5 ms·
'It' ? What exactly is immoral and why?
by defrost 3y ago
'It' ?
What exactly is immoral and why?
- kzrdude 3y agoThat support comes with requirements and they will try to get you "reintegrated" and into a job so that you can support yourself. To use it as a salary with no intention to work is not according to the purpose of this service.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 3y agoAnother way to look at this would be in the context of subsidies aimed at less populated areas of the country. A lot of people are concerned about the countryside going empty, and there are various policies aimed at reversing or at least halting that. They are necessarily income-transfer programs where cities subsidize the countryside. An individual getting paid 500 euros to live in a remote area doesn’t seem like a bad deal in that context. It’s a much more measurable outcome than many of these other programs, at least. But somehow giving money to an individual is much more morally controversial than giving money to a larger collective like a province or state. For example, Republicans generally don’t have a problem with federal programs that transfer income from rich states like California and New York to poor states like Alabama and Mississippi. But they would absolutely oppose similar income transfer on a personal level.
- danbruc 3y agoWould the aim of such programs not be to have a working society in those less populated areas instead of just filling it with non-working people completely dependent on others?
- pavlov 3y agoPeople change. Especially for young people, I personally think it’s valuable to give them opportunities that are not immediately productive. If you could get a 21-year-old to move into the countryside, it might have significant long-term upside even if the person appears like a slacker right now. They could find a spouse and have kids. They could come up with an online business (which might still look like “slacking at a computer” to most of the world). They could eventually do local volunteer work that is important but can’t get done at market prices. There’s a lot of ways that a young person’s life can go. For older people the equation is a bit different for obvious reasons. But most government programs can’t discriminate by age, so you’d have to aim at a compromise.
- danbruc 3y agoSure, but that is for the people that finance the basic subsidence to deside, they decide what they expect in return. If they want to give the money unconditionally, fine, then it would of course not be immoral to take them up on the offer. I do not know what the Norwegian rules say, so maybe it is like that. On the other if you structure it like that, you open yourself up for exploitation by people who could work but prefer not to. And this could very well make them reconsider the conditions or make the entire thing unsustainable.
- marak830 3y agoIt is something that is be interested to read about - using a basic stipend to redistrube wealth, to try and offset soloing (as in cities), which would (theoretically) help revitalise country towns (with more locals able to spend cash locally) An addition would be to create various centres to allow people to learn new skills and eventually reenter the workforce
- caskstrength 3y ago> A lot of people are concerned about the countryside going empty, and there are various policies aimed at reversing or at least halting that. They are necessarily income-transfer programs where cities subsidize the countryside. I wonder why. I would love to empty and re-wild more countryside.
- danbruc 3y agoTaking money from the state for which others worked to finance your life without making an attempt to finance your life yourself.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imtringued 3y agoThe inverse perspective is that you have been forced to not be able to finance yourself and I have both theory and evidence that this is true for a non zero percentage of the population. In that sense, not spending "other people's money" was never an option to begin with. Instead of using a framing that sees other people as parasites, I prefer to see it as a bribe to people to get them away from me and leave me alone.
- danbruc 3y agoWhat would those circumstances be that prevent people from working to support their life?
- mopenstein 3y agoIt's the coercive nature by which wealth is redistributed to other people that brings upon the questions of morality. If I'm forced at the end of a barrel of a gun to give up any portion of the fruits of my labor to support others, it is immoral.
- Podgajski 3y agoThat’s what you have to do when peoples hearts are spiritually dead. Otherwise, the people who have nothing will rise up against you anyway.
- danbruc 3y agoIf the majority of people in your country agrees that wealth redistribution is bad, then just elect a government that will stop doing it.
- caskstrength 3y ago> If the majority of people in your country agrees that wealth redistribution is bad, then just elect a government that will stop doing it. That is why they (the upper class) came up with progressive taxes - so middle class (the minority) would subsidize lower classes (the majority). Basically you suggest a pack of wolves and a ship to democratically decide who will be eaten for dinner.
- mopenstein 3y agoVoting is immoral too. If I don't support the potential outcome, how could I justify participating? Here's a scenario for you: 11 people in a room. They decide to take a majority vote to murder one of the 11 at random. What's your vote? No? What happens in the case you're outvoted? You are now complicit in murder. Vote yes? You are now complicit in murder. Casting your vote is your acknowledgement that the you accept the results. The only moral action is to object, conscientiously and refuse to participate. Now stand in a room of 300,000,000 people where the end result of your participation is endless evil and murder. Congratulations.
- kuschku 3y ago
- watwut 3y agoNot OP, but imo, these subsidies exists so that people who have issues can get by. And that is a good thing. Just making decision to live off that and spend time doing hobbies is abusing good thing and asocial. People who openly advocate for something like that are endangering existence of those programs for those who really need it because of mental health or physical issues. Moreover, those programs typically comes with social workers and requirements designed to make you change your life. You should cooperate with that goal so that you cease to be so dependent.