16 ms·
Russian Reshipping Service 'Swat USA Drop' Exposed
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoDo they not buy gift cards anymore? Back in the day you used carding to buy gift cards and then use the gift cards to buy the merch to resell. Gives you more time since the card could be cancelled quickly after first use and gift card is hard to trace.
- filoleg 3y agoThe OP says that the issue is that the scammers live in countries to which most western merchants refuse to ship anymore due to high prevalence of scams originating there (eastern europe, russia, etc.) and near zero ability to enforce the law against them by the US authorities. For all we know, those items sent to US-located “drops” (aka unaware victims and accessories to the crime) for shipping overseas were indeed bought with gift cards. That’s beside the point, the problems that those SWAT services are supposed address are explicitly related to shipping items (which were purchased with stolen credit cards, either directly or by using gift cards) to countries where most western merchants refuse to ship in the first place. Gift cards won’t even be needed here, since the only person who can get pinned for this is the US-based “drop” who was unknowingly helping out the criminals.
- wutwutwat 3y agoIt's physical onion routing/proxying to obscure the true origin of the scams and spread it over such a wide area (the world), or such a powerful and wealthy area (U.S.) that cutting off business in those regions is impossible because you'd put yourself out of business in doing so. The exit nodes, or true origins are the pockets of the folks running the whole scheme. Good luck finding them, and even if they are found, they are insanely wealthy, so nothing will come of it, because that's how the world works.
- filoleg 3y ago> they are insanely wealthy The OP mentions that the main guy running the SWAT service makes roughly $100k/mo at most. While it is certainly a lot of money, it isn’t even close to being “above the law.” The OP says that the service has been operating under a bunch of different names for somewhere close to a decade. Even though they certainly were not making $100k/mo from the beginning, let’s make the most generous assumptions possible and do some napkin math of the upper bound. 10 years = 120 months, so 120*100k = $12mil. And that’s the upper bound. That’s only a single order of magnitude more than what someone who bought a house in the US for about $600k a decade ago has in net worth (with the fairly realistic assumption that the value of it rose to at least $1mil), and there are tons and tons of those people.
- wutwutwat 3y ago> the main guy running the SWAT service makes roughly $100k/mo at most I can almost guarantee you that he wasn't the big fish/the end of the trail. His entire operation is just a proxy hop, one of many. $100k a month is an insane amount of money to me, and is more than enough to have power to buy people, lawyers, houses in countries that don't extradite or recognize the charges as crimes, and have people murdered. If you're not able to buy everyone around you with $100k every single month you're not even trying. I would assume anyway, who knows though lol buy == bribe/put in your pocket (just so it's not confused with literally buying people, which you could also do with that kind of money I'm assuming)
- morkalork 3y agoIt's a lot but it's not "buy yourself an American supreme court judge" levels of insane money. Anyways, those kind of criminals live in places like Russia and they don't live in a vacuum. They exist because the government and organized crime allow them to exist. Like a cute pet that pays kickbacks. I can't imagine being this flashy with I'll-gotten gains without being secure in the knowledge that everyone important has been paid off: https://www.businessinsider.com/millionaire-russian-hackers-evil-corp-car-pictures-video-2019-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/millionaire-russian-hackers-...
- ThePowerOfFuet 3y ago>The information leaked from SWAT also has exposed the real-life identity and financial dealings of its principal owner — Fearlless, a.k.a. “SwatVerified.” We’ll hear more about Fearlless in Part II of this story. Stay tuned. What a fun ending.
- meepmorp 3y ago> SWAT apparently kept its books in a publicly accessible Google Sheets document, and that document reveals Fearlless and his business partner each routinely made more than $100,000 every month operating their various reshipping businesses. Yeah, OpSec is hard, but come on.
- wutwutwat 3y agoThis shouldn't have required OpSec at all because any smart person would not have kept books online, and maybe not even on a computer at all. It's always boggled my mind that such intricate inditement records are kept, it's not going to end well. Tangent: if I were to open my house free for all to come and go as they please, but a bunch of criminals kept coming over and sitting at the kitchen table keeping their illegal record of their crimes, and I let them use my mailbox to contact their people to coordinate the executions of fruad and likely some murders sprinkled in there, and they would sometimes bring over suitecases filled with illegal materials or even filing cabinets, and store them in the living room for a bit and then some other criminal would come and take them out.... at what point would I as the homeowner become an accomplice to all the crimes being ran out of my house? I'm going to say at some point in time I would no longer be a oblivious homeowner and I would start to be viewed as a criminal and I'd be getting charges of crimes hurled my way. Now tell yourself the same story but instead of a house it's the Google product suite, sheets for the books, gmail for the comms, drive for the distribution of criminal data, etc. Sure Google is just the oblivious homeowner for awhile, but if I could be charged with being an accomplice to crimes, or aiding and abetting, surely something should be pointed at Google, or any other company, who is providing services to probably a massive amount of people using those services to realize crimes, all around the world, day in and day out. You can't have shit like that happening in your house and not know that it's happening, and these products are free so they can mine the data from us using them, which makes the "I didn't know some mobsters were keeping book at my kitchen table" defense hard to say and expect people to believe you. Not saying anything should happen, or that anything doesn't happen, I'm just pointing out that we don't really think about how often tech is used to commit crimes and I've never personally seen any news about the Feds going after Google for facilitating the back office of the criminal enterprise (maybe those Gov contracts Google does causes any LE to look the other way idk)
- irrational 3y ago> In reality, the crooks in charge almost always stop communicating with drops just before the first payday, usually about a month after the drop ships their first package. I feel like there needs to be a financial literacy class in school that includes a unit on scams with many examples of how you can be scammed.
- Terr_ 3y agoOh, absolutely. Recognizing common scam archetypes or features would be vastly more useful than some of the crap that gets into a US high-school curriculum, especially considering the time spent making kids (temporarily) memorize exact dates and place-names. I never tried planning out a curriculum, but I think in addition recognizing scams, people should also be aware of options they can request/demand that would protect themselves, things a legitimate partner would agree to but scammers would refuse. For example, putting funds in escrow, or "Oh, you work at the Important Institution? Please tell me your office-extension and I'll call you back through their official phone number." Other gaps that I would want to address if I were the Czar of Education include: 1. Debts, compounding, how bankruptcy works. 2. How contracts work, and what they don't do even if you've seen it in fiction. 3. Some basic tax stuff. (I've met adults-with-children who still think things like "I can't accept that raise, it'll put me into a higher tax bracket.") 4. What people can or can't usually sue each other for.
- filoleg 3y ago> I've met adults-with-children who still think things like "I can't accept that raise, it'll put me into a higher tax bracket." If talking purely about taxes and income without anything else in the context, you are correct. However, sometimes the logic you describe makes sense when it comes to government benefits. Totally made-up example: imagine the government gives some sort of a benefit/assistance to people in certain circumstances (e.g., heavily subsidized childcare), but only if they are below a specific tax bracket, and if you cross that threshold, the benefit eligibility is gone entirely. So even though you technically still made more post-tax income if you crossed into that bracket, you might have lost more overall than you gained due to not getting that benefit/assistance (the one that requires you to be below a certain tax bracket) anymore.
- morkalork 3y agoFascinating the ecosystem is big enough that someone can specialize in a niche like this: >“drops test” services, contractors who will test the honesty of drops by sending them fake jewelry;
- kasey_junk 3y agoThis was the thing that jumped out at me. I now want an expose just on this! How do _they_ get paid and made sure they aren’t also getting ripped off? Do they too run their own drops for shipping the fake jewelry? Do they advertise success rates?
- wutwutwat 3y ago> On a suspicion that the login page for portal-ctsi[.]com might be a custom coding job, KrebsOnSecurity selected “view source” from the homepage to expose the site’s HTML code Ahhh shit, it's time for some early 2000's "Antitrust" style quick pans to CRTs with HTML tags wizzing by while discount Bill Gates talks in the background about how you're either a 1 or a 0, alive or dead, before Teddy comes to the revolutionary realization that "The answer's not in the box, it's in the band." But in all seriousness, that screenshot shows a page clearly designed by a backend engineer so I find the suspicion of a "custom coding job" pretty funny. I've been out of the loop for a bit but I haven't seen anything make the rounds on HN about any criminal drop shipping saas graduating from a startup accelerator with a big ole seed round and a office in SF on the way. Of course all of their software is custom, in house stuff, or heavily adapted tooling, they can't really go and use salesforce now can they? And at the end of the day what does a "custom coding job" even mean, because trace any application that's ever existed and it was a custom coding job. And also I'm lol'ing because the article is trying to make viewing html on a "hunch" out like it's fucking Batman level detective work :) Why were they doing all of this on the clear net out in the open? They are smart enough to have a super intricate network of mules and delivery people, custom written software, and even have what appears to be management sending memo's about corporate policy, yet they weren't smart enough to put this all behind a private VPN or throw it on the TOR network AND also behind a private vpn? It almost seems like they were trying to get caught, and wtf kind of name is that? I'm not convinced this isn't a false flag for something else or a spark to act on something. It has the grab bag of things needed to breed more hatred at random countries that we've been told since grade school to hate.
- batch12 3y ago> And at the end of the day what does a "custom coding job By custom coding job, I think he just means that the file is unique enough to be used to fingerprint sites created by the same entity. Tracking unique assets on a page to find similarities is a solid way to hunt for malicious related sites. > yet they weren't smart enough to put this all behind a private VPN or throw it on the TOR network The use of Tor would limit the pool of mules either due to technical limitations or tripping BS sensors. Also, it's the dumb ones that get caught first.
- ahoka 3y agoIt seems like an easy way to get a free iphone.
- scrose 3y agoAs entertaining as it’d be to scam the scammers, it’s probably not wise to keep a device that was purchased and shipped to you using a stolen CC after also giving up tons of PII.. > Anyone can sign up at this website as a potential reshipping mule, although doing so requires applicants to share a great deal of personal and financial information, as well as copies of an ID or passport matching the supplied name.
- xwolfi 3y agoBut it wont be yours and you re the first node in the graph the bank and police will find after asking the merchant who bought it with the stolen card. We really really need scam literacy education if that's your first reaction.
- notpushkin 3y ago> you re the first node in the graph the bank and police will find And you can claim that you've sent it away. (Of course, you should forward a few packages before that and, for bonus points, keep copies of a few labels to show the police so that you can pretend you're acting in good faith.) Disclaimer: IANAL, not a legal advice
- wutwutwat 3y agoThe "stuffer" in the url they mentioned made me stop reading and go down a rabbit hole. Fwiw, there's a Joomla extension called EasyCreator that has a stuffer controller and it bills itself as being able to easily submit random forms, etc. Are these people using a modded version of joomla from someone, and they are just copying and pasting the php to random shared hosts affiliate internet marketing company style? > EasyCreator is a developer tool. > It tries to speed up the developing process of custom components, modules, plugins, libraries, templates, CLI- and Web Applications. > You can create a 'frame' for your extension and an installable zip package with just a few 'clicks'. https://github.com/elkuku/EasyCreator https://github.com/elkuku/EasyCreator https://extensions.joomla.org/extension/miscellaneous/development/easycreator/ https://extensions.joomla.org/extension/miscellaneous/develo... For all I know the rest of the article will clear it all up for me or this has nothing to do with it at all.
- wutwutwat 3y ago> For example, a stuffer buys a stolen payment card off the black market for $10, and uses that card to purchase more than $1,100 worth of goods. After the reshipping service takes its cut (~$550), and the stuffer pays for his reshipping label (~$100), the stuffer receives the stolen goods and sells them on the black market in Russia for $1,400. He has just turned a $10 investment into more than $700. Rinse, wash, and repeat. That is a lot of moving pieces and risk to take such little away in the end. Why not use the cards to buy crypto and pocket the whole $1100 with no complex network of goons taking half your money and getting heat sent your way? Or, with apps like cash app, venmo, fb payments, google payments, apple payments, hiding the source of a fraudulent transaction through a proxy of easy to create and throw away, bank accounts (those apps are bank accounts) has to be stupid easy. Hell, most of the time you don't have to do any ID verification on those apps if you stay below a certain amount and stay away from known scammers, and even then, fake IDs are better than ever. I'm willing to bet that fraud transactions below a certain amount won't even be looked in to, because the effort would cost more than the lost amount, and 1 billion is pocket change to these card companies, and the losses are either a write off, or federally insured anyway, so they aren't suffering. I bet they use that themselves to have money go missing so they can owe less taxes. People are stealing a made up thing and funneling it through nonsense to get back half of the made up thing, and we care for some reason. The network described here is overly complex and I don't see the need, but I'm not a criminal network so idk why it is needed. Feels fake though
- zoover2020 3y agoYou're missing the point that even when there's breadcrumbs to take, cybercriminals are still very interested. Typically these operations are scaled so that it adds up and actually can make the fraudsters a lot of money. Don't underestimate the power of scale
- wutwutwat 3y agoThe power of scale is getting them busted because too many people are involved. One person buying up crypto in small amounts or laundring funds through cash apps is not going to get any attention and will be making 2x as much, or need to work half as hard, depending on their goals. A lifestyle fraudster, if you will, who is only concerned with doing enough to live comfortably and doesn't need a startup scale crime network. Greed is what brings them down everytime, startups and criminals