6 ms·
DALL-E 3 Is So Good It's Stoking an Artist Revolt Against AI Scraping
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rntn 3y agohttps://archive.ph/heiQ0 https://archive.ph/heiQ0
- skilled 3y agoRelated, New data poisoning tool lets artists fight back against generative AI (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37990750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37990750) Oct 2023 - (85 comments) Nightshade, a tool allowing artists to 'poison' AI models (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38013151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38013151) Oct 2023 - (71 comments)
- namegulf 3y agoUnfortunately it's only available via ChatGPT plus No API
- _lvbh 3y agoIt has an API, just undocumented. Check GitHub and you’ll find a ton of libraries for it. I just added for DALLE today for mine (no documentation yet)
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoOpenAI has an API that is fully documented. Are you saying there are parts that aren't documented? For example, the documented API has calls for generating images with DALL-E 2. Is there undocumented API for generating with DALL-E 3? One that uses pay-as-you-go pricing like DALL-E 2, rather than requiring a $20/month purchase of ChatGPT Plus?
- _lvbh 3y agoYeah I mean the ChatGPT Plus one. It streams JSON similarly to the official API. Works well enough
- wodenokoto 3y agoAnd Azure
- robertheadley 3y agoAI is inevitable. That being said, artists deserve to be compensated for their work and I see something being set up to do that (perhaps begrudgingly) in the future. ChatGPT already doesn't allow you to copy the style of a specific artist.
- mistrial9 3y agonothing aside from the laws of physics itself, is "inevitable".. adding a quip about "protections are already there" makes the intent clear
- philipov 3y agonot even the laws of physics are inevitable, except for thermodynamics
- gnicholas 3y agoI wonder if you can ask it to describe an artist's style, and then use that description in a subsequent prompt for image generation.
- adventured 3y agoI asked GPT4 to give me prompt terms ideal for Thomas Kinkade > To evoke the style of Thomas Kinkade in a chat prompt, one might use descriptions like "radiant warmth," "soft-edged realism," and "gentle natural light." His paintings often conveyed a sense of bucolic perfection and peaceful retreats, featuring cozy cottages, flourishing gardens, and tranquil waters. The scenes are typically bathed in the golden light of dawn or the rosy hues of dusk, with a magical, almost ethereal quality to the light that seems to emanate from within the scene itself. The colors would be described as vibrant yet soft, with a harmonious palette that creates a nostalgic and dreamlike atmosphere. Using the terms provided, without mentioning the artist, Dalle3 spit out: https://i.imgur.com/10pr0A9.jpg https://i.imgur.com/10pr0A9.jpg https://i.imgur.com/kG4Mapf.jpg https://i.imgur.com/kG4Mapf.jpg The two prompts I used were [note: I picked a scene / location]: "generate an image for this prompt: "bucolic perfection, cozy cottages, flourishing gardens, radiant warmth, soft-edged realism, gentle natural light, bathed in rosy hues of dusk, vibrant soft colors" "generate an image for this prompt: "bucolic perfection, new york city, autumn, flourishing trees, radiant warmth, soft-edged realism, gentle natural light, bathed in rosy hues of dusk, vibrant soft colors" Seems to get you pretty close to the style of Kinkade with very little prompt effort.
- lemoncookiechip 3y agoDALL-E 3 is quite amazing for a single model without any additional tools like SD's, but it's so limited by what you can ask of it, that even some basic prompts like "woman" can get your prompt blocked immediately on occasion. Also, for those in the comments saying it's only available via ChatGPT, it's not. You can use it through both Bing Chat AI and Bing Image Creator for free, and although the latter as speed priority tokens that refresh over time, the Bing Chat AI doesn't and you can prompt it to do multiple images over and over as long as it finished commenting and the image is generating. If anyone wants to see what DALL-E 3 is capable of, they can check these two hashtags on Twitter/X #DALLE3Beta #DALLE3Art.
- ronsor 3y ago> that even some basic prompts like "woman" can get your prompt blocked immediately on occasion. Microsoft has decided that women are against their content policy.
- pseudo0 3y ago"White" and "Caucasian" sometimes get blocked as well. I was trying to generate a specific character for a D&D campaign and that kept triggering their filter. Subtracting that from the lengthy prompt would allow it to emit outputs.
- didntcheck 3y agoDo they also still inject words into your prompt to make it more "inclusive"?
- friendlynokill 3y agoThey do https://github.com/spdustin/ChatGPT-AutoExpert/blob/main/_system-prompts/all_tools.md https://github.com/spdustin/ChatGPT-AutoExpert/blob/main/_sy...
- latchkey 3y agoI tried the Bing freebie and after 7 minutes it still hadn't returned a single result. $20/mo for DALL-E3 is worth every penny.
- danShumway 3y agoEh... maybe I am less up-to-date on the current state of AI image generation, and I don't feel like I'm fully up-to-date with DALL-E 3's capabilities. But my experience around GPT has been that sometimes articles like this play up a controversy that may not have really changed much or that might be fueled by different causes or social conditions, and they play up that controversy as a way of playing up the capability of a specific model. This is very common with GPT: "our model is so good that it's dangerous." Sometimes worrying publicly and loudly about something is just a marketing technique. So I don't know that DALL-E 3 is the reason that artists are mad about this, and I'm not completely sure that they are significantly madder than they used to be, and it's not clear to me reading this article that anything beyond the opt-out form is specific to DALL-E 3. Artists are mad about AI image generation period, they are also upset about OpenAI's opt-out process (as one of many processes, Meta's opt-out process is even worse). But are they madder than usual about DALL-E 3's results? Are they actually mad about DALL-E 3 because they think it's crossing some technical milestone? The title here is an editorialization on behalf of the article writer that does not seem supported by the text or sources. I don't see strong evidence from artists that DALL-E 3 in specific is such a shocking leap forward for AI image generation that they are suddenly now more worried about this than they used to be. Again, I'm not fully up-to-date on everything, so maybe it is a leap forward. But the article doesn't make that case, it just kind of says that DALL-E 3 is amazing and implies that the current conversations are specifically the result of DALL-E 3 being just so good. I've just seen that play out before; I'm skeptical of any article that takes a general social trend and says, "this trend exists because this specific product is revolutionary." Is there a quote from an artist in this article that I've missed that is saying that DALL-E 3's capabilities have made them more worried about AI generated images?
- kderbyma 3y agonot impressed - it was a cool party trick but all stuff requires intelligence to apply....anyone can. make a bunch of crap and lower the temperature of the room...no one cares unless it impacts their lives in some appreciable way and so far this is just making people who didn't have talent to begin with now wrongly believe that they suddenly do....AI will never give people a good sense for design...nor will it help them appreciate music ...
- superkuh 3y agoIt's extremely obvious that the trained models for image generation are operating under fair use. There's absolutely no way a 3GB .bin file actually contains any substantial fraction of any one person's intellectual property. This is just magical thinking by some loud ignorant subset of the artist population. Or maybe not even that but just some lawyers claiming to represent them with a couple big name clients. I would not presume to think these loud ignorants represent even a substantial fraction of artists who probably understand the technical aspects of this and appreciate the new tools available. Viewing a website and the multi-media files displayed on it is not inherently evil or bad and giving it the name "scraping" does not make it so. Let's not adopt this lawyer-ese framing. These people seem to want to have their cake and eat it too.
- tanvach 3y agoI'm assuming you are not an artist?
- cjbgkagh 3y agoMachine learning is incredibly good at lossy compression, 3GB is a lot of entropy to work with.
- Ukv 3y agoTrue that ML is good for lossy compression, but it's not "produce a copy of any image with less than a byte average of information" good, like is claimed in the Joseph Saveri Law Firm lawsuit against Stable Diffusion: > Because a trained diffusion model can produce a copy of any of its Training Images—which could number in the billions—the diffusion model can be considered an alternative way of storing a copy of those images. In essence, it’s similar to having a directory on your computer of billions of JPEG image files.
- toss1 3y agoRight. Just like there is "no way" that a 3 Lb hink of gray cells can memorize epic poems or figure out how to design ships to fly to other celestial bodies. IOW: It doesn't work that way. The GPTs do not store representations, they store what are effectively generation instructions. A formula ir program can generate nearly unlimited terabytes of data, but we don't need to store the output to recreate it; we need only store the formula or code. So the "only 3GB" argument does not mean that sufficient instructions have not been stored via ingesting an artist's works to effectively infringe on that artist's works without literally storing copies.
- coldacid 3y agoDon't tell me that DALL-E is good. I'm still waiting for it to generate hands instead of shoggoth tentacles.
- unshavedyak 3y agoFunny, i bought art recently from an (human) artist who has trouble with hands.
- kolinko 3y agoWhat? Dalle generates hands with no issues.
- agildehaus 3y agoOften but certainly not always.
- pan69 3y agohttps://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/pranavdixit/ai-generated-art-hands-fingers-messed-up https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/pranavdixit/ai-generate...
- carnitine 3y agoJanuary 2023 is an age ago in terms of generative AI. DALL-E 3 has been out what, a month? I just tried and it generated hands no problem.
- pan69 3y agoSure. I get that. I was simply providing context to kolinko's comment (albeit in a low effort way) in case he/she wasn't aware that this was a problem at some in time.
- v64 3y agoA dated stereotype at this point. The latest versions of Dalle, Stable Diffusion, Midjourney etc. are much better at this. Generation of words (e.g. making signs that say specific things and not gibberish) has also improved.
- m3kw9 3y agoJust look at logos, you used to pay to have logos made, but you can get it cheap for 20 a month or if get your logo, it’s one time 20$ fee
- GaggiX 3y agoFor a logo you usually want a SVG, and software that converts raster images to vector images do not generate SVG that are topologically correct (so they don't use circles to represent circles but hundreds of lines), maybe there would be a model to do that in future (or there is one that I don't know about).
- jrm4 3y agoI'm not exactly certain right now, but from what little I've seen from the diversity of the whole SD ecosystem, I would be quite shocked if that didn't already exist.
- ThalesX 3y agoWhat makes you so shocked? SVG is a different format than PNG or JPG or BMP or the likes.
- jrm4 3y agoI'm aware of the difference between vector and raster; but this is image creation via mathematical modeling, which essentially is how vector graphics work. Seems like it would be a very small jump.
- riversflow 3y agoI mean, I can take a logo and create a vector image in Illustrator in an hour, without any tool. I'm not even skilled with Illustrator.
- m3kw9 3y agoBut it gives you a lot of interesting options, and most will tire out after an hour
- zwieback 3y agoAll of this handwringing over AI is justified but it really drives home the point that humans just aren't nearly as cool as they like to think. Also striking: if you average all our creative output and blend it together the result is something most individuals would have real trouble creating.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- newprint 3y agoYou are missing the whole point or ignorant of history: the "average mass" that you are referring to, is what keeps ART going and what keeps traditions. Geniuses and outliers propel ART forward. One doesn't exist without the others.
- zwieback 3y agoYes, agreed, I think you just rephrased my second paragraph.
- Animats 3y agoArtists are going to lose this one. Much of the training data is pictures of the real world. There's plenty of out-of-copyright human made art to train on for style. Legal problems come from trying to imitate popular culture, and that's a trademark and trade dress issue, not copyright. Disney will litigate that as needed. Expect something soon where you put in a book and get out a graphic novel. Then, put in a screenplay and get out a storyboard. Then, put in a storyboard and get a movie.
- The-Bus 3y agoNot a graphic novel you'd want to read, or a movie you'd like to watch.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLet the market, their dollars, and their attention decide.
- gedy 3y agoEven aside from "AI", movies are already formulaic - you plug in popular celebrities into an already-told story, pick a setting and music, there you go. I kind of wish they already let you generate this - you want that celeb in this setting, or a mixed race couple, or all Asian characters, etc, go for it vs studios picking and choosing for you.
- Animats 3y agoVirtual celebrities are here. Hatsune Miku was the first. They're a big thing in China.[1] Partly because they can't get into trouble in their private life. [1] https://www.insider.com/chinas-flawless-ai-influencers-the-hot-new-queens-of-advertising-2021-8 https://www.insider.com/chinas-flawless-ai-influencers-the-h...
- sogen 3y agoGorillaz, The Residents, GWAR
- mmmpetrichor 3y agoI don't think any amount of lawsuits is going to prevent AI from replacing many of our jobs. We're all going to be in squarely the same position as these artists within the coming couple of decades. There was a conversation between Elon musk and Rishi sunak where Elon was exclaiming that people wouldn't have to work, and made it sounds like they'd only need to if they enjoyed it. Unfortunately for "people", working is currently required as to not be homeless. And just as after globalization took away many of our middle class solid jobs, we won't all magically get "better" jobs after this new technology delivers even more wealth to the rich.
- Bjorkbat 3y agoI had no problems with this article other than the headline calling DALL-E “so good”. If you’re using AI art for anything other than personal curiosity you’re probably using it because it costs next to nothing to make a generated stock image for your blog or children’s e-book.
- Remolotpi 3y agoWhy? Having taste and knowing what you like doesn't mean you have to know how to draw or knowing the artist. It's enough if you can use ai for it. That's what people normally like on art: it's good. You don't see any issue and it speaks to you. There is no difference in going to art galleries or clicking through the internetz.
- mortenjorck 3y agoAm I the only one who can typically spot AI illustrations a mile away? It’s not nearly as easy with photorealistic imagery, which Midjourney has been able to produce passably for over a year, but for anything stylized, it feels like even Dall-E 3 content still has a thousand little tells. It’s as if the embedded rules of photorealism are well-represented enough in the training data as to reliably cross the uncanny valley, but in illustration, where the internal logic of an image is much more self-contained, there’s still too little to go on for any individual style of representation.
- famouswaffles 3y agoHow do you know you can typically spot it? If a illustration that was ai passed you by and you were none the wiser, how would you know to add that instance to your "tally" of ai illustration recognition?
- MacsHeadroom 3y agoThey can't, it's confirmation bias.
- cush 3y agoArtists have always gotten the short end of the stick. Maybe it's a perpetuation of the starving artist cliché, too many poster contests, or the "it will be good for your portfolio" trope, but AI has taken it to the extreme. We're at a point now where the value of most artistic, creative work - the work that arguably most defines us as humans - is now being syphoned up and rehashed on behalf of entitled tech billionaires. And even if artists had some kind of legal defense, they could never afford it. They can't even afford to strike. The AI revolution came too quickly for artists to guard themselves against it - to prevent their work from being stolen... yes, stolen. When the music industry took off, sparked by advances in radio and recording technologies, the pioneers of Blues, Jazz, and Rock and Roll were taken advantage of. They weren't compensated with royalties or profit sharing while studios sold millions of their records - still in print to this day. We know better now, yet artists are still being taken advantage of. Now, an entirely new market has been created from their work, with zero of the proceeds going back to artists. Some good advice for young artists, "Always keep your publishing rights" https://www.guitarworld.com/artists/steve-vai-frank-zappas-advice-saved-me-literally-millions-dollars https://www.guitarworld.com/artists/steve-vai-frank-zappas-a...
- tmaly 3y agoI have found the restrictions imposed on the model make it less useful. I do like the character consistency, but in terms of quality, I think MidJourney is better.
- alexalx666 3y agoDepends on what one considers Art