6 ms·
Google lays off employees working on its voice assistant
- yieldcrv 3y agoany insight into why Google would do this instead of sending them back to matchmaking?
- alex_young 3y agoAffected employees have 60 days to find a new role within the company or they will have to leave.
- yieldcrv 3y agothanks, it was paywalled for me beneath the fold
- trilbyglens 3y agoSounds like a way to fire without actually firing.
- Jensson 3y agoNah, you don't have to interview again, all you need is to look at open positions and contact a manager and if they say yes you got it, no hassle and you can start directly. It is good for both, you don't need to interview and the manager can see your performance reviews and code, so much easier to avoid bad engineers. Managers prefers internal candidates for this reason, so shouldn't be hard at all to find a new position unless you performed badly.
- refulgentis 3y agoThere aren't* open positions and there haven't been since August 2022. These used to be soft landings, now they're a brutal quick goodbye. Awful environment internally that I'm very glad to have left (voluntarily) recently. This was one of many silent layoffs. I found it dark and sad that Flexport took a lot of heat for rescinding offers, Blind's stuffed full of people who passed interviews & entered team match 14 months ago * a significant number of open positions, i.e., these events are well understood to be terminal now in practice. Times are strange
- Jensson 3y agoAh, I left years ago so wasn't aware. But not surprising, they constantly whittled down benefits or nice things or transparency when I worked there. Just a matter of time before things got this bad.
- filoleg 3y ago> There aren't* open positions and there haven't been since August 2022. This is plainly incorrect. Source: myself applied to an open position I saw internally on Grow in May 2023 (earlier this year), had a few talks with the team just to figure out whether it was a good match for both sides and to talk about my previous experience. Been happily on that team since June. And I wasn’t laid off either, my previous team/org just ended up becoming a poor self-destroying environment due to some very questionable leadership decisions (which led to a lot of level-headed leadership people that kept it together just quitting in anger, along with many senior+ level ICs), so it was time for me to go (as i felt like i started losing my brain cells trying to follow the leadership that didn’t know what they wanted and were running around like beheaded chickens, all while my actual tech skills were starting to deteriorate). The whole process was just a regular click and apply for an open position, without knowing the manager or anyone else in that org. No whiteboard interviews or anything like that. And I am not some rockstar engineer or whatever, just a decent L4.
- refulgentis 3y agoSure, it's plainly incorrect, if you ignore the asterix. He didn't need a massive in-line disclaimer about there being more-than-zero, because #1 that's obvious #2 his thing was "ah it's fine because they still do it the old way" Old school defrags, like the one I went through in 2017, were a completely different animal. They lined up replacement jobs for you and also let you find another. They do not do that now. Now you are cut off from all corp immediately except Grow and Gmail. To be very clear, you are lucky. The number of Grow postings is a fraction of a fraction of what it was before August '22. A massive number of your colleagues were let go in January and about as much have been let go since in individual firings. It disgusted me that your reaction amounts to "Overblown! I transferred! Btw here's a rant about how much I hated my old team at my current job that flattens everyone to characters!" I highly suggest talking to your peers more and also not flattening others to caricatures. There's a reason Memegen is worked up and despondent and it's not because everyone else is overemotional and won't take advantage of the plethora of opportunities to change it up. If Memegen is a bridge too far because you can't forcefully interrogate people whose feelings you don't understand without your employer seeing, try Blind. What I said is absolutely completely 100% uncontroverstial.
- Rebelgecko 3y ago>all you need is to look at open positions and contact a manager That only works if you still have full corp access
- Jensson 3y agoWhy wouldn't they have that? They are still employees during those months and gets paid.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoAlthough I work for Google I don't have any hidden insights. I can think of some potential reasons but it's probably best for me to refrain from speculating about why layoffs have been handled they way they've been :)
- gtirloni 3y agoSpeculation is our business here :)
- 1letterunixname 3y agoSeems like a company-paid vacation and new digs, IYAM. The stupidity of big corporate over-expansion of productive capacity is two fold: 1. in the execution of hiring too many people, and 2. not saving the jobs of good people in the haste to meet a particular cost target. OXPC-layoffs demonstrates a lack of leadership attention to business fundamentals and a blithe unconcern for the stability and security employees depend on for their lives.
- HerrMonnezza 3y agoIt really depends on what your current and wanted roles are... When it happened to me, I would have had to interview again because there were no other roles in my career ladder left in town.
- charcircuit 3y agoReducing investment in 1 area doesn't mean that a company doesn't want to invest in other areas.
- s09dfhks 3y agoMy guess is they are fully committed to sending everything through bard
- CSMastermind 3y agoIt's pretty stunning that no one has hooked their voice assistant up to an LLM yet. Alexa, Siri, Google, etc. are all trash that could easily be improved 1000x by leveraging existing LLM technologies.
- charcircuit 3y agoMeta's 2nd version of their smart glasses replaced the traditional voice assistant of the first one with a LLM based one.
- Jensson 3y agoGoogle apparently already started, it was linked in the article: https://www.businessinsider.com/google-assistant-with-bard-new-app-chatbot-ai-voice-text-2023-10?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/google-assistant-with-bard-n...
- brabel 3y agoThat will be great, everyone expects much more from "AI" (and at least I consider voice assistants to be an early AI prototype) and it would be great to have voice assistants understand what we ask better (like ChatGPT would, and perhaps Bard).
- yieldcrv 3y agoyou don’t like getting the weather and unsolicited google results?
- selcuka 3y agoI believe it's because it's at least a magnitude more expensive to run an LLM instead of a basic voice assistant ML model. Especially when considering anyone who has purchased a Google Nest Mini can use it, for free, forever.
- laristine 3y agohttps://archive.ph/eqog2 https://archive.ph/eqog2
- jensenbox 3y agoFrom the other news sources I looked at, this happened on August 1, 2023 - or is this a new one?
- mvdtnz 3y agoVoice assistant hasn't improved in literally years. Dead product walking.
- toyg 3y agoOh no, it "improved" several times - often getting worse. Which is why I was almost happy, reading the headline - sorry for the involved devs (who were likely crying in their 6-figure salary anyway) , but the best thing that could happen to Google Home/Assistant is to just stop messing with it.
- esafak 3y agoNo, just revert commit to where it was after it came out. Don't freeze it in its broken state.
- Jensson 3y agoI've noticed many things breaking like that. Features that aren't a major factor in a company's revenue seems to just get worse and worse the more people work on them. For example has happened to every voice chat program I've tested, skype, steam, battle net etc.
- pnut 3y agoDevs are a general purpose resource that translate business requirements into software, you are describing a product management failure. Unless Google forces devs to also be product managers? I can't believe that's true.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoIf your job relies on creating value for a customer (hint most do), then it’s also your job to make sure you’re creating that value for customers. Throw it over the fence almost always leads to outcomes like this.
- ryandvm 3y agoYeah, this is one of those products that Google has that somehow miraculously keeps getting worse. It's failings are particularly noticeable now that I can spend all day having rich conversations with ChatGPT, but Google assistant is telling me "I don't have any information on that" when I ask it the simplest of questions.
- ars 3y agoThe article says "20 employees", but how much is that as a percentage of total employees in that division? I mean 20 employees out of 50 is huge, 20 out of 1,000 is not.
- greatgib 3y agoIt would be so great on Android if we could totally disable button and setup nagging screen for the voice assistant. The last thing that appears recently is the setup of the voice assistant forcefully showing up each time you connect and reconnect to a Bluetooth audio device. I'm so pissed off about that.
- buro9 3y agoMove the launcher to Nova, install Firefox, then stop and disable the Google app. That's it. That's how to get an Android without Google forcing anything on you.
- deaddodo 3y agoI'm using Nova and Brave, the behavior described by OP still happens everytime I connect my Sony BT headphones.
- buro9 3y agodid you force stop and then disable the Google app? this is the step that takes care of it changing the launcher and browser have to be done first as the Pixel Launcher and Chrome really do expect the Google app to be running.
- fredley 3y agoThat's how I was rolling until I got a new (to me!) car to replace a very old banger. It has phone connectivity and it's great, but it basically requires voice control, which works quite well. This meant I had to re enable the Google app. I want the feature, I just want to be in control of when and how that feature is used, not have it pushed hard in my face repeatedly.
- gardenhedge 3y agoIt's always been a terrible product so this isn't too surprising to read
- 1letterunixname 3y agoGoogle had a whole storefront branded for recruitment at AfroTech on Wednesday. Despite layoffs, either HR still has budget to spend and/or they're still hiring.
- ppg677 3y agoSounds like DEI hiring initiatives.
- underseacables 3y agoDoes any voice assistant work? I feel like the only time I use Siri is to respond to text messages in the car.
- filoleg 3y ago> Does any voice assistant work? As a real human personal assistant would? Nope. As a nice utility for tons of different specific use cases? They absolutely do. Personally the things I use mine for: setting a timer while cooking or doing other things that keep hands preoccupied, setting an alarm while in the bed, checking the weather while I am in the closet trying to figure out what to wear, turning lights on/off without getting up, controlling the music while in the shower, checking time without opening my eyes (in case of me suddenly waking up during the night and trying to figure out whether i should try going back to sleep or abandon the idea due to having to wake up in an hour anyway), checking if i have any calendar reminders, checking when the next train arrives at the closest subway station, and controlling smart lights at home. All are fairly niche and definitely could be described as “i can live without it.” But it is really nice and helpful if you personally have any specific use cases that the assistants are good with.
- zeruch 3y agoIf its like Androids speech to text capabilities, it was likely just getting progressively worse anyway.