3 ms·
Which of Mozilla's "bets" ever remotely panned put? The only thing they got going for them, wasn't even an official bet by Mozilla, they were making the crappy
by coldtea 3y ago
Which of Mozilla's "bets" ever remotely panned put?
The only thing they got going for them, wasn't even an official bet by Mozilla, they were making the crappy bloated broswer + suite, and some community members created Firefox (then Phoenix).
They should focus 100% on regaining browser market share and innovating on the browser space, instead of the numerous diversions. Of course as long as the C-team is paid handsomnly while driving Firefox to the ground, and Google pays them, they won't care.
- 542458 3y agoIdk, Rust seems to be working out. Thunderbird is working as well.
- DoctorOW 3y agoRust is a Linux Foundation project, and the process of adding more Rust code to Firefox is (to my knowledge) less of a priority. I love Firefox, but Mozilla enjoys shooting itself in the foot too much.
- steveklabnik 3y agoRust is not a Linux Foundation project. The Rust Foundation is its own foundation.
- 542458 3y agoRust was created by a Mozilla employee and sponsored by Mozilla, and Mozilla was the debatably the most significant organization-level contributor to the project from 2006 through 2020.
- derf_ 3y agoIf you will permit me to tout things I worked on while there, Opus seems to have been pretty successful? The final story has not yet been written on AV1, but it is still the best chance we have had for a royalty-free video format and thanks to YouTube, Netflix, Facebook, etc. now makes up a non-trivial fraction of the bits on the internet. That ought to be enough to get it over the "ever remotely panned out" bar. I find myself using WebRTC quite a bit these days, too, so happy to have been a (small) part of that.
- 542458 3y agoThat’s another great example, thank you.
- coldtea 3y ago>Idk, Rust seems to be working out. Rust was created to write a new rendering engine in, which they abandoned half-way. Then they abandoned Rust itself. And, guess what, they also abandoned Thunderbird: "Thunderbird has been independent since 2012. See https://blog.lizardwrangler.com/2012/07/06/thunderbird-stability-and-community-innovation/ https://blog.lizardwrangler.com/2012/07/06/thunderbird-stabi... Many people have not realized this, but for Thunderbird to grow and adapt to a changing environment having some sort of income stream is important. There is a limit to what the volunteers can do. Hence significant fund raising efforts. The web site perhaps answers the current arrangement best. https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/about/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/about/ One of the issues we face is that people in general do not differentiate between Mozilla co the commercial entity that produces Firefox and the Mozilla foundation that owns it. Thunderbird's arrangements are with the foundation, not the company."
- 542458 3y agoI’m not sure why you feel my thunderbird point is invalid. The parent post on this thread didn’t specify which Mozilla entity they were talking about, so I interpreted it is all of them generally. Mozilla Foundation owns MZLA which pays for developers of Thunderbird. I don’t see that as Mozilla (collectively) abandoning Thunderbird. They just changed the fundraising umbrella.
- asadotzler 3y agoFirefox was created by, and planned, and executed by people on Netscape's dime at first then on the Mozilla Foundation's dime. There were a few really valuable volunteers that came later, PCH for example helped rewrite bookmarks before 1.0, but to suggest that Firefox just landed on Mozilla from "the community" is horse shit. Firefox was a considered bet by Mozilla's leadership team in the summer of 2002. I know this because I was on Mozilla's leadership team and in the meeting where it was decided. It took place at a table outside of Netscape's building 21 after Mitchell'd been laid off but while a few of us still worked there to manage the Mozilla project. The guy that started what would become Firefox, Ben Goodger (and who quickly abandoned it) was a Netscape employee. Like me, a couple years earlier he'd been hired by Netscape thanks to his Mozilla volunteering efforts. The guy that picked up the abandoned corpse and reanimated it was a Netscape intern named Blake Ross, a high school kid that I'd recruited into the Mozilla project as a volunteer. After Ben dropped it (perhaps to pursue Manticore, his .Net standalone browser project) Blake and I worked on it. Jason Kersey, another Mozilla volunteer that got a job at Netscape, contributed CSS and icons and gave us our first working theme I think (Remember mozillaZine? that was Jason, well, it was started by Chris Nelson, but Jason had mozBin, the place to go for binaries before Netscape/Mozilla provided them, well they joined forces for what most folks recall as mozillaZine's early years.) A few of us worked on "m/b" for a couple months, you could find progress updates at my blog, and as summer got into full swing, a couple other members of the leadership team and myself, at an outdoor table at Netscape, pitched the larger group on moving away from the integrated application suite to what would become Firefox and Thunderbird. There were a few good reasons, but chief among them, I believe, in convincing Brendan and Mitchell, was that a failure of one could not tank the other as with the integrated suite. If we had a crasher in MailNews, it took down the Browser, the whole suite crashed, ugly. They were tightly coupled and with AOL in shut-down mode with Netscape, and resourcing in doubt, that was a risk that standalone apps wouldn't have. Also, if you didn't need mail, you didn't have to take on that shared UI overhead. Two .exes were better than one. There were other arguments made, Dave Hyatt, who was in that meeting as well, I think, advocated for "XUL done right" a clean user interface implementation without the Netscape compromises that made Mozilla and Netscape slower than need be. Dave created XUL, he was one of the architects of the cross platform toolkit that Mozilla adopted when it moved to NGLayout (Gecko). Well, staff@mozilla was convinced and we began planning the transition. A couple months later I shipped the first public version, Phoenix 0.1. I may have a detail or two off here, but my point is I was there, an integral part of all of this, and Firefox was not "some community members" tossing something over a wall to a hapless Mozilla/Netscape. Firefox originated on Netscape's dime, by people Netscape harvested from the community, and Firefox's development up to v1.0, 95% of it anyway, was paid for by the Mozilla Foundation who employed Ben and Blake and me and others to take that prototype from a hobby project of a few Netscapers waiting for the axe, to a full product release with a strong and growing organization behind it. Surely most of you know, but for those who don't, Dave and much of his Netscape team went to Apple and did Safari on KHTML and Ben and several other Mozilla and Netscape folks went to Google and did Chrome. Firefox was founded in part by some of the founders of Safari and Chrome. We all worked closely together for 2 or 3 years in the end-times at Netscape, a few of us a bit longer. Were there volunteers that helped Firefox get to 1.0? Yes. For sure. Most of them were ex-Netcape(Mozilla) like Bryan Ryner, ex Netscaper who helped us go cross platform with Firefox. We had originally planned on Windows only with Camino on Mac and Galeon probably for Linux. Once we became the official Mozilla browser though we needed Mac and Linux support and bryner got those platforms standing up for us. We had two community contributed themes, before the Mozilla Foundation worked with artists and agencies to get a couple of professional themes. I mentioned Pierre Chanail's bookmkarks rewrite. In the end, Firefox was a Mozilla project through and through. It originated as a pet project at Netscape, not "from the community" as you've suggested, and Mozilla adopted it almost immediately. Before it even had a name, when Dave, Blake, Ben, and I just called it "m/b" for mozilla/browser the cvs repo where it lived, Mozilla's leadership team, a group that included Dave and myself, were advocating for adopting it as the official browser. As Netscape was imploding and we were creating the life boat Mozilla Foundation, the few remaining Netscape employees and a few laid off or moved on ex-Netscapers kept it alive with the Phoenix 0.x release (I managed almost all of those) until the Mozilla Foundation was created where we went through a couple of quick name changes and it finally became Firefox. BTW, I believe Jason gets credit for the name Firefox. Not 100% sure but we were all at the same whiteboard and that's my memory.
- g-b-r 3y agoMy experience is that the crap began with Firefox, Mozilla (the browser) was much better in terms of interface, and it felt better with xul (more control, much less bloat vs. Firefox + Thunderbird) than without it
- coldtea 3y agoFirefox was originally created with XUL and was still using XUL until around 2019 when it was totally removed. And nobody really loved and preferred Mozilla the browser at the time Phoenix/Firefox came out, this is why it immediately got huge adoption, despite being unofficial for a good while. The crap began with Mozilla leadership some years after Firefox - perhaps at the time of their mobile OS and smartphone efforts, but in general when starting to care more for getting the sweet Google cash and doing BS token attempts at anything they would "brainstorm" than being an actual player in the browser space.
- g-b-r 3y agoI can assure you that PLENTY of people loved Mozilla and were pissed off by Firefox. I'm still astonished that it gained fans, anyhow their crappy behavior towards users, privacy etc clearly began at that point, from what I recall. That then it got worse and worse with the years, absolutely