10 ms·
"Always ask whether the hypothesis can be, at least in principle, falsified. Propositions that are untestable, unfalsifiable are not worth much." This. That's
by Animats 3y ago
"Always ask whether the hypothesis can be, at least in principle, falsified. Propositions that are untestable, unfalsifiable are not worth much."
This. That's a good way to put it. I've mentioned Fred Hoyle's line on that, "Science is prediction, not explanation" (which is from one of Hoyle's novels), but Sagan's line is better.
Key point: unfalsifiable theories do not lead to useful technology. Engineering requires predictability.
- passion__desire 3y agoAdd to that David Deutsch's point that "Good explanations MUST be hard to vary"
- pengstrom 3y agoDeutsch also heavily argues for explanations as first-class existence on the level of matter. For him, predictions are simply a practical concern. I still fondly remember his dialogue between Socrates and Apollo in dream, where he convincingly makes the point that even there he can find true knowledge about the world.
- crabmusket 3y agoI also loved that chapter. Deutsch really argues for Popper's "conjecture and refutation" model of science (or as he renamed it, "conjecture and criticism") and one of the great points he makes is that both those processes can be done entirely in the mind. Physical evidence may be necessary for some kinds of criticism, but sometimes reason alone can produce useful criticism.
- pengstrom 3y agoThat's true, I might have been a little aggressive on the claiming
- walleeee 3y agoI also like his point (in conversation with Sean Carroll) that we have rigorous proof that the notion of explanation can't be formalized, yet explanation is at the core of the scientific endeavor anyway.
- crabmusket 3y ago"Hard to vary" is, I think, some sort of isomorphism of "easy to refute". I found it difficult when reading Deutsch to pin down exactly what made something hard to vary.
- passion__desire 3y agoLet's say we have 16 distinct phenomena. All of them are currently explained by a rooted tree T of explanations of depth 4. Say, we come across 8 new phenomena. Suddenly you can't rejig or shake your tree T anyhow. You have to preserve the original structure of T or at least relationships while constructing a new tree R such that it not only explains old 16 phenomena but also the new 8 as well. We might construct a new tree R such that tree T is a subtree of it. This new tree covers more ground and has more depth. In this sense, new explanations are constrained by whatever that came before and they are tasked with explaining more on top of that. There are very few ways to do it. In physics, they call the more general law to be valid at all time scales, energy scales and length scales, velocity scales and so on.
- wredue 3y agoI like Sagan, but he didn’t make these rules for a post truth world, unfortunately. There were certainly well funded lies in his day, but right now we are seeing massive investment, easily rivalling a large tech corporation or a Disney media empire, in to creating “news” orgs who’s specific goal is to lie, muddy waters, sow discord, and otherwise mislead the public, and who are seen as independent bodies of verification. It’s much more difficult now to find real facts, which is actually insane given that real facts should be available with the click of a button these days.
- omgwtfbyobbq 3y agoI think the increase in spending on spreading/amplifying certain kinds of information is because there's a greater depth and breath of information available now that people can and are using to derive their own opinion. Influencing people was less expensive when media/news/information/etc was relatively limited.
- wredue 3y agoYeah, but what Sagan is trying to give is a framework for forming opinions based on reality. While it’s a good start, it’s missing imperative steps like “if Fox News is your independent verification, it’s probably a lie”. As stated, we are in a post-truth world, and a framework from Sagan era for forming opinions with a factual justification is much more difficult.
- demondemidi 3y agoHello: "Flood the channels with shit." - Steve Bannon Goodbye: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine
- Animats 3y agoH. R. McMaster credits Putin's people with that concept. Until recently, propaganda was promoting your position. Russia came up with the breakthrough of just promoting extremists of all stripes to reduce the credibility of all news. This is a form of tactical misdirection. "To sow confusion and reap inaction", as Willie Sutton, the bank robber and prison escapee, put it. It wasn't really feasible at scale before the Internet, because it takes a large number of anonymous sources to make it go.
- esafak 3y agoFalsifiability is not his idea; it was promoted by Karl Popper. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability
- vivekd 3y agoThis is correct, Falsifiability was origionally concieved of by Karl Popper. I would also add, that while Popper had the best of intentions and good ideas in creating falsifiability theory, it is not generally accepted today by people who study philosophy of science. The consensus, which I agree with, is that it doesn't refelct how science atually works and it eleminatates many things that we do consider science. I mean many people may disagree with string theory, but it's hard for me to accept that it's science at all. Evolution also didn't pass Mr. Popper's tests, but he eventually recanted, not by changing his views on how evolution fits with his theories but just because his friends convinced him that it was "really important." Popper made contributions to science in that he was one of the main thought leaders that began the field of philosophy of science. That said, I don't think falsifiability by itself is a very good criterion for science or truth. I don't think the wikipedia article on this is very good. The encyclopedia of philosophy has a much better overview of his theory and where it stands currently https://iep.utm.edu/pop-sci/#H3 https://iep.utm.edu/pop-sci/#H3
- readthenotes1 3y ago" by people who study philosophy of science. The consensus, which I agree with, is that it doesn't refelct how science atually works and " Science 'works' today by p-hacking and data falsification. I'm not sure that we should consider current practices an argument against a quality threshold.
- jimwhite42 3y agoAren't you mixing two distinct things here?
- glenstein 3y ago
- clankyclanker 3y agoOr, more pithily, always ask "how can you disprove it?" - If you can't, it isn't science and can't be treated as such.
- ukj 3y agoHow can we disprove the hypothesis “If we can’t disprove it - it isn’t science.”? The scientific metaphysic relies on so many declarative/prescriptive statements which are themselves exempt from the criteria for science and are thus self-defeating on their own terms. It is so peculiar when scientists are so dogmatic about science. Are the formal sciences (logic/mathematics/computer science) not science? The testability/falsifiability criterion certainly excludes them from being sciences.
- vivekd 3y agoand you hit one of the main objections to the theory of falsifiability as the criterion of science. There are also other more serious ones, like the obvious fact that actual science does't seem to actually work this way. The idea is more to explain observations in a coherent way rather than to be falsifiable for example. One example is the big bang theory being proposed by a Catholic astronomer who didn't like the then prevaling idea that the universe did not have a beginning or end because it went against his religious beliefs. Or Kepler looking for planets at locations in accord with musical harmonies because he though it was consistent with the existence of a God
- ukj 3y agoPersonally, I am weary of the notion of “actual science” since science is not a well-defined term. The demarcation problem isn’t solved; and philosophers like Fayerabend in his book “Against method” suggest that science is more of an anarchic enterprise than any particular set of methods. Take any criterion and apply it too strictly and there is some scientific discovery/progress in history which violates the rules and wouldn’t pass for “science” given any definition… Take any given methodological approach - and you will always find counter examples in scientific history. Almost like genius isn’t algorithmic.
- gadders 3y agoDoesn't that apply to climate science/ climate change though?
- daanlo 3y agoWhy? Climate science works with quantative models and makes concrete predictions. So if the predictions don‘t come true the model is false. E.g. this random blog I found googling compares IPCC predictions with actual outcomes: https://johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com/2012/03/27/the-1990-ipcc-climate-projections/ https://johncarlosbaez.wordpress.com/2012/03/27/the-1990-ipc... [the link is just supposed to show how climate science is falsifiable. I have no idea whether the numbers in this specific source are trustworthy]
- godelski 3y agoMore comparisons here[0]. As is important, it's noticed that models even from the 80's made fairly accurate predictions. That's the real kicker: models accurately predict observable outcomes 20-40 years later (and have only improved since then). I'm not sure why there's so much contention about climate science given that we've been observing this trend for nearly 50 years now. Scientist makes prediction about something 50 years later and 50 years later the prediction is shown to be accurate. It feels weird to not trust a source with such a good and observable track record... [0] https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-well-have-climate-models-projected-global-warming/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-well-have-climate-m...
- gadders 3y agoThe thing is - there are so many predictions made and a lot that don't come through, it's hard to find which are the "real" ones. I also read somewhere that there are several different scenarios available for the IPCC climate models and a lot of the more "scary" predictions are based on the least likely model. Finally - we saw the limitations of modelling in COVID in the UK, with adverse consequences.
- Aunche 3y agoWhat are you implying? Scientists can't make stars either, but they can make models describing stars and make new observations about these stars that test the validity of these models. Plenty of climate models have been disproven by this exact way. What has been remarkably consistent is that man-made greenhouse gases are causing climate change. For example, models predict that man-made global warming would cause the stratosphere to cool, which is exactly what they measured. By contrast, increased solar activity would have also heated up the stratosphere.
- aeternum 3y agoIs climate change falsifiable?
- HPMOR 3y agoYes because you could simulate a small-scale atmosphere, and notice how changing the composition of the "atmosphere" affects average temperature or other features. John Von Neumann actually predicted climate change from first principles and described it as potentially more debilitating than nuclear weapons. --Great essay. https://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/von_Neumann_1955.pdf https://geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/von_Neumann_1955.pdf
- aeternum 3y agoWell that's more evidence for it, not an attempt to falsify. If we want to falsify, we should ask questions like: Was there a time in the past when the atmosphere contained even more CO2 than it did now? What was the temp and did life survive? What evidence or experiment would convince you the theory is false? Or is that impossible?
- mr_mitm 3y agoClimate change is not a fundamental theory. It is derived from thermodynamics, the Navier Stokes equation, quantum mechanics and probably quite a few assumptions on what is negligible. Falsify any of those and you falsify climate change.
- glenstein 3y ago>If we want to falsify, we should ask questions like: Was there a time in the past when the atmosphere contained even more CO2 than it did now? What was the temp and did life survive? Do you believe that question isn't already asked and answered? Just going off the top of my head, I understand historical considerations to be a routine observation as part of your typical course or even presentation on the history of climate change. If you believe this counts, then your answer to your own question about the falsifiability of climate change is yes. I also don't think that's the only kind of example - I think the routine things talked about on a day to day basis, including year by year and decade by decade temperature predictions would qualify, and these data are quite frequently discussed and quite visible. I also also don't think the distinction between "evidence in favor" and "attempts to falsify" makes a whole lot of sense. These are two different sides of the same coin, and evidence in favor of something is the same as surviving a test of falsifiability.
- jfengel 3y agoFalsifiability is critical for engineering, but not all science is for engineering. The further you get from engineering, the fuzzier the line between science and non science. We try to apply the tools of science to things like astrophysics and paleontology, but they're practically never going to have engineering consequences. That's fine. It's great that we want to know stuff just because we like knowing -- even if "knowing" sometimes gets hard to define. Falsifiability is a great tool for being able to say some things don't work. But it's important not to let it limit curiosity.
- croes 3y agoWithout falsifiability it's belief not science. How can a hypothesis become a theory if it can't fail?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foolswisdom 3y agoIf you can't explain how the statement could be falsified, at least in principle (although it may be not practical to do so), then you are admitting that reality will always be the exact same regardless of whether your hypothesis is true. And in that case, it's really not useful or meaningful for any sort of reasoning at all. A concept which will in no way ever make a difference, is meaningless.
- karencarits 3y agoBut it can be hard to know whether a concept will make a difference in the future. String theory may for example provide some testable hypotheses at some point. Theory building is important and original thoughts may have unpredicted consequences some way down the road
- kybernetikos 3y agoMWI of quantum physics is most likely unfalsifiable. But if I believe that there are other versions of me that will definitely win the lottery if I am the sort of person to enter it in particular circumstances then that may well change my behaviour. I would argue that occams razor is unfalsifiable but is still a great principle.
- dzwa 3y agoPopper
- canjobear 3y agoWhat about, for example, the Drake equation? Not falsifiable, but a useful tool for thinking.
- thicknavyrain 3y agoCertainly useful for thinking, but its lack of falsifiability, predictive power or validation is indeed why there's so much controversy around it and why it remains a hypothesised model rather than widely accepted scientific fact. The best you can do is test the assumptions of the model itself, or its constituent terms.
- cwillu 3y agoNot everything _has_ to be science.
- JohnFen 3y agoThe Drake equation is falsifiable. All you have to do is plug the values (which are all things that could technically be measured) into the equation, then count the number of civilizations in the Milky Way, and see if that's equal to what the equation predicted. it is possible that it's not, so the equation is falsifiable. That it's impractical for us to actually do the experiment just means that we cannot perform the experiment and so it doesn't help us in practical terms. But it is a thing that could be done, strictly speaking. That said, it's also a thought experiment, not a scientific postulate, and isn't meant to be "scientific".
- crabmusket 3y agoNot all useful tools for thinking must be considered science. I think it's quite fair to say the Drake equation isn't "science". However, I think Popper's "conjecture and refutation" is a more interesting model for thinking about the increase of knowledge than falsifiability is. Through that lens, you might say the Drake equation was a conjecture intended to stimulate refutations, which might lead to further productive theories. Popper's essays on Parmenides are really interesting on this. Popper frames Parmenides' philosophy as essentially a conjecture that "change is an illusion", and the history of western science since then as various "research programmes" in response to that. I'm summarising terribly, but I think he illustrates well the value of conjectures that aren't necessarily "scientific" in stimulating thought.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rossant 3y agoThis is a problem with shaken baby syndrome, which asserts that infants presenting a certain pattern of medical findings (mostly subdural and retinal hemorrhage) MUST have been violently shaken if no other alternative medical or accidental explanation is found. It is a diagnosis by default, which raises a number of legal issues. [1, 2] This medical diagnosis is "certain" even with no witness, no admission of violence, no antecedents of violence, no sign of trauma on the baby's body. There is absolutely no way to falsify the idea that this gesture occurred (and no way to prove one's innocence — it's a presumption of guilt). Yet, this theory is qualified as "scientific" by its proponents, but it does not lead to any predictions, only explanations. That shaking must have occurred on a given child at a particular moment, while the only person present with the child denies any violence, is an untestable and unfalsifiable proposition that is totally anti-scientific. [1] https://www.cambridgeblog.org/2023/05/a-journey-into-the-shaken-baby-syndrome-abusive-head-trauma-controversy/ https://www.cambridgeblog.org/2023/05/a-journey-into-the-sha... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37650402 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37650402
- pengstrom 3y ago"Only a sith deals in absolutes" Science clearly works because humans have a genuine curiosity to find truth. While every person is flawed and prone to error, the curiosity points in the same direction, rising above the noise. We've only recently had to even discuss this after the deployment of large scale truth poisoning making the errors non-uniform.
- BellsOnSunday 3y agoRecently like in the last hundred years?