6 ms·
Google AI chief says there's a 50% chance we'll hit AGI in just 5 years
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAs always, define "AGI". Define it well enough that we'll know whether we reach it or not. If you can't define it, Google's AI chief can claim he was right, but that will be like, just his opinion, man.
- pw6hv 3y agoIf he said there's 50% chances, then he'll be right in any case.
- ryanklee 3y agoNobody is going to be debating definitions when it's here. If there's a question, then the answer is no.
- famouswaffles 3y agoLol that's not true at all. Many people have definitions of AGI that are partially or wholly mutually conflicting.
- ryanklee 3y agoMy point is that actual AGI will make such debates totally irrelevant.
- famouswaffles 3y agoNo it won't. What is "Actual AGI" and why is it not simply a machine that is generally intelligent ?
- ryanklee 3y agoI think you might not be following my point. Actual AGI will be so enormously singular and distinct from anything we've ever encountered that only an idiot would look at it and say, "But hmmm, maybe this might not be it." The very fact of continued debates over definitions to act as criteria is all the signal we need to know that we aren't there yet.
- famouswaffles 3y agoWhy would it be "so enormously singular and distinct from anything we've ever encountered" ? What does being an Artificial General Intelligence have anything to do with any of that ? This is the point I'm making. You're hiding behind vague musings. ENIAC as the first general purpose computer was a declaration made years after the fact. Why do you think it's going to be any different here ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAnd yet, in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38113190 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38113190, you said that AGI is "a bar we have passed". That statement assumes that we have a clear enough definition that you can tell whether we have passed it. But here you say that many people have conflicting definitions, that is, that there's not a clear agreed-upon definition. I don't think you can have it both ways.
- famouswaffles 3y agoYes people have conflicting definitions of the specific term. But Artificial and Generally Intelligent is a bar that's been passed. Take a look at all those definitions i brought up and tell me which ones have anything to do with only being generally intelligent ?
- famouswaffles 3y agoArtificial and Generally Intelligent. That's what it's supposed to mean. What it used to mean. A bar we have passed. Now there's all sorts of weird offshoots where passing the bar is tantamount to Super Intelligence. "For some, it might mean any that is needs to do everything a normal human can. For some, non-biological life axiomatically cannot become AGI. For some, it must be "conscious" and "sentient". For some, it might require literal omniscience and omnipotence and accepting anything as AGI means, to them, that they are being told to worship it as a God. For some, it might mean something more like an AI that is more competent than the most competent human at literally every task. For some, acknowledging it means that we must acknowledge it has person-like rights. For some it cannot be AGI if it lies. For some it cannot be AGI if it makes any mistake. For some it cannot be AGI until it has more power than humans. These are several definitions and implications that are partially or wholly mutually conflicting but I have seen different people say that AGI is each different one of those." He should define his version but it obviously doesn't matter what he defines it as since humans are in the business of making up new posts on the fly.
- lm28469 3y ago> Artificial and Generally Intelligent. That's what it's supposed to mean. What it used to mean. A bar we have passed. Since when? You can ask 10 people and get 10 different definitions
- famouswaffles 3y agoThat was the idea when the term was coined. Obviously now it just means all sorts of things.
- lm28469 3y agoBut what's "general" ? Does it exist physically ? Can it play tennis ? Can it smell a flower ? Can it assemble an ikea shelf ? Can it make and serve me a tea ? Some people, even on HN, say chatgpt already is AGI for example...
- i67vw3 3y agoA 'consciousness' tries to reproduce (humans, animals, bacteria etc) to preserve itself. The day AI decides to kill not a human but humanity itself will be the day AGI is achieved. Until then 'AI' is vapourware, turing test and other such tests are meaningless.
- tutfbhuf 3y agoIf we achieve AGI, it will be such a significant event that everyone in tech and most not in tech will know about it, regardless of any definition.
- johnny99k 3y agoChatGPT4 already severely limits what you can do with it. I wonder who will eventually have access to unrestricted AI? I'm guessing the people with the deepest pockets.
- tmikaeld 3y agoWhat scares me more is what happens when criminals (with deep pockets) and no morals get their hands on it.
- agnosticmantis 3y agoWhat are some questions that you think the unrestricted AIs can answer and are worth paying for (and that restricted ones can’t)?
- inawarminister 3y agoRunning local AI models in your own hardware will be the ultimate case of freedom.
- Jeema101 3y ago5 Years Out! (TM). Just in time for fully automated self-driving cars! /s
- briffle 3y agoyet sadly, Nuclear Fusion is still 20 years out, just like it was in 2003.. and 2013.
- marginalia_nu 3y agoNot to mention 1993, 1983 and 1973.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoI'm currently doing ecommerce. I predict that in 5 years time all commerce will be ecommerce. I think we should budget accordingly fellows.
- kasperni 3y agoI'm currently doing ecommerce, own retail, and wholesale. I predict that in 5 years time all our commerce will still be ecommerce, own retail and wholesale. I think we should budget accordingly fellows.
- tmikaeld 3y agoI'm currently doing ecommerce, digital, physical and services. I predict that in 5 years time, all commerce will continue to be ecommerce, digital, phsyical and services. I think we should budget accordingly fellows.
- nrdgrrrl 3y ago[dead]
- eddtries 3y agohttps://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2017/09/in_technology_everything_is_always_five_to_10_years_away.html https://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2017/... > Slate has noticed a wily hedging mechanism among Silicon Valley soothsayers to circumvent these uncertainties—make predictions for “five to 10 years out.” It hits that sweet spot: just close enough that people can begin to taste it, but just far enough away that (almost) no one is going to call you out if it doesn’t become true. A review of press releases and tech articles stretching back to the 1990s finds that these Goldilocks forecasts are abundant. We’ve compiled a list of 81 predictions for innovations coming in “five to 10 years” to illustrate the cliché.
- the-dude 3y agoEinstein, bomb, 1939 : https://www.osti.gov/opennet/manhattan-project-history/Events/1939-1942/einstein_letter.htm https://www.osti.gov/opennet/manhattan-project-history/Event...
- mopierotti 3y agoCould you elaborate on what you mean by this?
- the-dude 3y agoKennedy, moon, 1962 : https://www.jfklibrary.org/learn/about-jfk/historic-speeches/address-at-rice-university-on-the-nations-space-effort https://www.jfklibrary.org/learn/about-jfk/historic-speeches...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- VHRanger 3y agoFSD is coming out next year, every year since 2016 (tm)
- FranzFerdiNaN 3y agoMakes sense. It will happen or it won't.
- sdfghswe 3y agoThat's not how probabilities work, Walter.
- lewhoo 3y agoThere might be a market for something like a CEOblocker for browsers.
- rossdavidh 3y agoThis just in: Google AI chief says his job is really, really important, and should be compensated accordingly.
- benrutter 3y agoBut also that, like, he might not have anything to show for it for a few years so get off his case already.
- paxys 3y agoCool now define what AGI actually is.
- amelius 3y agoToo difficult. We'll have to ask the AGI for a definition.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoIf it works like a human, works like a human, and quacks like a human, then it probably is a AGI.
- brap 3y agoTuring basically defined it 70+ years ago. Of course our ability to distinguish between AI and humans improves as AI evolves. It becomes more sophisticated, and so do we. 10 years ago GPT4 probably would have passed the Turing test.
- ziyao_w 3y agoBasically Shane Legg (who is probably not the Google AI chief), chief AGI scientist at DeepMind, who said in 2011/2012 (https://www.vetta.org/2011/12/goodbye-2011-hello-2012/ https://www.vetta.org/2011/12/goodbye-2011-hello-2012/) that > I give it a log-normal distribution with a mean of 2028 and a mode of 2025, under the assumption that nothing crazy happens like a nuclear war. I’d also like to add to this prediction that I expect to see an impressive proto-AGI within the next 8 years. By this I mean a system with basic vision, basic sound processing, basic movement control, and basic language abilities, with all of these things being essentially learnt rather than preprogrammed. It will also be able to solve a range of simple problems, including novel ones. is saying the same thing but pushed his timeline back a few years. I assume if you ask Shane 3 years ago before GPT he would look away and murmur something like "kurtosis".
- melagonster 3y agomaybe progressing of technology always happen suddenly, we can't predict what will happen.
- isaacfrond 3y agoI suppose with 'we', he means 'OpenAi'?
- abetusk 3y agoThe human brain is estimated at 2.5 Pb of storage [0]. Currently 1 Tb costs around $12.50 [1]. If this costs reduces by half roughly every two years, 2.5 Pb of storage will be available for roughly $4k. At $4k and below, that means we essentially have an affordable desktop computer that has the storage capacity of the human brain. My guess is that there will be a spate of startups that offer real value using AI when the price is around $10k, but that's just a guess and we're already at around $30k for 2.5Pb of storage right now. [0] https://www.cnsnevada.com/what-is-the-memory-capacity-of-a-human-brain/ https://www.cnsnevada.com/what-is-the-memory-capacity-of-a-h... [1] https://jcmit.net/diskprice.htm https://jcmit.net/diskprice.htm
- lm28469 3y agoUnless you can replicate how the brain works you can have 10000000000Pb of storage it doesn't mean jack shit > A human can run at 40kmh, since decades cars can drive faster than 40kmh, hence cars are smarter than humans
- heavenlyblue 3y agoAdditionally, our planet is smarter than human because the total amount of hard disk storage on it is larger than 2Pb (even those hard drives that are disconnected from power).
- abetusk 3y ago> Birds flap their wings to fly. Planes don't. Therefore planes can never fly. There were some implicit assumptions in my above post: * Human brains are physically realizable (there is no mind-body separation) * Human level intelligence is the result of a massively parallel computer running essentially simple algorithms on large data * Compute will follow the same Moore's law pattern Storage is taken as a representative metric. I argue that while storage is an insufficient condition, it's a necessary one. I agree that computation must follow suite but, to me at least, not only is the compute getting faster and cheaper, the core "fundamental algorithm" for intelligence are essentially already know and the limiting factor is the cost of storage and, to a lesser extent, compute.
- lm28469 3y ago_sent from my fully autonomous self driving Tesla model S in 2014_
- rrsp 3y agoWe’re 5+ years from the transformer and we’re still using the transformer for the most cutting edge llms. I don’t see what difference another 5 year is going to make unless someone invents something new that can surpass the transformer, and given the amount of money and resources that has been put into AI since 2017 and the lack of innovation since (in terms of fundamental architecture, not things like Lora and Rope) then I’d say the chances are way way lower than 50%.
- famouswaffles 3y agoWho says you need anything other than the transformer? We've clearly not squeezed all the capability out of it.
- rrsp 3y agoI don’t think it’s so clear. The transformer has been available for 6 years, if it were possible to train one to achieve AGI then what’s stopped anyone from doing this that won’t still be the case in 5 years time, given than there’s potentially ?trillions on the table for anyone that does.
- famouswaffles 3y agoI don't understand what you're saying. People have been been training up transformers in the goal of "achieving agi". Transformers have been getting better as they've been trained up. Nobody has stopped doing this.
- alienicecream 3y agoBut they haven't achieved AGI, not even close. It can't distinguish between truth and nonsense. An LLM is essentially outputting nonsense all the time, that has been massaged by training to approximate truth through the proxy of likely-next-word.
- rrsp 3y agoWhat I’m saying is if it is possible to train transformers to achieve AGI, then why hasn’t it happened yet? What’s the limitation that will be overcome in the next 5 years?
- RandomLensman 3y agoAre those the same five years that gave us all the self-driving cars?
- darthrupert 3y agoEither we do, or we don't. 50/50.
- thesuperbigfrog 3y agoDoubtful. However, predictions from Gary Bernhardt's 2014 talk "The Birth and Death of JavaScript" are still coming true and can be relied on: https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/the-birth-and-death-of-javascript https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/the-birth-and-death... Take note accordingly.
- coldcode 3y agoFortune tellers and stock gurus make lots of predictions, and randomly one will be right; they then promote how smart they were, and all the others are forgotten. Why would this be any different?
- jampekka 3y agoI'm quite sure that the Winter[1] is coming again, especially if this scifi-level AGI hype continues. We've seen this many times, and I don't think there's any fundamental development that would bring about such a "qualitative" change in "machine intelligence". The improvement in technical capabilities of neural netwoks (and RL somewhat too) has been wild and ANNs have jumped from silly toys to practical applications very quickly. But I think we are still deep in the Moravec's paradox[2]. The thing is that we tend to assess intelligence based on how human individuals are thought to differ in intelligence. Anybody can walk/drive, so walking/driving must be easy. Few master chess/painting/writing, so they must be hard. But e.g. DeepBlue showed clearly that actually chess isn't that hard, people just suck at it. And conversely the failure of self driving cars showed that driving is actually hard, but humans are just very good at it. I think it's the same thing with e.g. LLMs. People think that writing well is hard because humans who do it tend to have fancy degrees and high salaries. But writing/language is more likely closer to chess than it is to walking/driving. We just suck at it. Before we have machines that run in a forest and make a sandwitch in a random kitchen, I'm not too worried about AGI overlords. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_winter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_winter [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moravec%27s_paradox
- Yizahi 3y agoOh, we will definitely have AGI in about 5 years. The problem is that term will be as meaningless as AI term today. After assigning "intelligence" to some pattern matching script essentially, we have devalued it into the ground so the AGI had to be invented to denote "true intelligence, this time honestly". But what will happen when OpenAI marketing team will become bored with incrementing version numbers? Exactly, the rebranding into AGI will inevitably happen. :)
- jampekka 3y agoI'm not so sure this is gonna happen, or at least catch on. No matter how much they try to hype the intelligence, the failures will be so spectacularly stupid that it's impossible maintain the illusion. The current systems do these all the time but they're just ignored due to the marvel. With AVs that was already sort of tried, but when the Superhuman Eternally Vigilant Driver slams full speed into a truck that was plainly visible from a kilometer afar, it's hard to keep many people on the hypetrain.
- ghusto 3y agoDefine "intelligence", and we'll talk.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoOK... How soon until we have a scientific definition of consciousness? AGI is not simulation, it's supposed to be the real deal, machine awareness. I'm starting to feel like Charlie Brown when Lucy keeps yanking the football away. Marketers keep stealing all the terms we use to refer to the real deal for AI. R. Daneel Olivaw, R2D2, the AIs from Troy Rising, the Culture Minds... That's where AGI goes. AGI is not really good ML models that have no insight.