7 ms·
How America moves homeless people around the country
- tantalor 3y agoStop doing scrollytelling. It's horrible.
- chankstein38 3y agoEspecially because half of the visualizations had a large portion of the middle blocked off by the text with the white background. I could scroll it to be at the top and block less but it's still just an annoyingly flawed way to relay information.
- y-curious 3y agoHaha, nice term. I disagree, I think it's nice in small doses. Moving graphics can be nice for pieces like this
- atum47 3y agoSo it's a universal thing. I lived in a historical city near Rio de Janeiro, called Petrópolis. It has always impressed me how they do not had any homeless people or stray dogs around the city. Later on I discovered that the city would rent a bus and send them all to Rio de Janeiro, making it their problem.
- em-bee 3y agonot a universal thing. in the EU such an action would be considered against the right to freedom of movement. there are places that offer help to those homeless that want to go back home. but they are not forced out of the city that they are staying in.
- drivingmenuts 3y agoYes, but the EU does crazy things like offer, their citizens, free, healthcare, or low-cost healthcare. cries in American
- em-bee 3y agohealthcare is neither free nor low-cost. but insurance is pretty much mandatory. if you don't have insurance however an emergency room visit for a minor injury can set you back $300 at least in one case that i saw. (because the injury was minor they left and found a cheaper hospital that only charged about $100)
- burnerburnito 3y agoI just want to share that a similar ER visit in the US for a minor injury basically isn't possible / reasonable. If your injury is minor and you're uninsured, you're going to be dumping potentially thousands of dollars just to receive some gauze and time, or an IV and being ignored for a couple hours. It's seriously unimaginable for most Americans to even consider an ER visit for something that's not life threatening or extremely severe. $300 is unimaginably cheap for any level of care. $100 is less than the cost of a 20 minute scheduled visit to an in-network doctor (before/without insurance, which tends to bring it down to about 10-30 dollars). It's so absurdly cheap that, while I get the spirit of suggesting it's not free, that's absolute, absurdly low-cost compared to America.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI know several people in the US who get free healthcare via the ER. I'm sure they get bills, but they just don't pay them. It's like the dumbest and most expensive free healthcare system in the world.
- simonsarris 3y agoThe American government spends more on public healthcare per capita than any other nation. https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm
- thefourthchime 3y agoRegardless of your take on this, the animated graphics here are really nice.
- tekla 3y agoNo its not. Its horribly broken. I was wondering why scrolling was so goddamn weird, and realized the animations were broken and was fucking with me.
- dublinben 3y agoCities will do anything to 'solve' the problem of homelessness except building enough housing for everyone.
- gustavus 3y agoThe only housing that works for a dude that's cracked out on meth and smearing human excrement on the walls is a cement room. Until we can figure out what to do with people who refuse to live in the rest of society we'll be limited on any possible solution to assist people in need.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- badwolf 3y agoOverdoses and tweakers exist just about everywhere, you just don't see them because... they are housed.
- livefox 3y agoHaving been homeless before - fuck that mentality. The majority of homelessness is brought about as a result of circumstances, not drugs. Domestic Violence, lack of affordable housing, lack of social safety nets, LGBTQ individuals ousted from their families, mental illness with lack of support. I was homeless for 3 years, because I was LGBT and my parents cut me off from support. Rent in Seattle doubled when Amazon moved in, and the roommates I was living with were unreliable. I ended up homeless and moved to a small town that had even less amenities and had the mentality that if I was homeless I must have been on drugs. I was treated with disdain by most of the people I was trying to get help from, finding a job was much harder without a permanent address. Housing assistance programs had 3 year waitlists. I was told if I wanted more assistance I should have a baby because it would push me to the front of the list. The "cracked out methhead smearing human excrement on the walls" is someone that needs psychiatric help, not jail. And they are a relatively small portion of the homeless population.
- jjk166 3y agoSuch cases are a very tiny minority of homeless people. The vast majority go unnoticed because they don't "look" homeless. 74% of homeless people aren't drug addicts. 43% of homeless people are employed. Most sleep temporarily at friends homes, or in their cars, or in shelters. Homeless youth especially tend to blend in. Most people experiencing homelessness and housing insecurity do so because of economic reasons like high housing prices, poor employment opportunities, and low wages, often coupled with medical disability. The next leading cause is people escaping abuse. And homelessness is merely the most extreme case of housing insecurity, which affects around 12% of Americans. The idea that we can't do anything for 4 people because 1 of them has a drug problems is absurd.
- y-curious 3y agoI get a sense of extreme survivorship bias (in reverse) here. The failed cases of busing get much more airtime than the successes. As someone who is admittedly very sick of the homeless problem in the Bay Area, it sounds good to me. If the solution is more housing, which won't happen here due to the legislative detritus, moving people to places with more housing makes sense.
- surge 3y agoHousing doesn't fix the problem of homelessness. You can give someone a free house and if they're not capable of the basics of self care, due to mental health, drug usage, etc. Then the houses get destroyed/misused, becomes a problem for neighbors, etc. There's been a plethora of housing projects, charities, programs, etc. I supported my local one then realized it was making the problem worse. These programs don't talk about the failures, just the few success stories, because they need funding, and they think its worth it if you can save a few, but its not like there aren't other effects of giving someone a house whose not going to use it to make their lives objectively better. People have this naive notion that the solution is there and just no one has tried it. For every success story there's 9 other failures or worse unintended consequences and the waste of resources that come with it. The only thing that seems to "work" is temporary housing for those in a drug treatment program, but even that has its high degree of failures or relapses, but at least then its not giving housing to those who aren't frankly interested in getting out of their current situation. Think about it, they've chosen the addiction, even if the consequences were job loss, addiction, etc. In other cases, its a mental illness, often exacerbated by addiction. There are people who are "homeless" because of reasons outside their control and these programs work for them, but the majority of the homeless problem is not the people who are victim of circumstances and abuse. I support these programs because they save the 1 in 10 or whatever, until it becomes a draw for those that aren't looking for help to get out of the situation they're in and they conglomerate or stick around when bussed in. The bussing is annoying cause my city often ends up with them, and it overwhelms the resources we have to deal with it for a city our size, but we do the same in turn.
- matkoniecz 3y ago
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoAfter the pandemic I noticed a lot more homeless people traveling through our area. The actual town I live in is about 5 miles from the I-29 interstate but I saw a lot more people trying to panhandle/thumb rides. I've seen people trying to go north for oil field work...walking from North Carolina. I-29 goes basically to the Canada border. An hour south is Saint Joseph, and there were always people panhandling around Walmart. Last time I went, I saw they had put up "Don't support panhandling" signs all around that area. "Go die somewhere else" seems to be the solution most places take to homelessness.
- sergers 3y agoYea generally... Unfortunately? (Who am I to say, I am not doing anything to help). This has always been the case, I remember many years ago(30+) east coast/central cities shipping the homeless on 1 way greyhound to the west coast.... Maybe that explains Washington state(Portland/seattle), San Francisco, Vancouver BC etc
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoI was just talking with a coworker about this issue, where even if someone wants to break the cycle of homelessness the deck is completely stacked against them. People tell them to "get a job" when nobody is going to hire an unwashed homeless person for anything. They need to come back clean, have money to commute, and be reliable -- all of which are very difficult for a homeless person to struggle against. The obvious issue is that people tend to be homeless for a reason, and people always assume it's because they are drug addicted, so finding someone willing to hire the homeless in the first place (smelly or not) is a miracle. There is no easy solution but the "solution" most places take is throwing the baby out with the bathwater and burying it so no one has to see anything that hints at society being imperfect. It's easier to blame the homeless for failing society than it is to acknowledge that society has failed many homeless people who were willing to contribute to society, but were unwanted and ignored rather than helped.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- psychlops 3y agoThis is not America moving homeless, it's California.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoOne of the case studies inside the linked article concerns southern Florida.
- psychlops 3y agoI'm sure there are case studies all over, but the overwhelming problem is California. Any solution (and articles) regarding US homeless problems should begin and end there.
- gmarx 3y agoThey certainly try to give that impression in the article but if you look at the animation showing where all the homeless are being sent it sure looks like the bubble around LA and SF grew a lot during the time frame. Where these bubbles net flows or totals? Can't tell. I do strongly suspect and have read some (inconclusive) evidence that a large number of the drugged out long term homeless in LA and SF were shipped here from elsewhere. I don't believe that anyone has a special right to move to a nice city and adopt a street camping meth smoking lifestyle and expect the new city to not only tolerate it but subsidize it.
- Axsuul 3y agoTitle needs to be updated with (2017) appended.
- softwaredoug 3y agoIt’s hard to find a more important moral, economic, and environmental cause these days more actionable than just building more housing. There’s an increasing class of unhoused, transitory people. Not just in the US, but plenty of people around the world who are hard working decent people who have become refugees due to war, climate, or economic pressures. Not to mention the people who have to commute great distances for middle class jobs who would love to live nearby. Yet, we’re forced sadly, to hire teachers and essential personnel essentially as mercenaries with no connection to their community. The upside to housing in terms of fewer commutes, connected communities, a healthier humanity, and supporting sustainable businesses can’t be overstated.
- alexb_ 3y agoThe best way to get people to build more housing? Tax the land that it's built on. Not the building, like we do now. The way our property taxes currently function, any development is disincentivized and increases your tax bill for daring to improve the world around you. If you instead tax the land, people who sit around and do nothing with $1 lots will actually have to do something, or sell it to someone who will.
- niceice 3y agoThat seems to make sense. Are there any cities or states that have tried that? If not, why not?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoDetroit is considering it. Nobody else has tried it, so far as I know. Why not? Well, it's a... let's call it a "heterodox" economic theory. It's not mainstream. And, if a state were to do it, it would probably have negative effects on farming. (A city, not so much, unless there was significant farmland within the city limits.) Making most of the farms in your state less economically viable is probably not a formula for winning elections, so a state is probably not going to go for it.