4 ms·
> I wonder what the motivation is here, I've heard this sentiment expressed many times. I think it's the fantasy of having complete autonomy, of being complete
by JohnFen 3y ago
> I wonder what the motivation is here, I've heard this sentiment expressed many times.
I think it's the fantasy of having complete autonomy, of being completely free in the sense of never having to do anything that you don't want to do[1]. At least, that's that's the aspect of it that resonates with me.
But it's only that -- a fantasy. Much like other things that we fantasize about, it's impossible as conceived because it dwells on the upsides and omits the downsides. Humans run in packs. We are social. It's that aspect that has always been the key to our ability to survive even in extremely bad circumstances.
The trade-off, looking purely from a selfish point of view, is that we give up some degree of autonomy in exchange for benefits that are so essential and fundamental that we are in great peril without them. We have better lives as part of a group than in isolation, despite being unable to do literally anything we want.
In that sense, it's a lot like some kinds of sexual fantasies. Hot as hell in your imagination, but not so great (or even possible) in reality.
[1] As the Frank Zappa lyric goes: "Free is when you don't have to pay for nothin' or do nothin'. I want to be free."
- brnaftr361 3y agoI think it's more nuanced than that. As it's currently ordered society is a forced participation regime. I don't get the option to say "no." to a great many things. This is due to a loss of security, I don't get to refuse work at a job or in general, and in the case that I do it becomes a compromise, and this compromise is largely arbitrary because there are really very few actual social distinctions in the world currently because the undergirding has overwhelmingly been hijacked by this weird captive environment that has been engineered to support the dominant status quo. However, it is not necessarily the case that this is the "final solution." but the level of ossification presents a substantial challenge. I think this is particularly salient in the American domestic politic, but as the reigning sovereign of the world that has very significant geopolitical impacts globally. Not to mention the fact that we're also the largest consumer market and the most profound conglomerate of companies the world over. To the question of saying "no.", It's questionable that all but the elite suffer from such stricture. For instance if I were to purchase in full some allotment of land which I inhabited, the government would still extract taxes from it, taxes which I would be obliged to pay, and thus I would necessarily require some income. That's without considering the more likely case of mortgaging a home in the suburbs, taking a loan for a car, the myriad bills necessary to sustain a "functional" life, all the sundry little accessories that invariably set up a treadmill of break and replace... Factor in a family and the manifold complications it inserts - viola - no options available. This is, of course, not actually the natural course of things and all of this is malleable. Overcoming the massive inertia of the antiquated systems and their underpinning ideas is a huge challenge though. This itself largely due to the overwhelming coherent mass. But I think anyone would be insane to say they support things as they currently are at any level. But very few are positioned to refuse. It's indenture, but structured in such a way that "society" can point its finger and place blame on the individual.
- foogazi 3y ago> As it's currently ordered society is a forced participation regime Yes, as long as an entity owns the land they want to get paid for it - either to live on it, game, cross I’d say the free life doesn’t scale but maybe it doesn’t have to for those that can find their own corner of Earth Do Bedouin tribes pay taxes or tariff ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FooBarBizBazz 3y ago> the government would still extract taxes from it, taxes which I would be obliged to pay, and thus I would necessarily require some income. To solve this, you need to balance your obligations to the government (property taxes), against obligations from the government (bonds of some kind). I'll use TIPs for my example, because it's harder for the government to inflate away these obligations. A plot of land might have taxes of $1,000/yr. It looks like TIPs give a fixed real rate of 1.3%. So, $77k in TIPS will balance out your taxes. You need to add that to the true price of the land. Obviously, there is the question of how you obtain that capital. So in a sense we are generally born "in the red", and need to work our way out of these implicit debts. But it can be done, even within the system.
- azmodeus 3y agoReally cool perspective
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoTwo corrections: 1. If you look at recent Treasury auctions, 30-year TIPS are actually yielding 1.5%, not 1.3% (https://treasurydirect.gov/auctions/announcements-data-results/ https://treasurydirect.gov/auctions/announcements-data-resul...). 2. In reality, you have a finite lifetime, so you can spend down the principal. Suppose you are 30 years old (about the youngest I could imagine this being possible), and that you plan on living to 100 (most people don't). That's 70 years. If you do the math, and use the 1.5% rate, it works out that you only need $43k, not $77k, to hit that $1k/yr number.
- coldtea 3y ago>But it's only that -- a fantasy. Much like other things that we fantasize about, it's impossible as conceived because it dwells on the upsides and omits the downsides If one is OK with the downsides, it's completely possible, and a lot of people have done it for extended periods of time, even whole decades...
- JohnFen 3y agoI'm sure that there are people who have done this, but I'm also sure they're exceedingly rare. Almost always, people living independently like that are still relying on some aspect of society to some degree. They trade for products they can't manufacture, for instance, or benefit more indirectly (such as benefiting from the society's efforts to maintain some level of peace).
- coldtea 3y ago>are still relying on some aspect of society to some degree So? It's not like society would dissapear overnight, and those people would be left with no such recourse. The person asking just asked for some place without taxes and no price on a plot of land you can claim. They didn't say they want to move all of society to that, or that they want to make a point by relying on their own self entirely.
- JohnFen 3y ago(You were replying to my comment, so I took your comment in that context. My apologies is my reply is off the mark.) The point being that you're still giving up some amount of personal liberty in order to be able to successfully interact with society, even if that interaction is minimal. You are still a part of that society. You are not completely independent of it. Ashleigh Brilliant had a great one-liner about this: no man is an island, but some of us are very long peninsulas.