3 ms·
This is smart that there is an attempt in the DC Superior Court as well. There are a couple other lawsuits against Realpage with a similar premise as we speak
by alephnerd 3y ago
This is smart that there is an attempt in the DC Superior Court as well.
There are a couple other lawsuits against Realpage with a similar premise as we speak at the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, and the United States District Court for the Southern District of California.
I think the federal district lawsuits were all merged and moved to United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee a couple days ago, so a number of state level litigations will be a good backup.
Essentially, it looks like there is a coordinated attempt to define algorithmic antitrust at the Supreme Court level. If the DC Superior Court and the Federal Court have a conflicting interpretation, this needs to be reconciled and seems like the type of case that would end up in the Supreme Court.
This has massive implications for AdTech, FinTech, and multiple other industries, probably way more impactful than the Google FTC suit.
Edit: My Interpretation from my comment below
If a subset of companies use the exact same algorithm for price discovery, is there a form of price-fixing? This is the key question being argued.
If the courts rule against Realpage, then any form of algorithmic price discovery en-masse could be found to be anti-competitive.
This might mean you can't use TheTradeDesk and Google Adsense en-masse for example.
Basically, as of today, a lot of price discovery is now automated by a majority of companies using a handful of vendors for this.
Lawyers of HN (looking at your raynier) please hold me accountable for my explanation.
- danielfoster 3y agoIt will be interesting to see how this argued. I personally am not sure such a complex evaluation of the algorithm is needed. If everyone agrees to tell Frank what they charge with the understanding Frank will use this data to tell you what to charge, that’s collusion.
- alephnerd 3y agoYou don't need to evaluate the algorithm. If a subset of companies use the exact same algorithm for price discovery, is there a form of price-fixing? This is the key question being argued. If the courts rule against Realpage, then any form of algorithmic price discovery en-masse could be found to be anti-competitive. This might mean you can't use TheTradeDesk and Google Adsense en-masse for example. Basically, as of today, a lot of price discovery is now automated by a majority of companies using a handful of vendors for this.
- fbdab103 3y agoWhat if the algorithm turns out to be tuned in such a way as to essentially never reduce prices? That is, the algorithm is deliberately crafted in such a way so as to always favor the renters vs the rentees, could that weigh into the argument at all?
- alephnerd 3y agoIdk. To me at least, what the algorithm is doing doesn't actually matter. What actually matters is whether a set of players using a singular algorithm can count as price fixing or not. Like is that coordination or not? This is a fundamental question for the entire API industry, ML Industry, and any other industry dependent on algorithms.
- minkzilla 3y agoI think that is a good question. I am not 100% but I do think you could take the algorithm to extremes and it does matter. Algorithm A - professionally_evaluated_price + inflation Algorithm B - average_price_of_cohort_you_agreed_to_join + 0.01 The first algorithm is super simple and is conceivably how many landlords might do it anyway and is based on value of your goods. Everyone using it wouldn't raise prices or hurt consumers. The second algorithm is basically agreeing with a cohort that you will never undercut each other and slowly raise prices. This obviously hurts renters and raises prices.
- chii 3y agobut algorithm B requires that the cohort you joined be big enough to have a material effect on the market price of said goods/services. So at that point, it's not the algorithm, but the cohort that's at fault of price fixing. So is there proof that you joined a cohort? Does using the same software count as joining a cohort?
- fbdab103 3y agoThese two bullet points from the article seem to indicate that RealPage covers a large swath of the market, and that compliance is mandatory. >The software company actively "polices" landlords to ensure that they comply with the rent cost it generates, the lawsuit alleges. Failure to impose the RealPage rents could lead to landlords being expelled from the organization, according to the suit. > RealPage's software has set the rent at more than 30% of apartments in multifamily buildings in D.C. and 60% of units in large multifamily buildings, per the lawsuit. The percentages are even higher for the broader D.C. metro area.
- FireBeyond 3y ago... and each of you have a contractual agreement with Frank that you will charge what Frank tells you to at least 80% of the time ... ... and each of you knows that each of you has this same contract ...
- jibe 3y agoThere is no 80% contractual obligation. They just say them more you accept their suggested price the more effective it is. “To encourage adherence to its common scheme, RealPage explains that for its services to be most effective in increasing rents, lessors must accept the pricing at least 80% of the time,” according to the suit.
- FireBeyond 3y ago“And we will enforce that by secret shopping you and dropping you from the service if you do not”.
- jibe 3y agoThat's not in the lawsuit, so I don't think it is a valuable addition to the conversation. If it was even implied lawyers would be eager to include it.
- FireBeyond 3y agoThis is a 'complaint'. There is zero requirement to include all evidence that they intend to reference in court. That being said, it absolutely is referenced: > RealPage actively polices Defendants’ agreement to ensure compliance. > This data includes the rents that Defendant Landlords actually charge, providing RealPage with a mechanism for assessing whether Landlords “cheat” on their agreement by deviating from the rent dictated by RealPage’s RM Software. > Their agreement is reflected in existing documents, has been publicly acknowledged by cartel members, and is closely policed to ensure compliance. > Deviations from the RealPage-generated rent are referred to as “overrides.” Consistent with their agreement to impose rents generated by RealPage RM Software nearly all the time, Defendants agreed to limit overrides. For example, a RealPage LRO training document states: “Overrides should be few and far between.” Similarly, internal RealPage LRO training documents teach cartel members’ regional managers to beware of “Override Overload” or “rogue” leasing agents who too frequently override the LRO-generated pricing. > An internal presentation created by Defendant Greystar explicitly acknowledges that RealPage RM Software users should each seek to accept at least 95% of the RealPage-generated prices, emphasizing that “Discipline [o]f using revenue management increases more consistent outcomes.” > Former Greystar employees have similarly confirmed that negotiating rents other than those set by the RealPage RM Software was unacceptable. > Even where Participating Landlords do not enable auto-accept, most landlords cannot, on their own, charge rents other than those generated by RealPage’s RM Software— landlords can only “propose an override.” The landlord must then provide a written business justification for why they wish to depart from the RealPage-generated rent. Sounds like it's very much in the lawsuit. I'm not sure how you come to any other conclusion. It's a core tenet across multiple pages of it. In your previous comment you try to imply it's just "encouraged". And now you're making statements that are demonstrably incorrect (and I found those examples with less than five minutes of skimming the court complaint, so it's hard to imagine how you missed them all).
- tempsy 3y agoVery similar case against Las Vegas hotels for using software to raise room rates “ The lawsuit was originally filed Jan. 26, 2023, seeking class-action damages from MGM Resorts International and Caesars Entertainment, along with Treasure Island and Wynn Resorts. It alleged that the resorts’ use of software from Georgia-based Rainmaker to set prices constituted price fixing, and that supply and demand was disregarded. Customers paid higher prices because Rainmaker’s algorithm created a market that wasn’t competitive, lawyers argued.” https://www.8newsnow.com/news/local-news/judge-dismisses-lawsuit-claiming-las-vegas-strip-hotels-fixed-prices-lawyers-intend-to-refile-case/ https://www.8newsnow.com/news/local-news/judge-dismisses-law...
- alephnerd 3y agoThis explains why they merged the Realpage suits then and also initiated a similar suit at the State/Territory level. It has a very chance of giving conflicting advice on whether a group of organizations using a singular algorithm are committing a form of price fixing. Yea this is probably a Supreme Court case in 2026, and one that will definitely end up in AP Gov textbooks in 2-3 decades
- andy800 3y agoWhich was dismissed recently, although the judge allowed it to be refiled, if some additional details are included. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.reviewjournal.com/business/tourism/judge-rejects-hotel-price-fixing-lawsuit-but-it-can-be-refiled-2928138/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.reviewjournal.com/business/...
- CPLX 3y ago> If a subset of companies use the exact same algorithm for price discovery, is there a form of price-fixing? This is the key question being argued. Maybe so but this is far worse than that. This is actual coordination, like just literal price fixing. For example the software requires users to actively ask for an override if they deviate from the recommendation. It's pretty literally a "trust" in the old school sense, of some kind of organization that coordinates actors across a sector. Price discovery is probably also already illegal, but there's at least one layer removed, in the sense that competitors are sharing price data with each other and using the same algorithmic tools but coming to their own conclusions. My view is that also is and should be illegal, and I hope you're right that the whole approach will be under scrutiny right now. But the rent one is even more clear cut, it's almost impossible to justify unless you're using motivated reasoning to pretend that it's somehow different if you do it in a SaaS platform instead of a conference call or in a smoke filled room.
- alephnerd 3y ago> This is actual coordination This hasn't been decided yet. If 10 companies uses ACME CO's proprietary funded algorithm for price discovery, are those 10 companies commiting price fixing or not? They never explicitly chatted with each other to use ACME Co, yet they all profit from ACME Co's singular results. Is this price fixing or not? We don't legally know yet.
- fbdab103 3y agoI assume this broadly falls into the category of "tacit collusion"[0]. Wikipedia had a blurb on algorithmic tacit collusion was previously noted: >A few years ago, two companies were selling a textbook called The Making of a Fly. One of those sellers used an algorithm which essentially matched its rival’s price. That rival had an algorithm which always set a price 27% higher than the first. The result was that prices kept spiralling upwards, until finally someone noticed what was going on, and adjusted the price manually. By that time, the book was selling – or rather, not selling – for 23 million dollars a copy. >The book "The Making of a Fly" by Peter Anthony Lawrence, written in 1992, briefly achieved a price of $23,698,655.93 on Amazon in 2011.[25] An OECD Competition Committee Roundtable "Algorithms and Collusion" took place in June 2017 in order to address the risk of possible anti-competitive behaviour by algorithms.[26] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacit_collusion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacit_collusion
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- jamescostian 3y ago> This might mean you can't use TheTradeDesk and Google Adsense en-masse for example. Basically, as of today, a lot of price discovery is now automated by a majority of companies using a handful of vendors for this. IANAL but this seems incorrect. Price discovery is one thing, being contractually obligated to keep prices at a certain level 80% of the time is another. A court can make a ruling about that 80% number in the contract without saying anything that impacts one's ability to discover the prices competitors charge
- dataflow 3y ago> If a subset of companies use the exact same algorithm for price discovery, is there a form of price-fixing? This is the key question being argued. No it's not. You're missing a critical bit here. The argument is that there's actual enforcement of the price the software suggests, and at that point it really seems completely irrelevant whether the enforced price was determined by an algorithm or a person: "The software company actively "polices" landlords to ensure that they comply with the rent cost it generates, the lawsuit alleges. Failure to impose the RealPage rents could lead to landlords being expelled from the organization, according to the suit."
- anywhichway 3y agoOne potentially critical line from the article: > Failure to impose the RealPage rents could lead to landlords being expelled from the organization, according to the suit. Makes this arguably much more over the line than just a bunch of landlords that happen to use the same pricing algorithm. Landlords being pressured to not use the algorithm however they want, say setting their price $100/month below the algorithm, under threat of losing access to the algorithm may be what ultimately loses this trial for them. If that is the case, we may not get to a ruling that resolves the legality of the more general practice of many people using the same pricing algorithm.