3 ms·
AI is no different than proliferating nuclear weapons I mean, once the discussion goes THIS far off the rails of reality, where do we go from here?
by CamperBob2 3y ago
AI is no different than proliferating nuclear weapons
I mean, once the discussion goes THIS far off the rails of reality, where do we go from here?
- Mistletoe 3y agoCan someone outline how AI could actually harm us directly? I don’t believe for a second sci-fi novel nonsense about self-replicating robots that we can’t unplug. My Roomba can’t even do its very simple task without getting caught on the rug. I don’t know of any complicated computing cluster or machine that exists that wouldn’t implode without human intervention on an almost daily level. If we are talking about AI stoking human fears and weaknesses to make them do awful things, then ok I can see that and am afraid we have been there for some time with our algorithms and AI journalism.
- 2devnull 3y agoYou start by saying “show me examples of” and finish by saying yeah “this is as already a problem.” Not sure what point you’re trying to make, but I think you should also consider lab leaks in the sense of weaponized ai escaping or being used “off label” in ways that yield novel types of risk. Just because you cannot imagine future tech at present doesn’t indicate much.
- chasd00 3y ago> Can someone outline how AI could actually harm us directly? at best, maybe it adds a new level of sophistication to phishing attacks. That's all i can think of. Terminators walking the streets murdering grandma? I just don't see it. what I think is most likely is a handful of companies trying to sell enterprise on ML which has been going on since forever. YouTubers making even funnier "Presidents discuss anime" vids and 4chan doing what 4chan does but faster.
- hackinthebochs 3y agoI don't need to know how a chess computer will beat me to know that it will beat me. If the only way you will entertain x-risk is to have a specific scenario described to you that you personally find plausible, you will never see any risk coming that isn't just a variation of what you are already familiar with. Do not constrain yourself to considering only that which can be thought up by your limited imagination.
- chasd00 3y ago> Do not constrain yourself to considering only that which can be thought up by your limited imagination. Don't let your limited imagination constrain you're ability to live in fear of what could be. Is that what you mean? So it's no longer sufficient to live in fear of everything, now you need to live in fear even when you can't think of anything to be afraid of. No thanks.
- hackinthebochs 3y agoInstead of taking the most obtuse reading of my point, how about you try to engage intelligently? There are some manner of unmaterialized risk that we can anticipate through analysis and reasonable extrapolation. When that risk has high negative utility, we should rationally engage with its possibility and consider ways to mitigate it.
- Eisenstein 3y agoConsider an AI as a personal assistant. The AI is in charge of filtering and sorting your email. It has as a priority to make your life more efficient. It decides that your life is more efficient if you don't see emails that upset you, so it deletes them. Now consider that you are in charge of something very important. It doesn't take a whole lot of imagination to come up with scenarios like these.
- hyeonwho22 3y agoWhy not? It has already been shown that AI can be (mis)used to identify good candidates for chemical weapons. [1] Next in the pipeline is obviously some religious nut (who would not otherwise have the capability) using it to design a virus which doesn't set off alarms at the gene synthesis / custom construct companies, and then learning to transfect it. More banally, state actors can already use open source models to efficiently create misinformation. It took what, 60,000 votes to swing the US election in 2016? Imagine what astroturfing can be done with 100x the labor thanks to LLMs. [1] dx.doi.org/10.1038/s42256-022-00465-9
- dingnuts 3y ago>It took what, 60,000 votes to swing the US election in 2016? this is a conspiracy theory that gained popularity around the election but in the first impeachment hearings, those making allegations regarding foreign interference failed to produce any evidence whatsoever of a real targeted campaign in collusion with the Russian government.
- CamperBob2 3y agoEh, he's not wrong there -- our elections are subject to chaos theory at this point, more than the rule of law. Sensitive dependence on both initial conditions and invisible thresholds. The Russian "butterfly effect" in 2016 was very real. Even if it wasn't enough on its own to tip the balance in Trump's favor, they were very clear that Trump was their candidate of choice, and they very clearly took action in accordance with that. Neither of these statements is up for the slightest debate at this point. However, the possibility of foreign election interference, real or imagined, is not a valid reason to hold back progress on AI.
- visarga 3y ago> Next in the pipeline is obviously some religious nut (who would not otherwise have the capability) So you're saying that: 1. the religious nut would not find the same information on Google or in books 2. if someone is motivated enough to commit such an act, the ease of use of AI vs. web search would make a difference Has anyone checked how many biology students can prepare dangerous substances with just what they learned in school? Have we removed the sites disseminating dangerous information off the internet first? What is to stop someone from training a model on such data anytime they want?