3 ms·
Why doesn't someone just make a new site that works like the old OkCupid and isn't owned by Match Group?
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Why doesn't someone just make a new site that works like the old OkCupid and isn't owned by Match Group?
- crooked-v 3y agoThe OKCupid model doesn't have the same short-term profits and/or VC returns as desperate people shelling out for dating app subscriptions, so nobody will fund it.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoHow much does it actually cost? You set up a website. You put ads for chocolates and flowers on the site so you can recover your expenses. It's not like you have to build a state of the art fab. It's basically a messaging app, which is the sort of thing individuals have built as a side project.
- 7373737373 3y agoBuilding it is easy, moderating it is hard
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoModerating it is spam filtering. You limit signups to IP addresses in the the country of your target market and then ban signups from any IP address that tries to send an excessively large number of messages or has an excessively high block rate. At that point you're down to real users who are jerks, the solution to which is the block button and a message sorting algorithm that takes into account how many times it's been used against someone.
- user_named 3y agoThe why don't you do it. It'll be worth billions right. Now tell me all the reasons you won't do it.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoNo, it won't be worth billions, that's kind of the point. It should be possible to do it efficiently so that the operating costs are low and it doesn't need to make billions in order to be sustainable and outcompete the incumbents. As to why I don't do it, maybe I will -- but I wouldn't object if someone beat me to it. Because it still requires some combination of time and money, the amount of which can be feasible without being zero, and it's quite likely that of all the people in the world, someone who isn't me is in a better position to pull it off before I do.
- rchaud 3y ago> You put ads for chocolates and flowers on the site so you can recover your expenses This isn't going to be bring in anywhere near the amount of money you're thinking it will.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt's not supposed to make a lot of money. It's supposed to cover expenses so you don't go out of business if you do get a hundred million users.
- Nextgrid 3y ago> just make a new site that works like the old OkCupid Is such a thing even possible in today's world where attention spans are measured in seconds thanks to a decade of social media and endless pursuit of "engagement"?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoPeople are all burned out on "engagement" and hankering for something legitimate.
- pydry 3y agoNetwork effects. Your business could run the worlds most perfect dating app but it doesnt matter if it only has 10,000 users globally. Dating apps were easier to bootstrap back in the day before the whole market was swallowed up.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThey all start with less than 5000 users. Everyone is constantly complaining about the incumbents. Go to where they're complaining and tell them you've done it properly. Since you actually have, they tell others.
- PoignardAzur 3y agoThat's not how network effects work. Your complainers will go back to their subreddit and complain that your dating app is empty and all the profiles they're matched up with are 500km away. The only way to have a fighting chance is to start in a single metropolis (eg New York), and try to get everyone to coordinate trying at once. Since the demographics of people complaining about dating sites online is a bit small (and selects for the kinds of clients you don't want), you've got to advertise more broadly, eg with ads on Youtube or in the metro. That gets expensive.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoYou don't actually need everyone to sign up at once. Once someone signs up you send them emails when they get a match. When there aren't as many people they don't get as many emails, but now they're on the site, which creates more matches for people who join tomorrow. People need some way to find out about it, but not everything has to be corporate. Wikipedia has this page which ranks near the top for search queries like "list of online dating sites": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_online_dating_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_online_dating_se... You're an online dating service, so you get added to pages like that where people end up when they're looking to choose an online dating service. And then your site compares well against the other ones that are screwing everyone -- look how few of the heterosexual dating apps have free messaging. So people sign up and give it a try. You make sure your site is listed in places like that where people go to find dating sites, and people find it. And the more people find it, the more useful it gets, because that is how network effects work. At which point people start recommending it and you get even more users.
- andyjohnson0 3y agoOne problem that a new site/app would face is that, to be useful, it would need a geographical density of users. If you have 100k people signed up, but they're spread out across north America or Europe or wherever, then very few of those people will ever meet irl. So at best you have a messaging site for lonely people, but more likely just an unsustainable business. Achieving the necessary user density needs scale and advertising budget. Something highly local might work in a big enough city like Paris/London/NYC.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoThis is the reason the Childfree dating site I'm on is entirely useless. There are literally dozens of us! All spread out geographically.
- Shawnj2 3y agoThere was a really nice app that would literally create a curated dating app profile for you and free appointments with a dating coach etc. I ran into a while back, unfortunately all of the users were so far away it was completely useless lol
- djaychela 3y agoI believe they patented their matching system, so i guess you'd run into legal battles, and they would have deeper pockets. Edit: Match and others definitely did get patents, so I may be confusing them, but I guess no matter who, you'd get sued by someone.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoOkCupid is from 2004. Patents last 20 years. This can't be an excuse for much longer, and software patents are bullshit anyway.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thfuran 3y agoWhy should it matter whether you implement your algorithm with atoms that are arranged into transistors or ones that are arranged otherwise?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWhy would any algorithm be patentable, as opposed to actual inventions, like a new battery chemistry or a new kind of light bulb?
- poisonborz 3y agoBecause it became 5x as hard to do this well in 2023. The legal and community landscape changed immensely. Moderation needs to be top, and for that, profits and engagement, which is why you see the Tinder-like model.
- rchaud 3y agoOnline dating is now pay to win, how else would a dating site make money? It's not like the old days when throwing Google Adsense ads in between profiles could pay the bills.
- Vicinity9635 3y ago[dead]