6 ms·
Have all of the people scammed been brought whole? That would be justice. Someone sitting in jail isn't justice. It is punishment for his actions. I've never un
by dylan604 3y ago
Have all of the people scammed been brought whole? That would be justice. Someone sitting in jail isn't justice. It is punishment for his actions. I've never understood how someone being incarcerated has become considered justice.
- Xeoncross 3y agoPrior to justice-by-committee a lot of societies didn't have jails. Either what you did was so bad we need to end your life or you need to find a way to repay it even if you have to work for free as a slave to earn the money. I don't think that would work today, but what we have today doesn't work either.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoDon’t forget banishment, which isn’t really an option today. Though I don’t see why some large chunk of federal land couldn’t be designated as a banishment target.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoAlso don’t forget corporal punishments. Whippings, branding, amputations were common punishments.
- jtsuken 3y agoI feel like Elon Musk is about to propose a tech-driven innovative solution to this centuries old problem.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoBanishment to Mars?
- rurp 3y agoIn many historical contexts banishment was basically equivalent to a death sentence.
- NateEag 3y agoWhen I was younger I flirted with a banishment alternative to imprisonment for severe recidivist offenders. Fence in a few hundred thousand acres of wildlands. Send sentenced criminals in with a minimal backpack of survival gear, a waterproof survival manual (including a minified calendar), and their exit date and fingerprints engraved on a piece of metal (maybe their firestarter). You showed repeatedly you didn't want civilization, so here - you get what you chose. Man the walls with military or national guard troops who rotate out regularly (makes it hard to corrupt them) - come within 500 yards of the wall (interior or exterior) anywhere but a defined ingress point and you'll be shot after due warning. Approach an egress point from the interior with any other people and you all get shot. If you can't show that it's your exit date promptly on reaching the egress point, you'll be given five minutes to get clear or be shot. I'm no longer as convinced it's a good idea, and I'm sure the logistics are massively harder than I'm making them sound. It's certainly harsh and merciless. Still - there is a certain elegance to it.
- brianaker 3y agoYou are describing the plot to Robert Heinlein's short story "Coventry".
- NateEag 3y agoHuh. The things I missed growing up in conservative homeschooling. It is a very Heinlein plot device, now that I think of it.
- JohnFen 3y agoEscape From New York! Great movie.
- NateEag 3y agoI've never watched it, but I may well have been aware of its existence when I first thought of the idea. I think the concept works much better if it's wilderness, though. Even a ruined, abandoned city has an endless supply of the artifacts of civilization, so those imprisoned don't really get to understand what it is they've chosen.
- soup10 3y agoThey also had exile back in the day, among other punishments between life and death and incarceration.
- tornato7 3y agoIt seems likely that the FTX creditors will be made whole or nearly whole. This is in large part due to FTX's investment in Anthropic that did a 5X[1]. 1: https://coinscreed.com/ftx-creditor-claims-break-50c-as-buyers-made-whole.html https://coinscreed.com/ftx-creditor-claims-break-50c-as-buye...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- glenngillen 3y agoThis might well be true, but it’s not the slam dunk people seem to be treating it as. A private investment round can be negotiated by as few as two people agreeing on a price. It says nothing about the market clearing price for any other investment or sale like it does with a public market transaction. Public markets give you an order book of other competing offers where you can make some reasonable assumptions about how much you could sell at which price if you wanted to liquidate. There may be no other buyer for Anthropic at or near the current price. Conversely, it’s a private company and scarcity of opportunity to get in is also a thing. So it’s entirely possible someone will pay more than the previous round just to get in. Basically we don’t know until the investment bankers have done their jobs.
- gfsdgfsdgfeds2 3y agoHow is it "very likely" when most startups fail?
- timack 3y agoAnthropic is still in private investment phase, lets not forget WeWork was "worth" $45B at one stage.
- wmf 3y agoSince Anthropic is white-hot right now VCs would be very happy to pay cash for it.
- 3y ago
- loteck 3y agoWhile I agree with your skepticism about imprisonment equaling justice, one element to consider is whether a victim of a crime can ever be "made whole." Even if a victim was to receive 100% material reimbursement, the act of being victimized can cause changes in life that look a lot like opportunity costs. It doesn't surprise me then that we as a capitalist society look to imprisonment (the ultimate infliction of opportunity cost) as a sort of ethereal or "karmic" reimbursement (even if I don't agree).
- evantbyrne 3y ago> Have all of the people scammed been brought whole? I know zero details on where exactly the money ended up, but I have to imagine someone dumb enough to try and pull this off would have also effectively shredded a huge chunk of the stolen funds.
- eru 3y agoLots of the money indirectly ended up with clients again. FTX was an exchange. It was an attractive exchange partially because many things traded there offered tight spreads, ie difference between prices quoted for buying and selling. The tight spreads came from Alameda. Alameda was another entity connected to SBF. The problem was that Alameda wasn't actually competent enough to quote tight spreads and make money off them. So they lost many to savvier customers. FTX lent money to Alameda to keep them afloat. But that money was never paid back. There's lots of other things that went wrong. But this is probably the most ironic part: a large part of FTX's clients' lost money went to FTX's clients. (But not the same clients who lost money. And lots of money was lost in other ways.)
- deaddodo 3y ago> I've never understood how someone being incarcerated has become considered justice. Because, at least for Americans, there is a retributive mindset. "You did wrong, now I want you to hurt"; ergo, when it happens, they consider it justice. As opposed to repairing the victim's situation and/or attempting to reform the actor/criminal into a more trustworthy/desirable member of society.
- buitreVirtual 3y agoIs there any place in the world where it isn't that way? Honest question. How could SBF pay his victims back fully if he doesn't have enough assets?
- Zetobal 3y agoMaybe early access to his next scam some of them would probably do it. lol.
- dlp211 3y agoBut they are going to be made whole, or nearly so. It may take a while, but the guy they brought in to untangle FTX is the same guy that untangled Enron. He's said that FTX always had enough assets to cover its obligation, at least on paper, it just sucked at keeping track of them.
- StressedDev 3y agoHe never said FTX had enough assets to repay its creditors. Even worse, many of FTX’s assets are worthless (the FTT tokens are a prime example of this). What he said was he had never seen a company with such atrocious record keeping. BTW, the US government would not have charged Sam Bankman-Fried with fraud if the money was all there.
- therealcamino 3y agoThose are separate issues -- whether crimes were committed, and whether depositors will be made whole eventually. If some of the bets they illegally made end up paying off, enough to reimburse the people who trusted them, that doesn't mean it was legal or ok to take that money to make their own bets with in the first place. And while John Ray did say they were bad at record keeping, he also said that “This is just old fashioned embezzlement, taking money from others and using it for your own purposes,” he said. “This is not sophisticated at all.”
- LastTrain 3y agoYeah if they’d just let him go he’d go right out and make everyone whole again. He’s going to jail to hopefully keep other people from doing similar things. I’d like to see more jail for white collar crime - otherwise it’s just gambling.
- ziddoap 3y agoThe post your are replying to didn't say that punishment wasn't necessary, just that punishment and justice aren't really the same thing. Ideally he would be punished for his actions and there would be justice for the victims (i.e. being made whole).
- CydeWeys 3y agoHe's also going to jail to prevent him from defrauding more people. Meanwhile Adam Neumann is still out there starting new sketchy companies taking people's money, most recently some crypto token thing (because of course he would). If Masayoshi Son had been less interested in saving face and more interested in getting justice, Adam might be behind bars too. One could imagine a case for fraud being made there.
- StressedDev 3y agoFailing is not fraud. How did Adam Neumann commit fraud? Where is your evidence?
- babl-yc 3y agoDepends on how you define the word. "Justice is the ethical, philosophical idea that people are to be treated impartially, fairly, properly, and reasonably by the law and by arbiters of the law, that laws are to ensure that no harm befalls another, and that, where harm is alleged, a remedial action is taken - both the accuser and the accused receive a morally right consequence merited by their actions" https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/justice https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/justice
- MrRolleyes 3y agoYes, we in the US have a punitive justice system, which emphasizes punishment under the dubious concept of punitive deterrence over remediation and other forms of deterrence (eg poverty reduction, though that is obviously irrelevant here). Anyway, a law institution certainly has an incentive to push their own agenda when it comes to the theory of justice.
- notyourwork 3y agoI guess those people define justice as an eye for an eye. I see your point though.
- leetcrew 3y agounfortunately people don't just steal large sums of money and sit on it. it's rarely possible to make the victims whole without unwinding a web of (plausibly) good faith transactions involving others. having the perpetrator's transgressions officially recognized and issuing a sentence that may deter others is about as good as it gets.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fasthands9 3y agoIf someone steals $100 from me, and then a friend feels bad for me and gives me $100, that isn't justice. I think the historical use of justice has nothing to do with the victim being made whole - and not sure that word usage is a useful concept here.
- franga2000 3y agoWhile I agree that much more focus should be given to helping victims and much less to retribution, deterrence is also a key pillar of the justice system and should definitely be exercised here. It's likely not possible to make all victims "whole again", but we can make up for that by "making an example" to other potential criminals, showing them the "danger" of committing similar crimes. If "the next SBF" sees the risk of life in prison isn't worth it and decides against running a similar scheme, we've actually saved more people than we could've by only repaying damages to SBF's victims.
- MrRolleyes 3y ago> deterrence is also a key pillar of the justice system Oh is that why our justice system is so terrible at actually reducing crime?
- nradov 3y agoTerrible at reducing crime compared to what? Is there another justice system which is better at reducing crime (without introducing a police state)?
- MrRolleyes 3y ago> Is there another justice system which is better at reducing crime (without introducing a police state)? Many other countries—especially countries nearly as rich as us—manage a lower crime rate with a lower proportion of spending on policing and lower sentencing times. I have full faith we can improve on those systems, too—there's boatloads of evidence showing that financial safety nets invested in over decades is a much more cost-effective way of reducing crime. Regardless, even in justice theory there are other ideologies, such as restorative justice. This is not just idle windbagging.
- WindyLakeReturn 3y agoIs it terrible? If we were to remove the system and keep it gone for some set amount of time, once people realize it was really gone, would crimes not come back? We can compare to other countries and see their rates of crime, but such comparisons are difficult to make accurately because you are judging all social differences at once, not just a different legal system. Including things like how much lead has the population been exposed to, effect of poverty and sense of community. Things far beyond the legal system.
- jowea 3y agoI think everyone being brought whole is restitution. Justice is what a judge hands out.
- sob727 3y agoDo you have a better suggestion?
- WindyLakeReturn 3y ago>Have all of the people scammed been brought whole? Can you ever make them whole? Even if you pay them back all their money, there is the period of time without, the fear and pain from losing it, and similar that cannot be undone. For other crimes, there is often a victim whose state can never be fully reverted. If this is our view of justice, then justice becomes an impossible thing which can never be achieved. Does such a stance risk people eventually no longer chasing what can never be acquired?
- anonymoushn 3y agoNot only have creditors not been made whole, no attempt has been made by prosecutors or debtors to seize tens of millions of dollars of customer funds that were paid to SBF's close relatives for "consulting" or the ten million dollars he gave to his father.