11 ms·
Offshore wind has a cable problem
- iancmceachern 3y agoThey should use the power to disassociate sea water into hydrogen, store it, then have a barge come by and collect it. See the "Sea change" ferry project by the SF port for inspiration. Weird that this got down voted, what for?
- davedx 3y agoSo a lot of the bigger hydrogen projects in Europe are doing that except at the onshore connection point. Electrolyzers are hideously expensive so you probably don’t want to cosite them on the actual wind turbine itself. But IIRC there is a pilot project to build a “hub” in the North Sea like this. Edit: yes here it is: https://northseawindpowerhub.eu/hydrogen-production-could-take-place-sea https://northseawindpowerhub.eu/hydrogen-production-could-ta...
- ben_w 3y ago> Electrolyzers are hideously expensive I can easily believe the piping is hideously expensive, likewise the storage, but I find it difficult to believe that the actual electrolysers themselves are expensive, given I built a small one at such a young age I’m not even sure how old I was (single digit, but apart from that, IDK).
- lazide 3y agoefficient hydrolyzers are expensive, both to build and to maintain, especially if they use seawater. Sticking wires in saltwater is cheap.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoWeird that this got down voted, what for? I suspect it's because people get a bit tired of every article on infrastructure challenges getting responses along the lines of "They should just do this thing that I just read about that sounds really cool!" Chances are that the possibility occurred to at least one of the numerous technical experts and professional engineers involved in the project, and there's a reason that's not the favored approach. Sometimes it's because the linked idea has other complications that aren't actually that much easier to solve than the present complications (hydrogen is notoriously difficult to store, because it's so dang small, and it's pretty volatile too), and sometimes it's because a super cool emerging technology that might become the standard for the future isn't actually ready for large-scale deployment, because people literally just figured out how to make it work (why don't people simply have large batteries in every home to balance out grid loads? It seems like a really good idea!). Sometimes problems are hard, and as smart as I'm sure you are, I don't know that you're smarter than everyone involved in this project combined.
- iancmceachern 3y agoWow. I did not imply any of that in my comment. I also did not violate any HN guidelines that I'm aware of. You are assuming I'm a bunch of things I'm not, and then acting accordingly. I don't think that's fair. My comment was applying a classic problem solving technique of combining two problems into one symbiotic solution. Things like using waste heat from industrial processes to heat offices, etc. Check out TRIZ I am not just some random idiot on reddit, I have deep experience here. I don't really feel the need to explain why or how.
- LeanderK 3y agoRandom people proposing unrealistic solutions is something I personally am very tired of. It just really derails any intellectual discussion with baseless fantasising. For example it often happens for discussions on EV. So if you don't state your experience in any convincing way your comment is just noise to me. I won't research your credentials and google you just to judge wether it's random sci-fi or a realistic comment, there are just to many of these comments. I think the down-votes you got reflect this general sentiment. You don't have to explain your experience but then your proposition might not be taken serious. Your comment is also so short that it is really indistinguishable from the sci-fi spam comments.
- iancmceachern 3y agoRandom people trying to make the world a better place is how we move the world forward. There are a million examples of this. Getting outside ideas, outside blood into these kinds of projects is exactly what moves us forward. I'm a engineer, I've been designing large complex systems for 2 decades and I always welcome and even encourage outside perspectives and folks from other industries lending their advice. I was just chatting with the head of a robotics automation startup who found some great synergies in the cabinet making industry. It sounds like you are just tired. It doesn't matter much what your tired of, it sounds like you are tired of all new ideas unless they come from the same old places. That's just exclusionary.
- iancmceachern 3y ago
- iancmceachern 3y agothey could combine it with this desalination setup and not have to send the power out, just fresh water comes out. https://abc7.com/amp/water-desalination-technology-seawell-california-abc7-solutions/14005441/ https://abc7.com/amp/water-desalination-technology-seawell-c...
- teddyh 3y agoOr possibly ammonia? <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38053586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38053586>
- Tade0 3y agoAmmonia is really nasty. While it's technically lighter than air, as a result of spilling it tends to form an aerosol, which travels low to the ground - a cloud of death if you will. Hydrogen is impractical, but ammonia just dangerous. Meanwhile methane apparently can be synthesized pretty efficiently: https://news.rice.edu/news/2023/copper-based-catalysts-efficiently-turn-carbon-dioxide-methane https://news.rice.edu/news/2023/copper-based-catalysts-effic... While it doesn't condense into a liquid at reasonable temperatures, there's ample infrastructure to handle it, since natural gas is largely methane.
- limitedfrom 3y agoI was hoping they would have a clever way of determining what to do with the brine solution, but looks like they just disperse it on the spot. I wonder what the environmental impacts of that looks like.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tpmx 3y agoThe Danish government owns 50.1% of Ørsted. (See: https://orsted.com/en/investors/shares https://orsted.com/en/investors/shares - "Danish State (majority stakeholder)) It's effectively a state company. So, when you think Ørsted, instead think Denmark. Again, for the very slow crowd: here is the ownership graph again: https://orsted.com/en/investors/shares https://orsted.com/en/investors/shares
- ic_fly2 3y agoThis is a dumb take. Ørsted is not a state company. I used to work there. It is a utility. That means lots of ties to the state but the state does not influence decisions. Ørsted screwed up risk management. Norway is probably the wealthiest country on earth. Nothing to do with Soviets.
- tpmx 3y ago> Ørsted is not a state company. Except it is and you are wrong.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y agoIt’s possible for there to be a distinction between state-owned and state-run (see the BBC). Perhaps you could discuss why you think it is state-run rather than just state-owned instead of resorting to insults.
- tpmx 3y agoI responded to an insult. And I was being factual. Please reflect on your own behavior. And no, no there is no BBC-like distinction here. Ørsted is company run by the Danish government, period. The link above should be proof enough to any thinking person.
- LeafItAlone 3y ago> Except it is and you are wrong. It has been excepted.
- robomartin 3y agoLasers. Everything is better with lasers. Use high power lasers to transmit the power. In case it has to be said...joke.
- Ajay-p 3y agoWhat you say is not a joke. There has been research into space based solar power which would beam this power down to earth to a collector point. Perhaps it is possible? Could power be safely beamed from sea to port? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-based_solar_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-based_solar_power
- teddyh 3y agoIn space it could well be plausible, but I feel like the losses from air resistance would be more than could be done using an electrical cable.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Could power be safely beamed from sea to port? Beaming straight up and down incurs much less atmosphere than beaming horizontally at sea level.
- mNovak 3y agoInteresting that much of the issue isn't necessarily the cables, rather the insuring of the cables
- ic_fly2 3y agoYes, and why? That is the mad bit.
- erikpukinskis 3y agoPresumably because the coverage triggers happen at a frequency that makes the premiums more expensive than the developers want to pay? Insurance companies are usually quite happy to take your money as long as the premiums will cover their expenses.
- lazide 3y agoIt means the juice isn’t worth the squeeze for them (aka payouts have been > premium payments often, or so close they can’t make money.).
- swader999 3y agoThe cost of insuring the cables just reflects the underlying dynamics.
- hristov 3y agoThis would just be a minor improvement, but we should all stop and think how much better all society would be if every country just flat out banned fishing trawlers every where in its territorial waters. For one we would have more and tastier fish. We would also have less cables being damaged.
- staplers 3y agoMore fish = greater oceanic ecosystem top to bottom. Everyone forgets the ocean when discussing carbon capture. Micro organisms can help a lot.