3 ms·
Ok, but many of these AI tools are promoted as Programming bots with a capital-P
by croes 3y ago
Ok, but many of these AI tools are promoted as Programming bots with a capital-P
- kevinsync 3y agoThat's just marketing. McDonalds will sell you what it calls a Hamburger with a capital-H, but we could argue endlessly about the veracity of that. In the end it doesn't matter -- some people like it, some people hate it, it's good, it's terrible, it's whatever you at this moment in your life decide it is for you, but regardless of opinions, it's still edible. I just love what this guy made mostly because he followed through and made something, anything, and put it out there (presumably for the pure joy of creation).. and it got us all talking about it lol
- godelski 3y ago> That's just marketing. McDonalds will sell you what it calls a Hamburger with a capital-H, but we could argue endlessly about the veracity of that. Well they can't sell you a quarter pound of horse meat as third of a pound of beef. There are laws about this and I believe they do deserve criticism. But that criticism is completely orthogonal to how good the "hamburger" tastes and the nutritional value of it. But personally I could never do marketing. I feel like their skills lay in getting as close to a lie as possible without technically being one. But I also think this is why people are not happy with a lot of products, because they aren't getting what they were expected. But at the same time I think companies are in an arms race that has simply been a race to the bottom where we're at or near and no one can get an economic edge simply by telling the whole truth and nothing but the unquestionable truth. The (near) liars have the distinct advantage in a world where it is impossible to have objective validators. It's why we have reviewers but why reviewers also got metric hacked. Idk what the solution here is but I definitely understand why people are upset and I wouldn't call this a fruitful endeavour where we'll argue endlessly. That's more about people having difficulties in expressing why they feel frustrated.
- Waterluvian 3y agoAnd some people think Synthesia is actually teaching them piano. It might get them into the door. It might give them all they are seeking and that’s all awesome. They might find that they hit a wall and need to go learn how to read sheet music. Or they don’t. The thing about “it’s not real programming” is that I don’t think it matters. They might just end up a bit surprised that they hit a wall and have to go back and learn more of the fundamentals.
- yieldcrv 3y agoAI is good at that too I learned just enough about “chord progressions” in order to ask ChatGPT to make both the lyrics and chord progressions for me I just input them and humans like it I wouldn’t have initially known the terms to use. Nowadays I can prompt for that too though “what concepts do I need to understand in this field” “tell me more about number 3” and I hope it didn’t just make something up but it’s good enough to converse with humans about - who also make things up
- nativeit 3y agoAt best, I expect it will maybe reach parity with (more likely fall short of) the kind of accessibility that other low-code application development tools and WYSIWYG website builders have reached. Specifically, I can see where this kind of utility will be too limited for professionals and skilled amateurs to bother with, beyond maybe doing some kind of “boilerplate+”, and yet it will remain out of reach for the vast majority of laypeople who will quickly realize that programming requires more than just a grasp of syntax and an IDE. Square Space and Wix haven’t meaningfully impacted the professional web design market as near as I can tell, and Airtable hasn’t cost any SQL engineers their jobs. Just my gut instinct, though, and I’ve certainly been wrong before.
- godelski 3y agoSure, and that deserves more critique than this. But the critique there is that you're being marketed a product under false pretenses. I'll give you an example to help clarify. In another thread[0] the OP is showing off their ML programming assistant. The project is unquestionably cool and has every right to be on the front page of HN. But there are still major questions I have. The implicit critique here comes form the fact that the author says "beats GPT 4 at coding" but then their basis for this claim is simply via HumanEval performance. In reality the evidence does not support the claim (it doesn't say the contrary either, it simply is indeterminate -- not to be confused with orthogonal/irrelevant). This is marketing. I'm not sure if it is dishonest marketing, but I would not call it honest marketing either. It's in the gray. The thread originally had an intro from OP who was specifically requesting comments too and so the context is appropriate, other than the nature of simply being on HN. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38091869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38091869
- Aeolun 3y agoWell, most programming is just doing what was done before again? Anecdotally a lot of my coworkers seem to say they did something ‘with chatgpt’.