I don't know if the two are related though, but within a couple of months after the raid my IP address changed for the first time since I noticed it being "static". Likely to be pure coincidence, but after that particular experience there are all sorts of different things that could be "putting two and two together"-type paranoia. It's back to being reliably static at the moment... brb, someone at the door ;)
- underseacables 3y ago
- supriyo-biswas 3y ago> India never had the concept of static IPs for residential home Internet. I’m not sure about your experience, but I was always allocated a dedicated public IP (not static though) between 2009-2013 when on the mobile networks of two different ISPs. I even remember being able to host public websites off of them, from my phone.
- tambourine_man 3y agoYes, but I’d bet your ISP is required by law to store what IP was given to which customer at any given time for a certain period. In that sense, it’s just as bad privacy wise, just a better use of a finite resource.
- jasode 3y ago>Yes, but I’d bet your ISP is required by law to store what IP was given to which customer at any given time for a certain period. In that sense, it’s just as bad privacy wise, If the gp you're replying to is talking about CG-NAT[1] (which is common in India), the privacy leak is not the same. With CG-NAT, a hundred homes simultaneously share the same public-facing IP address at the same time. That's different from Verizon or Comcast in the USA where each house has a different temporary public ip address rotating from a pool of ip addresses. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT
- yencabulator 3y agoThe ISP can still be required to keep a record all the NAT decisions. But yeah, this thing shows other CGNAT consumers for me, with some questionable taste in books.
- 3c6bYDXLMj 3y ago[dead]