3 ms·
That depends heavily on what you think the purpose of the justice system is. For most purposes, nailing the whale and breaking up the party is enough to set an
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
That depends heavily on what you think the purpose of the justice system is. For most purposes, nailing the whale and breaking up the party is enough to set an example and send a message.
There isnt much value in incarcerating additional people simply for the sake of punishment/revenge. The other individuals are unlikely to cause future harm.
- zerbinxx 3y agoI tend to agree that both practically and legally, when you’re dealing with a fraud as big as this one, that successfully prosecuting the Big Man At The Top is the best strategy. People might scoff at mid-level fraud “doers” getting a slap on the wrist deal for their testimony, but the alternative where you go full scorched earth and fail to get a conviction would be terrible for the defrauded and the system beyond them. Capitalists (i.e. the owners of capital, the investor class, in this case) love a system where you don’t really have to quadruple check that a financial document is valid. Who can blame them? I certainly wouldn’t want to live in a world where something like FDIC doesn’t exist or where fraudsters can easily rip people off with low chances of jail time if/when the operation goes belly up.
- harry8 3y ago>There isnt much value in incarcerating additional people simply for the sake of punishment/revenge. The idea is that everyone knowingly involved goes to jail. This way others presented with opportunity to go along with such fraud /know/ there is a very, very real consequence. Rather than "CEO could go down for this but what the hell, I'll go along with it." It's not retribution, it's justice.
- mdasen 3y agoI'd also note that the people around often profit from these things as well. It's not like the CEO is doing something only for the CEO's benefit. The other people involved lived lavish lifestyles with high salaries and were looking at a huge pay day. They didn't just go along with it. They were looking to profit from it.
- bestcoder69 3y agoProsecutors need snitches.
- harry8 3y agonobody talks, everybody walks.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoyeah, I agree you don't want to prosecute the CEO exclusively every time, but beyond that, I dont think it makes much of a difference with respect to deterrence. Nobody thinks they will get caught to begin with, so the severity doesn't matter much.
- Tangurena2 3y agoThe federal prison system abandoned the concept of rehabilitation back in the 1970s. The current system is a combination of exile (we don't want you around), some punishment (this place sucks) and some mitigation (if you're in jail then you can't do more crimes). I do not believe that potential criminals are the sort who are capable of thinking something like "I better not do X, I don't want to be in jail that long". There's a YouTube channel called "Insider" and they have a series of videos called "how crime works" which are part interviews with past-criminals about how their particular scheme worked: https://www.youtube.com/c/thisisinsider/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/thisisinsider/videos The videos all have extensive credits and one thing was that very few of the participants actually considered potential punishment/incarceration beforehand.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoObviously it depends on the crime, but I dont think it is so much that criminals never consider potential punishment, but that they dont think they will be caught. To this end, perception of the likelihood of being caught is far more important than the severity of punishment when it comes to deterrence.