7 ms·
IANAL but the case against Google has to be even weaker than the one against Apple, right? Sideloading is much easier on Android and iOS.
by xnx 3y ago
IANAL but the case against Google has to be even weaker than the one against Apple, right? Sideloading is much easier on Android and iOS.
- pjmlp 3y agoYep, Supermarket A complains they cannot sell their branded goods at Supermarket B.
- flashback2199 3y agoYeah, this is strange to me. How can play store be a monopoly when you can just download and install any APK file anytime..
- loceng 3y agoOne of the main arguments will be that Google doesn't make it easy enough to sideload apps, purposefully, adding friction as a dark pattern.
- lawlessone 3y agoDoing this on Android is still trivial compared to doing it on iOS. Doesn't the US use "case law"? And would the verdict in the iOS case set the precedent here? Saying that, Apple was ordered to do some other things they don't like so maybe that's what they want applied to Google?
- leereeves 3y agoI don't think the Apple case sets a precedent, because that court didn't say that Apple wasn't a monopolist. > “The court does not find that it is impossible; only that Epic Games failed in its burden to demonstrate Apple is an illegal monopolist,” [U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers] wrote. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/09/10/apple-epic-decision-judge-market-monopoly/?itid=lk_inline_manual_16 https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/09/10/apple-e...
- singleshot_ 3y agoPrecedent is not set by a district court, but through the appeals process.
- wruza 3y agoHow exactly could Google improve the experience?
- lawlessone 3y agoDoes windows still have to show that menu when you install of alternative browsers? Maybe like that?
- wruza 3y agoThis could works for stores, not for apks. But I believe Epic would be happy to appear on that list anyway. That said, isn’t Epic Store (or what its name is) on PlayStore already? Unable check due to network issues.
- kyriakos 3y agoIt's literally 2 clicks
- kevincox 3y agoYeah, what Android has seems like a very reasonable balance of protecting users who don't know better vs usability. I do have complaints about Google embedding itself and privileging its apps in Android but difficulty of sideloading is not one of them.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoOne problem is that until recently (Android 13) it's two clicks for every app every update. Google Play Store gets to update apps in the background, but that's impossible with F-Droid (without rooting). If I want to update 10 apps on F-Droid, that's a prompt for each one.
- kyriakos 3y agoOnly the first app you side load requires to accept allowing non play store apps. I'm not sure about fdroid but samsung store updates are seamless same as play store.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoIt still requires a button to bring up the prompt. It would be a worse user experience to prompt the user without any warning. Compared to Google being able to do it all in the background. Samsung store can do it as it's bundled with the Samsung phone and installed as a system application that gets the same permissions as Google Play Store. A user can't give these permissions to a user installed app store without turning it into a system application, which isn't possible without root. For example if I tried to install Samsung's store on my Pixel. F-droid is able to do it if you have root: https://gitlab.com/fdroid/privileged-extension/ https://gitlab.com/fdroid/privileged-extension/
- oh_sigh 3y agoCompare the ease of using a pre-bundled Play Store with one click install, versus having to respond to multiple prompts saying "Yes, I know that doing this can give hackers all my data and steal my bank account"
- flashback2199 3y agoSo like the warning messages macOS and windows show when you install an app you downloaded from the internet?
- enragedcacti 3y agoNot really, Windows and Mac only show warnings for unsigned applications, and the policies for signing don't include revenue sharing with Microsoft or Apple. Android of course has an app signing system which could be used the same way to verify the authenticity of third party app downloads, but Google chooses not to protect users in that situation the way that Microsoft or Apple do. They do have Google Play Protect which scans all apps regardless of installation source but as far as I'm aware they don't go out of their way to confirm to the user that they are installing the real Epic Games Store.
- lawlessone 3y agoIt's even worse on Huawei devices. You get all their warnings and the google warnings. From memory I had to start an unlock process and then wait two weeks to actually be allowed to unlock it. The two week wait is part of the process for "security reasons" but really it's just because they know not everyone will persist through it.
- g-b-r 3y agoLast I heard even the two-weeks process has been removed, you can't unlock the bootloader on Huawei devices anymore ops no it looks like they found some workarounds (https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-honor-bootloader-unlock-potatonv/ https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-honor-bootloader-unloc...)
- henryfjordan 3y agoYou don't need to be a perfect monopoly for antitrust laws to apply to you in the US. You just need to be in a "dominant position" in the relevant market. Even if Google allows side-loading, so long as 95% of users go through the app store they need to take care not to abuse that position.
- flashback2199 3y agoThat makes even less sense because everywhere I look I see not-total-monopolies abusing their position every day
- lawlessone 3y agoYes. You can even sideload whole other app repos like https://f-droid.org/en/ https://f-droid.org/en/ Edit: "Matchgroup dropped out because google agreed to allow other payment channels" I get the feeling the real problem Match had was that it was too easy for customers to cancel a subscription.. They are notorious for constantly renewing subscriptions.. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/apr/10/matchcom-charged-me-cancelled-subscription https://www.theguardian.com/money/2015/apr/10/matchcom-charg...
- lern_too_spel 3y agoFor the most part, Google and Apple are allowed to choose which apps come preinstalled on their own devices. If there is evidence of pressure to keep a competitor from making a deal to preinstall apps on somebody else's devices (Samsung, Verizon, etc.), that's a problem. I don't see why Google would bother in this case, but I wouldn't be surprised if the discovery process exposes enough management stupidity to get a favorable outcome for Epic.
- enragedcacti 3y agoThey did in fact do that: > starting in 2019, Google ran a “Premier Device Program” that gave Android phone makers a greater share of search revenue than they would normally receive. In exchange, the OEMs agreed to ship their devices without any third-party app stores preinstalled. https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632806/google-epic-premier-device-program-lg-motorola-hmd https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632806/google-epic-prem...
- johnnyanmac 3y agoThat's what I thought this was about. It was buried under Epic v. Apple, but Epic Sued Google in the same time because Google blocked a deal with an OEM to include Fortnite on their phone. Surprised it went under the radar. I guess they settled to little fanfare. This seems to be a weaker case if they couldn't win against Apple. But then again, it sounds like it did a chip in the armor, so not a complete loss.
- leereeves 3y agoThe headline is wrong to claim that Epic lost to Apple. Epic didn't get everything they wanted, but: > U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled that Apple must allow app developers to “steer” customers to alternatives to the tech giant’s payment processing service, which collects a 30 percent fee on most digital transactions. That was previously not allowed by the company, and marks a major victory for developers which have long complained of the tight grip the tech giant holds over its App Store on the roughly one billion iPhones currently in use. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/09/10/apple-epic-decision-judge-market-monopoly/?itid=lk_inline_manual_16 https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/09/10/apple-e... So even if this case is weaker, and even if a weaker case leads to a worse outcome for Epic (not guaranteed), Epic might still win something they desire.
- labcomputer 3y agoFrom your source: > Tim Sweeney, chief executive of Epic, said in a tweet that, “Today’s ruling isn’t a win for developers or for consumers.” Also, > Epic lost, though, on the foundational allegation of its lawsuit. Epic tried to convince Gonzalez Rogers that Apple’s App Store was in itself a “market,” over which Apple is a monopolist, and wanted the judge to force Apple to allow alternative app stores and payment processing systems on its phones. My understanding is that Apple must allow app devs to tell customers about alternatives (and even provide a link to those alternatives), but Apple is still allowed to dictate what the in-app payment options are.
- leereeves 3y agoThat's my understanding as well, so I guess the question is: if you lose on one claim, and win on another, and win a significant change in terms, did you win or lose the case?
- willseth 3y agoThey lost on almost all the claims - critically, any claim that would have allowed them to circumvent app store fees - so it's reasonable to simply say that they lost. The anti-steering provision was the one exception.
- enragedcacti 3y agoGoogle's market position, actions, and internal statements could net a different result. Particularly: 1) The "Premier Device Program" where they offered additional search revenue to OEMs who promised not to preinstall any app stores other than Play Store. 2) Made a number of efforts to combat Epic's plan, which they called a "contagion", including trying to make a special deal with Epic, paying out hundreds of millions in special deals with huge devs like Tencent and Activision-Blizzard to stay on the Play Store, and even considering purchasing Epic to make it go away. 3) Had internal communications that acknowledge the considerable friction presented by sideloading 4) Had internal communications that discuss the serious financial risk to Google if an alternative App Store took off through OEM bundling. That said, this is all info from Epic's filing and shouldn't really be taken as an unbiased presentation of the facts or that any of it was actually illegal. It mostly just goes to say that Google extended themselves differently when defending their app store income stream. https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/6/22612921/google-epic-antitrust-case-court-filings-unsealed https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/6/22612921/google-epic-antit... https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632818/google-project-hug-game-developers-play-store-millions-epic-lawsuit-complaint https://www.theverge.com/2021/8/19/22632818/google-project-h...
- dagmx 3y agoSort of. Google is more vulnerable in some ways because they allow options, but then engage in tactics to prevent other stores being set as the default. They lost a case earlier this year or last year related to it. Effectively, by having choice they allow for competition. But by then trying to ensure their dominance despite that choice, it turns into anti competitive behaviour.