4 ms·
Photo check deposits
- mason55 15y agoOn the other hand... I use an online-only bank (Ally) that hasn't enabled phone deposits yet. I've found the Chase app to be pretty lenient about what it accepts (except for the $2k/day limit). I tried to switch to USAA but found out only vets can use the phone deposit. The Chase phone deposit app is so convenient for me, even given that I live in NYC where I pass 5 Chase ATMs per day, that I keep an account open with a minimum in it to avoid fees, just so I can use the phone deposit app. Yes, the ATM deposit might be more convenient, when there are no lines, and the ATM isn't broken, and when I actually have a Chase ATM card, which I don't because I don't use them as my regular bank. If you're trying to min/max your banking experience then the Chase app is pretty nice to use as a funnel for money to other accounts.
- ap3 15y agoAgreed. I keep a Chase account just for the convenience of phone deposits. I have an ATM right across the street and have never used it. Phone deposit has only failed me a couple of times but these seemed like back end type issues, tried again the next day and it worked fine. What other banks allow for phone deposits ?
- ecspike 15y agoI guess it's vets and families because I've had electronic deposit ever since they rolled it out something like 3 years ago. USAA deposit by phone is my only option unless I want to post the check to TX and wait 5 days (USAA has been my only bank since 2006 or so)
- mason55 15y agoWeird. I called to cancel and specifically told them that was the only reason. I would have thought if there was a way they could enable it for me they would have to keep a customer. Of course, I tried to deposit a check via the Chase app while I was typing this and it failed for the first time ever for me.
- epikur 15y agoI like USAA's iPhone (or scanner) check deposit. You have to have a credit card or a loan with them, but when you submit a check, you instantly get the money. However, you also have to write a little note with your account number on the back of each check, which could be a pain if you had a stack of checks.
- lancefisher 15y agoUSAA is great. I used to deposit with a crappy android phone, and it would fail half the time, but since I got the iPhone 4S it has not failed once. I'm sure it's related to image quality. USAA has a $5K limit per day, and you can log in with just a PIN. Their service in general is awesome, and the phone deposit is very convenient.
- ecspike 15y agoFor some, it's a $10K limit.
- gergles 15y agoYou can't get a credit card, loan, or insurance product (and by extension, remote deposit access) without a "military connection". I really wish the breathless USAA cheerleaders that come out of the woodwork all over the Internet every time there is a banking thread would remember to mention this.
- rnemo 15y agoI'm having trouble getting a reference to USAAs current eligibility information, because their website is a mess of badly named links and what Google finds redirects me to their homepage, but as I understand it pretty much everything under their banking umbrella is now available to everyone, including the credit card and loan stuff, and with it, remote deposit access. That said these breathless USAA cheerleaders should try having actual contentions with them sometime, it's a pretty poor experience reminiscent of news stories you hear about BoA and similar
- X-Istence 15y agoI've used the Chase app for depositing a multitude of checks and after the first two or three times I got down exactly how it wanted me to take the picture and it was extremely easy and convenient. I haven't had a check that wasn't accepted. After that I've kept the checks in an envelope after writing (cashed) on the back so that I know they were deposited. The convenience and ease of use is fantastic. I really wish my other bank (ING Direct) would support something similar.
- wdewind 15y agoAlternative experience: I've deposited about 60 checks lifetime through the app over the last year or so, and literally had it fail twice the first few times I used it, then they updated it and it has only failed once since. So I mean, ~57/60 successes on first try, and 100% overall success ain't bad. I LOVE this app (and generally hate Chase otherwise...)
- ecspike 15y agoAgree USAA is awesome. FWIW, you should always endorse your checks.
- BryanB55 15y agoI completely disagree. I absolutely love digital deposits. Unfortunately I have Bank of America who is incredibly slow at implementing this but I use the same feature on the PayPal app as a way to get around not having it with BOA. I've seriously considered switching to Chase just for this feature. I hate going to the bank. PayPal limits you to $1,000 a month which is pretty annoying but is still way better than nothing. It's nice to have when you get checks for a few hundred dollars and it's not worth going to the bank for. I've never had one check rejected. I just really wish BOA would implement this already.
- guynamedloren 15y ago> Sometimes, new technology is not progress You like ATM deposits? That's great. Other people prefer digital deposits. The cool thing about technology is that we have a choice.
- pyre 15y ago> You like ATM deposits? That's great. Other people > prefer digital deposits. I think that you're missing the point of the article. The point of the article is that it's supposed to be 'the future,' but the experience is horrible compared to the ATM. Just because it's 'on the iPhone' isn't enough to make it a better experience.
- guynamedloren 15y agoThis is true, thanks for pointing this out.
- joezydeco 15y agoNo, his experience was horrible. I've used the exact sane app for small miscellaneous deposits and haven't had 1/10 the problems Marco had. The Chase app isn't perfect, but it works in a pinch. If only we had his problem of not being able to deposit more than 5k/day...
- subhobroto 15y agoThis experience sounds specific to the "PC Deposit" implementation by Chase and if it's how they have educated their customer like the author, I am worried: 1. A check never "clears" the same day. The check may post the same day but they take at-least 3 business days to clear. This is because all checks I am aware of use the ACH in the U.S. 2. You are never supposed to "destroy the paper check". Most institutions recommend you hold onto it for at-least 90 days. 3. It's really a challenge to OCR a check photographed by a iPhone unless the lighting conditions are absolutely perfect. Hence, it's better to ask the customer to use a scanner if that's available, but if not, only then suggest using a phone camera. I almost exclusively use Alliant and DCU for my check depositing needs and am yet to have any issues. They do require me to use a scanner for best results, but scanning a check takes me less than a minute and I am able to import it into GNUCash as well. Neither do I have to obsessively check if my deposits cleared, I get emails automatically about the status. I will never go back to an ATM, unless "I need money now" and there are no places around that will take plastic. Photo deposits is part of the future I want to be part of: I want to be part of a future where regular banking is done online allowing me to focus my time on things I like better.
- hippich 15y agoi have similar feature with smaller credit union. similar steps involved, but their tool is just more thought through and somehow their app able to recognize bad shot and ask to redo one. so far it was easiest way to deposit for me. tl;dr; this is bad implementation, not idea/technology.
- switz 15y agoI think this is kind of a ridiculous claim. I have deposited checks twice with PNC Bank's app and both times it took only a minute or two to complete and I didn't even have to leave the house. Neither were rejected. Just because Marco's bank's iPhone app sucks doesn't mean that the technology isn't there. Marco better than anyone should know that it is. > Sometimes, new technology is not progress. How about – Sometimes, technology sucks.
- mrmekon 15y agoSeems like we all agree that USAA is awesome. In regards to him having trouble scanning checks with Chase: that sounds like a problem with Chase's implementation, not the technology as a whole. I have been using USAA's online service as my only form of check deposit for 5 years (started with flatbed scanner, now iphone). I have never had a check refused. Hundreds of them have gone through (have to re-take the photos sometimes, but they always eventually work). It works, and it works really well.
- yason 15y agoSometimes, new technology is not progress. Well, the last contact with checks was, IIRC, in the 80's when I saw my mother occasionally using them and they were being phased out at the time already. This was in Europe. So, I don't think any technology to have to do with checks can ever be considered progress.
- pinaceae 15y agoTHIS. As someone from Europe that clunky check-based system of the US is simply dumbfounding. What exactly is the purpose of it? Is there no e-banking available? Over here people rarely even use banks, as in physical entities, anymore.
- saurik 15y agoI had some friends in college that had a roommate on an exchange program from Norway, and when they explained to him that we used the moral equivalent of IOUs scribbled on sheets of paper to do a majority of our finance, he thought they must have been making fun of him (as in, telling him things about the US that are false so that he'll make a fool out of himself; to be clear: they did not do that to him).
- stephengillie 15y agoWe draw our names in functionally illegible ways on legal documents as authentication, even though we've known it's a broken system for hundreds of years. Part of the problem is that checks became "free" some years ago but all other alternatives charge fees. Rent is one of the biggest demands for checks, as most landlords don't want to pay Visa or Mastercard (or Paypal or Square or Mint) a percentage of thousands of dollars a month.
- saurik 15y agoI feel like this comment was missing the punchline; are you saying that in other countries (where, at least in Norway, apparently even rent is not paid with IOUs scribbled on sheets of paper) checks cost as much as bank transfers, or that bank transfers are free? (Also, FWIW, in many countries in Europe two-factor authentication is incredibly common, if not expected or even legally required; it is my understanding from some business deals I was a part of that Germany, in particular, is quite the stickler on this front.)
- slardat01 15y agoE*Trade supports this now too. So far I've done a couple of checks and it worked fine.
- kogir 15y agoWhen you have the check, it's true, sometimes photo deposits are less convenient. But if all you have is an image of the check, it's awesome. Say I wanted to send money to my sister. Before this I had to actually mail a check, or worse, pay for a wire transfer. Now I can just send an image of a check via email, and she'll have access to the money before a mailed check would have arrived. No third party brokers the transaction, and nobody extorts any fees (be they for postage, sending the wire, or receiving the wire). The trick is to use this to enable things that just aren't possible at the bank branch or ATM.
- amccloud 15y agoPayPal will have this same photo check deposits soon. Also fun fact, your PayPal account is actually a Chase bank account. Read the back of your PayPal card. I frequently go to Chase to withdraw money from PayPal with no fee and no wait time.