3 ms·
China isn't even remotely "green". Most of the official statistics coming out of there are highly manipulated. In particular they haven't built even a fraction
by nradov 3y ago
China isn't even remotely "green". Most of the official statistics coming out of there are highly manipulated. In particular they haven't built even a fraction of the storage capacity that would be needed to keep their factories running when the sun isn't shining, nor are they likely to do so in the next few decades.
- nl 3y agoChina is building multiple 1000km+ HVAC transmission lines which gives climatic diversity (and power source diversity: wind, solar and three gorges). That removes the need for storage (and is what every other country should be doing as well).
- ben_w 3y ago"is/is not" != "can/cannot be". MacKay's work (and the update under discussion) about the UK, and also my claim about China, is about the latter.
- nradov 3y agoLots of things could happen in the sense that they don't violate the laws of physics. But your claim about China isn't grounded in any sort of economic or political reality. The demographic issues alone make a total green energy transformation impossible.
- ben_w 3y agoWhy on earth would demographics make the slightest difference in either direction?
- nradov 3y agoBecause that level of industrial transformation requires huge labor and capital resources that China simply doesn't have. The CCP cadres have been reporting exaggerated numbers up the chain for years in order to keep their jobs so any metrics coming out of the central government are basically junk. https://youtu.be/kBMSZ7v3KxQ?si=ZxlQlOHc6r6tj7n7 https://youtu.be/kBMSZ7v3KxQ?si=ZxlQlOHc6r6tj7n7
- ben_w 3y agoWe know they've got the capacity for the required level of transformation just by looking at the things they export to us, along with satellite pictures[0] of their growing power sources (and indeed all other infrastructure) of all types. [0] Well, remote sensing in general. You can argue if a map at specific spectral lines to detect industrial byproducts is a picture or a graph.