3 ms·
> This has long been a trade-off of American innovation philosophy: we can freely exercise our First Amendment rights to share ideas, creating a vibrant intelle
by mschuster91 3y ago
> This has long been a trade-off of American innovation philosophy: we can freely exercise our First Amendment rights to share ideas, creating a vibrant intellectual exchange, even at the risk of others benefiting from reading our textbooks, journals and patents.
Sometimes, we have to re-evaluate our positions. We cannot risk supplying our enemies with stuff they can turn around and use as weapons against ourselves any more. The sooner broader society wakes up and realizes that we, as collective Western nations, are at war, the better. It may not be a "conventional" war yet, but that doesn't make it less dangerous!
- krispyfi 3y agoHave you ever read "The Player of Games" by Iain M. Banks? We won't win by allowing the enemy to make us more like them.
- mschuster91 3y ago> We won't win by allowing the enemy to make us more like them. I agree on that when it comes to a ton of the "anti terror" measures introduced after 9/11 because these are plain bullshit that don't do any objective good, other than annoy passengers. But regarding high tech capability? Not at all. We have to do everything we can to impede China's progress there, at all costs - because the cost of a Chinese victory would be outright catastrophic.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoIf what separates the status quo from Chinese victory is having RISC-V chips, we already lost. (And spoiler: modern technology won't give them victory over the West. Not even close.)
- germandiago 3y agoI think there are far ways in which we are destroying ourselves by not focusing in many of the important aspects AND not sticking to our values. If we promote free market (more or less, nothing is pure), freedom of speech and many others as those should be respected as much as it is possible. We are departing from that and I think it is harmful for us. We should not be blaming enemies for these things.
- jakobson14 3y agoDo you want the suppler of low cost, powerful RISC-V based microcontrollers to be china or the USA? Oh wait, most of the good MCUs already come out of china these days, like the ESP32 (now made with RISC-V). If everyone is turning to chinese manufacturers for their fancy new microcontrollers, american firms stop making them or die. Now chna's the only supplier. Next thing you know, china's conflict with taiwan goes hot and china threatens to cut off exports of chips and products using them to anyone that intervenes. Sudently the USA takes the place of russia, who are scavenging STM32s from washing machines because of their war with ukraine.
- MeImCounting 3y ago"'War is a long cliff.' You can avoid the cliff completely, you can walk along the top for as long as you have the nerve, you can even choose to leap off, and if you only fall a short way before you hit a ledge you can always scramble back up again. Unless you’re just plain invaded, there are always choices, and even then, there’s usually something you’ve missed — a choice you didn’t make — that could have avoided invasion in the first place. You people still have your choices. There’s nothing inevitable about it.” -Banks - who ought to be quoted more often, here and elsewhere
- retrocryptid 3y agoIt worked pretty well for us in WWII.
- kragen 3y agohe said as he sent the japanese-americans to internment camps except you aren't at war, you're trying to start one
- mschuster91 3y ago> except you aren't at war, you're trying to start one I would rather like it for there to be no war. The problem is, that decision is not mine, it is not ours to make - China and Russia did that for us, decades ago, when they decided to wage cyber warfare on us: the Chinese mainly in industrial espionage, and Russia in terms of propaganda and "ordinary" cyber crime. Unfortunately we didn't react on this, to the contrary we kept on doing deals with them - all while the few opposition in Russia and China got more and more silent or outright sent to the gulags. It was our inaction that allowed Xi and Putin to be where they are today, and the cost of stopping both of them got incredibly large as a result, like it tends to happen with deferring problems to the future. Or to put it figuratively, we stood there like a boxing sack while Xi and Putin punched in on us. Side note: The next one to watch on that front is India, IMHO - Modi has been going ever more authoritarian for years, has zero problem doing deals with Russia, and India is doing absolutely nothing to rein in their scam callcenters that steal billions of dollars a year, and yet we don't even take care to re-home at least parts of the pharmaceutical industry which is causing severe havoc as Europe, especially Germany, is dealing with a massive shortage of basic medicine.
- kragen 3y agofalsely claiming that non-war activities such as propaganda are actually war, as you are doing, is an extremely common way to try to start wars, and has been for millennia you must think hn readers are astoundingly dumb i mean, we are, but not that dumb if you would like there to be no war, here are a couple of things you could try - don't try to dictate where rulers of foreign countries get to be or to stop them from ruling their own countries - don't exaggerate grievances like your industrial espionage nonsense like, let's suppose there's someone today posting on weibo 'It was our inaction that allowed Biden to be where he is today, and the cost of stopping him got incredibly large as a result, like it tends to happen with deferring problems to the future.' in chinese do you think that hypothetical post makes war more likely or less likely
- germandiago 3y agoI think it will be more harmful for us in the long run.