12 ms·
Big landlords used software to collude on rent prices, DC lawsuit says
- lsmeducation 3y agoAt what point can a hostile housing market be considered a discrimination issue (on financial basis)?
- foxyv 3y agoWhen it is shown that landlords are discriminating based on a protected "Class" such as race, religion, etc... Otherwise they are just discriminating against the poor. Until we make housing into a much less attractive "Investment" we will see obscene pricing levels. The only way to do that is to increase supply of housing. The hands down best way to do that is to end R1 zoning, minimum offsets, and parking minimums. At least within 20 miles of major cities.
- mnd999 3y agoThe private homebuilding sector is not going to build at the rate required to improve supply, because excess supply will cut into their margins. Deregulating will just allow them to build a ton of cheap low quality housing and still charge enormous amounts for it. Landlords would just pass that on. The solution is quality social housing, built by the state in large enough quantities to disrupt the market.
- ecshafer 3y agoWhat do zoning changes have to do with quality of housing?
- foxyv 3y agoR1 zoning prevents the creation of affordable housing. Since you can only fit maybe two or three households per acre, and land prices are sky high, the only affordable housing is in the middle of nowhere, 2 hours from anything. Something like this would be a huge improvement and reduce housing costs. https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/6/6/toward-dynamic-zoning-codes https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2018/6/6/toward-dynamic-...
- ecshafer 3y agoI agree with this. But the person i responded to was implying that relaxed zoning rules would leave more shoddy houses by developers. Despite building regulations being completely different than zoning.
- foxyv 3y agoAhh! Yeah I was thinking the same thing. It makes no sense that zoning would affect building quality.
- bugglebeetle 3y agoThis is being downvoted, but it’s actually what countries that have solved this problem have done. Even everyone’s favorite “no zoning, build, build, build” paradise Japan accomplished this by also building a large amount of public housing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danchi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danchi Housing didn’t become a depreciating asset there over night. It was the express result of the state intervening in the market.
- mnd999 3y agoSounds a bit too commie for the yanks.
- foxyv 3y agoThe younger generation is coming around. In a hundred years or so things may change, but until then we're stuck with our current political economic system. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/09/19/modest-declines-in-positive-views-of-socialism-and-capitalism-in-u-s/pp_2022-09-19_socialism-capitalism_00-06/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/09/19/modest-decli...
- davidw 3y agoIt can be a 'yes, and' thing. You can do both. You can't build a bunch of Japan style public housing if you do not have Japan style zoning.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BobaFloutist 3y agoIf you convert 10 single-family-homes worth a million dollars each into a skyscraper with a thousand units there's plenty of room for profit, even if the thousand units are cheaper than the current median cost for a condo (or rental). Cities have been writing laws and zoning that prevent economies of scale from kicking in for decades. If they just stop doing that, we'll get more housing.
- triceratops 3y ago> Deregulating will just allow them to build a ton of cheap low quality housing and still charge enormous amounts for it. You're stating this like it's a fact, but you haven't explained why. In a free market, competition is on the basis of price and quality.
- foxyv 3y agoAllowing existing homeowners to increase their revenue by densifying housing will drive prices down. Although developers for single family dwellings will not be as happy about it, if you have a 1/3 Acre lot 10 miles from downtown S.F. which you can turn from a single family $3000 a month rental into a multi-unit $30,000 a month rental then you will be happy to do so. Even if it drives down the value of your $800/month rental in the middle of nowhere. Imagine if you are currently owning and occupying a house and have a chance to pay your mortgage by building a rental property on the unoccupied half of your lot. A lot of people would be very happy to do so if it were legalized. Edit: But you are totally right that socialized housing would be an excellent solution.
- bequanna 3y ago> Until we make housing into a much less attractive "Investment" we will see obscene pricing levels. The only way to do that is to increase supply of housing. That isn't the only way. We could eliminate the many tax benefits like: accelerated depreciation, 1031 exchange, step up cost basis for inherited property, etc.
- bhickey 3y ago> step up cost basis for inherited property Heck, there's no policy justification for having the stepped-up basis at all.
- deschutes 3y agoPeople who have houses like it. Doesn't mean it's good policy.
- foxyv 3y agoEven without those tax benefits, I still made $60k in equity just by owning my own house. Probably more in the time since I last checked. There just is too much money and not enough houses.
- bequanna 3y agoSupply and demand. Decrease the benefits for owning an investment property, then the number of people purchasing investment properties will be lower and prices will likely fall.
- geodel 3y ago> Until we make housing into a much less attractive "Investment" we will see obscene pricing levels Yeah same for health, education, insurance, internet, medicine etc.
- fragmede 3y agoNo, the best way is to build housing. As long as we try make developers build housing through whatever incentives we can invent, they'll always be an investment. Developers aren't going to make new housing out of the goodness of their hearts. It is a business deal, an investment with an expected ROI. Making it a less attractive investment is going to end up with less of it being made. If the government builds housing, or subsidizes it (improving ROI for developers), we'll have more housing.
- davidw 3y agoOP is talking mostly about housing being considered an 'investment' for the average homeowner, I think. Homeowners, on paper at least, are the biggest beneficiaries of the housing crisis: https://oregoneconomicanalysis.com/2021/03/16/who-benefits-from-the-housing-market-graph-of-the-week/ https://oregoneconomicanalysis.com/2021/03/16/who-benefits-f... Granted, those are paper gains, but still, better to have that option than to be priced out of the market completely, as many are.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- triceratops 3y agoGP said > The only way to do that is to increase supply of housing And gave some examples of reduced regulation (zoning, parking) that would make it easier to build. They didn't say anything about government subsidies. You said > No, the best way is to build housing Aren't you both saying the same thing? I think you might have stopped reading at "don't make housing such a good investment" and not considered the substance of their argument.
- salamanderss 3y agoAnd yet when I actually go building the only place I could afford it was to go to a place with no code or safety inspections. This make HN mind melt, many folks here want to maintain the house crushing regulatory machine because all said they'd rather an extra homeless guy freeze behind a dumpster than elevate risk of fire spreading to their home.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- coding123 3y agoPeople don't understand this yet: The only way to increase the housing supply is to increase the price of the house. So you're left with a death spiral. Build to lower prices, but the actual building is costing more than what people are willing to pay for a house, let alone the markup needed to justify KB homes (or others) to get involved at all. Sure they're building, and you can go to job sites, but they're not going to charge what you think they will at the end. Long gone are those signs that say NEW HOMES LOW $400s!!! And if you do, they're undesirably small condos. The sales cycles are extended or, unfortunately, they're just going to keep selling at the $800 prices you're seeing for a new home.
- foxyv 3y agoThe problem is that it is illegal to build more housing in cities because of zoning restrictions. No matter what the price.
- lukas099 3y agoI don't think ever. If the rich and poor could afford the same things, money would have lost all meaning.
- dfxm12 3y agoRich people can still stand out with their fancy watches & flashy sun glasses. Shelter shouldn't be a status symbol.
- lsmeducation 3y agoAnd I'd even add that shelter is also one of those things we shouldn't just let the free market sort out (as it has been, and we all see how that's been going).
- conqrr 3y agoWholly agree. Basic necessities Food, Water, Shelter, HealthCare etc should not be left to the whims of the free market. It isn't even hard to fix in the US where land is still plenty but artificially controlled by regulations as opposed to heavily population density places like Japan.
- lukas099 3y agoIt's interesting that you decry the free market, but explicitly agree that regulations (market distortions) are what's preventing abundant housing.
- prewett 3y agoWe've tried public housing in the past, and it hasn't gone so well, so I'm not sure that's a great solution, either.
- lukas099 3y agoIt's a pipe dream to expect public housing to meet the demand for shelter in a political climate like that of the USA. That said, I'll still take as much public housing as I can get in my city.
- Nasrudith 3y agoPossibly when they refuse to accept a buyer offering the listed price, absent a higher bidder because of perception of wealth.
- xyzelement 3y agoWhen you sell the thing you sell (say, your labor) - do you try to sell it to the highest bidder (ie, prefer high salary) or do you not "discriminate" in this way?
- lukas099 3y agoThis is very interesting to me. Even if landlords had no interest in colluding, if they all use the same software to decide on prices, it seems like it could amount to the same thing. In reality, the case against the landlords and RealPage seems stronger than that, but I find even the theoretical case interesting.
- lukas099 3y agoI wonder if there is upward pressure on housing prices due to Zillow's Zestimate feature? Or on used car prices due to Kelley Blue Book?
- voisin 3y agoOr AirBNB hosts relying on its pricing feature.
- lsmeducation 3y agoThey mostly just look at most recent sales in the area. It sounds simple, but can be bewildering. Just because everyone gobbled up mortgages at low interest rates in 2020, does not mean you can keep pricing houses at 2020 levels. But that's exactly what the housing market keeps doing because they simply care about the last max bid/sale.
- spicyusername 3y agoAt the end of the day people will only pay what they will pay. Data like Zillow's Zestimate may impact the prices that people start with, but supply and demand take care of the rest. I think that the lack of housing supply in most markets and higher demand for housing is what is keeping prices inflated. If anything, this shows how high prices _would have gone_ had the interest rates stayed low, given that they are still high with today's high mortgage rates lowering demand.
- conqrr 3y agoI don't think supply and demand would autofix the issue. When a baseline is set, everyone believes it to be the new price. Same as how when a lie is repeated multiple times, it can dangerously become the false truth.
- presidentender 3y agoEven for units that aren't priced directly using RealPage's offering, RealPage units are comps. Formal collusion isn't the only means by which rents might rise in tandem across a market.
- aliljet 3y agoThis is such an odd circumstance. The OAG is not saying each of the management firms is actively colluding, but is accidentally colluding by agreeing to use RealPage pricing. In practice, this looks like RealPage is simply collecting rent data to determine what pricing looks like in the market. Yes, these RealPage estimates seem to be used, but if these estimates were wrong, the large landlords would simply fill up their competitor's units and would create an incentive to create more competitor units. Perhaps the DC governemnt would do better to simply build it's own brand of low-cost housing.
- ethanbond 3y ago> would create an incentive to create more competitor units. if only there were a way that landlords could actually prevent the creation of more competitive units... you'd probably want to preclude development in certain zones of the city... maybe could call it "zoning" or something.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> In practice, this looks like RealPage is simply collecting rent data to determine what pricing looks like in the market. Not really. RealPage "recommends" what you should set rent rates at, and even tells you that they "discourage" you from deviating from that recommendation, as it is based on an assumption of other landlords in the area (including those using RealPage) will be doing. It's plausible deniability for landlords, at most.
- flutas 3y ago> RealPage "recommends" what you should set rent rates at, and even tells you that they "discourage" you from deviating from that recommendation, as it is based on an assumption of other landlords in the area (including those using RealPage) will be doing. Worse than that. They require you to agree to their pricing at least 80% of the time.
- userinanother 3y agoI think that 80% thing brings it from price discovery system to criminal conspiracy to restrict trade. If the government were serious we would have filed criminal charges against everyone involved
- ramesh31 3y agoYeah no kidding. You think it was a coincidence that all the new built 2 bedroom apartments in Cincinatti ended up costing the exact same as the ones in Denver or Portland? The national convergence of rent prices over the 2010s was a real sight to behold. Those in major metros were cushioned by wage increases, but the people stuck paying $1800 for an apartment in the midwest got absolutely screwed.
- alsodumb 3y ago* Nods in agreement and cries from my 1200$ one bedroom unit in a Midwest college town * To be honest, I could have found a cheaper place as a grad student. I just wanted to live in a newer place, closer to my lab. But pretty much every new construction is priced as if it’s in a major city. There are a few buildings here in Champaign Urbana where the rent matches the rent in areas close to downtown Chicago.
- LeafItAlone 3y ago> Nods in agreement and cries from my 1200$ one bedroom unit in a Midwest college town Having lived in a remote college town long before such software could have been popular, I think a lot of college towns were probably already overpriced. There’s an almost guaranteed supply (students), often growing (as more students are accepted each year), and universities are often slow to build their own housing. Students want to be close to campus, often don’t have a car, and have access to cheap loans so landlords nearby can charge inflated rates.
- davidw 3y agoInterestingly, the people at that company doing the actual economic research into pricing are saying what everyone else is: > The surge in apartment construction is softening the Class B market more than any other asset class. In high-supply submarkets, Class B rents fell more than twice as much as Class A over the past year. Yet in submarkets with no new supply, Class B performed right in line with Class A. https://www.realpage.com/analytics/class-b-market-softening/ https://www.realpage.com/analytics/class-b-market-softening/ This is pretty much in line with what economists everywhere are telling us: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/10/20/housing-shortage-cities-build-more/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/10/20/housing-s... Not to defend the company; if they caught them trying to fiddle things, throw the book at them. But I just don't see their software being powerful enough to manipulate prices that far out of line with the market. You can't charge San Francisco prices in Baltimore. Of course, people want a Big Bad, a bogeyman to blame for the housing crisis, not 100's of small decisions in their city and state regarding zoning and taxes and so on that has shaped the North American city over the past 100 years.
- soperj 3y agoThe software is recommending keeping units empty in areas with rental shortages because it pushes up prices.
- testfoobar 3y agoThere is nothing wrong with keeping units empty to manage overall rental yield. It becomes an issue if a group of landlords agree not to rent below a certain threshold in a community. This is classic price fixing - leaving renters no alternative other than paying the minimum rate set.
- tristor 3y ago> It becomes an issue if a group of landlords agree not to rent below a certain threshold in a community. This is classic price fixing - leaving renters no alternative other than paying the minimum rate set. This is exactly what's happening, though. Landlords using RealPage/YieldStar are required to follow its guidelines and need permissions from the company to make exceptions. It's technology mediated collusion to price-fix.
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoAs someone who rented in Arlington in the 2010s, anecdotally this sounds 100% accurate. Early on I was able to negotiate lower lease renewal agreements than the apartment building's first offer. But at some point the management company started using some "software" to come up with "market rents" and the employees were reportedly "forbidden" from charging some other amount. Negotiation completely stopped and all offers became take-it-or-leave-it based on their software.
- chung8123 3y agoThat doesn't mean there was collusion though. In most places employees cannot change the price of something and we wouldn't consider that collusion.
- rozap 3y agoIn and of itself, no. But this case goes deeper than that. There were repurcussions if lessors deviated from the price mandate. That's just a cartel, plain and simple.
- kaibee 3y agoRepercussions for who? The employee in charge of pricing or the real estate company?
- flutas 3y agoThe apartment complex management. RealPage required 80% acceptance minimum of their pricing quotes. They required written reasoning and approval from someone at RealPage to change the price of a unit. If you went under 80% they kicked you from the program.
- flutas 3y agoYup. Applied for an apartment and was accepted. Before signing my lease rent in all the other units were lower by $300-400. Asked about it and well... "The computer sets the prices, we can't change that. We can move you to a different unit though." Suddenly the unit I applied for is back on the site at the new lower price... This was at a complex that proudly had the realpage logo on their homepage. Renewal offer was $600 more after a year (~25% increase). They wanted to ask me why I was moving out... I pointed out my car had been vandalized twice and they shrugged. I did this a few times with various things (gunshots, water pouring on my head during an interview..., my water heater blowing up and them keeping me waiting for 2 days on a replacement) and they basically shrugged off everything and kept insinuating that they would be withholding my security deposit no matter what. Final thing I mentioned was the original RealPage lawsuit... suddenly they want me out the door asap and promises of my entire deposit back...
- mullingitover 3y agoMany companies bar engineers from visiting the USPTO site or looking at patents, because of the treble damages risk. It should be be the same deal for landlords. Using this site should constitute evidence of collusion and multiply the penalties.
- kaibee 3y agoEh. Is it collusion to look at the prices for similar properties on craigslist/zillow and then set your rate accordingly? Is it collusion to pay someone to do that part for you? My initial reaction was that yes what they're doing is collusion, but in a supply limited market, prices going up due to market pressure is the same thing. Essentially isn't the company at this point just acting as a market maker, by figuring out the market clearing price where as many units as possible are filled at the highest price?
- ajmurmann 3y ago[flagged]
- wizerdrobe 3y agoGas stations buy routine shipments of fuel with fluctuations based on the broader market. Renting out real estate is quite a bit different, you buy it the once and lock in customers… nothing stops me from going across the street for my next 12 gallon purchase. Seems a stretch to compare the two here…
- ajmurmann 3y ago> Gas stations buy routine shipments of fuel with fluctuations based on the broader market. Not sure how this impacts sales prices. I know gas station owners first hand who pre-everything-being-online were asking for reports of gas prices in neighboring towns to adjust their prices. >buy it the once and lock in customers… nothing stops me from going across the street for my next 12 gallon purchase. How often do rental prices get adjusted and how often do tenants move? The frequencies anecdotally seem not that disconnected. The only reason we are arguing about any of this is because housing supply is super short because of broken zoning and permitting. Build more and take market power away from suppliers!
- epistasis 3y agoThis is one form or market manipulation that we can all agree is suboptimal for renters. But in order for it to even have a chance at success, there's a deeper and more insidious market manipulation: an engineered shortage of apartments. If there was adequate housing supply, landlords could not profit from this collusion. However, we embrace this collusion through heavy restrictions on housing supply, which directly enrich landlords. This is the true collusion that we should remedy, and perhaps there should be lawsuits against the city and its land use officials.
- solidsnack9000 3y ago"There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to one who is striking at the root." Henry David Thoreau
- gedy 3y agoWhy the focus on RealPage? Aren't there other software companies like Buildium, Appfolio, Yardi, etc that do this as well?
- WoodEye 3y agoMy guess is that realpage has a very large share of the market.
- zoomablemind 3y agoI wondered this too. My guess, it may have political benefits, as it's D.C. Will see how the other companies would react to this. I'd guess, they would enforce the notion of "recommendation" to whitewash the outright collusion.
- Buttons840 3y agoWhat is collusion exactly? I think it's when cooperation replaces competition in the market. Free markets, like everything, have pros and cons. The pros of a free market depend on competition. Some markets are so small that everyone in the market grows to trust each other and they find a mutually beneficial arrangement; they stop competing and there goes all the benefits of a free market while leaving all the cons. Did I miss anything? It reminds me of https://ncase.me/trust/ https://ncase.me/trust/ . Often it's a good thing to have trust in a group, the elimination of competition is good. But, again, the merits of a free market are based on the assumption that companies will compete, and to the extent this is not true, the benefits of free markets are undermined.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoBy this measure, are stock markets and commodities markets collusion because they determine the market clearing price?
- denverllc 3y agoIf all the sellers used software to enforce a minimum price (which is what’s happening here), then yes that would be collusion. And things like that have absolutely happened in finance (see: LIBOR, bid ask spreads in the 90s, etc.).
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSo you agree that if there is no requirement to enforce price, there is no collusion? It seems like half the people in this thread are arguing that simply knowing the market price constitutes collusion.
- niam 3y agoWhere else do we require charges of collusion to be substantiated by hard-requirements?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoEverywhere? In general the legal system requires all charges to be substantiated by evidence. In general logical or rational thought requires allegations to be well founded. In contrast, where else do we simply let charges and outcomes be dictated by sentiment or allegations opposed to evidence?
- niam 3y agoThe presumption there being that the only possible evidence for collusion is the existence of hard-requirements levied on each party. Unless you're misreading my reply to mean the absence of hard-evidence.
- jmyeet 3y agoThis is capitalism working as intended. Whenever libertarians or deregulation-loving neoliberals start arguing for "smaller government" or deregulation just point them to examples like this. Only government stops thinks like price-gouging, housing discrimination and many other state functions. What we're dealing with here in economic terms is what happens when you apply a largely unregulated market to a necessity that (by being a necessity) has inelastic demand. You need somewhere to live so the only function of capitalism in that case is to extract as much wealth from you as possible for something you can't possibly do without. Some will point out not all landlords do this (that's just a matter of time) and there is other software. This is the lie of competition when what we really end up with is price-fixing. Except price-fixing is technically illegal so instead you end up with "price leadership", which is the same thing but legal. This is where Delta decides to start charging $30 for a checked bag and United and American Airlines mysteriously follow suit. "Leadership". This isn't innovation. It's not even market efficiency. It's coercion, which is state violence, something people seem blind to. If you don't pay the sheriff will show up and phyusically throw you on the street. Eviction is violence.
- aidenn0 3y ago> This is capitalism working as intended. 1. Many capitalists and libertarians are in favor of antitrust regulations. Cartels are second only to the government in their ability to distort markets 2. Calling the housing market "unregulated" is a joke. In many places the supply is constrained largely due to regulations. 3. The tension between socialism and libertarianism in the US has ended up with kind of an anti-dialectic where we end up with the worst-of-both worlds (if your not a rentier). Any legislation that can reduce competition is framed as benefiting the poor, while any legislation that might upset the status-quo is framed as government overreach.
- pphysch 3y ago> Many capitalists and libertarians are in favor of antitrust regulations. Cartels are second only to the government in their ability to distort markets Who enforces these "antitrust regulations"? A gutted "small" government? > The tension between socialism and libertarianism in the US has ended up with kind of an anti-dialectic where we end up with the worst-of-both worlds This is an interesting framing, because during the original rise of socialism in the mid 20th century, USA had an extremely productive dialectic of socialism+libertarianism (1930-1960). It was only after the capitalists took over again in the 70s, and pushed back against socialism, that things started to go south for the median American. To say there is a significant component of socialism in today's USA is absurd, and demonstrates how foreign the concept of "socialism" has become. We are controlled by corporations and the corrupt politicians they manage. There is clearly NOT a dominant thread of "public servitude" that is required for a socially-oriented economy.
- narinxas 3y agowhen can we openly discuss this in terms like: "software used hapless land-onwers in DC to make more money" ???
- pbalcer 3y agoOn a tangentially related note, big companies often say that they perform pay benchmarking by contributing compensation data to third-parties to then determine the market rate for employees. After reading the article, it strikes me as a very similar process, just for a different type of market (housing vs labor). Did anyone try to challenge pay benchmarking in court?
- alistairSH 3y agoFrom what I'm reading, the key distinction is RealPage pressures landlords to adhere to the pricing suggestions. That's what puts them over the line (not simply "because algorithms" as the headlines and teasers state).
- happytiger 3y agoWe dig the coal out of the ground, refine it, ship it to where it’s to be used, but we don’t encourage you to use it so that makes what we do ok. Not an attack, but isn’t that almost the same logic they’re using?
- scarby2 3y agomaybe. But the thing here as well is not just that they suggest pricing but that it's not necessarily prioritizing occupancy. If you have the ability to pressure more than one party into allowing lower occupancy you can set an artificial floor on pricing or slow the amounts rents should fall during a downturn.
- happytiger 3y agoIt’s a simple case of conspiracy price fixing. It’s just our laws haven’t caught up to the distributed nature of the collusion.
- alistairSH 3y agoNot sure what coal mining has to do with price fixing? My very simplistic take on this... - offering a sampling of current rents in the area for $50/month [not price fixing] - offering a sampling of current rents in the area for $50/month, and then facilitating collusion between land-lords, and also pressuring landlords to adhere to rent rates [price fixing] Obviously, there's a lot more nuance there, and I'm not a lawyer, but seems to be the gist of it.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 3y agoRegardless of what you call it (collusion or not), the anticompetitive effects of everyone using the same algorithm and not deviating from its seems clear. I would love for this kind of lawsuit to win. In an algorithm driven world, systems level views are critical and I hope the law keeps up. If anticompetitive prices are an emergent feature without a literal “let’s collude” handshake, it still needs dealing with.
- nikanj 3y agoCollusion only works if there isn’t enough supply for real competition. Just let them build, man
- coding123 3y agoPrice collusion has been moved into software. Automated systems that recommend pricing for Gas and everything else. We're at the tip of a huge iceberg right now. Computers have a way to automate collusion and hide it's existence. In every major industry there is a small cottage industry that provides pricing data. The obvious response someone can reply with is that there needs to be a way to punish non-colluding players, but the reality is, you only need to have the whales involved. The small players can charge less, but realize that if they're only providing 5% of the market (combined), and cannot exceed that, they have no downward pricing pressure. Combine all that with the fact that the FTC asleep at the wheel to this and monopolies gobbling up all of the competition. Almost all of our food is owned by a handful of companies that own hundreds of brand names.
- xkcd-sucks 3y agoSounds like there's about to be a new market for "pricing stratey consultants" who work individually with landlords to teach them generally how to estimate market rates and how to optimize vacancy/lower rate, etc. Or an author to publish "the magic formula" in a textbook that is popular among landlords Or self-hosted software that does the same thing as RealPage except bring-your-own-data (companion app: craigslist scraper) and phrases recommendations more like "probability of these consequences using this strategy"
- hnburnsy 3y agoOne of my offspring leases from a company that uses this type of software. We offered to pay the lease term in full up front for a discount but there was no negoiating. It felt like no one even had the ability to negoiate and they could only offer the terms that the AI told them.
- lr4444lr 3y agoIANAL, but data sharing does not sound like it meets the threshold for collusion.
- esalman 3y agoRecently moved to Irvine, and I found that almost all decent apartment complexes are owned by the same one company.
- eagleinparadise 3y agoI seem to be the only person here that's actually used YieldStar. RealPage basically is a big data play where they can project forward demand because most larger landlords are using their software. Landlords are NOT communicating with each other "colluding" on property management & leasing decisions. That's ridiculous. Landlords hire a property management company. The property management team works with ownership to determine the budget and financial goals and the property manager works does leasing/works with YieldStar to hit those goals. The property management company may have other clients as well (like Greystar, which manages most large properties) As a YieldStar user, you basically set the desired occupancy you want, like 93% or 95% (and before you have a misinformed take about 95% occupancy = landlords keeping units vacant... this is an industry standard... there is always some slack in the market). So YieldStar basically tries to pull/push forward demand to get to the desired occupancy by changing the rent. You could make your occupancy 100%. But it's actually less revenue to do that. Is this all legal? No idea. I'm eager to wait to see how this plays out. But an interesting thought is: Are property management companies "colluding"? They work on behalf of other landlords in the same area. They "aggregate" leasing data and act as a central operator to conduct leasing. There are probably A LOT of other industries where some central party is aggregating data, which makes the market more "efficient" from a capital perspective. What's funny though, is i can't think of any other industry begging to let us build housing, which reduces rents and income for landlords. We are seeing rents come down fast in these oversupplied apartment markets. Maybe there's a lesson. Want to reduce rents? You have to add supply (i.e. TX), or reduce demand (San Francisco's years of mistakes making it lease desirable).
- GypsyKing716 3y agoIronically enough, one just has to watch a history of Louis Rossmann's (think Right to Repair, youtube.com personality - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl2mFZoRqjw_ELax4Yisf6w https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl2mFZoRqjw_ELax4Yisf6w) videos about his rent / lease in the commercial space of NYC, to understand how the equations work. I think the city and state governments are the bigger issue. The collusion meets with government bureaucracy as well. This doesn't seem to be a unique situation, but in NYC and the exodus of big tenants in the city matched with post-COVID beliefs that costs will remain high turns out for a toxic environment there for business at least. Naturally the "Rent is TO damn high" guy from a few election cycles ago (look on Google for that) is also the case. I don't know how the used car market and rental market will return to what it was before for a forseeable future.
- anjel 3y agoIts no different than the yield management software long-employed in the travel industry. Can a distinction be made where it is legal for use in a hotel but not in rental housing?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- arrosenberg 3y agoSure would be nice if one of these bandits went to jail. If you steal $100 worth of groceries, Walmart calls the cops. If they steal $100M worth of rent, who do you call?
- culi 3y agoSimilarly, if a Walmart worker steals $10 of merchandise, they face serious repercussions and even permanent markers on your record. Walmart stole over $100m in wage theft and won their court case. The only price being some lawyers wages.
- SauciestGNU 3y agoJail would be nice but seizing the housing stock from them and administering it as a public good would be my dream.
- rhelz 3y agoHow about software engineers collude for bigger salaries? It's not even against the law, its called 'unions'.
- RecycledEle 3y agoThat's nothing compared to the Texas Apartment Association (TAA) that prints one contract and refuses to let any member of the TAA use any other contract. Literally every single place has the same multi-page, 2-collum contract. A collective refusal to deal is a crime under Texas law. I have filed many complaints. I get no action.
- JaDogg 3y agoAll landlords are Ferengi. One day you can exploit others too haha.
- nocsi 3y agoMeanwhile on the west coast, the renter protections are so strong that landlords are either killing their tenants or paying them to leave. Seems like housing is a hot mess on both sides of the country... in their own ways.
- ath3nd 3y agoAt this moment, are we even surprised that big-capital-anything is doing amoral things in the singular pursuit of profit?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoThe complaint: https://oag.dc.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/DC%20OAG%20RealPage%20Complaint%20-%20Filed.pdf https://oag.dc.gov/sites/default/files/2023-11/DC%20OAG%20Re...
- fsckboy 3y ago> to keep rent prices high in a city with a housing affordability crisis this phrase undermines their whole case. A city experiencing a housing affordability crisis is not going to see a decrease in rents regardless of this software (which may be illegal and ok, throw the book at them) Housing affordability crises are caused by shortages of housing compared to demand for living in that place.
- camila45 3y agoDo you need hackers for hire? Do you need to keep an eye on your spouse by gaining access to their emails? As a parent do you want to know what your kids do on a daily basis on social networks ( This includes facebook, twitter , instagram, whatsapp, WeChat and others to make sure they’re not getting into trouble? Whatever it is, Ranging from Bank Jobs, Flipping cash, Criminal records, DMV, Taxes, Name it, We can get the job done. They are a group of professional hackers with 10 Years+ experience. Contact at ( remotespywise @gmail com) … Send an email and Its done. Its that easy, try us out today.
- camila45 3y agoI just wanted to share this just incase anyone is in a situation where they don’t trust their partners anymore. There is no harm in wanting to know what your second half is into, it saves you from wasting more years of your life with people who do not deserve you. I will leave the hacker’s contacts below just incase anyone needs his services and assistance. Just a mail to remotespywise @gmil com.