5 ms·
As far as I'm aware, every language out there is dumb, and English isn't especially dumb. Yes, its particular wart is pronunciation, and then also phrasal verbs
by crazygringo 3y ago
As far as I'm aware, every language out there is dumb, and English isn't especially dumb. Yes, its particular wart is pronunciation, and then also phrasal verbs especially [1].
But what are the dumb things English doesn't have? Noun genders (why?). A hundred different suffixes for regular verb conjugations (ugh). Subjunctives all over the place (maddening). A character-based script that isn't phonetic at all (e.g. Chinese). Insanely complicated grammar. Word forms that change based on the social status of the speaker relative to the listener. And so forth.
Truth be told, English is actually one of the easier languages out there. And while learning pronunciation is annoying, it turns out it's actually not a big obstacle in practice at all. In terms of what students struggle with in ESL (English as a Second Language) classrooms, it's basically bottom of the list. Students struggle way more with the present perfect, for example (when to use "I've eaten" instead of "I ate").
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_phrasal_verbs#Distinguishing_phrasal_verb_types https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_phrasal_verbs#Distingu...
- gilcot 3y ago> Truth be told, English is actually one of the easier languages out there. Sure …when, as native, you don't have to spent years leaning it that easier language …like others. Oh wait, you dunno toki-pona nor esperanto :(
- Aloha 3y agoThe hardest part about english as far as I know is vocabulary - which is vast - something like 1/3rd larger than other languages because of the dual parentage of English and French - and thats before you get into words that have three or four definitions. The one nice thing about English is you can totally munge it, wrong tenses, slightly wrong words, wrong word order, and its still intelligible. Like, you can transliterate spanish or french (or any number of languages) into english, and it will be perfectly understandable in most cases to a native speaker.
- HPsquared 3y agoIt's still intelligible* (Unless that's the joke)
- Aloha 3y agoI fixed it in an edit just as you posted your comment lol!
- yurishimo 3y agoEh, the vocabulary thing I don't think is unique to English. If you look at this Wikipedia article, the first entry for English when sorting by headwords is around 140k. German by example is around 100k for it's lowest entry. At the high end it's approaching 400k for German and 470k for English. I'm omitting the Wikipedia dictionaries for all languages. I suppose that doesn't disqualify your point either. For me, the greatest strength of "English" currently is that it's widespread adoption means that native speakers are excellent at understanding accents when compared to other nations where non-standard accents are not as common. This goes to your point as well about transliteration. By contrast, I am learning Dutch and it's a bit of a meme that Dutch people will switch to English if they detect a hint of an accent (excluding regional dialects of course). My theory is that they do not have an ear for it _because_ most Dutch nationals tend to also speak English at a B2+ level. Contrast that to native English speakers, where the 3 major nations are home to a huge number of immigrants from all around the world, and it makes sense. If English speakers refused to talk with anyone that didn't have a perfect British/American/Australian accent, then nothing would ever get done. In countries where the local population is tolerant of individual accents, I think the native language tends to thrive (Germany, China, Brazil, etc). Edit: article link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dictionaries_by_number_of_words https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dictionaries_by_number...
- mkingston 3y ago> native speakers are excellent at understanding accents when compared to other nations where non-standard accents are not as common Interesting to read this; I had developed exactly the same hypothesis about French speakers: that they're less accustomed to a variety of accents (with the obvious caveat that it's even more risky to generalise from an anecdote than from data!).
- avgcorrection 3y ago> native speakers are excellent at understanding accents when compared to other nations where non-standard accents are not as common So you assert.
- yurishimo 3y ago
- crazygringo 3y ago> something like 1/3rd larger than other languages This is basically an urban legend. Comparing vocabulary sizes between languages is essentially impossible, as what counts as a word is measured differently. (Think those long compound words in German, for example.) And using things like "total dictionary size" is similarly unhelpful because most of the words are technical or archaic, and it mostly depends on how deep a dictionary wants to go into rare words. It's true that English has two main historical roots for vocabulary, but that doesn't mean native speakers use more words in terms of everyday normal speech. There are a handful of classic examples ("cow" and "beef", "pig" and "pork"), but they're very much exceptions rather than the rule. (There aren't dual words for "head" or "feet", or "apple" or "orange", or "chair" or "table", and so forth.) There's zero evidence that vocabulary size is a difficulty for learning English. (On the other hand, English does seem to overload words with multiple definitions more often than a lot of other languages -- so that definitely can be a minor difficulty for language comprehension, especially at the beginning.)
- Aloha 3y agoWe do have lots of overloaded words, I sometimes catching myself using like definition 5 of a word - which with some of my friends I can do that - I need to code switch to something simpler when I'm speaking with people in my work environment.
- nicoburns 3y ago> There aren't dual words for "head" or "feet" There aren't two words for "feet", but the medical specialism that deals with "feet" (germanic root) is "podiatry" and if you want your feet beautified then you get a "pedicure" (both latin root). In some cases both roots are commonly used.
- klyrs 3y ago> There aren't dual words for "head" Unless you count "chef" and "director"
- oneshtein 3y agoI learned how to read and write in my native language in 2 weeks at age 6, when I learned half of alphabet, because I figured out rest of alphabet on my own. I'm reading non-stop since then. How much it takes to learn how to properly read, write, listen, and speak in English? It took me about 20 years in total, but I still cannot talk properly.
- psunavy03 3y agoLanguages are more easily absorbed in childhood due to brain development. It's biologically harder to learn a language as an adult, because that part of your brain is more fully developed. Doable, just harder.
- hashmush 3y agoBut at age 6 you've already been immersed in the language for 6 years. The problem there is to link it to its written form. When you learn a second language you have the baggage of the first language hindering you (talking about orthography here), and you normally don't start by speaking the language exclusively for 6 years before learning how to read. If you don't know what the language is supposed to sound like, of course it's hard to understand how to read in it.
- stevekemp 3y agoMuch harder. I listen to my six year old boy read Finnish and English. Finnish is trivial, the pronunciation follows the spelling. English? A word like "night" turns into "nig-hut" which kinda makes sense, but is also completely wrong. There are so many times when I have to say "No, actually you say XXX". Speaking is fine, mostly. Though there were a few *years* where I had to say "Mommy is a woman, so you say 'she' not 'he'." as Finnish doesn't have gendered pronouns. "Your friend is a girl so you say 'her ball', not 'his ball'". That took a long time to sink in, even though he was fine when people spoke to him he'd almost always get it wrong when women/girls were involved - and even Finnish adults make those kind of mistakes quite often. ("I have a girlfriend, his name is Sally".)
- throwaway626 3y agoCJK characters do encode some phonetic content, it’s just an imperfect process and is more or less unreliable from dialect to dialect.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoOh, really? Let me introduce you to the "order of adjectives" rule: https://www.inc.com/minda-zetlin/grammar-bizarre-weird-rule-adjective-order-matthew-anderson-mark-forsyth-cambridge-dictionary.html https://www.inc.com/minda-zetlin/grammar-bizarre-weird-rule-... Talk about bizarre! Every native speaker has this internalized, but they never teach it in school.
- crazygringo 3y agoOh believe me, it's definitely taught in school -- it's a part of every standard ESL curriculum. Generally third or fourth year. (Although if you miss class that week you might never see it again.) It's a weird one, but also pretty easy to internalize just through experience. It's not like anybody's usually stringing together five adjectives in regular speech. If you just learn a single prototype phrase like "ugly little green wool sweater", that will probably get you 99% of what you need in daily usage.
- bumbledraven 3y agoI think GP means it doesn't come up in primary or secondary school grammar lessons for native English speakers.
- nitwit005 3y agoEvery language has things like that where you'll sound odd if you don't phrase things a certain way. That's why at a certain point you just need to get experience using the language.
- otteromkram 3y agoNot so sure if this is ironclad. Like, if someone messes up the order of adjectives, a native/fluent English speaker would still understand what they're trying to say. The author also introduces Cambridge, Oxford, whatever, when the first ordering is pretty standard. For example, the common term for an tiny, aged woman in the US is, "little old lady." Size, then age, then the rest.
- 3y ago
- iainmerrick 3y agoEnglish also seems very amenable to loanwords from other languages -- you can usually just drop foreign words directly into English without any special twists. It seems much more fiddly in French, German, etc. In Japanese you always have to modify the pronunciation of English words (though maybe that comes easily with practice); in English you just go ahead and say "karaoke", "tsunami", etc. Am I right in thinking English is unusual in that respect? I'm not expert enough in any other languages to know for sure.
- psunavy03 3y ago"English doesn't borrow from other languages. English follows other languages down dark alleys, knocks them over and goes through their pockets for loose grammar." - Terry Pratchett
- x3n0ph3n3 3y agoI would say it does the needful.
- ThrowAway1922A 3y agoOn one single occasion I said this at work without thinking about it. I'd been working exclusively with Indian devs for months and it just slipped out. Thankfully it was taken well.
- scarface_74 3y agoFunny enough, I’m from south GA. But when I speak on conference calls to customers, I try to speak without my natural accent especially since many non native speakers especially who aren’t in the US seem to struggle to understand my natural accent. I was using my normal “consultant voice” with some clients in Tennessee and as I started talking to them, I naturally without thinking started being less careful and throwing some “y’all’s” and southern twang came out. I heard second hand that they thought I was mocking them. I had to explain I was born and raised in South Georgia and that was my natural voice.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoEnglish is also pretty forgiving when spoken. You don’t need to know all the rules to mostly make sense. In many other languages the threshold to be understood feels higher. Maybe that’s because everyone knows some English though
- leetcrew 3y agoEnglish has subjunctive mood, it is often used in counterfactuals like the first clause of "if I were taller, I could reach the ceiling". sometimes you can get away with saying "was" instead of "were" in these constructions, but your middle school english teacher would be disappointed.
- CannisterFlux 3y agoThis use has almost died out in everyday speech though. I listen to many podcasts in which different people across different age groups and backgrounds are always messing it up, e.g. "if I was good at this", which really clangs to my ears, but it's very common.
- crazygringo 3y agoYes, but barely -- it's literally just a single instance of using "were" instead of "was". While Portuguese? Welcome to full sets of conjugations for past subjunctive, present subjunctive, and future subjunctive. And everybody uses them in regular speech, they're not like a formal writing thing or something.
- D-Coder 3y agoAn Esperantist friend of mine who spoke ten languages said that English is the easiest language to learn to speak badly and the hardest language to learn to speak well.
- gilcot 3y agoPracticing seven languages here (and knowing some others a bit) and having the same feeling. However, I'll put French (one of my primary languages) as ex-aequo.