9 ms·
Mint is shutting down, and it's pushing users toward Credit Karma
- hiddencost 3y agoRest in peace. You were too beautiful to live. Mint was my (and I think many people's) first introduction to budgeting apps. It was life changing.
- subreal 3y agoFor a second I was afraid this is about Linux Mint
- red-iron-pine 3y agonah. but you can use GNU Cash, a similar FOSS app as Mint, on Linux Mint
- whitepoplar 3y agoWhat's the best free alternative these days?
- ianschmitz 3y agoGhostfolio is pretty slick and can be self hosted! https://ghostfol.io https://ghostfol.io
- ToucanLoucan 3y agoI have so many of these self-hosted apps in my server now, it's getting rather full but it's so freeing to know my cloud is just mine. My data stays on my machine and isn't reliant on some server farm christ-knows-where, their infrastructure, and their security policies which are all effectively required to be taken on faith. I absolutely love it and I have so much appreciation for the people building this stuff.
- pixelbyindex 3y agoCare to share some useful apps you have been using? I recently got a NAS and found out it's quite easy to host a service via docker and forward connections with cloudflared. So far I am running vaultwarden and an audiobook server using plex.
- crazygringo 3y ago"716 Monthly Active Users" That is... not inspiring confidence. Either it's accurate so nobody uses it so I don't have confidence in it, or the number is wrong but nobody's noticed this glaring error on the home page and so I also don't have confidence in it...
- sudofail 3y agoI personally use RocketMoney. I think it actually does a better job than Mint
- paxys 3y agoAnd is owned by an even shadier company than Intuit.
- harshreality 3y agoledger, hledger, beancount: https://plaintextaccounting.org/ https://plaintextaccounting.org/ Gnucash Firefly III The plain text accounting options are by far the best if you're willing to give up automatic pretty navigation and graphing.
- pragmatic 3y agoAnd auto syncing of back data. I spent some time trying to set up hledger so that I’d actually use it. With multiple accounts it really got tedious but I loved the actual double entry accounting and level of detail. My wife was blown away by the year end summary I made with it. You can see early how much went to taxes, fica etc etc. I once had ambitions to combine this with tiller or some other syncing app. I just use tiller now.
- JaggedJax 3y agoNot that you should trust that your info is any safer than with Mint, but has anyone tried Personal Capital? I've seen it recommended in the past, but they seem to have rebranded and their site doesn't list much detail about it. https://www.personalcapital.com/ https://www.personalcapital.com/
- lbotos 3y agoI use personal capital and it's just about the same as mint, with a more "investment" focused tooling set as they want you to buy their fund. Beyond that, a few CC providers have terms that say "you aren't protected if you give out your password to services like this" so do keep that in mind (I didn't wire up some accounts explicitly for that reason, and I track them manually in the tool) Wish the US would get it's act together and mandate a modern open banking API.
- pragmatic 3y agoI got tired of the pushy sales calls for their managed option. Kind of turned me off. I wish I could have just paid for it. I eventually switched to tiller ($5/mo) as it mostly works and is super configurable (just a spreadsheet synced with bank data)
- loco5niner 3y agoI use it and like it. Just as good as before.
- bendoidic 3y agoAssuming you mean "free" as in "I don't need to provide a credit card to sign up", then https://ghostfol.io/ https://ghostfol.io/ If on the off chance you mean "free" as in "freedom from having my data sold", then You Need a Budget (YNAB) is a popular option. But be warned, YNAB is more than software...it's a new way of thinking about budgeting. It takes some getting used to. https://www.ynab.com/ https://www.ynab.com/
- zie 3y agoI use Fidelity Fullview(must be a customer of Fidelity but that can also be free). Fidelity also has eMoney, which is a more comprehensive option, but requires going through a financial advisor that supports it. Otherwise the other options people have mentioned are decent, particularly hledger.
- ixwt 3y agoAnd this is why I'm still using YNAB 4. Cloud hosted services have their perks, but owning my own data and not having to worry about being forced to another service is nice. Though, I have a feeling I'm going to be pushed eventually to something else.
- dividefuel 3y agoYeah. It took some extra steps to install on both a new Android phone and a new Mac. I'm tempted to remake its functionality in a spreadsheet, but haven't mustered the will power yet
- yieldcrv 3y agoI wish there was money in building offline apps Maybe a nonprofit could do it, especially with treasury rates so high it could self sustain itself for 30 years easily with a big endowment
- SnorkelTan 3y agoIf you have an office 365 subscription microsoft money is a spreadsheet that can connect to your accounts through plaid I believe. Not offline, but also probably not going away.
- alexdig 3y agoLooks like it just got discontinued, too? https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/end-of-support-for-money-in-excel-faq-f0e0a388-1bb0-42cf-8753-9574c5424ba4 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/end-of-support-fo...
- BobaFloutist 3y agoWhat's the privacy policy like?
- localhost 3y agoI haven't used this before, but are there things that you wish you could have used Python to analyze the data in the workbook? I currently use Mint, so need to migrate to something and maybe I could find a way to extend any missing functionality via Python (disclosure: I'm a founding member of the Python in Excel team). Edit: I see that it was shut down too.
- pragmatic 3y agoI think they are directing people to Tiller. https://tearsheet.co/new-banks/tiller-the-personal-finance-platform-replacing-microsofts-money-in-excel/ https://tearsheet.co/new-banks/tiller-the-personal-finance-p...
- abootstrapper 3y agoLong live offline apps! I have a copy of Family Tree Maker that is decades old and still works.
- eMPee584 3y ago"The budget tracking app Mint is going away on January 1st, 2024."
- paxys 3y agoPushing users toward Credit Karma...which has next to zero feature overlap with Mint. I'm surprised they couldn't even bother to try a paid offering before throwing in the towel. There have been people diligently using the service for over a decade who would definitely pay $10/mo if given the option rather than having to migrate somewhere else.
- piyh 3y agoI would 100% pay to keep my Mint account
- Astronaut3315 3y agoIn what way is a credit monitoring app (Credit Karma) a viable alternative to a budgeting app (Mint)?
- paxys 3y agoIt is a viable alternative for Intuit because they can collect more data and show more ads while providing no ongoing service.
- manicennui 3y agoCredit Karma is a lead provider for lenders. They probably make a boatload of money from that. I don't think they care about providing the same functionality.
- CodeWriter23 3y agoGuess they didn’t make a Mint.
- rwl4 3y agoI've been an extremely happy user of Rocket Money for a couple years now.
- hx8 3y agoI use to look at Mint once a quarter. It gave a good high level overview of my finances -- it linked to all my accounts, had records of my assets, etc. Once a quarter I'd load it, see my total assets grow and my debts decrease, and get a strong sense of security. What are some of the best alternatives for this sort of personal finance view?
- miah_ 3y agoCheck out YNAB (You Need a Budget), its subscription based but can give you a good overview of your spending, and account health/wealth.
- paxys 3y agoYup. Most alternatives people are proposing need you manually enter every transaction you make, and that instantly makes it useless. I want one that connects to every single bank account/investment portfolio/loan I have and updates it in real time. I have never found something as seamless as Mint in that regard.
- tenacious_tuna 3y agoI used Actual for a little while and ran into the same frustration; having to manually download and re-upload CSVs was driving me crazy. I also loathe the idea of having to hand over the account credentials to any third party service--what I really want is my financial institution(s) to send webhooks of my transactions, or even just allow for an automated download of the CSVs. (I'd write a playwright bot, but the 2fa makes it difficult. Of course the accounts should have 2fa, I just want an API for getting my transaction data.)
- paxys 3y agoPlenty of banks now support OAuth and only provide limited read-only access.
- mikeyouse 3y agoI used Mint in the same way and then migrated to Personal Capital after the Intuit acquisition. Unfortunately, they were sold by come company called Empower recently but it hasn't seemed to impact things on the Personal Capital side yet. Apparently it's branded as "Empower Personal Dashboard". I've got ~4 or 5 bank accounts, a few different 401ks, some individual stocks via Equiniti or whoever, our mortgage, our credit cards, our house and car as assets (with values derived from Zillow and I think KBB?) - the only issues are the same ones I had with Mint where occasionally some service would need another login / password / 2FA or something and time out. https://www.empower.com/sites/default/files/styles/large_hq/public/image/2023-01/Dashboard-image2.png?itok=Cd-lKq2Q https://www.empower.com/sites/default/files/styles/large_hq/...
- rqtwteye 3y agoI still miss MS Money. It did everything I needed and I didn't hand over my account passwords to a cloud service like Mint. It's kind of mindboggling that this got ever accepted as the way to do things.
- jmisavage 3y agoI still have a copy that I run in a VM. Doesn’t do as much as before, but I’m surprised how bad most of its replacements are at the basic feature level.
- heywire 3y agoYou can still use Microsoft Money sunset edition completely offline. I did this myself until about 2 years ago, when I broke down and wrote a simple web app to fill the need.
- Dennip 3y agoI think they cancelled it in 2023, but MS did release for a while an Excel template replacement for MS Money - I think it even had some advanced stuff like bank integration via plaid.
- cashsterling 3y agoI'm using YNAB desktop edition which still works great. Cost me ~60 USD about 8-9 years ago for permanent license. YNAB decided to go to a subscription based model, which is fine, but the annual cost of this software service seem ridiculously high for how simple the software is overall. Applies to monarch money too... 100 USD is a lot for simple personal accounting software.
- dangus 3y agoI pay for the YNAB subscription product. To me the value is in bank synchronization, which is a big ongoing cost for the service. I can centralize all my financial information across accounts. The habit of checking my transactions in a centralized place and categorizing them has led to me catching fraudulent transactions multiple times. I might have never noticed them without YNAB. That alone has paid for years of the subscription. I know some people find that manual transaction entry helps them control their spending better but to me that’s just not practical. I don’t have time for that, there are too many transactions. I also value the mobile app and automatic synchronization. It’s nice to be able to share a budget with multiple people and not fiddle around with local files or having to get on my desktop computer. I use YNAB on mobile 95% of the time. If I give it a negative it’s not really the price, it’s that I’d like to see more progress on the software. I know they are still a small company but I’d like to see more ways to visualize without needing rely on external tools, and I’d like to see an overall a faster pace of feature development.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoWhy is it shutting down? Kinda crazy to me that one of the biggest names in personal budgeting couldn't find enough value for its stakeholders. And how is Credit Karma not just a feature they could bolt on to Mint as a "Credit" tab. All of this is prob just weird organizational convection forces inside the Intuit megacorp rather than anything that's going to make practical sense.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCredit Karma is a better funnel to credit providers (cards and loans). They are a credit broker. They make money when they refer a customer to someone issuing credit. When you provide them access to your credit information, that is used by partner models to credit decision. EDIT: This is likely a cost efficiency effort, sunsetting what is underperforming and bolstering support for more profitable ventures. https://www.creditkarma.com/about/partners https://www.creditkarma.com/about/partners https://www.creditkarma.com/about/personal-loan-disclaimers https://www.creditkarma.com/about/personal-loan-disclaimers
- enumjorge 3y ago> Kinda crazy to me that one of the biggest names in personal budgeting couldn't find enough value for its stakeholders. The downside of getting acquired by a large company is that they want large-sized business. Lots of medium and small sized products that would be very viable on their own end up getting shut down because in the context of their parent company, they don't make sense.
- manicennui 3y agoI'm sure Credit Karma makes far, far more money as a lead provider to lenders.
- devrand 3y agoIt must be quite expensive to maintain. It predates Plaid, so unless they migrated, they're maintaining all the scraping logic and the services to actually do it. The credit card ads are probably not generating enough revenue to justify the upkeep.
- 3y ago
- Ozzie_osman 3y agoIt's always sad to see products that were truly innovative when they came out end up getting neglected and sunset due to large co M&A-based strategic decision-making. Disclaimer: I'm one of the co-founders of Monarch Money, a (paid) competitor to Mint founded by the original PM on Mint.com. I had written a HackerNews front-pager a couple years ago about why Revenue Model is More Important Than Culture [0], and my co-founder wrote some thoughts about why Mint ended up going this route. Since this announcement, we've seen an unprecedented influx of "Mint refugees" moving over. I think a lot of Mint folks have felt like the product has been neglected for years, but it was free and they often had years of history in the product. This was kind of a forcing function for them. 0: https://somehowmanage.com/2020/09/20/revenue-model-not-culture-is-the-dominant-term/ https://somehowmanage.com/2020/09/20/revenue-model-not-cultu... 1: https://www.monarchmoney.com/blog/mint-shutting-down https://www.monarchmoney.com/blog/mint-shutting-down
- alsodumb 3y agoThanks for working on Monarch! Does Monarch let you in some way import years of transactions data from Mint? From what I understand, if I signup on Monarch now and connect my accounts, there’s a limit on how far you can go into the history of my account to get the transactions, right? Or can you get every transaction from the first day of my bank account?
- Ozzie_osman 3y agoSo we do have a Mint import flow: https://help.monarchmoney.com/hc/en-us/articles/4411877901972-Move-data-over-from-Mint-to-Monarch https://help.monarchmoney.com/hc/en-us/articles/441187790197... There are some quirks to it (ie Mint only lets you export up to 10K transactions at a time) but there are work-arounds to it. You can sign-up, link your accounts, then import from Mint to fill in the missing history. If you hit any issues, just Contact Support from within the app and our Customer Support team will work with you to get it sorted out.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neogodless 3y agoWhile I haven't used it in ages, I'm surprised no one has mentioned Personal Capital (now Empower). I thought it was largely a feature parity competitor for Mint. But, perhaps it was acquired and made terrible... ? https://www.empower.com/ https://www.empower.com/ EDIT: https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/investing/advisors/empower https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/investing/advisors/empowe... > Empower acquired Personal Capital in 2020, and in Feb. 2023, Personal Capital finished its rebranding under the new name Empower. The service and its offerings remain largely the same.
- dalyons 3y agoIt’s not terrible. Not improved afaic since the acquisition, but not worse. Still better than mint
- loco5niner 3y agoSo far it is just as good for me. They do some sales pitches and I talked to an advisor. I didn't go with their pitch, but they left the analysis up for me for free, and I used it to adjust my investments.
- thedougd 3y agoI've mentioned it elsewhere on HN; I am not affiliated but a fan of TillerHQ. TillerHQ Syncs your account transactions to a Google Sheet or Excel Spreadsheet. $79 a year. https://www.tillerhq.com https://www.tillerhq.com
- ds 3y agoThe fact that this is being shut down vs being sold or at least integrated deeply in credit karma speaks so poorly for the intuit management I am not even sure what to say. The app has to be capable of generating millions a month in revenue at the least. Who is on the leadership team for mint, so I know to never work or partner with them in the future? This is so insanely incompetent its just.. shocking. This is a fumble not seen since skype fell asleep and did nothing during 2021 while google and zoom came and took their entire market. At the very least, make the app paid only. If you are worried about upsetting me because I have to pay for something that used to be free, trust me- Im going to be way more pissed about not being able to use it at all. I dont know, this whole thing just rubs me the wrong way. Intuit is a public company that should be focused on maximizing revenue. Destroying a app thats worth 500m-1b on the private market seems like its worthy of a shareholder lawsuit. I dont say this out of spite or trolling. I say this as a user of mint since they launched in 2007. Ive been with this app, letting them ravage and sell my data for over 15 years. https://i.imgur.com/XlioSth.png https://i.imgur.com/XlioSth.png . My old startup even participated in the same crunchies award as mint did, when we both won (us for bootstrapped startup and mint for founder of the year) so I am nostalgic about them being put out to pasture for no reason.
- sydbarrett74 3y agoThe Intuit management are doing exactly what they seek to do. The company is nothing more than a pure rent-seeker. Yay, rentier capitalism!
- gk1 3y ago- Intuit's revenue was $14.4 billion last year. An app making "millions" per month is a drop in the bucket. - Intuit paid $4.7 billion for Credit Karma, and only $170M for Mint. - Credit Karma had expected revenues of $1.5 billion in 2021. (https://techcrunch.com/2021/12/05/how-credit-karma-acquired-amid-covid-chaos-fared-in-its-first-year-under-intuit/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/12/05/how-credit-karma-acquired-...) - We don't know how much it cost (in time and money) to keep Mint running.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y ago
- Volundr 3y agoI switched from Mint to LunchMoney a few years ago, because I assume with it being free, Intuit was probably selling my financial data. It's pretty awesome, highly recommended.
- joewhale 3y ago+1 data point Really enjoy using their web app.
- uberduper 3y agoMint was originally built on the back of Yodlee.com which is something I had a small part in building. I was gone before that deal was.. minted, so I have no idea what the terms were like. My options ended up being worth like $15 and Mint got bought by Intuit, so I'm guessing not great for yodlee. AFAIK they only used yodlee for the first couple years until they were able to secure their own connections to financial institutions. Makes me a little sad thinking about how long I've been at this now..
- beembeem 3y agoAs someone who was in the trenches on this - what were/are your thoughts on putting all your financial passwords in one place?
- uberduper 3y agoI do it today with 1password. I did it back then with yodlee and mint. I've always avoided including any email, phone or utilities account creds since these are, unfortunately, ways financial companies frequently use to authenticate you or authorize changes. I didn't want to be locked out of them in the event my bank or trade accounts got taken over.
- hammock 3y agoWhat is the best Mint alternative? Can Personal Capital pull down CC line items and automatically categorize them?
- Rebelgecko 3y agoYes although IIRC Mint did this a bit better (in terms of customizable rules for overriding wrong categories)
- ultra_nick 3y agoIf you prefer projection over bank statement tracking, then Projection Lab is nice. https://projectionlab.com/ https://projectionlab.com/
- scubakid 3y agoStoked to hear you like it ultra_nick! Disclosure: I made this :)
- myth_drannon 3y agoThat's bad, very bad. I do my taxes using Mint transcations data. I've been using it for 6 years now. I would be happy to pay for it.
- softwaredoug 3y agoOne thing that happened since Mint came out - banks become more technically savvy. My credit card's app now gives me a pretty decent breakdown of my spending whereas before, Mint was more-or-less the only tool that would do this.
- chewbacha 3y agoI’m a little heartbroken. I loved mint and jumped at paying them a monthly fee when offered. I shooketh.
- simonw 3y agoIt took me a while to find it, but there's a page at https://accounts.intuit.com/app/account-manager/myData https://accounts.intuit.com/app/account-manager/myData where you can request they email you a copy of all of your Mint data.
- NelsonMinar 3y agoMint had plenty of anti-consumer sleaze in its years. Like in 2009 when they promoted freecreditreport dot com (which is a deceptive site and not actually a free credit report). It's possible that came more from Intuit, in line with all the deceptive marketing of Turbotax, etc. https://www.flickr.com/photos/xwrn/3180947702 https://www.flickr.com/photos/xwrn/3180947702
- js2 3y agoIf you're a Fidelty customer, they offer something called Full View[1]. Like everything with Fidelity, it's clunky but mostly functional: https://www.fidelity.com/spend-save/full-view/overview https://www.fidelity.com/spend-save/full-view/overview [1]: Under the covers, it's something called eMoney Advisor, LLC with its own TOS[2]. [2]: https://www.fidelity.com/spend-save/full-view/terms-of-use https://www.fidelity.com/spend-save/full-view/terms-of-use
- sydbarrett74 3y agoLet's just acknowledge an open secret: the main reason one company acquires another is to eliminate competition. Full stop.
- dehrmann 3y agoUnless Mint had QuickBooks ambitions, there was never much overlap. It felt like Mint was a way for Intuit to get into the consumer space. You can see that here. Credit Karma isn't exactly a replacement, they're not recommending QuickBooks, and no one here is recommending an Intuit product.
- nunez 3y agoHa. When I created my own money management spreadsheet in 2014, some people asked "why not just use Mint or YNAB or something like that?" Back then, the answer was "I budget biweekly, which Mint can't do, and YNAB has opinions on budgeting that I don't agree with." When Mint gained that capability, my new answer was "because things just disappear on the Internet" And here's Mint becoming another victim of the 2023 tech enshittificnado. I'm pissed on behalf of everyone who has years and years and years of data that will likely (but hopefully not) be impossible to fully export and now needs to find a new home for it all. I'm doing the same with Expensify and moving that data into Google Sheets, then later into Excel (because Google Drive still existing is a miracle)
- gigel82 3y agoIs there an alternative to just download transactions from credit cards and banks? I'm fine with Excel even, just need a way to get the data. I tried getting ofxget working every now and then and it always breaks in mysterious ways :(
- ttymck 3y agoI quite literally _just_ switched back to Mint from Personal Capital after about 8 years. Guess I am all-in on GnuCash
- red-iron-pine 3y agoGNU Cash it is. Of all of the GNU apps I think I'd be using daily, that's not one of them but its decent.
- crazygringo 3y agoAs someone who uses Mint heavily, it's incredibly unclear whether this is going to negatively impact me or not. Because: > [Credit Karma] “offers a simplified way for you to build awareness of your spending, and track your savings.” Intuit says it still plans on adding ways to view transactions, track spending, and aggregate financial accounts. > Earlier this year, Credit Karma added one of Mint’s key features: the ability for users to track their net worth. Intuit says Mint users can transfer their accounts by logging into Credit Karma from the Mint app. In my Mint usage, I've never cared about budgeting or categorization (their auto-categorization was never accurate anyways). I just want to aggregate all my accounts, track my monthly spending, and track my overall net worth. So this might be... fine? Or it might not be? It's just truly bizarre that: 1) They're forcing the transition to a ludicrously short 2 month period (why not give 6 months or a year to migrate?) 2) They're doing a horrible job at conveying whether Credit Karma is a good replacement or not (how about a simple comparison chart of features?) 3) They're destroying the Mint brand, which is valuable and consumer-friendly. Meanwhile "Credit Karma" just sounds like a scam If Intuit wants to better monetize Mint, it seems like it would be vastly better to port the profitable Credit Karma features over to Mint, rather than migrate Mint users to Credit Karma. What Intuit is doiung is utterly baffling to me, and smells like internal politics over at Intuit is taking precedence over good/profitable product decisions, which does not give me faith in the overall management at the company. Shutting down Mint to replace it with Credit Karma has very strong vibes of shutting down Digg v3 to replace it with Digg v4. I hope this turns out well in the end, but given what an atrocious job they're doing in communicating it, I'm not holding my breath.
- alsodumb 3y agoTo be honest I don’t think their decisions are that baffling once you start thinking in terms of money. 1. Credit karma doesn’t have all the features that mint does. I suspect they don’t plan on adding them either. But if you say that no one’s gonna sign up on credit karma. Might as well keep it vague and hint the new app can do that and hopefully some people end up signing up on credit karma. 2. I don’t think the care about mint brand. It’s pretty clear that mint wasn’t making enough money and they decided the effort needed to manage it isn’t worth it. On the other hand, credit karma is probably making a lot more money and much much easier to maintain - all it does is pull data from credit agencies. Credit karma recommends cards/loans etc. which I suspect is how they’re making good bucks. Either way, it sucks for us. I suspect mint did some user surveys to see if they could make a paid version of mint work and realized not a lot of people are gonna pay for it. Sucks for us.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoLooks like mainly the budgeting features are getting cut? From https://support.creditkarma.com/s/article/Intuit-Mint-and-Credit-Karma https://support.creditkarma.com/s/article/Intuit-Mint-and-Cr... > Your favorite Mint features are moving to Credit Karma: Continue to see your financial accounts in one place Continue to view your transactions Continue to track your spending Continue to view your cash flow Continue to track your net worth trend over time
- jwells89 3y agoOne thing I’ve not seen any competitor to Mint reproduce is the Mac app it offered back in the mid-2010s. It lived in your menubar and presented a popover when clicked which was very handy for quick reference, much nicer than having to switch to a browser tab or pick up my phone. I’ve considered building a simple WebView menubar app that wraps the Personal Capital mobile site or something which would kind of approximate the old Mint app’s experience, but it wouldn’t be as good since it’d be fudging a touch experience on desktop.
- Topgamer7 3y agoI'm still waiting on access to some API for Canadian banks (RBC mainly) so I can get transactions and account balance information for my own account. Its garbage this isn't available in 2023.
- mtnviewer 3y agoMint holds a place in my heart because we were basically neighbors. I lived a block away on the same street as their old Mountain View office. I remember being impressed when I first tried it, and even applied for a job there, but never heard back. Over time, my account connections started to rot, and as banks got acquired and accounts changed, data got glitchy, and I started seeing duplicate transactions. For a while, I'd diligently re-categorize transactions, hoping some sort of basic ML would learn from my updates, but it never did. My account fell into disrepair, and the information it offered became inaccurate and noisy. Over time, I just lost interest. I said I applied for a job there. I was never sold on their business model, and their suggestions to me never made any sense. At the same time, all the $100 per year replacements people are suggesting also make no sense. Mint offered an incredible product, especially for its time, but I'm not sure if there's a business there.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] (these verge articles are never on time) More discussion yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38105299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38105299
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoThe US banking system needs an enforcement model like PSD2. That one mandated an API that EVERYBODY can use. I should be able to write an application that pulls data directly from Chase / BofA / CapitalOne via a standardized API, without having to pass through systems like Plaid. This is essentially the largest hurdle that open-source applications have. Not that they don't have enough knowledge, but their adoption is hampered by a difference in features between applications like Mint. Mint worked seamlessly. No need for CVS exports & imports, mapping columns etc. It just worked. The fact that we can't get that without having to sign large contract is scandalous.
- entropicgravity 3y agoOh oh, just about had a heart attack there that Linux Mint is shutting down :O But it's not. The Mint app is shutting down and I'm breathing easier.
- smitty1e 3y agoCan vouch for https://www.ynab.com/ https://www.ynab.com/ Wife and I have been on You Need A Budget for ~6yr now. Not free, but the juice is worth the squeeze.
- bmaupin 3y agoHere are a couple open-source budgeting apps that can be self hosted: - https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii - https://github.com/actualbudget/actual-server https://github.com/actualbudget/actual-server I'd be curious what some other options are.
- wryrickdeckard 3y agoGovernments should provide citizens free or very low cost basic financial account transaction balance aggregator service with connectors to all financial providers. Perhaps also option to grant the likes of Credit Karma etc access to this basic aggregated transactions to try to add value eg budgeting, etc.
- olympus_money 3y agoI was with Intuit last year when they made the announcement internally. Since then, I've been working on something to help people as a replacement app. It's not ready yet, but I'd love to get people's thoughts on it. I'm in the middle of building now and can always use more customer feedback. Anyone who's interested can email me at jd@olympusmoney.com or check out the website so far: www.olympusmoney.com.