4 ms·
The bigger problem here is that public officials are increasingly using privately-owned social media channels to conduct day to day business. If my local politi
by paxys 3y ago
The bigger problem here is that public officials are increasingly using privately-owned social media channels to conduct day to day business. If my local politician or police department is posting photos of their kids I don't really care if they block me. If their Twitter account is the only place I can hear about active shooter threats in my area or submit feedback on an upcoming piece of legislation, then yeah, they have an obligation to allow public access even if I say something that offends them.
- ajkjk 3y agoIt is not that different from using television or radio or private phone lines to conduct business in the past. I would not ask public officials to communicate in silly suboptimal ways out of an imagined principle that it's important that their communication only be on public channels.
- paxys 3y agoIt's very different than using (broadcast) TV or radio or phone lines. All of those are still strictly regulated, and you can't be arbitrarily barred access. Your only obligation as a citizen is to own a receiver. This does not apply to random websites on the internet.
- lolinder 3y agoThe government is and always has been tightly involved in television, radio, and phone services. The first two were traditionally broadcast through the airwaves for anyone to pick up and listen to, and the latter is a tightly regulated public utility that unfortunately functions as a government-ordained monopoly. All three are widely regarded as part of the commons. Twitter never has been treated that way, and is rapidly becoming more and more private and less and less a communal resource that is equally accessible to all.
- macinjosh 3y agoCable and satellite radio do not have much government involvement. Terrestrial broadcasts in the US are really the only place your argument has any standing and almost no one uses those these days in comparison.
- lolinder 3y agoYou're completely ignoring the context of my comment: > It is not that different from using television or radio or private phone lines to conduct business in the past Terrestrial broadcasts in the US in the past are the subject of this comparison. Whether my description of said historical broadcasts is applicable to modern cable and satellite radio is immaterial, because we're not talking about modern cable and radio usage. Yes those are different, but they're also not used as official channels for government communication any more the way that broadcast TV and radio used to be. They've been transferred
- likeclockwork 3y agoThey don't really "use" television and radio though, do they? They hold a press conference and television and radio stations show up and broadcast them. The stations aren't under any obligation to show up and if they declined to do so the officials would get no airtime without using the emergency broadcast option.
- pixl97 3y agoAt least in the more distant past in the time of the fairness act the broadcast stations had somewhat of an obligation if they were showing news/politics they had to have a somewhat 'balanced' showing.
- macinjosh 3y agoBelieve me they use those mediums plenty. They even pay for ads during election season.
- plagiarist 3y agoTelevision and radio were literally unencrypted public channels, I don't think that person would object to a public broadcast of that nature.
- redeux 3y agoWhich of these is silly and suboptimal? 1. Communication on a novelty social media platform that limits the amount of I formation you can relay at any one point, by design and that [probably] less than 25% of Americans use. 2. Communication over a set of public frequencies that nearly every American can access free of charge from their home. 3. Communication over a regulated public utility that every American with a home can access?
- xorcist 3y agoIn what country do you need to register and give up personal identifying information in order to read a newspaper or listen to the radio? If the idea to centrally register every reader before they were allowed to read news articles had been raised in the 50s or 60s, it would have rightly been regarded as undemocratic. In our age it passes without discussion, and any suggestion it may be problematic is regarded as useless nostalgia.
- count 3y agoWould you rather they call you on the privately owned telephone network, or print a story in the privately owned newspaper? There are functionally ZERO non-private methods of communication from the govt to citizens in the US.
- xhci 3y agoIt transmits over privately owned networks, but isn’t this what’s the FCC’s Emergency Alert System is for? https://www.fcc.gov/emergency-alert-system https://www.fcc.gov/emergency-alert-system
- admax88qqq 3y ago> If their Twitter account is the only place I can hear about active shooter threats in my area ??? Do you actually use your local politicians Twitter to see if there's an active shooter?
- InitialLastName 3y agoThis is a less extreme example, but my town uses its Facebook page as the primary means of reporting concerns (e.g. potholes and other road maintenance issues, parking exceptions).
- tomohawk 3y agoMany local governments post things to social media sites instead of on their own infrastructure, so blocking access to these sites prevents people from these important communications.
- warner25 3y agoI've been beating this drum for a few years now, and the key point that upsets me is precisely that they already have their own infrastructure, like you said, but they have practically abandoned those official .gov, .mil, .org websites (leaving behind stale information and dead links) to use Facebook and Twitter instead. I think this is mostly a problem among small towns, counties, etc. so residents of big cities may not notice it as much (like the death of real local journalism). I think it usually boils down to the fact that it's easier for a lay person to update a Facebook or Twitter page than it is to maintain their own website, and IT people are expensive. I'm in the US Army, and "Big Army" at the top level does OK with its websites (e.g. army.mil), but it also consists of many geographically distributed, semi-independent, sub-organizations (units) that each have a handful of people doing public affairs work. The official websites at those lower levels have been rotting for years, and public affairs folks have freely admitted to me that they don't know how to update their official websites besides changing the photo and biography of the new commander once every two years.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoThis may be easier to relate to: During the pandemic, my state governor had an official Q&A regarding the state's policies, on Facebook. I couldn't participate without accepting Facebook's T&Cs. I'm not sure if that was illegal, but I'd like it to be.
- DSMan195276 3y agoI feel like you're identifying two distinct issues here - preventing you from commenting on posts, and preventing you from seeing them at all. It depends on the platform whether you can actually separate the two though (regardless of whether either should be legal).
- paxys 3y agoNot sure why there should be a legal distinction between the two. There are many possible ways to interact with stuff online (view it, "like" it, comment on it, save it, share it etc.), and if it is government-sponsored content then no one should be barred from doing any of this.
- bandyaboot 3y agoI would somewhat disagree with this and say that if someone is to be barred from doing any of this, there needs to be some semblance of due process in the form of clearly defined circumstances when that can happen, for how long, etc.
- echelon 3y agoAnd a private entity should have zero say or lever over this. Twitter, Reddit, Facebook, etc. should have no right to censor public discourse.
- graeme 3y agoWell let’s say someone just spams a prominent account with bot accounts, such that any and all discussion beneath their posts is ruined. Or fills the mentions with slander, hateful comments etc. twitter is the Wild West right now, full of bots and comments that violate rules but take a while to get enforced. Blocks solve that. But also deprive people of being able to hear announcements. Splitting the ability to listen to a broadcast and the ability to broadcast on a broadcast seems sensible. You could, after all, be removed from a courtroom or government press conference for being disruptive.
- underseacables 3y agoI agree, public officials should not be using private accounts - email social, etc. - for public/government work. It seems a lot of politicians are doing this, and quite possibly to avoid public records requests and scrutiny
- macinjosh 3y agoThe newspapers where they write op-eds, or the radio and TV channels where they give speeches are private too. I don't see a difference
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoNY Times can't block you from buying their newspaper, and public broadcast television can't block you from getting their reception. One wrongthink on twitter can get you banned from there, and if your local government uses twitter to 'do whatever', you're effectively banned from that.
- hn_acker 3y ago> NY Times can't block you from buying their newspaper This is not true, beyond discrimination against protected classes. The New York Times is a non-governmental business. The First Amendment freedom of association is freedom to do business with anyone, or refuse business to anyone. A newspaper company can ban whoever and refuse to sell to whoever, so long as no government or government official coerces the company to do so. > One wrongthink on twitter can get you banned from there As a non-governmental company, Twitter has a First Amendment freedom of association. Twitter can legally ban you (not saying should ban you) from viewing a government's posts so long as no government or government official coerces Twitter to do so. The government official should mirror the contents of their social media posts on a freely accessible government website. I would favor a new law requiring mirroring and archival in this vein.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYou're not buying NY times from NY times directy, but from one of the thousands/millions of newspaper sales points, and getting fully banned (no where to buy it within reason) is for most people unimaginable. On the other hand, everyone knows someone who got banned from one platfor or another, and if not in person, there have been many articles of people getting banned from random platforms for random stupid reasons, even just saying a foreign word ( https://news.yahoo.com/japanese-apex-legends-players-being-200629036.html?guccounter=1 https://news.yahoo.com/japanese-apex-legends-players-being-2... ) I live in a non-english speaking country, and a word exchange of "Is Marko there?" - "He's not" would here be: "Je marko tam?" - "Ni ga" ... guess how the last sentance is pronounced, and how that could get misinterpreted if used in a video uploaded to eg. twitter/facebook/whatever.