10 ms·
A fourth of U.S. health visits now delivered by non-physicians
- subharmonicon 3y agoHonestly I’m surprised the number isn’t already much higher. For at least the last 15 years most healthcare providers I deal with try to get you into a nurse practitioner or physicians assistant, and most have quite a few more of those than MDs and DOs. Perhaps that’s a West Coast thing, though, and it’s not as common in other parts of the country?
- SoftTalker 3y agoMDs are limited in supply by the AMA. NPs and PAs are not, and for routine cases, sore throats, minor injuries, vaccinations, routine physical exams, etc. there is no reason an MD needs to be involved.
- a_e_k 3y agoAnd for the routine stuff I often have a pretty good idea what's ailing me from past experience and I just need someone to write up the prescription again for whatever's worked well before. I have no problems with seeing an NP for that. In some cases, an NP may have more current experience with figuring out the routine stuff than an MD who's a bit more removed from that kind of practice now.
- georgehaake 3y agoWhere I work we have a physician who doesn’t see patients. He reads procedures and supervises 8 mid-levels. It’s an assembly line. There are inservices that in effect ensure maximum level of encounter complexity to maximize billing.
- fnfjfkdngh 3y agoBecause PA time is cheaper to the provider than MD time. Give it a few years and a trip to the doctor's office will mean using a touch screen a-la-mcdonalds to describe your symptoms and then the first-line medication pops out of a drawer. I'm pretty jaded with our (US) healthcare system. As long as you stay on the happy path it's fine, but if you stray from that, good luck. Over the last few years I was given antibiotics for a gut infection, a lung infection, and currently a sinus infection. None were improved by antibiotics, but no doctor was willing to do a culture to see what the infection was before prescribing antibiotics because that's the happy path (most infectious are bacterial). I think it might be a systemic fungal infection (I've also had bouts of what I think is thrush), but that possibility is immediately rejected without investigation because 'only immunocompromised people get fungal infections'. Similar for SSRIs. Asked the shrink why SSRIs versus something else - 'got to start somewhere'. Asked them why one SSRI over another, same answer. Throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks is fine if the cost of being wrong is just the list time of needing to recompile your code. It's 100% not ok when being wrong means fucking up your tendons or making you suicidal.
- foolish79 3y ago[flagged]
- smcin 3y agoTo keep it constructive, please explain why systemic fungal infections is not likely to be the cause, and what coule be the cause.
- Spivak 3y agoThere's nothing actually stopping you from getting a fungal culture yourself. The turnaround time is over a month though. Unless you're at a huge hospital they just farm it out to Labcorp and the like and you can buy direct. Like it makes sense, if it's high-probability bacterial you might as well try the z pack first. It's faster to just treat it and see than to test if it's bacterial. Also for SSRIs there's nothing to test, you just try them under medical supervision and if they help they help. There is an experimental DNA test that might be able to narrow down the antidepressant options but unless you're struggling to find one that works for you it's usually not worth bothering. Medicine is crazy advanced in some specific areas but for the long tail we're not that far from leeches.
- mv 3y agoleeches are still in use…
- FireBeyond 3y ago> Similar for SSRIs. Asked the shrink why SSRIs versus something else - 'got to start somewhere'. Asked them why one SSRI over another, same answer. At the risk of over-simplifying - and certainly not justifying blasé, ambivalent answers... the brain is a very complex organism. And we have barely scratched the surface of how it actually works. Most of it, we just don't know. So, from this to psychiatric drugs - SSRIs, MAOIs, SNRIs. Read the drug information sheet in the packet. Not just the "standard" paragraphs on side effects and warnings. All prescription drugs are required to specify "how" the drug works. For a startlingly high number of these drugs, this paragraph starts with the words: > It is not understood precisely how [drug] works. It is believed that it does X, Y and Z... (emphasis mine). We know that they can work for some people and not others. But while we can perhaps make decent educated guesses, a lot of the time, we can't, because, hell, we don't really know how it even actually works, so we can't know it will work for you. Disclaimer: while I am medically educated and work as a prehospital provider, I'm not a MHP, despite my use of 'we' in the previous para.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoHonestly, I don't have any problem with this, and I see it as a great thing. 95% of the time when I go to the doctor it's something routine and basic, e.g. I just need someone to diagnose my cold/flu/infection etc. My question, though, is where are all the "savings" going if so many visits are now seen by lower paid professionals? I was referred to a sleep study, where a PA or nurse practitioner just proceeded to ask me some basic questions from a form to see if I qualified for the study. She added practically nothing to the process (literally she was just reading questions from a form) and then charged my insurance company $200 for 15 minutes of her time. The whole thing was insane. That visit should have cost $20 max, yet people are lining their pockets at every step.
- twoodfin 3y agoThat my insurer gives me significant financial incentive to see an NP at an urgent care clinic vs. going to the ER suggests the cost savings are translating into lower premiums, all else being equal.
- jdsleppy 3y agoWhy go to the doctor to be told it's a flu or a cold? There's nothing to do but treat yourself well and wait, right? I wonder what portion of visits are for common viruses.
- bshacklett 3y agoMany jobs require a “doctor’s note” for absences.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoBecause if it's flu and it's early enough there is treatment (Tamiflu), and it's helpful to differentiate from things like strep, where there is also treatment.
- penjelly 3y agocanadian anecdote: i havent seen my GP ever. He just oversees resident (student doctors). Ive had chronic health issues for 3 years now without much relief, despite having been to the doctors office 20+ in that time. Most of the time they deflect me from specialist care.
- hahahb3nme 3y ago[flagged]
- rafram 3y agoThat’s a horrible thing to say.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sterlind 3y agothere's been an issue with MAID being recommended or encouraged to people who don't want to die, but who have complex chronic illnesses that are expensive to treat. there's been a few really shocking cases of that happening, even sometimes crossing the line into coersion.
- acover 3y agoIt's a morbid joke but 30% of bc residents don't have a family doctor. Maid is being used as a tool to lighten the load on the system.
- rchaud 3y agoI'm Canadian too, and the only time I didn't see my family doctor (phone appointment) was at the height of the COVID lockdown. Are you located in a remote area?
- penjelly 3y agono i am in ottawa, and i go to a major hospital, their family health division.
- vsskanth 3y agoThe number of new physicians in the US are restricted because you need to go through residency and the number of residency slots are limited because they have to be funded by Medicare (why ?). There's a huge lobby (AMA) to keep it that way, to ensure their members salaries remain high. PAs and NPs don't have the same restriction so hospital systems are pushing to have them handle office visits as much as possible. This also has the advantage of being more profitable because they can charge the same. In the last 5 years me and my wife have never been able to see a doctor, only a PA, even though we pay the same.
- rcpt 3y agoAMA stopped lobbying for that around ten years ago
- Afforess 3y agoWhich given the 8-10 year pipeline to become a physician, means we have yet to see the effects. It will take years more.
- sseagull 3y agoIt doesn’t help that doctors and other healthcare professionals are leaving because of burnout. It will only get worse in my opinion. “Warning signs for the U.S. health system are piling up” “Nearly half of practicing U.S. physicians are older than 55” https://www.axios.com/2023/10/26/health-care-doctor-shortages-warning https://www.axios.com/2023/10/26/health-care-doctor-shortage...
- j-bos 3y agoIt wouldn't be so bad, except so many MDs, PAs, and NPs are just bad. This is coming from someone who has been traveling with a sick family member for a few years. There are great (read: skilled, thoughful, patient, investigative, this.patient data driven) professionals out there, but they are badly outnumbered and booked for months near a year into the future. A huge bunch display the interest, skill, or attention of someone working a a declining fast food franchise. Worst of all, most of the good medical practitioners don't even have their own practices, they can't afford the combo of liquidity and red tape, at least that's what a couple have told me.
- mips_r4300i 3y agoThis was my experience going through a half dozen doctors. I found a great one finally, but they didn't even bother taking insurance, and it was very expensive.
- monero-xmr 3y agoExcluding emergency situations, the biggest issue IMO is diagnosis. So many tests, scans, listening, observation, etc. is all about understanding what the problem actually is. Once you accurately identify the problem, treatment can be effectively given (if one exists) via the current system. For mysterious problems that elude a simple diagnosis you can really be stuck. Most doctors don’t have the time for complex cases. It’s worth becoming your own health researcher if no one else can identify the issue.
- hirvi74 3y ago> It’s worth becoming your own health researcher if no one else can identify the issue. This is something I have been a big advocate of. I would never claim to know more than a professional nor would I ever give medical advice to another individual. However, it has helped me plenty of times. I feel like I have been able to ask more important and impactful questions to doctors, and I have been able to push back on some choices that doctors would have made that I think might have been incorrect. For example, I was almost prescribed a medication. That particular medication might have treated its indicated condition well, but it is known to exacerbate my immune-mediated disease as a side-effect (to clarify, the medication was not for the immune-mediated disease). When I mentioned it to the NP I was under the care of, she said, "I have never heard that side-effect." Well, she looked into it, and it turns out I was right. Had I not done my research prior to our visit, then I might have been subjugated to changes to a disease that could have been entirely been avoided. I still think she is a wonderful NP, and no one can know everything. I even have another account. I asked an MD about a newer medication for my immune-mediated disease. He said, "I have never heard of that before." After discussing it with him, he did not seem to be interested in trying it. I swapped doctors, mentioned it to the new doctor, and she prescribed it. It's actually the single most effective treatment I have tried since I acquired the disease 7 years ago. As Schoolhouse Rock once said, "It's great to learn 'cause knowledge is power!"
- gnicholas 3y agoI get annoyed when I send a message to my doctor and it takes 3 back-and-forths to get a message from him, and not the nurse. The nurse's advice tends to be along the lines of what I would find with Google, some semi-relevant copy/pasted advice. I get the sense that they make the messaging system useless so that you have to sign up for appointments/video appointments. They know that for GP appointments, you only pay 30 bucks or so, but they get paid 10x that by your insurance company. I try to resist this, partly because I generally don't need an appointment to answer a simple question, and partly because this is one of the causes of rising insurance premiums.
- ejb999 3y agoThey don't want to solve your problem over a messaging system - and prefer you to come in - the MD can't bill anyone for answering you questions over the phone or even via messaging - which is why they push for an appointment. Not sure what line of work you are in, but are you willing to answer endless emails and or voice mails from customers, all for free? I know I am not - and while you personally may only ask one question a year, a typical MD may have a panel size of 1000 to 3000 patients (at least the ones I know); multiply one question per patient by 2000 patients, and all of a sudden you find out you worked for free for most of the year. Maybe if insurance companies had a billing model that allowed the MDs for charge for this type of 'support', that made them some money it would be workable - but I can't blame them for not wanting to give out free care this way.
- nyx 3y agoThis is a problem they're working on solving, I think. The hospital group I've been using in the Portland area recently announced that patient-initiated messages that take more than a few minutes, and require e.g. digging through a chart, are billable to insurance: https://www.legacyhealth.org/messages https://www.legacyhealth.org/messages MyHealth is just what this hospital system calls their patient-facing Epic portal.
- hx8 3y ago> Not sure what line of work you are in, but are you willing to answer endless emails and or voice mails from customers, all for free? It's common practice to answer emails and take calls from customers and not charge them for it in many industries. If you have 3000 patients, and you spend 3 minutes/patient/year on these interactions, then you spend ~30 minutes a day answering emails or leaving voice mails which is pretty standard.
- pen2l 3y agoIn a very meaningful way the line between physician and non-physician had been blurring anyway. There's a software called Epic which is used by virtually all large healthcare centers, and while most know it as a database system to store patient history and health records (problems and conditions they've been diagnosed for, lab work results, medicine they're currently taking or have taken in the past), it also has a little tab where a healthcare worker can put in some keywords, e.g. the symptoms a patient has, and Epic guidelines gives the health-provider an action plan for that patient, as well as guiding them with differential diagnoses for non-simple issues. Of course for common ailments a nurse practitioner knows as much as a primary care physician anyway and their treatment plans wouldn't differ, but the thing is a physician basically effectively will also only follow one script that the healthcare/insurance system in-place allows for, that Epic will spit out also. In the same way some of us see the task of building a CRUD app as something fairly unremarkable (owing to existing frameworks, existing 'best practices' etc), a physician's day-to-day work is really not challenging, and a "people-person" non-physician equipped with Epic software could arguably work to deliver equal or if not better healthcare outcomes.
- enragedcacti 3y agoOnly planning for the common case is an insane thing to do in healthcare. We don't train doctors for 12 years so that they are faster or more efficient at diagnosing the common cold, we train them so that they have a wide breadth of knowledge, experience, and skills. People already have difficulty getting satisfying diagnoses from MDs with 12 years of training + Epic, imagine how much worse it would be if the person had no clue illnesses other than what Epic spits out even exist.
- FireBeyond 3y agoExactly. Not everything is a zebra, plenty of horses, but... When I teach new EMTs, there's a common topic that comes up. For clarity, EMTs undergo about 200 hours of training, for what is called BLS (basic life support) - essentially non-invasive processes. Generally they can only administer about 5 medicines (oxygen, aspirin, epinephrine, glucose, nitroglycerin). Paramedics undergo up to 1600 hours of training, for ALS (advanced life support), and can start IVs, administer ~40 medications, and do a variety of invasive procedures. So our local EMS protocols say that if you administer a caloric supplement (i.e. glucose) for someone with hypoglycemia, you must "upgrade" that call to ALS and have a paramedic respond. "But what if the patient is getting better?" As expected, as hoped. And if the hypoglycemia is really just that, then 99% of those patients won't need, or want, further care/transport. And for 99% of that 99% (arbitrary, but very high, percentages), it's probably entirely reasonable. "So if they're getting better, why do we want a higher level of care?" For the zebras. For the person with endocrine issues, or for whom hypoglycemia isn't a simple diabetes-related thing, but actually symptomatic of early organ failure, or other things, to get a deeper review to make sure we don't say "Sure thing, Mrs Smith, just stay home and have your husband make you a PB&J or two for some complex carbs" to the patient who has something more serious going on.
- Waterluvian 3y agoA month ago my kids had pink eye. One resolved within days, the other got worse. Instead of a doctor’s appointment the next day, we went to the pharmacy where the pharmacist evaluated him and prescribed an antibiotic. Whole thing took 15 minutes. Really made sense for “a parent could diagnose this” kinds of minor ailments. Also: if it’s the pharmacist determining a med and immediately administering it, is she really “pre-scribing” anything?
- stefan_ 3y agoThe eye is immune privileged and infections can develop into permanent damage within days. It is really not the kind of thing to be diagnosed and monitored at home.
- diogenescynic 3y agoIf you go to urgent care, you most likely won't get a physician. 9/10 visits are urgent care you only see a PA or NP and they can't even really do much. Urgent care seems to also provide really poor results--every time I've gone it's a long wait, the workers seem over-stressed, you barely get any time with the doctor, and usually they just do a strep test or give you a Zithromax pack and hope you'll go away.
- sys_64738 3y ago> If you go to urgent care, you most likely won't get a physician. Not my experience. Every time I've gone to urgent care I am always seen by a MD.
- brewdad 3y agoYou are very lucky. I don't think my urgent care even has an MD in the building anymore. Anything more than a cold or obvious case gets a "nothing we can do" and follow-up with your doctor. Anything mysterious but potentially severe gets you referred to the ER.
- philwelch 3y agoIf all you need is a strep test or a Z pack, urgent care is a great deal.
- diogenescynic 3y agoSure, but what about those outlier scenarios? How do I know the NP or PA is actually going to catch those nuances? For example, a few years back I had a sinus infection in the spring and the NP/PA thought it was just allergies and tried to get me to try allergy medication... it was a useless trip. I'd much prefer a physician, but my primary doctor usually is booked out.
- NegativeK 3y agoAnecdote that isn't remotely data: I went to an urgent care facility the first time I had a migraine aura without headache. I described it to the receptionist as a "visual hallucination", since it was a flashing checkerboard pattern that obviously wasn't real. The receptionist _ran_ to the back to get a doctor. The doctor, in an exam room, very careful, and with significant compassion, explained that they don't have the ability to treat me at that location -- but would I accept an ambulance if they called it? I took an Uber to the ER, where the admitting nurse gave me a flat stare and said "That's not a hallucination," but still put me at the front of the line to have an attending doctor and a bunch of students stare into my eyeballs before confirming that it was a headacheless migraine. To this day, I use that experience as an example of a lay person and a professional completely failing to understand each others' word choice.
- subharmonicon 3y agoRelated: I was shocked when I tried to get a COVID booster in NY State and they told me they didn’t have a registered nurse on staff that day so they couldn’t do any vaccinations. In California, all of my vaccinations have come from phlebotomists, and it seems that pharmacists can also do them here. Why does NY State require an RN?
- FireBeyond 3y agoWA state during COVID basically authorized EMTs to administer the vaccine. I mean it's literally "find this landmark on the lateral arm, steadily insert needle into muscle tissue, depress plunger, withdraw needle, massage site, bandaid". They had to do a 30 minute "training" on it.
- outlace 3y agoMD here. I'm of two minds about this. On the one hand, obviously there's a bit of defensiveness since I went through 12 years of school and training to be an independent physician (4 years college, 4 years medical school, 4 years residency) and I've definitely seen subpar care from other "providers" (not a fan of the term) with less training. The wide variety of different "providers" is also confusing to patients who have little idea the differences in training and scope. The training for non-MD "providers" seems very variable, unlike the quite standardized MD training. I definitely think residency training is a much more robust and you need to have that critical feedback from supervising physicians to improve, which I think can be lacking in non-residency based training. Overall, nothing against PAs/NPs, I know some great ones. On the other hand, a lot of what I do doesn't require 12 years of training, so I am sympathetic to making health care more accessible. I am also a bit jealous that my non-MD colleagues can easily switch from e.g. being a primary care PA to being dermatology PA, whereas as an MD I'm pretty much stuck in my specialty unless I go through another 4+ year residency. Instead of MD-training getting shorter to compete, it's actually getting longer in many cases. Residency trainings are getting longer not shorter for a number of specialties (e.g. neurosurgery, interventional cardiology, pediatric hospitalist).
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoThe current choices are 1) Uniterested, slapdash care from an MD with 12+ years of training and no ability to listen or empathize but eager to make the money s/he went into medicine to make 2) The same from an assistant of some kind who uses ever-degrading search engines to look up not-your-problem and give you potentially dangerous suggestions The future will undoubtedly be worse. As someone mentioned below, we'll pay current premiums (+inflation) for a touchscreen interface to Chat-whatever-it-will-be.
- vrc 3y ago1) isn’t being entirely fair. MDs or any other practitioner are generally restricted by what they can bill insurance since only a minority of patients opt for concierge care. So if insurance allows for “X minutes for Y service”, that’s what they generally do in most “eat what you kill” practices (which is most). Some will go above and beyond, but that’s to their detriment. Insurance billing generally makes care “billability”-centric.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI'd like to see every visit for a chronic illness attended by a medical professional, the patient who is paying for the visit, and another patient who is farther along in the progression of that chronic illness. The input of someone who has been there and seen their disease progress farther is valuable.
- thenerdhead 3y agoVisits delivered by non-physicians, but charged as if they’re all MDs. Late stage capitalism is great.
- ultra_nick 3y agoQuick care beats quality care past a certain level of time and money.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoI hope AI replaces most of them. My experience in the ER, at least in Canada. You're not getting a doctor. You're getting a doctor's 10 minutes attention, while they're running around from patient to patient. Don't expect your diagnosis to be anything more then the most obvious, A -> B diagnosis. When your problems conflate from the drugs they just wrongly gave you, and add in random screw ups, staff and equipment shortages. You will be getting reactive medicine, as your condition worsens. A death spiral, from which you will not escape. Many will be transitioned to the after life in hospital in this way. Give AI better diagnostic testing data, and AI will make better care decisions then any doctor. The doctors/nurses will still be needed to take care of the patient. But it seems pretty clear that AI will be making the decisions, in the short future.
- gustavus 3y agoSounds like you're getting what you pay for in Canada.
- underseacables 3y agoIt's getting harder to see a doctor, they only let you see a physicians assistant, Who acts like a doctor, but isn't. I understand they meet with a doctor later to discuss the case, but… It's just not the same. A physicians assistant is not a doctor
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWait until your insurance demands you use their "AI" first before even visiting your doctor.
- Shekelphile 3y agoSome states have weaponized this. In Florida for example a huge amount of offices are staffed by NPs but they have passed legislation to lock certain groups of people out from receiving care from them as they are the target of the current political hot button issue. Being told you need to find an MD when most offices won't let you see one and may not even have one in the building at the time is laughable.
- NonAnonCoward 3y agoPerhaps I’m just getting crap doctors but I’ve had so many bad experiences even with specialists that it seems nearly impossible to get help with anything past super basic issues. Over a year ago I had a dive related injury to my ear and I can’t get any help past “everything looks great” from any ENT. For context I can barely stand to be in many social situations without earplugs in one ear because I’m hearing some frequencies extremely loud and distorted and in my head instead of from their source.
- Pigalowda 3y agoENT aren’t a bunch of dummies. What tests did you get? Only thing I can think of when you say “everything looks great” is an otoscope exam. But if they did audiometry, CT temporal bones, MRI IAC and those are normal? Then those are tough breaks because they can’t fix a problem they can’t see. Only thing I can think of is maybe a subtle/occult ossicular chain disruption. Is there a little incudomalleal diastases? Anyways I give up that’ll be $500 see ya
- renewiltord 3y agoMost MDs are just prescription-gates. This is a good thing because we have other reasons why we can't make more people to let you in the gate, so it's best that we just use different non-physician staff. I can match the performance of many of these people with a modern AI today, for the things I've needed a doctor for. The things I can't do are effective surgery and emergency care. They're good at that.
- yumraj 3y agoPersonally I’d be happy to see a PA IFF my copay is less. Why should I pay my standard copay to see a PA for a regular visit, or pay the same much much higher specialist copay if I’m seeing a PA instead of an actual specialist MD.
- sershe 3y agoMy OD (I have an anti-hippy bias, so I checked and the online sources claim MD and OD are really not different; not sure if my bias is actually correct, maybe MDs are better?) literally googles symptoms. Thanks, I could do that myself without paying $150 for the visit... What I would really prefer is not a non-physician - it's the ability to get any medicine without prescription + without liability (if you take something that works as intended and harms you, no suing for damages), and the ability to easily get tests, specialist appointments and things like x-rays for cash (e.g. I had a complete change of treatment after having to insist on some test that they didn't think was needed... more than once, usually for injuries). People should be able to direct their own care as long as they pay for it. Interestingly, the best physician I had (in terms of being correct and helpful, and no googling) was also the most open to that. When I asked about some drug once he was like, "I think the evidence you refer to is weak, and it won't do anything for you, but if you really want I can prescribe it" My OD refused to order an online gut test (that for some idiotic reason has to go thru a PCP) cause "I don't know what this test is, you don't need it". I was kinda tempted to say "well maybe you should google it, as usual"