6 ms·
Facing 110 years in prison, Sam Bankman-Fried "can't recall" what he did at FTX
- tibbydudeza 3y agoIt wasn't me defense.
- nathias 3y agoeffective altruism praxis
- WendyTheWillow 3y agoHe’s not facing 110 years in prison…. At this point, adding up the time for each charge is journalistic malpractice.
- VHRanger 3y agoHe's facing that maximum but odds are hell actually spend 7-20 years physically in prison before being paroled out.
- WendyTheWillow 3y agoNo? That’s not how federal sentencing guidelines work, at all. > Adding up all the statutory maximum sentences for all the counts charged in an indictment is an exercise in clickbait disinformation. [0] [0] https://popehat.substack.com/p/beware-the-flood-of-trump-sentencing https://popehat.substack.com/p/beware-the-flood-of-trump-sen...
- carabiner 3y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Adding up all the statutory maximum sentences for all the counts charged in an indictment is an exercise in clickbait disinformation Its not, even in the context where that is true [0] when the guidelines range calculated based on the facts charged plauisbly meet or exceed the sum of the statutory maximums for the individual offenses. And $ amounts involved are a factor in the sentencing guidelines, and while there have been some changes to what is charged, I remember guidelinea calculations based on the original indictment were off the chart and I don't think the changes have done anythinf which would make that less true. [0] the calculation is always an important fact, because it bounds the legal range of sentences, and even where thr guidelines make a sentence unlikely, the guidelines are not mandatory, and departures both above and below thr guidelines are within the power of federal judges, only the statutory minimums and maximums are hard limits, but it can sometimes be misleading to present the maximum sentence as likely on conviction.
- WendyTheWillow 3y agoAt no point during the process of sentencing calculation does the idea of "let's add up all of the charges and their combined sentences" get applied. That's not how federal sentencing guidelines work, is the point. It can still be a Very Long Time (Ken White calls this the "life plus cancer" treatment), but that number isn't arrived at as described by the submitted article. From the article I linked (emphasis mine): > First, the core of the Post’s article is a splashy infographic meant to act as Resistance porn. It adds up, on a Candyland-style path, the maximum sentence on each count in the New York state indictment against Trump, the Florida federal indictment for wrongfully retaining documents, and the new Washington D.C. indictment for his January 6 fraud. The infographic is plainly the beating clickbait heart of the piece. It’s also completely useless. The combined maximum sentences from the three cases is a meaningless, masturbatory number. It has nothing to do with what federal sentences he faces, as I note above, and New York criminal law experts (and I am not one) say that the maximum sentences in that case have nothing to do with the plausible sentence he faces there.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> At no point during the process of sentencing calculation does the idea of "let's add up all of the charges and their combined sentences" get applied. That's both, in the general case, technically true (the processes isn't adding up all the statutory maxima at one point) and substantively false (as for each charge, the sentence is clamped to the statutory range, and thus the sum of the statutory ranges is the actual legal maximum that can be applied, even though at no point in the sentencing calculation are the statutory maxima summed to get to the actual sentence; the actual sentences that are scheduled to run consecutively, which are already clamped to the statutory range, are summed.) Moreover, its particularly wrong, IIRC, and if the various changes to the charges haven't changed this, in SBF's case, because working through the facts in the indictment at least originally against the guidelines calculations for each charge very plausibly reached a guidelines range at or beyond the statutory maximum. > That's not how federal sentencing guidelines work, Federal sentencing guidelines are not mandatory, and federal courts can make departures within the range between the statutory minimum and statutory maximum above or below the guideline sentence. They are, to borrow from Pirates of the Carribean, more what you'd call guidelines than actual rules. Moreover, clamping sentence for each charge to the statutory range is exactly how the guidelines work. Yes, it would be very useful (though highly subjective; even when departures aren't ultimately involved, whether conditions in the guidelines are applicable based on the jury verdict and the evidence at trial is the domain of often extensive post-verdict litigation that can amount to a mini-bench-trial on the guidelines; jounralists predicting the outcome of such would be getting in to highly speculative and error-prone rather than fact-based reporting) for coverage of federal criminal trials to present useful context around how the guidelines might apply based on the facts alleged in the indictment. Popehat's repeated banging on the point that the reporting by the media of statutory ranges is generally useless for any real purpose is accurate and something that adds to the knowledge of someone who encounters it who has no pre-existing knowledge of how federal sentencing works. And for people who get the oversimplified idea from it that "adding up the sum of the statutory maxima never tells you what the realistic outer limit is for sentence in federal criminal cases, it is always significantly lower" will probably, for most cases they see reported in the media, mostly not have the wrong idea, even if they are working from a rule that is almost as oversimplified as "the sum of the federal statutory maxima is a realistic, if guaranteed to not be low, sentence estimate in federal criminal cases in general". But several facts remain true: 1. The sum of the statutory maxima is the actual legal maximum total sentence, and 2. There are cases where that will ultimately set the maximum sentence under the guidelines, because the pre-clamping guidelines range for each conviction will exceed the statutory maximum, 3. There are cases where the actual sentence will exceed the guidelines sentence, and the maximum there will still be that set by the statutory limits on each offense. To actually assess the likely range of federal sentences for a given indictment, you would need to review the indictment, the guidelines, and try to assess each of the potential guidelines factors against the allegations in the indictment (both the full set of facts alleged and the set of alleged facts that would allow conviction on each charge but produce the minimum guidelines range), and then compute what the actual sentence would be for the various possibilities under the guidelines, and then be familiar with the history of similar federal cases (especially in the same trial court and judge) and whether and in what circumstances departures from the guidelines ranges have been given, and assess that. All of which often gets into highly subjective, highly contentious, opinion, even when experts are involved. OTOH, you can not purport to report a likely sentence, and then report a maximum sentence, and you will be reporting a verifiable, clear legal fact, even if arguably one of often limited usefulness in predicting what people might like to predict.
- dragonwriter 3y agoParole was abolished for all federal prisoners convicted after Nov 1, 1987, so, no, barring an actual change of law, he won't be paroled.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoTIL. Wikipedia has an article on federal parole[0], and the first citation in the References section is to a PDF (now available only from Archive.org) that clearly explains why federal parole was abolished in the 1980s. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_parole_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_parole_in_the_United_S...
- throwaway290 3y agoInteresting. At first I thought banning parole makes sense (instead of max sentence + parole give a reasonable term) but apparently the reason is people stopped believing criminals can be rehabilitated via prison: > Americans became more concerned with ensuring that people were punished – often severely – and began to doubt that prison could rehabilitate a person. The SRA rejected rehabilitation as the primary goal of our sentencing system. Instead, it stated that the purpose of imprisonment is punishment.
- userinanother 3y agoPresidential pardon is not out of the question for someone of his profile
- JohnFen 3y agoI suspect that it is out of the question, because the president would suffer from a lot of political blowback if a pardon was issued. Any president would have to gain something greater than the cost of that blowback. What would be the upside?
- userinanother 3y agoHunter could get a juicy new gig at a crypto firm. Or be the head of a new ICO for a hookers and blow coin. Maybe a NFT of his “ART”. Oh the possibilities
- perihelions 3y agoIt's a realistic range for someone who's maxed out the federal sentencing guidelines—whose alleged crimes are off the scale. - "adding up the time for each charge is journalistic malpractice" I agree with you 100%, 99% of the time. Adding together the statutory limits, and publishing that without context, is journalistic malpractice (but great clickbait!). But it's not entirely wrong in this, exceptional outlier, case.
- WendyTheWillow 3y agoNo. Just, no. That is never, ever, how it works.
- aaronmdjones 3y agoTell that to Madoff, who pleaded guilty and still received the maximum possible consecutive sentence of 150 years.
- WendyTheWillow 3y agoOkay, but he already knows that's not how it works, as he was not sentenced by adding up the maximum possible sentences for each of his crimes. "A long time" does not equate to "simplistic addition-based sentencing calculation".
- aaronmdjones 3y ago> Okay, but he already knows that's not how it works, as he was not sentenced by adding up the maximum possible sentences for each of his crimes. Yes, he was. https://www.justice.gov/media/785641/dl?inline https://www.justice.gov/media/785641/dl?inline I look then to Section 5G1.2{d) of the guidelines, which tells us that where there are multiple counts, and the guideline range exceeds the statutory maximum for the most serious count, the court must impose consecutive terms of imprisonment to the extent necessary to achieve the total punishment. There is a little bit of ambiguity, however, as to what is meant by "total punishment" where the guideline calculation calls for ~ife imprisonment, but Second Circuit case law makes clear that in such a situation, the district court is to stack or add up the maximum sentences for all the counts. In United States v. Evans, for example, 352 F.3d 65, where the guideline calculation called for life imprisonment but no count carried a life sentence, the court held that the guideline range is 240 years, the maximum sentences for all the counts added together. Accordingly, here the guideline range is not life imprisonment, but 150 years, the maximum sentences for each of the 11 counts added together.
- hoten 3y agoTo be clear, you are referring to the complicated / rigid way that federal sentencing guidelines operates (via its point system and previous criminal history status, and especially the consolidation of like-infractions), right? LegalEagle taught me what I know about this topic: https://youtu.be/kr8gSdJ_Ggw?si=GVELc4ETIbg3FcB3 https://youtu.be/kr8gSdJ_Ggw?si=GVELc4ETIbg3FcB3
- perihelions 3y agoThe "110 year" figure from the article is the statutory limit for the charged crimes. It's not a federal sentencing guidelines calculation.
- paulpauper 3y agoIt's not without precedent at all. There have been cases of defendants getting maximum or close to maximum of similar duration
- adolph 3y ago> adding up the time for each charge is journalistic malpractice Well at least they weren’t intimating that the Bureau of Prisons had a state of the art life extension program.
- dmoy 3y agoWe see here a big example of why it's very strongly advised to not testify in your own criminal trial. (Especially not a federal one)
- eftychis 3y agoWhat was the strategy for him testifying?
- mminer237 3y agoObviously nobody knows for sure but him and his lawyer, but almost definitely he just didn't listen to his lawyer because he thought he could convince the jury.
- dwater 3y agoIn short: His goose was already cooked, he did so much brazenly stupid stuff in full view of the public and ran his mouth off after doing it that the case looked like a slam dunk. If he went on the stand he at least had a chance of convincing the jury that he was unaware that everyone around him was committing fraud. He didn't have much to lose.
- dmoy 3y agoDepends on if it was his lawyer's strategy or if it was his own idea (and I'm guessing it was the latter, just based on the prior behavior of "can't shut the fuck up and stop digging own grave") If it was his idea, it often goes like: (a) I am very smart, (b) I've always gotten my way by being very smart, (c) I (think I) am smarter than everyone who will be in the courtroom, and therefore (d) I'll get my way out of this by being smart. Lot of smart people in fields other than law think that it'll translate to law. It doesn't, typically. You see a less extreme form of this on HN frequently where people try to treat law as some boolean code thing, with statements like "well technically it says XYZ and because of ABC constraint...", when the reality is that any judge will take a look at the situation and wave the heavy wand of "spirit of the law" or whatever. If it was his lawyer's idea, then I guess probably he decided case was already 99.9% lost, might as well hailmary it and see what happens.
- qualifiedai 3y agoHe "donated" (in other countries it is called bribed) enough money to enough politicians to not get in any serious trouble, maybe a slap on the wrist is what he'll get
- AlexandrB 3y agoUnless he also donated to this specific judge, I don't think that will help him.
- newsclues 3y agoWhat was the party split on the political funding ?
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoNot sure how that matters. Neither party is going to affect what sentence he ends up with.
- shadowgovt 3y agoPresidents can pardon federal crimes.
- JohnFen 3y agoThey can, but that doesn't affect what the sentence was. It's just saying what the court found doesn't matter.
- newsclues 3y agoI think it matters if he funded an election
- wmf 3y agoAround 50-50. I agree with the sibling comment that SBF's political donations won't save him though.
- 3y ago
- btilly 3y agoAlready discussed yesterday at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38087761 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38087761.
- Dudester230602 3y agoWe cannot travel to the past my friend, and HN design encourages re-creation of topics since old things go off main page.
- lolc 3y agoLooks like he's finally listening to his lawyers! Before his bail was reluctantly revoked, he was generating an astonishing stream of evidence for the prosecution.
- vkou 3y agoHe still isn't. It looks utterly horrible when he provides an incredibly detailed account that paints him in a positive light, but then can't give a straight answer when the prosecutor asks him what he had for breakfast, or why his testimony directly contradicts Exhibits A, B, C, and D - documents/e-mails that he signed/sent. His defense plan seems to be 'throw a mountain of shit at the jury, maybe some of it will confuse them enough.'
- amenhotep 3y agoMaybe my Matt Levine reading is showing, but doesn't that seem like obviously his best plan? They did a bunch of crime, wrote a bunch of documents about all the crime they were doing, and all the people he told to do crime are testifying about how he told them to do crime - it is difficult to come up with a sensible way to defend against that case. But it's easy to hope that you can bamboozle one juror with the same bamboozling techniques that worked on all the VCs. It's transparently not a good plan, but it doesn't have to be, it just has to be better than the other options.
- JohnFen 3y agoI dunno. If he's sure that he'll be convicted, then it seems that a better plan would be to cooperate fully, show actual remorse, and plead guilty in the hopes of getting the lightest possible sentence.
- amenhotep 3y agoThat's really the only other option, yeah, but it's hard to judge whether it's better. There's not really any incentive for leniency, he's the big fish and they want to make an example of him, otherwise what's the point of giving all the subordinates deals? Maybe some contrition would get a perfunctory sentence reduction but I would absolutely trust a legal analysis saying he's already so screwed that trying for a hung jury is worth it.
- AlexandrB 3y agoPuts a new spin on the WHAT HAPPENED tweets[1]. [1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ftx-bankruptcy-tweet-sam-bankman-fried/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ftx-bankruptcy-tweet-sam-bankma...
- bennylava 3y ago[dead]
- modzu 3y agoi mean, to be fair, shouldn't justice be swift? in the time its taken me to get my case heard, ive had kids, moved twice, changed jobs.. i legit am just going off my notes at this stage and the rest is made up..
- stronglikedan 3y agoThat's likely because one of the first things you did was waive your right to a speedy trial on the advice of your attorney. That's one of the first things any wise attorney will advise their client to do.
- olalonde 3y agoInner City Press[0] has some pretty detailed coverage and transcripts of the trial in case anyone's interested. [0] https://twitter.com/innercitypress https://twitter.com/innercitypress