6 ms·
AI companies have all kinds of arguments against paying for copyrighted content
- anotherhue 3y agoYou've got to love the idea that copyright doesn't apply to input code (from others), but does to their output code. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24117932-apple https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24117932-apple
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoYeah I would love it if these companies simply took a principled stance against IP restrictions, but alas. Like they are literally running directly in to the main problem these restrictions create and then thinking “we need a way to say those don’t apply to us while making sure they still apply to everyone else”.
- alphanullmeric 3y agoHere’s a principled stance: you don’t have the right to a sound, arrangement of pixels, or ideas. IP for nobody. If you disagree, then it should be “IP for everyone” and not “whether or not I support IP depends on who benefits from it”. An answer that differs from piracy to AI training is not a principled answer.
- artninja1988 3y agoCurrently it looks like ai generated content, as well as model weights can't be copyrighted. Either way, free reign for everyone would be great. But I'm afraid big rights holders will try and lobby against this.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoYeah. I think one can fairly clearly make a strong argument against these restrictions, but the organizations that would directly lose in the short term include basically most of the wealthiest companies in the world, so the lobbying effort would be enormous. The whole reason these companies are so wealthy is that IP restrictions very effectively concentrate wealth. This is to the detriment of everyone else, but they will fight hard to keep things this way.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoRight. I believe IP restrictions are harmful, don’t actually do what we commonly believe they do, and are a significant net negative to society. I am in favor of either slowly or quickly abolishing IP restrictions. Tho I think it would need to be done slowly to avoid shocks to an economy which has become dependent on these restrictions.
- 300bps 3y agoWho will pay for Stack Overflow servers and maintenance if OpenAI is just going to scrape their content and stop people from going to Stack Overflow?
- alphanullmeric 3y agoSounds like you support IP then, including stopping piracy.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoGenerally my view is that if we change the way IP works, the world would adapt just fine. Instead of large centralized services we might see smaller federated services. For example something like stack overflow could be hosted on an activity-pub based federated system. The way the fediverse currently works is that a large number of enthusiasts support their little corner of the fediverse with server expenses probably in the hundreds of dollars per year. So instead of one big site with hundreds of thousands of dollars in server costs per year you would have thousands of federated servers with costs in the hundreds of dollars per year. What’s great is that as the user base grows so can the number of servers and the number of enthusiast server operators interested in running their own server. We might also see people start to break down barriers to server costs, for example by lobbying for legal rights to serve content from home with no ISP restrictions related to servers on home internet service. A big company like stack overflow can simply spare the cost of a dedicated business line but thousands of home users might really want to serve content from home. My point is that when you really think it through, you realize that people will find ways to share the information they want. What’s also cool is that for things like the fediverse there generally are no ads. That’s something big central services fail at. And then there’s sites like Wikipedia. I guess I don’t know their license but they simply ask people for what amounts to over a hundred million dollars a year in donations and they get it. So centralized models can work on pure donations if they are appreciated by a large number of users.
- ryandrake 3y ago> Companies will always amorally argue for whatever makes them more money. I There are no principles involved when companies advocate for or against things. Companies will always amorally argue for whatever makes them more money. They are entirely capable of arguing two opposing viewpoints if in one context viewpoint A makes them money and in another context opposite-viewpoint B makes them money. Being consistent, either logically, morally, ethically, or in principle, is not necessary. "Copyright is good and necessary when it makes us money, and copyright is bad and wrong when it doesn't make us money" is a mundane and totally expected opinion coming from a corporation.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoYeah, fair. For my own failings I still find it disappointing when that happens.
- vasdae 3y agoThat's the way it's always worked. You read books to learn to code, then write code and you get paid for it, but that money doesn't trickle down to the writers of the books that taught you to code.
- freejazz 3y agoThose books you read were copyrighted.
- vasdae 3y agoDespite the books being copyrighted that doesn't give the authors any rights over the code I have written.
- anotherhue 3y agoIt does when you produce the code verbatim, as happens frequently.
- jnovek 3y agoBetcha I’ve spontaneously produced code that’s been written before. Who do I owe royalties to?
- sensanaty 3y agoYou're not a computer whose sole purpose is to regurgitate code verbatim at massive scale when requested, unlike an LLM designed for exactly that purpose.
- andromeduck 3y agoExcept LLMs aren't exactly optimized for verbatim regurgitation.
- mistrial9 3y ago
- raytopia 3y agoThere are a lot of double standards when it comes to AI generation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hoosieree 3y agoIf not for Wilhoit's law, we wouldn't have any laws at all!
- JCM9 3y agoThere are potential arguments to say one should be able to use copyrighted material to train a model, but it’s a very slippery slope that leads to logic that also says the resulting models shouldn’t be protectable intellectual property. Thus these arguments could backfire on those making them real quick. At this point though they have no choice but to make them as they’ve all clearly used copyrighted works to build their products. The other challenge here is there needs to be some protection and compensation for folks producing original works in the first place. If we just end up with ML models training on the generated output of other ML models this is all going to go downhill real quick.
- Arubis 3y agoAnd those arguments are now getting attention and legal consideration now that they’re being posited by the rich and the well-capitalized. Some of these rhyme with the fair use and similar arguments put forth by the free software and anti-corporate-owned culture folks for the last couple decades. More honest (if cynical) is A16z’s take, of “the rich already put in a bunch of money, so now you can’t stop it.”
- caconym_ 3y agoOPINION REGARDING SOFTWARE CORPORATIONS' USE OF COPYRIGHTED DATA IN TRAINING PROPRIETARY AI MODELS RE: FAIR USE DOCTRINE, PSEUDOLEGAL REASONING, FACILE, BEAUTIFUL REASONING, FULLY SPECIOUS, TRENDING ON YOUTUBE, WONDERFUL BEAUTIFUL, FALSE EQUIVALENCE, STRAW MAN, TRENDING ON THE VERGE, LOGICALLY INCOHERENT, BEAUTIFUL, TRENDING ON GOOGLE NEWS, FACILE JUSTIFICATION, DEEPLY TORTURED, BEAUTIFUL, WE WILL SAY LITERALLY ANYTHING WE JUST WANT TO KEEP MAKING MONEY WITHOUT COMPETITION, NO RESPECT FOR INDEPENDENT CREATORS, NO RESPECT FOR ACTUAL LEGAL DOCTRINE, NO RESPECT FOR ANYBODY, THE MOST BEAUTIFUL REASONING, TRENDING ON ARS TECHNICA, HACKER NEWS, BY GREG RUTKOWSKI, BY CRAIG MULLINS, BY SPARTH, TRENDING
- artninja1988 3y agoCringe
- breadwinner 3y agoWhat would be the basis of a distinction between artificial vs. wetware intelligence? In both cases, a neural network is being trained.
- Manfred 3y agoScale and speed of adoption influencing the impact on the value of the source material. A person can only service a few projects a year and it takes day or weeks on ingest new knowledge. A trained network only needs to train once and faster than a person, it can then be replicated and is only limited by computing power. That skews the market and the value of the books. I would not write a book if it was then ingested by and AI and never sold to a person.
- breadwinner 3y agoIf that logic is allowed to take hold, consider this: Would it make sense to charge a smarter person more for reading the same book? For example, if a college professor reads a book, and then uses the knowledge gained to teach, that reduces the value of the book (assuming the professor doesn't then use the book as the textbook for a course).
- Manfred 3y agoIt might make sense as a theoretical approximation of the value proposition. But you're going to piss people off if you try, so it's probably not a great sales technique.
- kmeisthax 3y agoAI parameters are at least theoretically ownable while physical collections of neurons are not ownable as per 14A. So long as AI researchers are going to assert ownership over their network parameters, then they also need to conform to the ownership rules over the things they train the parameters against. Of course, those ownership rules are garbage, but the tech industry stopped caring about copyright reform back in like 2004.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 3y agoIf I take a copyrighted song and remix it do I owe the artist a royalty? Yes. Stop making excuses. AI training on copyrighted works is straight wrong no matter how much you don't want it to be. All of my internet comments are copyrighted btw, but I do offer a license of $1b usd/year for using them in a model if you'd like.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoAnd your comment is just a remix of words from things you've read. The question is whether the result is a derivative work, which... I can't completely rule it out, but it's not obvious that that's all LLMs do. It pretty quickly gets to a question of exactly how the tech works and then gets philosophical (what is creativity?).
- mistrial9 3y ago> your comment is just a remix of words from things you've read. authorship in many fields is well defined.. this comment slips into nonsense territory, whatever the view or jurisdiction regarding copyright laws
- Ukv 3y ago> If I take a copyrighted song and remix it do I owe the artist a royalty? Yes. I don't think anyone's saying that the output of the model should be subject to more lenient copyright standards than human creations. If you're selling a remix with substantial similarity to an existing song and it fails the fair use factors, then it'd already be infringement regardless of whether you made it with AI or by hand. The question is: what about the songs that you've listened to, and potentially influenced you, but don't have substantial similarity to the remix? Do you also owe royalties on all of those? For humans the answer is no, but the law doesn't necessarily have to treat AI the same way.
- mg 3y agoIn wonder if copyrighted content will be needed at all in the future of AI training. AlphaZero learned to play chess via self-play, not by reading books about chess. Why couldn't the same happen for art for example? For coding, won't a sufficiently advanced neural net be able to figure out how to use a programming language when given just the documentation? And when most of our interactions are with AI, it will learn from our conversations with it. Asking some AI system why feature X was removed from programming language Y in version Z teaches it something. The next person who asks it which feature was removed from Y in version Z might be told "X". Without the AI system ever having to read about it. The interaction with AI could become a self-learning loop in and on itself.
- riku_iki 3y ago> AlphaZero learned to play chess via self-play, not by reading books about chess. > Why couldn't the same happen for art for example? > For coding, won't a sufficiently advanced neural net be able to figure out how to use a programming language when given just the documentation? some domains are too complex and large to be cracked that way.
- mg 3y agoFor humans, it works.
- riku_iki 3y agohuman brain may still be orders of magnitude more powerful computation tool compared to modern GPU clusters, and you have 8B semiorganized humans on the planet.
- jakeinspace 3y agoI don't think a human deprived from birth of interaction with cultural artifacts or other people would be that much more intelligent than a chimpanzee.
- fwip 3y ago> Why couldn't the same happen for art for example? For starters, because "art" does not have an objective scoring function.
- andy99 3y agoCopyright holders make all kinds of arguments for why they should be get money for incidental exposure to their work. This is all about greed and jealousy. If someone uses AI to make infringing content, existing laws already cover that. The fact that an ML model could be used to generate infringing content, and has exposure to or "knowledge" of some copyrighted material is immaterial. People just see someone else making money and want to try and get a piece of it.
- ethanbond 3y ago> People just see someone else making money in a way that is completely dependent upon their own prior work and want to try and get a piece of it
- qt31415926 3y agoIt's actually impressive that Weird Al has made it as far as he did now that I think about it
- sensanaty 3y agoWeird Al explicitly seeks out the permission from the people whose songs he's parodying, despite not really having to (legally), and he compensates them in kind as well, so kinda the exact opposite of what the AI crowd wants to do.
- kmeisthax 3y agoWeird Al gets permission and licenses for every song parody he makes. The legal definition of parody in fair use wouldn't exactly cover everything he does. That being said, there's still occasionally times where he gets screwed over by the licensing machine anyway - either because the label forgot to ask the artist (Amish Paradise) or because the artist forgot to ask the label (You're Pitiful).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- andrei_says_ 3y ago“We have spent the money of some very rich people and created a popular product. These laws that we ignored go against our interests and should not apply to us. Did we mention, we represent some very rich people. “
- mistrial9 3y ago.. we are going to generate a LOT of money and you (gov) might get some if you treat us well!
- tomjen3 3y agoFor the last time: If I read a book and use an idea in it and you sue me for part of that idea, you will get laughed out of the court room. If I do it with 100 books you will still get laughed out of the court room. AI is only different because it can do the same to a million books.
- simple10 3y agoThe argument of the training inputs are "just like reading a book" seems like a fair statement IMO albeit antiquated these days. However, generating text, audio, or images in the specific style of an individual creator seems like a slippery slope that ultimately deserves some kind of renumeration. I'm glad I'm not a lawyer or politician trying to sort this out. If AI gets commercially crippled, I really don't want to live in a world of black market training data.
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> However, generating text, audio, or images in the specific style of an individual creator seems like a slippery slope that ultimately deserves some kind of renumeration. It never has before. Why now? Someone (more commonly, some group) invents Impressionism, or Art Deco, or heavy metal, or gangsta rap, or acid-washed jeans, or buzz cuts and pretty soon there are dozens or hundreds of other people creating works in that style, none of whom are paying the originators a cent.
- Ukv 3y agoMaking "style" into private property subject to infringement seems like the far more slippery slope to me. I think existing copyright laws are more than sufficient, for cases where there are actually generations with substantial similarity to some protected work.
- Tadpole9181 3y ago> However, generating text, audio, or images in the specific style of an individual creator seems like a slippery slope that ultimately deserves some kind of renumeration. It's hard to find a foothold. Human output doesn't have this restriction. Further, it feels like regulating solar power so coal miners can keep their jobs. Just banning it or regulating output may seem like a solution to some, but all that means is that we'll cripple ourselves so other, more technologically progressive economies can sprint past us in affected markets. Neither saving the jobs in the end, and ultimately hurting more people than the markets we tried to save. But we do desperately need to sort out how this is going to devastate entire markets of labor before it risks major economic upheaval with no safety nets in place.
- 3y ago
- kmeisthax 3y agoCasual reminder that unionization is a far more effective bulwark against AI trash art than copyright ownership and lawsuits are.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoI'm generally pro-union, but I can't see the connection here. Can you expand on this?
- kmeisthax 3y agoThe new WGA contract has fairly strong prohibitions against publishers wielding AI as a tool to devalue writers. They can't insist on writers using ChatGPT and they can't demand a lower rate for "AI-assisted" writing. Individual writers can still prompt ChatGPT but they don't have to use it. Meanwhile, the lawsuit against Midjourney for training on copyrighted work is going... not that great[0]. The judge is paring down a lot of the arguments in the lawsuit. The actual idea behind using copyright to stop AI is that if we give copyright owners of trained-on works the ability to veto that training, then we can just "stop AI". The problem is that most artists don't actually get to own their work. Publishers own the work, it's the first thing you have to bargain away in order to work with a publisher. So they're going to look at their vast dragon's horde of work, most of which isn't particularly profitable to them, and license it out to OpenAI, Stability, MidJourney, or whoever at pennies on the dollar because at their scale that becomes a pretty big deal. To the publishers salivating over generative AI, this cost is not a big deal, because they already spend shittons on writers. So if your goal is to stop worker replacement, just adding a cost to that replacement isn't a good idea. Actually making it illegal or prohibited to actually replace workers with AI is the way to go. [0] https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/judge-pares-down-artists-ai-copyright-lawsuit-against-midjourney-stability-ai-2023-10-30/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/judge-pares-down-ar...
- strken 3y agoIt's a bit ridiculous that a computer is allowed to read books from pirated sources but a human isn't. If you legally buy a copy of a book I don't think the law should distinguish between a human reading it vs an ML system reading it, but training your ML system on a torrent of books that a human couldn't legally read seems a lot worse.
- LeafItAlone 3y ago> It's a bit ridiculous that a computer is allowed to read books from pirated sources but a human isn't. Where does this come from? If I visit your house and you have a Kindle with pirated books, am I liable? Or just you for doing the actual pirating and downloading them? Are AI companies except from the restrictions of accessing copyrighted material they legally are restricted from? Serious question. I remember an article recently about someone suing an AI company claiming that they must have illegally accessed material, but I can't find it now to know how it turned out.
- strken 3y agoI'm thinking specifically of companies which used the books3 dataset (a rip of the private tracker bibliotik) to train LLMs. I was wrong about it being legal, however, and there are ongoing lawsuits.
- kderbyma 3y agohot take. abolish copyright and setup cryptographic systems that base themselves on the concepts of issuance. that way the copyright content is only different because it is 'official' and this way you can have clout because you have the 'legit' copy, but do not enforce arbitration or copyright law. If I want to have the legit copy then I will seek it out, but if I do not know, cannot afford the 'official' copy, then let me get access to the knockoff pirate version ... I accept the risk ....and society benefits from my knowledge gain....GDP is promoted by intelligence, Innovation, hacks, etc. and to achieve that access to knowledge is paramount. that means access to technology
- rickydroll 3y agoI am getting tired of corporations taking public resources, keeping profits for themselves and pushing the costs onto the public. Therefore, I suggest the training sets (content, labeling) for AI systems should be considered world wide common property that everyone can use benefit from.
- amai 3y agoI believe this is relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remix#Copyright_implications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remix#Copyright_implications