3 ms·
> it’s how arbitration agreements work [...] It’s not a blanket covering of all dealings with a company by default. Again, I agree that's how things ought to
by Terr_ 3y ago
> it’s how arbitration agreements work [...] It’s not a blanket covering of all dealings with a company by default.
Again, I agree that's how things ought to be, but in practice it seems like the "wrong" outcomes are still happening anyway.
For example [0] a company allegedly sold a customers products contaminated with bedbugs--a physical, tangible good with a harmful defect--and one guy started a class-action lawsuit over it. However the company managed to get a judge to cancel the lawsuit and force everything back into arbitration, based on the website ToS.
If you read the details [1] you'll see the consumer made all the sensible arguments just like the ones you're saying would easily prevail against McDonalds... but they didn't work.
__________
[0] https://www.consumerreports.org/mandatory-binding-arbitration/forced-arbitration-clause-for-concern/ https://www.consumerreports.org/mandatory-binding-arbitratio...
[1] https://casetext.com/case/gorny-v-wayfair-inc https://casetext.com/case/gorny-v-wayfair-inc
- 1123581321 3y agoWayfair's terms are different; they govern the broader business relationship.) In this case the judge should've done the 'common sense' thing and allowed the case to proceed despite the ToS--but that would've actually gone against the agreed terms, unlike what we are talking about with McDonald's app. It's a troubling case and I understand why you are afraid of judges accepting spurious arguments from corporate defense, and I understand how many people don't appreciate how the difference in wording affects them and so can be intimidated.