9 ms·
Experiment: Living Without A Home Internet Connection
- evincarofautumn 15y agoFascinating, but perhaps not for everybody. I can waste a fair amount of time online, but most often when I do it’s because of a general lack of motivation due to a depressive mood. If I didn’t have the internet at such times, I would just sit around and mope. At least on HN I can learn things.
- jaysonelliot 15y agoI think you and I have very similar situations. My time wasted online is often for the exact same reasons. Before the internet was such a large part of my life, that time was spent writing in my notebook or reading books (somehow watching TV just made me feel even worse). A lot of that time was also "wasted," but some of it was really valuable time that I spent getting to know myself and my own thoughts better. One thing wasting time online has never done for me is lift my depression. The only thing that ever does that for me is getting out of my environment and wandering around outside.
- evincarofautumn 15y agoAgreed. Putzing around online is a symptom of an underlying problem, and I know it’s time to get up, make a sandwich, take a walk, whatever. Knowing that, lately it’s been a lot easier to stay motivated.
- frou_dh 15y agoI think messing around on the internet for long periods of time is more dangerous than moping because it's an active thing that builds habit and reinforces itself. If you're depressed and moping you're under no illusion that you're not in a bad place.
- evincarofautumn 15y agoThat’s very true—and many sites are outright designed to be habit-forming. Still, if you’re feeling down, you’ll take any small comfort.
- jambo 15y agoI'm doing a light version of this starting in a few weeks. I've canceled my home internet, but I still have my Nexus S & access from work and cafes. It was motivated in part by the ridiculously poor level of service/price in my area, and part by the same notion that I might be happier without it. Sadly, I can't easily travel to Cuba for this experiment (US American).
- orofino 15y agoWhile interesting, I have to ask, what makes reading books, watching TV, and watching movies higher value than whatever it is you're doing on the internet? I learn about travel, science, technology, and countless other things through the internet. While not a replacement for real life experiences, I certainly think it could be considered a high-value experience (personally I think it is better than TV), perhaps on par with reading books. Sure, if you're spending all your time playing minecraft online... wait we have kids building graphing calculators in minecraft, nevermind.
- jaysonelliot 15y agoOne word: focus. When you're on the internet, you're engaging in bite-size activities and constant task switching. Quick, how many tabs do you have open right now? Until about 1999 or 2000, I accomplished at least four times as much per year as I do today. Before that time, there either was no Web to putter around on, or it existed but without the speed and content it has had since then. Have you ever noticed that your best ideas come when you're in the shower, or maybe on a long drive alone? It's down to focus, and lack of distractions. Even if you think you're reading long-form journalism or other content online, you're most likely doing it in a window of a browser, with visual clutter all around, from UI elements to menu items to the dock at the bottom of the screen. They're all subtle cues to your mind to stay alert for extra input, and not get too zoned in on whatever you're reading. Not to mention the amazing amount of visual crap most webpages surround their content with. There's value to the vast amount of information available online, but you have to be discerning. Information for the sake of information is not always worth the mental and time tradeoffs we make for it.
- _delirium 15y agoPerhaps I'm just bad at doing things, but I noticed this way before the internet. Something like this random-walk path: reading a semi-scholarly book, run into an endnote, turn to the end of the book to read it, find a concept I don't know, open up my dead-tree World Book encyclopedia to find it, follow up some cross-references there, eventually remember to go back to the book, try to remember what endnote I was reading and where I got there from, restart. The internet makes it easier, but the pattern doesn't seem new! It's even worse in university libraries, where you can actually follow up all the references by grabbing them off the shelf. The number of books piled up around you with post-it notes marking pages is roughly like the number-of-tabs metric...
- aaronjbaptiste 15y agoInteresting perspective. The problem is what you're spending time online doing. If you're looking at cute cats or on facebook, it's likely you're wasting time. I would also bet that lots of time is spent procrastinating. On the flip side I find time away from the computer to be highly unproductive. It's good if you need time away to relax, but overall there's alot of time wasted drinking beer, socialising etc. It's all about balance and getting important stuff done.
- evincarofautumn 15y agoOn-computer and off-computer time are equally (un)productive. I like to spend a long time thinking about a problem without writing any code, then get it all out in one go as a foundation to build on; something like the Feynman Algorithm. And time spent socialising is only wasted if you don’t make the most of it. Like you said, it’s important to enjoy yourself and maintain a good work–life balance—otherwise you’ll just be unproductive and depressed.
- TwiztidK 15y agoSince leaving home to go to University I've completely stopped watching TV and that has increased my free time by quite a bit. Unfortunately, I would have a pretty hard time living somewhere without internet, mostly because I don't own a phone (cell phone or landline) so email and Skype are the only methods I have for communicating with the outside world.
- joeyh 15y agoSince 2000, I've spent half my time in locations with only dialup internet access at home. While I can still get distracted by Hacker News (as I just now have when I had meant to come out and enjoy an hour of spring twilight), it does cut down on the distraction level significantly. My laptop is entirely self-contained, with everything from mail archives to my blog in git (and large files managed by git-annex). So when the net does go out I can easily not notice for an hour or two. Or, this winter, when my solar power reserves got really low and I couldn't afford to run the internet connection after dark, it was not a big deal. In time periods when I have broadband at home, I have considered putting a dialup throttle on it, but could never quite bring myself to do it. :)
- AndrewNoNumbers 15y agoVery interesting post. The biggest thing it’s gotten me to think about is whether we’ve been using the internet “wrong” the past two decades. Maybe at some point in the future (or the present, for this blogger), the internet will be confined to something we only use at a certain time of the day. Or something else will supplant the internet as our leisure activity. I’ve actually been running similar experiments, and you can start trying this in a much easier way than cancelling your internet. http://ndrw.me/2012/03/01/afternoon-refresh/ http://ndrw.me/2012/03/01/afternoon-refresh/
- djloche 15y agoSimply put: the lack of work/life balance due to not setting environmental boundaries at the onset of self employment had destroyed your productivity within both work and life. I suggest continuing to work from an office of some sort - be it the coffee shop, a co-working space, or renting a room or desk in someone else's office, so you can continue to separate your work and life environments. You can turn on the internet at your apartment, but place priority in what you actually want to do outside of work by granting those things greater space in that environment. If you like to read, have books easily accessible for you to pick up and read. Get a nice chair/couch for you to sit and enjoy reading. Build a nice wall of bookshelves for your books. Join book clubs, arrange lunch/dinner with people who also like to read, etc. Make your priorities visual.
- lordlicorice 15y ago> Encryption (for secure banking): Witopia. I think your bank is doing something wrong if you need a secure VPN to do online banking.
- jonmb 15y agoI think he's using the VPN because he's accessing the banking site through an open wireless Internet connection at his coffee shop. I don't know enough about wireless security to say if the VPN is protecting him or not, though.
- lordlicorice 15y agoThe encryption should be between your browser and the bank's servers, not between your network driver and the VPN provider. You do this with TLS/SSL (it's that little lock icon or security information panel you see when you're at an https:// https:// URL).
- jonmb 15y agoAh, I understood that SSL encrypts the data, but I always assumed there was still a risk of it being intercepted (before encryption) if I was on an open WiFi network.
- graeme 15y agoOP here, that was my worry. But, I admit I didn't thoroughly look into whether bank-side encryption eliminates my risk from a public network. Maybe it does, but there are enough other unencrypted sites that I'd rather have the VPN.
- AndrewNoNumbers 15y agoHeck, for way more than secure banking! I would use a VPN just to check my email at a cafe!
- ulisesrmzroche 15y agoI feel that you jumped to conclusions in blaming the internet for not keeping up with your reading list, to be honest. Why should anyone be judged on how they choose to waste their time?
- AndrewNoNumbers 15y agoI feel that you jumped to conclusions by believing giving up the internet doesn't have other effects on your mind and daily functions (not just a matter of using time!).
- devinfoley 15y agoI lived without home Internet for about a year in 2002 when I lived on a boat. I eventually got a wireless 56k connection. I spent time at coffee shops and wardriving for Internet. I don't recommend it.
- jodrellblank 15y agoWhy don't you recommend it? What particularly did you miss and what didn't you miss? What do you regret having now, but you put up with because it's worth the trade-off?
- ctdonath 15y agoSimple matter of self control. Something isn't right when you have to visit a communist dictatorship to have that control inflicted on you because the source of distraction is brutally oppressed there.
- jodrellblank 15y agoWhen you say it's a "simple" matter, and "something isn't right", why don't people "simply" fix it? What isn't right? I claim your dismissal of it as simple isn't right.
- shasta 15y agoMaybe "I don't even have Internet access" will be the new "I don't even own a TV."
- toyg 15y agoMore like "I don't even have a phone". Internet is bidirectional, a TV is just a receiver. The difference is huge. I do live without a TV quite happily, but I could never live without at least one bidirectional medium. It would mean returning to XIX-century communication methods, which were way too time-expensive for modern life; for example, I'd have to get dressed and leave the house every time I want to communicate, find a shared communication device (public phone, post office, etc) and then have to put up with contention issues and delays (wait for my turn, get a bad line etc) on which I have no control. OP does that -- he's relying on shared wifi at his coffee shop. Which means he's putting up with slow speed and the impossibility to download large chunks of data -- unless he's being a dick or his coffeeshop is run by Cisco, he won't be able to get that 600mb Linux distro or those 6 Gb of Oracle installers, ever. And the day someone decides to be a dick, good luck downloading your email while the pipe is saturated by Mr. Streetpirate uploading HD movies from the safety of an anonymous IP. He might be happy with that, I don't doubt it, but his lifestyle is not for everyone.
- arkas 15y agoInternet is became too important for us. So it' not problem of using it, it's how we us it. Most people use it for social networks, porn and other irrelevant stuf.
- andrewpi 15y agoIt's an interesting experiment, but I don't see how you avoid using your iPhone to waste time in the same way as you would on your laptop. (unless you cancel your data plan as well)
- biftek 15y agoHave you tried browsed the Internet for extended periods of time on an iPhone? It's painful. The mobile experience still sucks for 90% of the web, bandwidth is limited and slow, and don't even imagine having all your standard tabs open. Mobile web is still very much broken. I pointed it out earlier but like the author also don't have home Internet. It's pretty easy to avoid grabbing the iPhone and opening up safari for anything more than reading a few blog posts.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- abalashov 15y agoI think most of us depend on fairly constant and reasonably ubiquitous connectivity to do our work. That, and it strikes me as kind of Ludditic; the Internet is here to stay. We should learn to productively adapt to it in a long-term, sustainable way, instead of trying to tune it out, however selectively. Finally, who said that what I do on the Internet is less meritorious than my analogue alternatives? To be sure, the Internet has brought changes to the way we learn and the way information is diffused, and some of those changes, in terms of attention spans, length, substance, etc. are ambivalent at best, and in any case, not unambiguously good. But if you weigh this against all the ways in which the Internet has expanded our overall productivity, democratised learning, and chipped away at the pillars of credentialism and occupational guilding in our economy, the net benefit seems pretty clear. Besides, at this point, rolling back its transformative place in the world seems like trying to put the milk back in the cow.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 15y agoFor those looking to try a less drastic version of this, I recommend LeechBlock: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/leechblock/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/leechblock/ It lets you list websites and then set rules around when and how much you can access them. My current way to set it up: during business hours, I have to wait 60 seconds to access a distracting website. And by wait, I mean sit there and stare at the countdown screen; if the window loses focus it cancels the countdown. I'm amazed at the number of times a day I try to access something like HN when, after 5 seconds of thought, I really don't want to.
- thebigredjay 15y agoThat actually sounds incredible, I might just start using it. Thanks!
- RegEx 15y agoI've just been using my hosts file for the same effect, but this sound like a more elegant solution.
- msutherl 15y agoI use a combination of SelfControl.app, my hosts file and OpenDNS content filtering. I need 3 layers of protection.
- RegEx 15y agoActually it's only 2 layers of protection, as SelfControl.app just appends things to the hosts file.
- msutherl 15y agoI'm not entirely sure how it works, but SelfControl is resilient to you manually editing the host file while it's running. I know it runs a daemon and I'm not sure if it just keeps the host file updated or if it has a secondary blocking method.
- dadoftheyear 15y agoIf u don't mind me asking, as a bit of personal curiosity,...what do u do to support yourself from home? I too would like to become self employed, so I'm looking for any input on ideas to begin my venture. Thanks for your time, - Jay
- thebigredjay 15y agoI have been considering making the same leap. For me it's about forcing some boredom into your life. With the Internet and TV I feel hyper stimulated all the time. To find entertainment I merely collapse into my chair, click a few buttons, and begin passively consuming. Without something neurotically occupying my attention (ie internet) I quickly become bored. When bored I then proceed to think through everything I could possibly do, prioritize the ideas, and choose one to act upon. Even if I end up watching a television show the important thing is that I chose to watch that specific show rather than passively accepting whatever was being played at the time. I have not had TV in a long time, so that's not a problem, but whenever I've momentarily had no internet I find I eat better, exercise more, have a cleaner house, and knock more things off of my to do lists. It's not that I want to go without internet, it's just that I do not want the internet at home. I've been without it before and really enjoyed the experience, now I just have to make the leap of canceling internet completely.
- pyre 15y agoI'd say that it's less about the Internet at home and more about the 'always on' aspect. You could try emulating the 'dial-up experience' by forcing some sort of 'connection ritual' that you must go through to get the Internet. An example setup (assuming you only have a laptop) could be to disable wifi, and force yourself to plug in an ethernet cable every time. With this setup you can still have Internet for things like an HTPC, for your television while still having the 'no Internet' on your computer experience.
- thebigredjay 15y agoAbsolutely. I have a wireless button on my laptop and I generally disable wireless when I want to get work done. I like the idea of a physical ritual, I kind of want to build a big cartoony internet switch now. It's like forcefully inserting a brief moment of reflection before you use the internet.
- frou_dh 15y agoI totally agree. If I waste an entire day messing around on the Internet, I go to bed with my mind frazzled. It's like guzzling a load of "empty calories" and feeling no benefit from them. I've done the no-internet thing before for several months and while it wasn't a magic cure-all, I'd like to do it again. One downside is a certain feeling of lonliness when you're used to being able to swoop in and out of interesting discussions at any time of the day or night.
- octotoad 15y agoI've had some form of Internet connection since ~2000 and up until a few years ago I never thought I could go without for more than a week or so. In 2010 I had to cut off my DSL account due to financial reasons. I was offline for around nine months and in this time I found that, code-wise, I was the most productive I'd ever been. When hacking on random stuff while I was online, I'd often find myself starting off opening a browser to load an API reference manual or something similar, and before I knew it I was faffing about on something completely irrelevant. Sometimes it'd be related to the project I was working on (sort of a Wikipedia effect; you can't stop at just one link) and other times it would be random crap. While I was offline, since I was stuck with the basic essentials related to a particular project (appropriate development packages, documentation etc.), I found myself not only more focused on the task at hand, but generally more interested and enthusiastic about the problem I was working on. I am currently without a home internet connection again, but this time I have a 'smartphone' that I can tether when necessary. I've noticed having that option available can be a really bad thing for my productivity. I certainly benefit from having absolutely no possibility of accessing the internet, as long as I have all the tools and resources at hand that I need to get the current job done.
- munyukim 15y agoI agree with author,you can still accomplish a lot of things with limited access.I just launched a website http://www.mixdem.com http://www.mixdem.com from internet cafe in Zimbabwe , Africa.
- lionhearted 15y agoI've had this a couple times in my life. The two nicest things about it are -- 1. A consistent bedtime and better sleep. I usually read books before bedtime, and crashed out earlier. 2. When you do get the internet in your home again inevitably, you appreciate it more. Seriously, it's an amazingly powerful thing, the internet. But we spend so much time drowning in it that we often don't notice/appreciate it enough.
- sparknlaunch 15y agoGreat idea and can relate after two months without proper internet availability. I spend so much time just surfing and having a smart phone doesn't help. I don't have the self discipline just to stop. Maybe ISP s can offer a service tolock your connection at certain times off the day?
- smsm42 15y agoLooks like the same problems people have with eating: consuming a lot of useless stuff, not consuming enough of proper stuff, hurting their (intellectual) health by that. I wonder how soon people will start selling internet diets - some software that installs on your computer and controls your browsing and counts intellectual calories and vitamins for you. I'm sure there are apps like this already but not a major business like diets... So if you want to be a millionaire, make a startup doing this.
- paulhauggis 15y agoI can see cutting cable (which I did a year ago and it's been great). But, I need the Internet. I run an online business and many times things come up in the middle of the night. I also communicate with most of my friends and family though email or Facebook. You just need to have some self-control. It's not easy, but it can be done.
- biftek 15y agoFor what it's worth, I've not had Internet at home for about a month. I still have access at work, so not entirely the same situation, but it is nice not having the vice at home. And like the author have filled the rest of my time productively. I recommend anyone give it a go, and if you haven't get rid of your tv too.
- graeme 15y agoWow, I didn't expect my first submission to hit the front page. Should have done that third edit I decided to forego. There are some good replies here. The only point I want to make is that the people accusing me of lacking self-control are 100% correct. I disconnected my internet not because I see no value in it (far from it), but rather because unfettered access was taking too much time away from other things that I value. Lest you get the wrong idea, I'm quite capable of avoiding the internet. I wrote ~350,000 (profitable) words last year. I got lots of other things done, too. But, I had to use up willpower at all times to avoid the easy pleasure of surfing the web. It was unpleasant. Most of my work is on the computer - I'm no technophobe. It's so much easier to use my computer now that it mostly does work related things unless I'm in a cafe. I readily admit that some people may have no trouble with the internet and self-control. That's great - you have all the advantages of limitless information, and none of the disadvantages of distraction. Many people, unfortunately, are more like me. The internet is valuable for us, but a potential pitfall. I'm hardly the first to point this out, pg had an essay on point. http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html I'd be interested to know if he ever figured out a workable system. He posted somewhere on here that his dual computer system eventually broke down.