4 ms·
Nailed it. They’ve been spending goodwill like crazy with debacles like pushing out SMR junk under the Red name. In my experience, their overall quality contro
by kstrauser 3y ago
Nailed it. They’ve been spending goodwill like crazy with debacles like pushing out SMR junk under the Red name.
In my experience, their overall quality control has plummeted over the last few years. I’ve bought 3 Red drives for my home Synology. After about a year with each, the drive utilization graph will start creeping up toward a steady 100% while the other drives in the RAID are mostly idle. All drives have the same throughput. All drives have the same IOPS. And yet, the Red starts taking longer and longer to complete its requests. There aren’t any SMART errors or warnings. If I pull the drive and run WD’s diagnostics, it’s fine. It shows every sign of being perfectly healthy, other than being dog slow up until the day I replace it. I’m 3-for-3 with this happening. Maybe I’m the only person and they work great for everyone else. I won’t buy another, though.
I think we’re seeing WD turn into HP. People will still buy it for the name on the label, but those in the know will steer their friends to calmer waters.
- lloydatkinson 3y agoI also had two Reds showing bad sectors after around a year, with a Synology. What "colour" drive do you usually buy now? Or even which manufacturer?
- sersi 3y agoI've switched to only buying Toshiba, been very happy with them. They're also more silent as a bonus.
- kstrauser 3y agoI've had good luck with Seagate Iron Wolves. They're a little noisier than others, but I've never had one fail. The Toshiba I've had in there for 3 years has also been fine. After years of seeing many brands of drives go through good and bad years, I'm hesitant to recommend any particular manufacturer. Seagate had a rough stretch, but they seem to be pretty good right now. WD used to be great, and now I don't want anything to do with them. Anytime I look for a new drive, I check out the latest Backblaze report and hope for the best.
- Scoundreller 3y agoHP or HPe? Basically the same segmentation of “good business” and “bad business” there too.
- AlphaSite 3y agoWhich is which?
- spectre3d 3y agoAre your drives WD Red, Red Plus, or Red Pro? Not that it should matter, just curious. To add another anectode, I’ve been running a 12TB and a 6TB WD Red Pro (both CMR) in my Synology without issues (knock on wood) for 16 and 38 months respectively. I recently added an 18TB Seagate Exos and a 16TB WD Ultrastar, which are also both CMR and are intended for data centers (with twice the MTBF of Ironwolf or Red Pro). The enterprise drives are quite a bit louder, but since the NAS isn’t within earshot it’s not a problem. The NAS runs 24/7 as a Home Assistant and Plex server, as well as handling backups from machines on my LAN. So far, so good, but I’m not kidding myself about eventual drive failure. I know it’ll happen at some point. WDDA analytics are not turned on. Don’t need to see a pointless warning at the 3-year mark.