7 ms·
Israel was removed from Baidu Maps earlier today
- jlangenauer 3y agoI see we're going from "UI changes, the cause or reason of which we don't know" to "geopolitics" without considering any of the obvious alternative explanations. If China decides (and no-one is saying that it has) that it no longer recognizes Israel, then it will simply announce that, and not get a private company to make subtle UI changes to reflect a secret policy instead.
- FroshKiller 3y agoNot that I agree with the tweet's conclusion, but pray share one of the obvious alternative explanations.
- viraptor 3y agoChanges in that area, resulting in broken database entries and skipping the country entry/label. People break stuff all the time. Let's see if it stays missing for more than a couple of days...
- master_crab 3y agoGuy in tweet also adds: “Major provocation from China.” If this is a major provocation I’d hate to see what he considers something more substantive than a UI change.
- zmgsabst 3y agoWhy should Israel respond as if this is less serious than China does when Taiwan is listed on a map? China is extremely offended when that happens — and should be held to the same standard, regarding others.
- master_crab 3y agoChina is extremely offended by a lot of things done by a lot of countries. Welcome to the club. What this definitely is not is a major provocation.
- happytoexplain 3y ago>China is extremely offended by a lot of things done by a lot of countries Yes, that's bad. Hence, "should be held to the same standard". You may reasonably disagree with that, but as it stands your implication is that the more bad things a country does, the less we should care.
- tazjin 3y agoReminds me of the problems with contested borders, which e.g. Yandex runs into because they operate in Western and non-Western jurisdictions. They ended up just removing all national borders from the maps for this reason, which has made the UX worse, especially for international trip planning. Google (used to?) opts for a different approach where some borders are drawn based on where they geolocated you to.
- persnickety 3y agoWe'll all be better off by shifting to a borderless paradigm. Yandex is just a canary in the coal mine.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoI mean, depends on use case right? Certainly for travel and navigation purposes I very much want to know when I'm about to leave a country :-). For any economical or political review as well, country birders are extremely relevant data. There certainly are geology and other scientific endeavours which perhaps don't care too much for countries, but even they probably need them when they interface with regular humans (I.e. This lake is in such and such country, this volcano is about to explode over there, etc)
- persnickety 3y agoTourist endeavors really care about borders for 2 aspects: as barriers, and as places where legal or social rules change. If administrative borders had their powers limited to, say, statistical purposes, and not social obstacles, a tourist would stop caring about them. Interfacing with humans does not necessarily have to be done along social borders. I'm sure it wasn't that way before the rise of the nation-state. Everyone knows where the Alps are, or where the Great Lakes are. Pretty much every place on Earth is covered by some geographical-not-political area name. Why shouldn't places be referred to in that way? It's harder to politically push for a change in the definition of the Gobi Desert than of an arbitrary administrative unit.
- hluska 3y agoThe obvious alternative explanations?? Like they just randomly and accidentally decided to erase an entire state? Particularly an extremely contested state? Give me a break - you’re really not making a good argument.
- mcphage 3y agoWhat's the... I guess, non-alternative explanation?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aaomidi 3y agoThis literally happens constantly in contested regions, even on google maps.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hluska 3y agoCan you show me an example of a UN country being erased from a map during a major event in which others are calling for them to be wiped off the globe?
- Waterluvian 3y agoChina publishes an official political map each year, which the companies must treat as canon. They also swapped a contested half-Russian island to being fully China. I think it’s a way to assert some politics at a lower volume. I can’t say for sure this is that, but I can say for sure that there is tremendous political power in cartography and the simplest act of choosing the label levels for placenames. This move has been done countless times before so I wouldn’t be surprised at all if it’s intentional.
- bigger_inside 3y agoit also has little incentive to do so, as it's positioning itself as a possible mediator, one that also does a lot of business with Israel. And remember, the thing that led to the short animosity between China and the Soviet Union (well, one of the things) was that the SU was a country with a mission to spread its system, while China wasn't, and isn't. China seeks to do business with everyone without telling them how to run their affairs, quite unlike the US. The more likely explanation is that the companies are catering to their custmer base. As in most of the world, there is huge public support to stop the killing of Gazans. Western companies, and companies in Wester-capured neocolonies, can't show support for Gaza. Maybe this is ALibaba testing out if it can. It'll be interesting to see if it lasts, or if it gets changed again in a few days. This should tell you more.
- infamia 3y ago> China seeks to do business with everyone without telling them how to run their affairs, quite unlike the US. Tell that to the Austrailians and now the Israelis, where China has sent a naval task force. China is building aircraft carriers like nobody's businesss for force remote projection, which is the one thing they're really good at. China has the same desire to project force as the US, they simply lack the means to do so as effectively. Their recent actions in the Gulf is proof enough of that.
- kkzz99 3y agoThe truth is that this was always the case, no change happened. All that happened was that a known anti-china fake news "reporter" associated with the falun gong cult was spreading lies on twitter. See for example here: https://twitter.com/CurtExplores/status/1719334699599122690 https://twitter.com/CurtExplores/status/1719334699599122690
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- teekert 3y agoI don't understand this. China is not exactly pro-muslim as we all know. Why would this happen? I'm not very knowledgeable in this subject but it looks to me like some mistake or bug? Or just "when a country's name is displayed at when zoom level compared to the size and shape of said country"?
- sofixa 3y agoYou don't have to be pro-Muslim to disagree with Israel's genocide or anti-Miuslim to disagree with Hamas' terrorist acts. Also, it could easily be just opting to not display any disputed borders, which Israel has multiple of (Gaza, West Bank, Golan).
- teekert 3y agoWith "not exactly pro-muslim" I mean they have their own share of anti-muslim history and this does not rhyme with that. As said, I'm not knowledgeable on the subject but would like to learn.
- sofixa 3y agoYeah, but disagreeing with another country's genocide against Muslims doesn't mean they will disagree with their own. Geopolitics is often hypocritical (see US getting pissed the Soviet Union deployed ICBMs in Cuba while they have theirs in Turkey; or US collaborating with the ICC to help the investigation against Russian war crimes in Ukraine, while sanctioning ICC prosecutors when they try to investigate American war crimes in Afghanistan; China being friendly and investing in many Muslim-majority or Islamic countries while genociding their own Muslims).
- timeon 3y agoTrying to find patterns of ideological consistency in geopolitics is probably not useful approach.
- justinclift 3y ago> it could easily be just opting to not display any disputed borders Aren't the majority of China's maritime borders disputed?
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoIt reminds me of something similar with Google Maps and others "Google Maps accused of deleting Palestine" - https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/10/google-maps-accused-remove-palestine https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/aug/10/google-ma... For Baidu, it's probably just a mistake, they would have communicated it otherwise
- badcppdev 3y agoI think there's a big chance it's a bug. Small chance it's a political motivated 'sabotage' from someone low down in the hierarchy. Super low chance it's a political statement from the company management. A funny thing I just noted that could lead to this behaviour is that if you wanted to place the label for Israel at the centre of Israel then I think it would be in Palestine. I'm not 100% sure because Google Maps doesn't show a label for Palestine.
- hartator 3y agoI think it’s still showing as normal on Baidu Search: https://serpapi.com/playground?engine=baidu&q=以色列 https://serpapi.com/playground?engine=baidu&q=以色列
- EdSharkey 3y ago[flagged]
- liveoneggs 3y agoI don't see any country names on the map. When I type 'israel' into the search bar I get the same chinese characters that are being shown under Jerusalem (耶路撒冷) -- I don't ready or speak any chinese -- If I play with the zoom I see many small countries without labels (no idea what they say) -- cyprus, israel, and lebenon included
- yorwba 3y agoNot being able to read Chinese explains your difficulty spotting country names on a Chinese map, but you could have tried using a dictionary to find out what labels to expect for Cyprus (塞浦路斯), Israel (以色列), Palestine (巴勒斯坦), Lebanon (黎巴嫩) etc.
- j16sdiz 3y agoThe chinese have official response: https://m.163.com/news/article/IICVKOU50001899O.html?spss=adap_pc https://m.163.com/news/article/IICVKOU50001899O.html?spss=ad...
- underseacables 3y agoGosh, wish this were translated. Could you tell us what it says ?
- schrectacular 3y agoIt basically says that the foreign ministry says they have a formal relationship with Israel and that the ministry publishes an official map with Israel on it and that if you search for Israel on any of those map providers it will show Israel.
- torginus 3y agoI just love that in the minds of Westerners, 'Chinese company does X' is the equivalent of 'China does X', and when queried on why they think this, they'll tell you that Xi Jinping, like Oz the Great Wizard, pulls the levers of more than a billion Chinese individuals from behind the curtain.
- tupac_speedrap 3y agoTo be fair, it basically is, you won't get very far in China without the CCP's approval.
- pb7 3y agoAll companies in China are under control of the CCP so it's the same thing. The "West" isn't an authoritarian state so this might be why people think of it like this.
- torginus 3y agoI have to ask you - do you have substantial firsthand experience on how businesses operate in China or are you just 'well read' on the subject?
- pb7 3y agoA bit hard to find open, unbiased, and independent information about a country that forcibly suppresses anything negative about itself, isn't it? Jack Ma criticized the government and suddenly disappeared for years losing his position at the company in the process. If they can do that to one of the most powerful people in the country, they can do it to anyone else. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Ma#Disappearance_from_the_public_eye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Ma#Disappearance_from_the...
- kkzz99 3y agoJack Ma never disappeared though, same case with the Chinese Tenis player. Thats the exact same thing the other poster was criticizing. Its the western media making up stories to fit the anti-china narrative.
- underseacables 3y agoI wonder how the Chinese would react if Google Maps renamed places like Tibet as Chinese Occupied Territory..
- fwjlwo 3y agoCall it what you want, just FREE THE PALESTINES!
- kkzz99 3y agoIt is actually quite funny and sad to see so many Americans fall for the most braindead fake news propaganda in regards to China.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]