8 ms·
I designed my own keyboard layout. Was it worth it?
- sweettea 3y agoJonas' keyboard layout is so awesome and incredibly inspirational for my own journey -- probably the single most read documents that I've spent time with this year.
- okasaki 3y agoI also designed my own layout (https://i.imgur.com/C7GSCoE.jpg https://i.imgur.com/C7GSCoE.jpg) I used it for around a year, but I'm back to qwerty now, specifically on a low-profile keyboard with red switches from aliexpress. Pros: - Some people think it's cool - It's interesting to do it - It's fun getting fast at typing on a new layout Cons: - Most people think it's weird - It can get expensive - Although I was eventually able to switch quite seamlessly between my layout and qwerty, for a few months my qwerty skills were very bad. - If you don't want to carry it to and from work, you need 2 keyboards, or suffer two layouts - When typing I sometimes found myself thinking about the keyboard and layout rather than what I was writing - There's no ergonomic benefit that I could see, but I don't have any problems with normal keyboards
- sleepybrett 3y agoI tried to switch to workman a while ago. I only did it on my kinesis advantage (my main work board). I left my gaming keyboard, normal flat 65. I was able to switch back and forth but I credit that to a kind of muscle memory because of the advantages physical layout. I also went back, partly 'getting back up to speed' frustration and partially because I'm really not sure what I was going to get out of it. After almost 40 years with qwerty keyboards ... it doesn't seem like i'm going to get that much benefit if there is even a measurable benefit.
- Keyframe 3y agoI just need a HHKB with macbook keyboard's arrow keys to the right side.
- sleepybrett 3y agoI know i've seen them but it might be easierjust to go with a layout like one of these.. I'm not suggesting this particular company, i have no experience.. but just easy to find photos: https://www.keychron.com/products/keychron-q1-pro-qmk-via-wireless-custom-mechanical-keyboard https://www.keychron.com/products/keychron-q1-pro-qmk-via-wi... This layout seems cool though I'm pretty sure you could find one w/o the f-frow. I've gone with a 65 for my only 'flat' board. https://www.keychron.com/products/keychron-k2-pro-qmk-via-wireless-mechanical-keyboard https://www.keychron.com/products/keychron-k2-pro-qmk-via-wi... You might be able to find one with the hhkb 'missing molars'.. HHKB/Realforce did make a hhkb lite with inverted-t arrows in 2001... you can see it on this page: https://hhkeyboard.us/about/history https://hhkeyboard.us/about/history
- jwells89 3y agoI’m pretty happy with just plain HHKB, just wish I could have that layout on a laptop. Maybe one of these days some company will produce aftermarket HHKB layout keyboard components for Framework laptops…
- Keyframe 3y agoI'm super happy with it. So much so that I have two. However, occasionally I do want to "play pacman with one hand and eat pizza with other". Impossible to do with HHKB.
- strongly-typed 3y agoThe ANSI HHKB does not have the arrows, but if you're willing to use the JIS HHKB, it actually comes with dedicated arrow keys, and even a split spacebar with extra thumb keys that you can reprogram with software to act however you want.
- sleepybrett 3y agoshot answer, probably not unless it's an accessiblity thing (missing fingers etc) The whole 'least keys possible i'm 31337 hax0r' optimization fuckery I just find hilarious.
- smrq 3y agoIf you haven't experienced RSI to the point where you understand that reaching for distant keys is literally painful, then I can see how you might come to the conclusion that it's just for e-peen points.
- sleepybrett 3y agoYes about 20 years ago, I switched to a kinesis advantage (then called the essential) it solved all my problems and I still have a relatively normal amount of keys.
- markmark 3y agoLots of the fancy keyboards coming out at the moment are settling around the layout the advantage has had for decades (although usually without the nice curve the advantage has).
- sleepybrett 3y agoyeah no the whole ergo-dox moonlander blahblah family is just 'advantage but way easier to build cause it's flat'... and they all suck because they are flat. I tried out a friends glove80... it's just kinesis but still worse, there are a few things that kinesis does. It's better than the ergo-dox because keywells.. it's better than the glove 80 because of the keycap profiling. I do think the profiling on the 360 is a little worse than the older advantage 1/2 but it's pretty good. .. but like the glove 80 all the keycaps are the same height from the switch and it's not great. (to give props advantage basically stole from maltron but the build quality on those is so so shitty.. vacuform cases sometimes)
- hinkley 3y ago
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoIn my case it was worth it. I kept qwerty but moved each half outward so g and h are now where f and j used to be. From there I moved all of the outer keys to the two new columns in the center, plus a few other tweaks. Got enter on the corner so it's a palm-press. If I use a normal keyboard my pinkys start to hurt again, goes away when I switch back to my custom one.
- gsuuon 3y agoI partially went down the alternative layout path before I realized simply lifting my palms off the palm rest was enough to relieve my RSI issues.
- coldtea 3y agoKISS and Pareto would be proud of you!
- justsomehnguy 3y agoThis sounds like 'hah, I have that one trick', but as someone who benefited a lot from being conscious about the ones posture... please, take a look at yourself before.
- magicalhippo 3y agoWhen I learned to use computers I naturally gravitated towards holding my arms at about 45 degrees, with fingers on left-shift, A, W, D and K, O, ;, '. After some time we had some touch typing in classes at school and it was so painful trying to have my hands square on. So I just ignored that whole thing and continued my style. Never had any issues.
- pyridines 3y agoI typed for years in a similar way, and only developed RSI after forcing myself to type "properly"
- seec 3y agoI find that most of the time people pretend there is a proper way to do things its actually them talking about their lack of skill or insecurity. They seem to have it right because they have been doing the thing for much longer than you, so it is almost always an unfair comparison. If you look at it through the prism of ability development over time, it completely changes the dynamics and I believe those people are very often wrong because they only speak from their experience that is driven by their mediocrity or lack of skill. In particular I learned to cook both professionally and for my own benefit and I discovered around professional kitchen that cooks are taught many stupid things that are mostly about covering somebody's ass for security or enforcing an inefficient way of working to keep people busy. You would be amazed how little relevance the pro cook learning has to the actual completion of the task efficiently; in fact they would often gain so much efficiency if they learned to let go of their learned behaviors. Another pet peeve of mine is the requirement of "warming up" before sports like running or the like. In my youth, every single sports teacher of mine pissed me off by requiring this nonsense even though I really felt it was at best a waste of time and even counterproductive. And now we actually have studies that prove this as a fact, which would have been clear to someone who is not completely incompetent. Also, I have the performance numbers to back this up nowadays, so I am not taking any more of this nonsense. In general, I feel it is sometimes hard to explain nicely to people that their limitations do not necessarily apply to everyone; it gets pretty hard to patiently listen to peoples that are clearly mediocre trying to teach you how to do stuff even though they are not very successful at the task they are teaching.
- IshKebab 3y agoI had RSI and experimented with Dvorak, vertical keyboards, even vertical mice (terrible idea). None of them helped. Surprisingly the thing that helped was getting a really good chair (I recommend a second hand HM Mira; don't get anything that sells itself as "ergonomic"), and a really deep desk so you can properly rest your forearms on the desk. With that my RSI went away completely, even with a totally plain qwerty keyboard. Dvorak was definitely nicer than QWERTY but when you add up... 1. You know qwerty. You'll probably never be as fast with Dvorak. 2. Ever want to type on any other keyboard in the world again? Yeah good luck. You will underestimate how often you type on coworkers' keyboards. 3. Ever use keyboard shortcuts? Well now they're awful. ... it definitely isn't worth it.
- svachalek 3y agoI learned Dvorak 30 years ago due to RSI, and it's a pain for reasons 2 and 3. Maybe 10 years ago I just dropped it and went back to Qwerty. Got RSI, switched back to Dvorak, fixed it. But speed is just a matter of experience. I don't know if I'm faster on Dvorak, but a speed that is really hammering keys in Qwerty feels comparatively effortless in Dvorak.
- gilcot 3y agoSimilar here: Dvorak fixed my RSI. I think I can be faster on Dvorak because I type less quickly and with more comfort to reach the same level.
- rgoulter 3y agoEven without RSI, overwhelmingly the anecdotes about Dvorak are that it feels more comfortable. In terms of speed: I learned Dvorak, then went back to QWERTY. I returned to Dvorak a few years ago, and can now be faster with Dvorak than I was with QWERTY.
- dheera 3y agoI got a HM Sayl. It is comfortable but it makes a racket of squeaks, creaks, and wailing noises every time I move. So much so that I try not to move at all during meetings these days. My previous $80 Staples chair didn't have this problem. Are the other HM chairs any better?
- input_sh 3y agoDoes anyone do this and type in multiple languages regularly? I could see myself getting into it if I only had to bother with a single layout, but since I deal with three different layouts on a daily basis, no way.
- dheera 3y agoI use Dvorak and regularly type in both English and Chinese (Pinyin). On Linux and Mac it's no issue to input both using Dvorak. On Android, however, none of the Chinese input methods support Dvorak so I had to decompile and modify Google Pinyin's APK and rearrange the XML layout files to Dvorak. https://github.com/dheera/android-googlepinyin-dvorak https://github.com/dheera/android-googlepinyin-dvorak I never learned QWERTY, so I'm extremely bad at typing with it even on a phone, regardless of language.
- terr-dav 3y agoI recently switched to Dvorak for iOS, which I was delighted to find as an option. While I can still function on a full-size QWERTY keyboard on account of using them regularly, I almost never pick up someone else's phone, so my thumbs have forgotten it entirely.
- antoinebalaine 3y agoI use the French bepo layout for everything, but all my languages are Roman languages.
- silverpepsi 3y agoI type in Chinese regularly It is annoying that Windows keeps Qwerty for it while Mac uses Dvorak. If it was just consistent (I constantly switch machines) it would be easy to handle and entirely subconscious by now... But I start typing the wrong layout every time and lose a few seconds mentally reorienting myself.
- dheera 3y agoI don't use Windows so I don't have an definitive answer for you but it seems possible to have Dvorak+Pinyin. This is 6 years old so I don't know if the latest versions of Windows work the same way https://medium.com/@jiayu./how-to-set-your-pinyin-ime-keyboard-layout-to-dvorak-on-windows-8165ae0de6b5 https://medium.com/@jiayu./how-to-set-your-pinyin-ime-keyboa...
- effnorwood 3y ago[dead]
- neom 3y agoThis was on the front page yesterday also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38108427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38108427
- gumballindie 3y agoThe only customiseable keyboard i want is one made of glass - a screen like macbook’s touchbar - where i can move keys around, add custom keys, or simply “enable” and show only those relevant to what i’m using. Ie if i play a game to only shows wasd plus tool keys. And those tools keys to be renamed to whatever their purpose is.
- bee_rider 3y agoThis would be a nice application for eink, if it ever got cheap enough.
- rgoulter 3y ago> move keys around This isn't a common feature, but I've seen that Dumang keyboards can do this. https://www.velocifiretech.com/products/dumang-dk6-ergo-v2?variant=39757815677046 https://www.velocifiretech.com/products/dumang-dk6-ergo-v2?v... > customiseable keyboard i want is one made of glass - a screen like macbook’s touchbar Other than using a tablet as a keyboard (I guess), I've seen keyboards like https://fluxkeyboard.com/ https://fluxkeyboard.com/ which sorta seem to go for this "customize the labels based on what I'm doing". IMO, though... your hands are covering the keycaps. If you have to look down at the keyboard to see the labels, it's going to be more cumbersome than just presenting a toolbar on the screen.
- fsiefken 3y agoColemak was just released when I decided to switch to a better keyboard layout to prevent a return to RSI. I looked into rolling my own based on statistics. I didn't care if it would look like QWERTY, if I needed to switch cold turkey for my health or future comfort I'd do so. I decided to use the tried and true DVORAK and tweak a minimum to make it even beter; switch the U (qwerty F) and the I (qwerty G) as the I is used much more frequently in both English and Dutch. Next to being optimized for finger travel the DVORAK layout has more so called 'hand alteration' during typing due to the vowels being on the left. It took months before I was 'up to speed'. I thought I would type significantly faster, but that is'nt the case as I often think slower then that I can type. It's much more about comfort. I don't regret it, it really is more comfortable. I switch between QWERTY and DVORAK-IU often so I am bilingual. Typing in alphabetic shorthand (for example Yash) with yet another optimized layout is another possibility. Or Yash with morse code or braille mapped like chording or just chording. https://www.artofchording.com/layout/chorded-keyboard.html https://www.artofchording.com/layout/chorded-keyboard.html Soon we will be talking to our LLM's a lot, so it's not a real big deal, but the nerd in me likes to optimize. Still I think, perhaps I could have designed the very best layout for my personal style and Dutch en English and the latest theories regarding what's more optimal (rolls, hand alteration, compression, chording). Perhaps an LLM can help? Not sure if I want to learn a new layout again. In the meantime alternating between QWERTY and DVORAK-IU suits me well.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Soon we will be talking to our LLM's a lot, so it's not a real big deal Regardless of how good voice interfaces get, the inherent limitations and restrictions that come with it means that we'll all still be doing a whole lot of typing until/unless a new and better input method is invented.
- NikkiA 3y agoThe only replacement for typing I can see taking over would be a mind interface, but even there I have a suspicion that it'll require 'thinking in a different voice' that'll make it almost as tiring as voice control.
- coldtea 3y agoI've never seen Betteridge's law of headlines more applicable than to this title - and I haven't even read TFA.
- jug 3y agoThe only one I’ve seriously considered is to open the mechanical keyboard market for me as a Nordic ISO layout user by using the Swerty layout: https://johanegustafsson.net/projects/swerty/ https://johanegustafsson.net/projects/swerty/ There is a FAR greater custom keyboard market with ANSI layouts and that one is exactly that. ANSI layout for the traditionally ISO Nordic languages.
- sesm 3y agoI use QWERTY layout on Ergodox with some keys removed. Moving symbols to a separate layer and Esc to Caps Lock position was enough to relieve my hands. https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/40EJq/latest/0/29/ https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/40EJq/latest/0/2...
- Radle 3y agodesign hardware for vim xD
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sam0x17 3y agoannnnd vim user, no surprise there :D
- ge96 3y agoTanget/OT I smashed the screen on my phone one time and this piece of tech that could summon a car was useless. I was stuck/had to figure out a bus system, was hungover so it was bad. I was thinking of vibration input. I still rely on/envision the standard qwerty layout Those rock wrist rests are fancy
- major505 3y agoThanks, I hate it. I been using qwerty since the IBM PC XT where a thing. Before that my mother tauch me to type in eletronic typewriters. It's a terrible layout for Portuguese, ok for english, but but I spent so many years perfecting the necessary motor skills to use it that I would prefer to lose a hand than type in anything else now.
- atoav 3y agoIf all I did was type on my own private keyboars maybe I would consider another layout. But since I spend quite some time on other people's computers it is not worth the brain-knots that happen when switching.
- PeterisP 3y agoI do a custom layout to get the diacritic non-English letters from my "proper local" layout but all the special characters/symbols as per US keyboard, since the "proper local" layout has them moved around for some reason. That was annoying, so many years ago I spent the 15 minutes to prepare the layout files and then I just need to install them on every new computer I get.
- james2doyle 3y agoNice breakdown. I actually just passed my one year anniversary using the "Workman" layout on an ErgoDox EZ. I also eventually added home row mods. My current layout is here: https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/aPAE5/latest/0 https://configure.zsa.io/ergodox-ez/layouts/aPAE5/latest/0 I am not faster than I am on QWERTY when using my built in Macbook keyboard. But man, is it way more comfy. I did manage to recovery from some serious wrist pain I was getting when using QWERTY and the standard layout. So I will stick with a split ortho keyboard and Workman for now. Before anyone mentions it, I did try Colemak and Colemak-DH and I didn't like either. They just didn't sink in the same way that Workman did. I think the Workman home row is more comfortable to me.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoHow does it compare to DVORAK?
- carabiner 3y agoDvorak, the inventor's name. No need to yell.
- Obscurity4340 3y ago[sowwwy, ^dvorak]
- andbberger 3y agoi think the ship has sailed on qwerty for me, but it's hard to deny the benefits of a thumb cluster keyboard. i've had a kinesis advantage sitting on my desk for a couple of months but have yet to figure out the best way to remap the thumb cluster for emacs. and the days when my wrist hurts enough to motivate me to try using it are the days i definitely, definitely don't have time to have my productivity crippled by my silly keyboard.
- rudy6912 3y agoFor Emacs with Kinesis (or Glove80), move Control and Alt where the arrow keys are. I have been using it that way for quite a while, and it has been working great.
- jareklupinski 3y agoi mapped Ctrl-W to one of my mouse buttons and can't navigate the internet now without it now middle click opens tabs, thumb button to close after scrolling down a bit, putting me at the top of the next thing i middle-clicked a few tabs ago refusing to upgrade it until i can find another mouse that will let me bind Ctrl-W to a button without a daemon running (onboard memory only)
- iimblack 3y agoPloopy has qmk so you can map it.
- jkaptur 3y agoFor those just looking to dip a toe in different layouts: I remapped movement keys and it's awesome. I made a demo so you can see for yourself: jkaptur.com/layout/
- kogus 3y agoThis sounds like a colossal waste of time, and a lot of fun. The “repeat” key is a cool idea though.
- rperez333 3y agoI went through this rabbit hole about 2 years ago. I assembled 2 versions of also 34 keys designs, split, low profile keyboards. That helped a lot with my RSI but eventually my thumb got stressed since is constantly requested for the layers. I eventually assembled a design with a few more keys, pretty similar to the Voyager. I switch between this and the Microsoft Sculpt, and it definitely helped me with the constant discomfort. https://www.zsa.io/voyager/ https://www.zsa.io/voyager/
- alanbernstein 3y agoThe tripod mount for the Voyager is exactly what I want. Too bad there is no integrated pointing device.
- throwaway14356 3y agoone of my innovation formulas is to query/ask what completely obvious thing everyone has missed all along. Usually a bunch of vague concepts pop up. Pianists transfer a lot of data with timing, force, duration and pressing multiple keys simultaneously. They also get to use more than one keyboard. I did some toy text compression fooling around, enough to think we have the means to figure out what the most frequently used symbols and combinations are for a specific task. Autocomplete probably offers great clues too. a key could be " = function(" with a key "){" to the right. Imagine a HTML keyboard that has keys for tags, you have it on the side attached to an arm, the less often you use it the further away. The big button at the left top is called: <!DOCTYPE html> <html> <head> <title> An additional coding keyboard can have a button for a "for(var i=0;i<" and one next to it ";i++){" long press allows a custom var in stead of i just spewing thoughts here, i haven't done the homework nor the required pondering to call it ideas.
- throwaway14356 3y agothe pianist can also sing. Maybe some kind of narration combined with imperfect key pressed can add up to an accurate result. Maybe it isn't ideal to press buttons as it involves a lot of muscles that could send signals on their own. Typing while wearing data gloves could capture failed key presses, use them for autocorrect. if the brainwaves are also detected it seems possible to gradually get more lazy with your typing without losing anything. Maybe looking at keys on the many dedicated keyboards could be enough to trigger them at least eventually. posture could also do things. Stand while typing for all caps.
- keyle 3y agoI must be lucky but I haven't developped RSI since I've been programming non stop since the 90s. Sometimes I ask myself, why? Surely by now, I should have symptoms... I genuinely think it's because I spend most time thinking and reasoning, navigating through code, and very few time actually typing. I don't have long steady streams of typing nearly as much as if I type a message here for example. I also don't type "properly". My fingers travel. Which is why I never could get on board with split keyboards. I type fast, even though I was never taught how to type properly. The H key for example will be accessed by both hands depending of the word I'm typing as to save time, and my left hand travels way further than the right (invades the right). A big difference I've found though is to drop keyboards with keypads. That way, my QWEF fingers are about inline with my left shoulder (slightly off inwards) and my mouse in the right hand is in front of my right shoulder. My resting hand are angled with the thumb area being clearly above, even when mousing. All I can say after years of working on CRTs is to make sure you neck/shoulders are where they're supposed to be. Use a small pillow for your lower back (above your bottom), and that your natural gaze on the screen is just below the chrome of whatever application is in front of you, at arms distance at least. Also make sure you have glasses that protect your eyes as much as possible from fatigue (sharpening/blue filter). If you have RSI, as a software developer, consider copilot. It takes off 70% of my typing these days.
- KolenCh 3y agoThe fallacy in your argument is to think RSI means something wrong is done. It is like a game, where you think it would be like go or chess that skills is strongly correlated with outcomes. But I’d think that is more like monopoly, where great skills with poor luck will not save your day. From what I’ve seen and read and experienced, some people do all the wrong things and never have developed RSI, some does everything correctly and yet a mild usage of keyboards results in RSI.
- lawn 3y agoLike health in general. You can be a heavy smoker, drinker, and never exercise yet live a healthy life until you're a 100 years old. Or you can eat healthy food, exercise, and do all the right things, yet be plagued with poor health your whole life.
- zamadatix 3y agoI'm working on kind of the opposite of what most everyone does: a larger-than-full-sized keyboard. Bringing back the f13-f24 physical keys (mostly because they make good non-global hotkeys), surrounding the number pad with characters for hex, : for IPv6, "," bc why the hell isn't it there, moving the number pad to the left so the keyboard is more balanced. I've been playing around with re-arranging some of the keys (particularly above the arrow keys) but I'm trying to keep the majority in the same place because I can't exactly expect this keyboard everywhere and it's already a big enough pain going between different standard layouts. Oh, and the caps lock is a layer key for whatever seems fun, I'd like to find a good way to enter raw unicode hex values via the number pad in that layer mode but I haven't really gotten that far. The other big feature is it'll also stay completely unmarked. Partially because it looks nicer, partially because it means looking never really helps you just are made to remember very quickly, and partially because that means if anything doesn't work out it's just a reprogram of the firmware or using a single type of key so they can be moved around instead of ergonomically shaped for their position. Hearing it was worth it for the author (for whatever reasons) is good to hear. I honestly don't think I'll find all this worth it... but at the same time it is one of those things where "even if it's not worth using once it's made it's worth not wondering if it would be anymore".
- User23 3y agoI wish would-be keyboard designers would read John Napier's marvelous book Hands, because I see little evidence of the biomechanics of the hand being considered in any sort of systemic way by practitioners.
- spit2wind 3y agoEvery time I see a post like this, I mention steno (stenography). I do it not to dunk on someone's fun. I think this project is super cool and inspiring. I hope to do my own design some day. I mention steno because so many responses are about RSI and, as far as I can tell, there is no better solution today to RSI than steno. Simply, steno is a chorded keyboard in which some combination of keys maps to some output. You press down the keys and the output is handled on release. The mapping can be anything you like. A common one is phonetics. Assign each key to sounds like "Kuh", "Eee", "Buh", "Oh", "Er", and "Duh". You press down, release, and translate that to "keyboard". There are many improvements possible (that happen). This is just a basic example. Speech-to-text often comes up. This is a valid solution, as it removes the problem (hands). However, it presents at least two major problems. One, you need to develop a theory pretty much identical to steno. As far as I know, no standard theory has been developed. Steno has been around for at least 100 years. It's well understood. If you use a steno system for voice, you can use a steno system for steno. Two, you have to talk which is not only tiring, open office spaces are trendy and not going away. The most common response is, "But can you code with steno?" Yes! Absolutely! And it's great! I have programmed professionally exclusively using steno for at least two years, full time. You need two features to make steno practical for programming. In the steno jargon, these are called "repeat" and "one up". Repeat is straightforward enough. It allows you to repeat a keystroke. The problem arises because steno is chorded. The stroke is only sent on release. Doing something like pressing "<down>" becomes hell if you must do separate strokes. Repeat typically works by looking for a "double tap", a press-release-press-and-hold within some short time threshold. "One-up" means being able to send a partial stroke. Again, this shows up with navigation. A common way to map up-down-left-right is with a "prefix" and a key pattern that looks like WASD. For example, the left hand may hold down STPH and the right hand maps up-down-left-right to PBRG (see https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZAkkTtsPKOA/maxresdefault.jpg https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZAkkTtsPKOA/maxresdefault.jpg). This means STPH-P maps to up, STPH-B to down, and so on. Again, stroking each movement separately is hell. However, one-up allows you to hold the prefix, STPH, and then press and release the remainder of a stroke, such as -P. In this way, you can navigate and fingerspell easily. Combined with repeat, this feature makes programming with steno practical. Steno is obviously a commitment. It's also less keystrokes. Keystrokes is a root problem. Steno took me about 3 months of 15 minutes practice in the morning each day. The world record is something like 360 words per minute. I find that 30 wpm is sufficient to do practical programming work. Think of it like the difference between Yngwie Malmsteen and Kurt Cobain. One is technically possible and cool, the other gets the job done. You learned to program. You can learn steno. It's worth it. Best of luck with your RSI and do go see a physical therapist. Seriously!
- vander_elst 3y agoWith custom layouts how do you deal with editor shortcuts? I tried Dvorak but the cost of losing vim muscle memory was too high for me. Do you remap editor shortcuts (e.g. hjkl navigation) or do you learn the new positions from scratch?
- moozilla 3y agoColemak user here, one of nicest things about Colemak IMO is that the ZXCV keys on the bottom row stay in the same location. I tried out a variant for a while that had XCDVZ and my brain could never get used to it. For other common shortcuts (Ctrl+T when browsing, Ctrl+F, etc) I didn't find it too hard; I guess some shortcuts are more muscle memory and others are associated with the letter in my mind. I will say, having learned Colemak early on has made me give up on learning vim more than once for the same reason you highlighted -- I want to have my navigation on the homerow but the burden of remapping all of the keys without knowing what I'm doing was too high. I've heard that many people just use hjkl in the standard Colemak positions and don't remap keys at all, but that seems crazy to me, since they are spread all over and J is in the worst possible spot on the keyboard.
- lawn 3y agoI (the post author) designed the layout with Vim in mind, so I placed hjkl in decent spots and added som Vim specific combos. But other than that I just learned all the positions from scratch. For me it's not so much the positions I think about, but the mnemonics. For example "d" deletes, so I just have to think "press d", not "press this key in this spot. So learn the new layout and the Vim commands will follow.
- myaccountonhn 3y agoI use Colemak and learnt the new positions. It’s easier since I use it in combination with other tools (aerc, tig). Now it’s second nature.
- zubairq 3y agoI find that changing working position and keyboards often makes sense for me. Also I too navigate code far more than I type