4 ms·
They're saying anything that disagrees with them is bullying and criminal. But, labelling anything that disagrees with them as bullying, is a bullying tactic to
by keepamovin 3y ago
They're saying anything that disagrees with them is bullying and criminal. But, labelling anything that disagrees with them as bullying, is a bullying tactic to try to silence dissent.
Why do they want to silence opposition? Because their position does not stand up to scrutiny.
- charcircuit 3y ago>They're saying anything that disagrees with them is bullying and criminal. That is not want was said. People making direct and indirect threats against the author are not acting in good faith and want to just silence the author without anyone fairly evaluating the proposal. >Why do they want to silence opposition? Threats are not productive for deciding if a proposal should be adopted. They are just noise. Wanting to get rid of noise and focus on signal is not "silencing opposition."
- keepamovin 3y ago> People making direct and indirect threats against the author Indeed that would be the case if that were so, yet it looks like what actually occurred here is the author is abusing the labelling of bullying and criminal in order to falsely tar all disagreement as that. This labelling abuse is itself a bullying act designed to intimidate and shame into silence any disagreement by misrepresenting it as a threat. Which is itself a threat: agree with me or I will accuse you of evil and silence you. That's what it seemed like at the time. Let's note that the quoted comments are from a months' old thread. Do you have any evidence to support your claim about there being direct and indirect threats?
- cbolton 3y agoIn the linked Groups post, the author reports "physical threats and other forms of abuse". I find that very easy to believe and your post reads very uncharitable, unless you have concrete reasons to think that the author is lying.
- tremon 3y agoI find that very easy to believe Yes, and that's the problem the GP is pointing out. We're a social species that's predisposed to defend a victim, that's why playing the victim is a very successful bullying tactic.
- charcircuit 3y ago>Do you have any evidence to support your claim about there being direct and indirect threats? Read the Github issue and you will see people irrationally freaking out about this, indirectly and directly threatening to sue the author, etc. The people disagreeing and bring up problems were much more civilized until it went vital and then it turned into a cess pool of unproductive discussion.
- tjpnz 3y agoThere's a big difference between using robust language and threatening someone. What we're seeing here is an obvious attempt by a small minded individual to play the victim.
- charcircuit 3y agoThere isn't playing the victim here. He was pointing out the large amount of noise around this. 99% of the people making this noise have not even read the proposal and do not actually understand what it means. It is hard to engage in a productive conversation if people are arguing against a something that your proposal doesn't even do.
- meiraleal 3y ago> It is hard to engage in a productive conversation if people are arguing against a something that your proposal doesn't even do. First thing they should stop taking for granted the right to make proposals. Which obviously leads to the fact that they should accept when their BS is rejected.
- meiraleal 3y agoThreats can never be a justification for them to act against all of internet users, this is BS. One threat which can be manipulated by themselves (false flag) and now they have an excuse? Bullshit. If they have any problem with that, call the police, that's no excuse.
- zlg_codes 3y agoPushing anything in tech uses this playbook. Look at systemd and Wayland. They take the bullying approach and act like their intentions can't be questioned. We need a stronger response to their arrogance. Something that will affect network performance and intercept revenue. We can start by blocking them at the DNS level. Host with Google? Too bad your choice in tech sucks.
- meiraleal 3y ago> Pushing anything in tech uses this playbook. no, they don't. Google just criminally accused the opposition to their new "internet law" of being doing so in order to continue committing crimes.
- zlg_codes 3y agoPoint out a single Big Deal in tech that wasn't misrepresented or accusing the opposing side of some character flaw. The behavior from Google fits the same bill. The way they're doing it is just the difference between FOSS 'communities' and multi billion dollar corporations. They likely have psychs on staff to manipulate the narrative around their totalitarian software and services.