5 ms·
That would be a major upheaval. This one feels legit; DNT has been around (and ignored by everyone) for a long long time. But the summary here is saying, oh, t
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
That would be a major upheaval.
This one feels legit; DNT has been around (and ignored by everyone) for a long long time. But the summary here is saying, oh, the consumer signalled something so sites have to obey. It feels like fools could make up all kinds of arbitrary signalling systems packaging all manners of data handling directives to sites.
So, what if any limits does the court see or allow? If DNT is something sites have to obey, what's something sites wouldn't have to obey? And how do sites become aware of all the different mechanized ways consumers might send processing directives to them?
- krageon 3y agoThis legal proceeding is about do not track. It is not about anything else which you're pulling in. This is an appeal to ridicule and these are generally not very interesting.
- fxtentacle 3y agoI'd say website should be required to honour any signal that more than 1 mio potential users know about. That seems like a fair trade-off between pushing work onto companies while simultaneously closing laziness as a loophole.
- wirrbel 3y agoI assume you are asking in good faith. I could configure my browser to add some custom headers to my HTTP requests, like `DONTDOTHISTHINGTHATISIMPORTANTTOME` or something. I don't think courts would accept that, as it's not an established interface / protocol, and furthermore GDPR does in fact allow for data-processing if it's needed / required to offer the service. By providing an interface standard, however, the browser vendors have kind of set the stage for the courts accepting DNT as a valid communication medium for the service consumer to state intent to the service provider. This is akin to the courts taking into account how the card-payment terminal works when ruling on matters of card-payment in stores, etc.
- nvm0n2 3y agoYou don't think courts would accept that, but you don't know, because EU privacy law is so vague and badly written that the courts regularly "discover" new things about it that nobody had previously considered possible. For example the fact that everyone had a right to remove stuff from search engines if it was about yourself was never written into law by any elected body or even any non-elected body. It was a right that a court simply invented. Ditto for not being able to use Google Fonts. The EU has had problems with this kind of activist lawmaking for a long time. It's one of the factors behind Brexit. Some Leave campaigners argued that it was impossible to make any kind of deal or compromise with the EU if it meant staying in, because no matter how clearly written it appeared to be and no matter how watertight the international treaty encoding it was, the European courts would simply ignore it and/or rule it invalid. This criticism landed because there was precedent for that, where the courts had previously done exactly the same thing with other agreements. The same debate is now playing out around the ECHR as well, which the UK stayed in because it's not technically an EU court, just a European court. Same cultural issues though.
- wirrbel 3y agoAre you saying the Brits complained about case law?
- nvm0n2 3y agoYes bad EU case law that can't be fixed with legislation has been a common complaint of both political parties and independent groups over the years. An example is the Charter of Fundamental Rights which the UK and Poland thought they had negotiated an opt-out of, on the grounds that it was bad law and they didn't want it to apply. The opt-out was negotiated and agreed between all countries and was written in a simple and supposedly "watertight" way. The ECJ simply ignored the agreement and ruled the UK had to obey the Charter anyway. https://www.politics.co.uk/news/2013/11/13/the-stolen-referendum-european-court-robs-britain-of-vote-by-overturning-uk-opt-out/ https://www.politics.co.uk/news/2013/11/13/the-stolen-refere... It was one of the events that led to the ECJ's perception as an activist court that makes EU law unknowable, because what is or is not illegal can't be understood by reading the treaties or laws. Here's an example of some British lawyers expressing that view: https://lawyersforbritain.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/eu-charter-after-brexit-not-retain.pdf https://lawyersforbritain.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/eu-... The effects of the Charter, whether applied to UK laws made before or after Brexit, cannot be predicted as its operation would be dependent on the rapidly evolving and expansionist case law of the European Court of Justice, and would open the door to judicial adventurism in our own courts. Not just the UK has complained about this. Here's an example of corruption in the ECJ uncovered by Irish journalists, in which the ECJ was trying to surreptitiously expand EU powers: https://euobserver.com/investigations/131569 https://euobserver.com/investigations/131569 It is clearly corrupt to hear a bogus case like that where the plaintiff doesn't even know they're in a court case at all and both sides are represented by the same firm, yet nothing was ever done about it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]