3 ms·
Being big is also a problem, but I did in fact mean heat. "Not melting itself" is not the threshold we need to meet for a phone. We should probably consider 5
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Being big is also a problem, but I did in fact mean heat.
"Not melting itself" is not the threshold we need to meet for a phone. We should probably consider 5 thermal watts the limit. If we have a 30% efficient betavoltaic panel, then we can produce 1.5-2 watts of device power within that limit. If we have a 5% efficient panel, then we're only getting a quarter of a watt. A quarter of a watt can stop an idle phone from draining, but you'd only recover about 1% of a normal phone battery per hour.
By the time we're considering external devices, I think "battery bank with a solar panel" beats betavoltaic on the technical merits even when we're ignoring difficulty and radiation. Even a tiny panel built into the back of a phone generally wins.
- Reason077 3y agoHigher levels of waste heat could be sold as a benefit, especially in cold climates. Nice little personal heating device to keep you warm on cold nights? Optional accessories could harvest the heat to heat water, make coffee, cook food, etc?
- Dylan16807 3y agoThose people typically want to use their phone indoors too. There's really no good way to spin an uncomfortably hot phone. If it's separate from the phone then you don't have to worry about that, but again if it's separate from the phone the entire scenario that made you want this kind of device starts to collapse because the requirements are so different.